{ "name": "BriefAuthority citation-review release: actual Word exports", "version": "2.2", "date": "2026-10-07", "license": "CC BY 4.0 (measurement data)", "candidate": { "version": "2.2", "frozenAt": "2026-10-07T08:14:12.928Z", "buildId": "na0oNz-gVQYhPfx04CBh-", "compiledFiles": { "41b25ed6.2a80c333396423f0.js": "2dd06e5d816ee616914388157f0443089c9921adb58f7f4169e5702a1bb5b4e8", "607.0653e54fc0c769fb.js": "b89473cf19bf869a7311038b872bd3f1254fca061b9e1ca82f3c0bfa6f72eafa", "635.df698210ab240a38.js": "765db7af4f8eecee3330344f1ff19f3fce24e8d126596124c87ebde2157e9800", "123.223ce29a00bbc7f9.js": "08a1949bc95a1bdc70b4a13ee68916f9c84826111a6c76097cc3a4ef12203114", "138.f62f083da676c238.js": "7fcc9976bf475aacf549bfe38b4ec4d23d7a6d6fb45d92c88eb74cb1a3117b0f", "430.df07357e043f1ac7.js": "98664337b2e8075b5268eeb7ba232c7ad68fd97e7a043fb5f71b43a8a8de2c8a", "51fb665c.1aec834e604f8016.js": "97cc4b820348bd4538495e52bfef2a27899d2bac79a492054023454d228b863b", "8187f03c.5da911f881179d34.js": "fce1ed3df6e78e0773b2f6de2fb764511f11bc19f29e6c4e72ac4fb8552994a5", "8f7ad201.899cde37fdf071bd.js": "09db1e599b7cdb91fc50761124169c430159c403be92f8bd49f39d2c6324ee20", "aaea2bcf.3f2f8c95dec3f6bc.js": "17a778e0241d1d3cdfe1e5740d1df598f805e9ab011ded8b795d833df050aec7", "131.3565abe77fd2ff30.js": "1c9c6da193eff1d895ce2b8c5361c79cce49c7a18ed480c595ae600ee59d3bab", "193.6eeae8c993827606.js": "1d8afda22a867147c83c6682e749e4841ed00f3914fdc92014898572c87cd9d4", "2.8d5f17dc7092451e.js": "615ed9cf8404248fde27f0c3ae5ec95911b575b3dc38b38032cf8be099ae3843", "208.cf20866320842cb3.js": "9454289185c4b6b6b25c01c9c12f3d838c4289b136e8c9507e53d0d8206dc272", "257.28ea6af0deda7a63.js": "bf1d03e425114813656a13480a83a2cc4a5c3343f8acc6f643c3934233173c96", "434.c81092b11c9130b1.js": "46f258352b541c0b3fd354b64860bc40f1b43f2066418fef9530e68213a2cbce", "572.2d9d8d77761dd3ae.js": "bddd2397919d66a185d37f40c30cb069e1fbd6fefbef153d954a2ee43b0c5b33", "705.ab6e2e86a1ba5850.js": "e95252739597fd6f19faf24bcbc278f95fe7b0e92f6d0129d67b243671bd640e", "960.308239f1136d8100.js": "dcb1c9df6cfb46b222889e34c19be6fea4c86c6f5a44574e6bd39ad611b188c2", "388-80892b43a1135816.js": "7f76715ce50ead435a4d70fc7f8e3fccf08e14bd834bdcfd62e9d202ba67504b", "567-07dc30ceb5d233bd.js": "ea2d1c559f1251728fee3377cff487e861fd56227df0eec3de27568037ee07c2", "870-60cd170830bcbc2c.js": "8eb90fb3a8fb436417f55b11cafce2fb797ec67e914e22995b63c1b3043ff3b8", "polyfills-42372ed130431b0a.js": "0973c1d64c88adc8e3c950410cb58b288f72118d5965b78049438deb8f2f9683", "117-c4aabb7264156747.js": "7bd6f41cfe0ce8b68c0fcfc0c580bf3f21c9d7b49f22665e6b21bb5ef49b476a", "fd9d1056-db6fccca77d6df56.js": "b8bddf9481d859d648e1e050f8322eb3defe3dd3f9bd13f4c44dd6f2ecf5ab80", "framework-f66176bb897dc684.js": "4250d53f0bc756ece2ddd690a008add1d7fdc887528c671f4dfe8d916d7787b7", "webpack-632dd2a1d3f6f9f8.js": "c55fc530be00e5799c8b540dda2c2777b75a9d76aa6490d915701796b54e70ec", "main-app-c49a10369d3b3aa8.js": "3c933ff31bf696d5a9d80783233009396e39158431f972fafa476f0b47d97aef", "main-b672056a2d22dcaf.js": "3c985a1ef814721a0f1a829ee5b851f0c14e785fda881182cd927035f4cf6ded", "app/table-of-authorities-generator/page-ea65b8c025cf3ee6.js": "a60338d7e82c4f3b8fb8136182553453a9c25d75e430eacfb8feb568f6b515c8" }, "model": { "format": "fp16 ONNX", "parametersApprox": 17000000, "threshold": 0.76, "temperature": 1.4579029083251953, "ownRecordCutoff": 0.5, "sha256": "950e1e90b28ed8d6fa0fb739731815f41aba725bec85da2088ca0584f7d6a12c", "tokenizerSha256": "9ba7e2769ee8927f15f04be8cce1bf5ec0423d4f12d4529987998fd008a78695", "bytes": 33772015, "defaultEnabled": true, "manualConfirmation": true }, "scorer": { "scoreSha256": "6abc3a20fc02fc8b8d671da84bd91ec57febb5ff3f72095a350003f1a2dfdc84", "citeSha256": "b6d3245d553ed9599bfcce1bd7f9516e5f3c614183ee75a9ea7174d6e2ca5129", "reviewerSha256": "ace8d41d1f43428df0c1e4f22705f8a9b7050275b8b1f2e6c9d432f579055bce" }, "sourceVerification": { "testsPassed": 627, "testsSkipped": 1, "productionBuildPassed": true } }, "freshManifestSha256": "594e16b7d7e6ac1ce36c4aea3dfc90110184ed3f4d4e19e463aa620d27194871", "method": { "page": "https://briefauthority.com/table-of-authorities-benchmark", "conditions": "Same frozen application build and scorer; explicit model=0 versus model=1; first and careful actual browser downloads.", "careful": "Automated key-informed reviewer accepts printable titles matching an omitted key authority and dismisses other suggestions. It does not fix unrelated yellow lines. This is an upper bound, not a timed human study.", "errors": "Independent scorer flags, not individually adjudicated legal mistakes. Gold and counsel keys have different limitations.", "weights": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 5, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 1 }, "decisions": "Asked review items plus unsurfaced corrections, not measured clicks or minutes; safe fixes are excluded.", "fresh": "The fresh sample and preparation were frozen before evaluation. Counsel tables are not lawyer-verified gold; source/case-family overlap checks have the scope recorded in its manifest.", "regression": "These 40 documents have been used for product development and are not an untouched holdout." }, "cohorts": { "regression": { "documents": 40, "role": "development regression", "measuredAt": { "off": "2026-10-07T08:21:22.668Z", "on": "2026-10-07T08:23:59.371Z" }, "firstExportXmlIdentical": 40, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "files": 40, "errors": 263, "weighted": 1369, "byType": { "missing": 156, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 9, "wrongPage": 51, "badLine": 32, "idPage": 15, "duplicate": 7, "nameOnly": 65, "cosmetic": 16 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 780, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 45, "wrongPage": 204, "badLine": 128, "idPage": 45, "duplicate": 21, "nameOnly": 130, "cosmetic": 16 }, "total": { "key": 1883, "found": 1724, "exact": 1485, "defensible": 159, "passim": 14 }, "split": { "hunt": 142, "suggestions": 21, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "decisions": 362, "asked": 139, "unsurfaced": 223 }, "careful": { "files": 40, "errors": 255, "weighted": 1329, "byType": { "missing": 148, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 9, "wrongPage": 51, "badLine": 32, "idPage": 15, "duplicate": 7, "nameOnly": 65, "cosmetic": 16 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 740, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 45, "wrongPage": 204, "badLine": 128, "idPage": 45, "duplicate": 21, "nameOnly": 130, "cosmetic": 16 }, "total": { "key": 1883, "found": 1732, "exact": 1492, "defensible": 160, "passim": 14 }, "split": { "hunt": 143, "suggestions": 21, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 8, "falseDismisses": 13, "suggestionClicks": 21 }, "decisions": 363, "asked": 139, "unsurfaced": 224 } }, "on": { "first": { "files": 40, "errors": 263, "weighted": 1369, "byType": { "missing": 156, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 9, "wrongPage": 51, "badLine": 32, "idPage": 15, "duplicate": 7, "nameOnly": 65, "cosmetic": 16 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 780, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 45, "wrongPage": 204, "badLine": 128, "idPage": 45, "duplicate": 21, "nameOnly": 130, "cosmetic": 16 }, "total": { "key": 1883, "found": 1724, "exact": 1485, "defensible": 159, "passim": 14 }, "split": { "hunt": 73, "suggestions": 139, "modelShown": 118, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "decisions": 411, "asked": 257, "unsurfaced": 154 }, "careful": { "files": 40, "errors": 212, "weighted": 1103, "byType": { "missing": 92, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 9, "wrongPage": 59, "badLine": 37, "idPage": 15, "duplicate": 7, "nameOnly": 66, "cosmetic": 16 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 460, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 45, "wrongPage": 236, "badLine": 148, "idPage": 45, "duplicate": 21, "nameOnly": 132, "cosmetic": 16 }, "total": { "key": 1883, "found": 1788, "exact": 1531, "defensible": 167, "passim": 16 }, "split": { "hunt": 87, "suggestions": 139, "modelShown": 118, "trueAccepts": 65, "falseDismisses": 74, "suggestionClicks": 139 }, "decisions": 438, "asked": 257, "unsurfaced": 181 } } }, "suggestions": { "modelAcceptedByKeyReviewer": 57, "modelNotAcceptedByKeyReviewer": 61, "note": "Not accepted means absent from the missing-key recovery plan, not proven false or nonexistent in the brief." }, "rows": [ { "id": "g01-scotus-sg-resp", "task": { "id": "g01-scotus-sg-resp", "source": "fmt-sg/scotus-05-1120-sg-respondent.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "scotus", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "SG brief" ], "why": "SG merits brief, 95 gold entries, heavy statutes/Pub. L. and counsel typos in its table" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g01-scotus-sg-resp.first.docx", "lines": 94, "keyEntries": 95, "keyPieces": 95, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 33, "found": 33, "exact": 29, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 43, "found": 41, "exact": 37, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 9, "found": 3, "exact": 2, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 94, "found": 84, "exact": 75, "defensible": 8, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 10, "weightedScore": 60, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 3 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 3 }, "corrections": 13, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 1 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. NRDC, 467 U.S. 837 (1984)", "line": "Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. NRDC, 467 U.S. 837 (1984)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "FDA v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 529 U.S. 120 (2000)", "line": "FDA v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 529 U.S. 120 (2000)", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555 (1992)", "line": "Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555 (1992)", "lines": [ 15 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. Const. Art. II, \u00a7 3, Cl. 4 (Take Care Clause)", "detail": "constitution" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "42 U.S.C. 7585(b)(2)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "42 U.S.C. 7602 (\u00a7 302)", "line": "42 U.S.C. \u00a7 7602", "lines": [ 63 ], "detail": "lacks 20,33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "42 U.S.C. 7661d(b)(2)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Climate Change Fact Sheet (May 18, 2005) ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Climate Change\u2013U.S. Policy: International Cooperation ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Council on Environmental Quality: Addressing Global Climate Change ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "EPA: Climate Change: U.S. Climate Policy ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Interview with Debra Saunders of San Francisco Chronicle (Oct. 11, 2006) ", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, opened for si", "line": "Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, opened for signature, Mar. 16, 1998, 37 I.L.M. 32", "lines": [ 91 ], "detail": "lacks 31 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change, Kyoto Protocol ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, opened for signature, Mar. 16, 1998, 37 I.L.M. 32", "lines": [ 91 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer, Sept. 16, 1987, S. Treaty Doc. No. 100-10, 1522 U.N.T.S. 29", "lines": [ 92 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "S. Rep. No. 228, 101st Cong", "lines": [ 93 ], "detail": "under the law heading" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 12, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 9, "cosmetic": 3 }, "decisions": 14, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 9, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g01-scotus-sg-resp.first.docx", "sha256": "f8813b79e9f71f696d6a67678cdb8ee8a4d825007b340fb7a280988e0c58ae27", "documentXmlSha256": "7b4fdc7eca2c2d976cf99b1c4e434711ce52c8cca3f850302e0ebec5e4fe8297" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g01-scotus-sg-resp.careful.docx", "lines": 94, "keyEntries": 95, "keyPieces": 95, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 33, "found": 33, "exact": 29, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 43, "found": 41, "exact": 37, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 9, "found": 3, "exact": 2, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 94, "found": 84, "exact": 75, "defensible": 8, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 10, "weightedScore": 60, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 3 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 3 }, "corrections": 13, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 1 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. NRDC, 467 U.S. 837 (1984)", "line": "Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. NRDC, 467 U.S. 837 (1984)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "FDA v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 529 U.S. 120 (2000)", "line": "FDA v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 529 U.S. 120 (2000)", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555 (1992)", "line": "Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555 (1992)", "lines": [ 15 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. Const. Art. II, \u00a7 3, Cl. 4 (Take Care Clause)", "detail": "constitution" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "42 U.S.C. 7585(b)(2)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "42 U.S.C. 7602 (\u00a7 302)", "line": "42 U.S.C. \u00a7 7602", "lines": [ 63 ], "detail": "lacks 20,33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "42 U.S.C. 7661d(b)(2)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Climate Change Fact Sheet (May 18, 2005) ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Climate Change\u2013U.S. Policy: International Cooperation ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Council on Environmental Quality: Addressing Global Climate Change ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "EPA: Climate Change: U.S. Climate Policy ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Interview with Debra Saunders of San Francisco Chronicle (Oct. 11, 2006) ", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, opened for si", "line": "Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, opened for signature, Mar. 16, 1998, 37 I.L.M. 32", "lines": [ 91 ], "detail": "lacks 31 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change, Kyoto Protocol ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, opened for signature, Mar. 16, 1998, 37 I.L.M. 32", "lines": [ 91 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer, Sept. 16, 1987, S. Treaty Doc. No. 100-10, 1522 U.N.T.S. 29", "lines": [ 92 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "S. Rep. No. 228, 101st Cong", "lines": [ 93 ], "detail": "under the law heading" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 12, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 9, "cosmetic": 3 }, "decisions": 14, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 9, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g01-scotus-sg-resp.careful.docx", "sha256": "11a40da1f4fa34c5d8d753f571097450cf885634d3e41aeafd2ff863d6198740", "documentXmlSha256": "7b4fdc7eca2c2d976cf99b1c4e434711ce52c8cca3f850302e0ebec5e4fe8297" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g01-scotus-sg-resp", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g01-scotus-sg-resp.first.docx", "lines": 94, "keyEntries": 95, "keyPieces": 95, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 33, "found": 33, "exact": 29, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 43, "found": 41, "exact": 37, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 9, "found": 3, "exact": 2, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 94, "found": 84, "exact": 75, "defensible": 8, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 10, "weightedScore": 60, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 3 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 3 }, "corrections": 13, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 1 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. NRDC, 467 U.S. 837 (1984)", "line": "Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. NRDC, 467 U.S. 837 (1984)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "FDA v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 529 U.S. 120 (2000)", "line": "FDA v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 529 U.S. 120 (2000)", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555 (1992)", "line": "Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555 (1992)", "lines": [ 15 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. Const. Art. II, \u00a7 3, Cl. 4 (Take Care Clause)", "detail": "constitution" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "42 U.S.C. 7585(b)(2)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "42 U.S.C. 7602 (\u00a7 302)", "line": "42 U.S.C. \u00a7 7602", "lines": [ 63 ], "detail": "lacks 20,33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "42 U.S.C. 7661d(b)(2)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Climate Change Fact Sheet (May 18, 2005) ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Climate Change\u2013U.S. Policy: International Cooperation ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Council on Environmental Quality: Addressing Global Climate Change ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "EPA: Climate Change: U.S. Climate Policy ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Interview with Debra Saunders of San Francisco Chronicle (Oct. 11, 2006) ", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, opened for si", "line": "Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, opened for signature, Mar. 16, 1998, 37 I.L.M. 32", "lines": [ 91 ], "detail": "lacks 31 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change, Kyoto Protocol ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, opened for signature, Mar. 16, 1998, 37 I.L.M. 32", "lines": [ 91 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer, Sept. 16, 1987, S. Treaty Doc. No. 100-10, 1522 U.N.T.S. 29", "lines": [ 92 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "S. Rep. No. 228, 101st Cong", "lines": [ 93 ], "detail": "under the law heading" } ], "asked": 11, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 9, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 6, "cosmetic": 3 }, "decisions": 20, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 9, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 6, "suggestions": 9, "modelShown": 9, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g01-scotus-sg-resp.first.docx", "sha256": "1e3e233c29b056cd37273463c1fdd60c075328f47fae62121f40ce51aec15df5", "documentXmlSha256": "7b4fdc7eca2c2d976cf99b1c4e434711ce52c8cca3f850302e0ebec5e4fe8297" }, "seconds": 7 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g01-scotus-sg-resp.careful.docx", "lines": 97, "keyEntries": 95, "keyPieces": 95, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 33, "found": 33, "exact": 29, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 43, "found": 41, "exact": 37, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 9, "found": 5, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 94, "found": 87, "exact": 77, "defensible": 8, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 6, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 9, "weightedScore": 53, "byType": { "missing": 6, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 3 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 30, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 3 }, "corrections": 12, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 1 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. NRDC, 467 U.S. 837 (1984)", "line": "Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. NRDC, 467 U.S. 837 (1984)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "FDA v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 529 U.S. 120 (2000)", "line": "FDA v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 529 U.S. 120 (2000)", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555 (1992)", "line": "Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555 (1992)", "lines": [ 15 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "42 U.S.C. 7585(b)(2)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "42 U.S.C. 7602 (\u00a7 302)", "line": "42 U.S.C. \u00a7 7602", "lines": [ 64 ], "detail": "lacks 20,33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "42 U.S.C. 7661d(b)(2)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Climate Change\u2013U.S. Policy: International Cooperation ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Council on Environmental Quality: Addressing Global Climate Change ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "EPA: Climate Change: U.S. Climate Policy ", "line": "U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change, Kyoto Protocol (visited Oct. 24, 2006)", "lines": [ 96 ], "detail": "lacks 9 (cited there) / adds 30 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Interview with Debra Saunders of San Francisco Chronicle (Oct. 11, 2006) ", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, opened for si", "line": "Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, opened for signature, Mar. 16, 1998, 37 I.L.M. 32", "lines": [ 93 ], "detail": "lacks 31 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change, Kyoto Protocol ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, opened for signature, Mar. 16, 1998, 37 I.L.M. 32", "lines": [ 93 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer, Sept. 16, 1987, S. Treaty Doc. No. 100-10, 1522 U.N.T.S. 29", "lines": [ 94 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "S. Rep. No. 228, 101st Cong", "lines": [ 95 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "http://www.state.gov/g/oes/rls/fs/46741.htm", "lines": [ 92 ], "detail": "not readable as a citation" } ], "asked": 11, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 11, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 6, "wrongPage": 1, "cosmetic": 3, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 22, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 9, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 6, "suggestions": 9, "modelShown": 9, "trueAccepts": 3, "falseDismisses": 6, "suggestionClicks": 9 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g01-scotus-sg-resp.careful.docx", "sha256": "a5c5f7c8970998b2a2c6fa8329763967a979f4aa262317bba3c47f75f7e5063a", "documentXmlSha256": "9aae943e1c2955111e69e4bd889622bad3896db66d85805c2345e40c52e2e3d0" }, "seconds": 8 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g01-scotus-sg-resp", "accept": [ "U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change, Kyoto Protocol (visited Oct. 24, 2006)", "Art. II, \u00a7 3, cl. 4", "http://www.state.gov/g/oes/rls/fs/46741.htm" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change, Kyoto Protocol (visited Oct. 24, 2006)", "key": "U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change, Kyoto Protocol " }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Art. II, \u00a7 3, cl. 4", "key": "U.S. Const. Art. II, \u00a7 3, Cl. 4 (Take Care Clause)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "http://www.state.gov/g/oes/rls/fs/46741.htm", "key": "Climate Change Fact Sheet (May 18, 2005) " } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Section 202(a)(1) of the Clean Air Act" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Section 602" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Section 302" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2006/07/ 20060711-7" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "104 Stat. 4058-4062" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "http://www.epa.gov/ climatechange/policy/internationalcooperation.html>" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g02-scotus-sg-pet", "task": { "id": "g02-scotus-sg-pet", "source": "fmt-sg/scotus-11-1025-sg-petitioner.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "scotus", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "SG brief" ], "why": "SG petitioner brief; counsel's table has isolated wrong pages (amend. IV at 38)" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g02-scotus-sg-pet.first.docx", "lines": 71, "keyEntries": 62, "keyPieces": 62, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 34, "exact": 31, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 3, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 21, "found": 21, "exact": 17, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 62, "found": 59, "exact": 51, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 12, "errorsInFile": 5, "weightedScore": 25, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 2 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 16, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 2 }, "corrections": 7, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 2 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "50 U.S.C. 1801(a)(1)", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 1801(a)(1)", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "lacks 2,3,6,7,8,10,33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 3" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "50 U.S.C. 1881 et seq. (Supp. II 2008) (Tit. VII)", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 1881(a)", "lines": [ 53 ], "detail": "lacks 9,38 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "50 U.S.C. 1881a (Supp. II 2008) (\u00a7 702)", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 1881a", "lines": [ 54 ], "detail": "lacks 22,24,40,45,46 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Exec. Order No. 12,333, 3 C.F.R. 200 (1981 Comp.), reprinted as amended in 50 U.S.C. 401 n", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 401 note", "lines": [ 37 ], "detail": "lacks 33,41,45 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Letter from Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper to Speaker John Boehner et al. (Mar. 26, 2012)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "S. Rep. No. 174, 112th Cong., 2d Sess. (2012)", "line": "S. Rep. No. 174, 112th Cong", "lines": [ 70 ], "detail": "lacks 38 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "S. Rep. No. 174, 112th Cong", "lines": [ 70 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "S. Rep. No. 701, 95th Cong", "lines": [ 69 ], "detail": "under the law heading" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 3, "cosmetic": 2 }, "decisions": 12, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 3, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g02-scotus-sg-pet.first.docx", "sha256": "eb69917d441d777787101da6ad8863f283e11ac3ba8ddf0c20027967fa2e344d", "documentXmlSha256": "98f64962ec9fd270a624644bd3ed4d118ae543f9b493f43b6ec61eee7aafc0a0" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g02-scotus-sg-pet.careful.docx", "lines": 72, "keyEntries": 62, "keyPieces": 62, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 34, "exact": 31, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 3, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 21, "found": 21, "exact": 17, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 62, "found": 60, "exact": 52, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 12, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 2 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 16, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 2 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 2 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "50 U.S.C. 1801(a)(1)", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 1801(a)(1)", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "lacks 2,3,6,7,8,10,33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 3" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "50 U.S.C. 1881 et seq. (Supp. II 2008) (Tit. VII)", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 1881(a)", "lines": [ 53 ], "detail": "lacks 9,38 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "50 U.S.C. 1881a (Supp. II 2008) (\u00a7 702)", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 1881a", "lines": [ 54 ], "detail": "lacks 22,24,40,45,46 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Exec. Order No. 12,333, 3 C.F.R. 200 (1981 Comp.), reprinted as amended in 50 U.S.C. 401 n", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 401 note", "lines": [ 37 ], "detail": "lacks 33,41,45 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "S. Rep. No. 174, 112th Cong., 2d Sess. (2012)", "line": "S. Rep. No. 174, 112th Cong", "lines": [ 71 ], "detail": "lacks 38 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "S. Rep. No. 174, 112th Cong", "lines": [ 71 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "S. Rep. No. 701, 95th Cong", "lines": [ 70 ], "detail": "under the law heading" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 3, "cosmetic": 2 }, "decisions": 12, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 3, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 2, "suggestionClicks": 3 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g02-scotus-sg-pet.careful.docx", "sha256": "0f452bbc4eb067579420752abbafcdc046a68a66f7a16a804c8ead867c80f224", "documentXmlSha256": "adb2779c4e78010368d6baa7a4b915460d577c7a87513f9533b38435e15f564c" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g02-scotus-sg-pet", "accept": [ "Letter from Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper to Speaker John Boehner et al. 1 (Mar. 26, 2012)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Letter from Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper to Speaker John Boehner et al. 1 (Mar. 26, 2012)", "key": "Letter from Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper to Speaker John Boehner et al. (Mar. 26, 2012)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "3 C.F.R. pt. 210" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, 42 U.S.C. \u00a7 2000e et seq." } ] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g02-scotus-sg-pet.first.docx", "lines": 71, "keyEntries": 62, "keyPieces": 62, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 34, "exact": 31, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 3, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 21, "found": 21, "exact": 17, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 62, "found": 59, "exact": 51, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 12, "errorsInFile": 5, "weightedScore": 25, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 2 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 16, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 2 }, "corrections": 7, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 2 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "50 U.S.C. 1801(a)(1)", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 1801(a)(1)", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "lacks 2,3,6,7,8,10,33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 3" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "50 U.S.C. 1881 et seq. (Supp. II 2008) (Tit. VII)", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 1881(a)", "lines": [ 53 ], "detail": "lacks 9,38 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "50 U.S.C. 1881a (Supp. II 2008) (\u00a7 702)", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 1881a", "lines": [ 54 ], "detail": "lacks 22,24,40,45,46 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Exec. Order No. 12,333, 3 C.F.R. 200 (1981 Comp.), reprinted as amended in 50 U.S.C. 401 n", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 401 note", "lines": [ 37 ], "detail": "lacks 33,41,45 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Letter from Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper to Speaker John Boehner et al. (Mar. 26, 2012)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "S. Rep. No. 174, 112th Cong., 2d Sess. (2012)", "line": "S. Rep. No. 174, 112th Cong", "lines": [ 70 ], "detail": "lacks 38 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "S. Rep. No. 174, 112th Cong", "lines": [ 70 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "S. Rep. No. 701, 95th Cong", "lines": [ 69 ], "detail": "under the law heading" } ], "asked": 9, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 3, "cosmetic": 2 }, "decisions": 14, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 3, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 5, "modelShown": 2, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g02-scotus-sg-pet.first.docx", "sha256": "991e63e8d7a77a010b867dee8e2a9c9b06dde127743bb9c5f3c235f0e6990fd8", "documentXmlSha256": "98f64962ec9fd270a624644bd3ed4d118ae543f9b493f43b6ec61eee7aafc0a0" }, "seconds": 5 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g02-scotus-sg-pet.careful.docx", "lines": 72, "keyEntries": 62, "keyPieces": 62, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 34, "exact": 31, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 3, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 21, "found": 21, "exact": 17, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 62, "found": 60, "exact": 52, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 12, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 2 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 16, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 2 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 2 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "50 U.S.C. 1801(a)(1)", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 1801(a)(1)", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "lacks 2,3,6,7,8,10,33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 3" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "50 U.S.C. 1881 et seq. (Supp. II 2008) (Tit. VII)", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 1881(a)", "lines": [ 53 ], "detail": "lacks 9,38 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "50 U.S.C. 1881a (Supp. II 2008) (\u00a7 702)", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 1881a", "lines": [ 54 ], "detail": "lacks 22,24,40,45,46 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Exec. Order No. 12,333, 3 C.F.R. 200 (1981 Comp.), reprinted as amended in 50 U.S.C. 401 n", "line": "50 U.S.C. \u00a7 401 note", "lines": [ 37 ], "detail": "lacks 33,41,45 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "S. Rep. No. 174, 112th Cong., 2d Sess. (2012)", "line": "S. Rep. No. 174, 112th Cong", "lines": [ 71 ], "detail": "lacks 38 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "S. Rep. No. 174, 112th Cong", "lines": [ 71 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "S. Rep. No. 701, 95th Cong", "lines": [ 70 ], "detail": "under the law heading" } ], "asked": 9, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 3, "cosmetic": 2 }, "decisions": 14, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 3, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 5, "modelShown": 2, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 4, "suggestionClicks": 5 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g02-scotus-sg-pet.careful.docx", "sha256": "18919228c284c14801aede6a8a0a89df3a539f5561262e77bae01b8e831cb055", "documentXmlSha256": "adb2779c4e78010368d6baa7a4b915460d577c7a87513f9533b38435e15f564c" }, "seconds": 7 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g02-scotus-sg-pet", "accept": [ "Letter from Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper to Speaker John Boehner et al. 1 (Mar. 26, 2012)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Letter from Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper to Speaker John Boehner et al. 1 (Mar. 26, 2012)", "key": "Letter from Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper to Speaker John Boehner et al. (Mar. 26, 2012)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "3 C.F.R. pt. 210" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, 42 U.S.C. \u00a7 2000e et seq." }, { "kind": "model", "title": "\u00a7 702, 122 Stat. 2438" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "121 Stat. 552-555" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g03-scotus-bio", "task": { "id": "g03-scotus-bio", "source": "grow-scotus/scotus-22-842-brief-in-opposition.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "scotus", "jur": "US", "tags": [], "chatbot": true, "why": "brief in opposition, cert-stage format" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g03-scotus-bio.first.docx", "lines": 37, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 32, "found": 32, "exact": 28, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 35, "found": 35, "exact": 31, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 10, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Backpage.com, LLC v. Dart, 807 F.3d 229 (7th Cir. 2015)", "line": "Backpage.com, LLC v. Dart, 807 F.3d 229 (7th Cir. 2015)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Bantam Books, Inc. v. Sullivan, 372 U.S. 58 (1963)", "line": "Bantam Books, Inc. v. Sullivan, 372 U.S. 58 (1963)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "lacks 16,17 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 16,17" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Okwedy v. Molinari, 333 F.3d 339 (2d Cir. 2003) (per curiam)", "line": "Okwedy v. Molinari, 333 F.3d 339 (2d Cir. 2003)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 20,21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Rattner v. Netburn, 930 F.2d 204 (2d Cir. 1991)", "line": "Rattner v. Netburn, 930 F.2d 204 (2d Cir. 1991)", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "National Rifle Association of America v. Cuomo, No. 1:18-cv-00566 (Mar. 20, 2023)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 2, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1, "cosmetic": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 2, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g03-scotus-bio.first.docx", "sha256": "367ceeb8fec9a692a3c730b778dad8b5749a7c43d795a04e5f4c9673225e3a57", "documentXmlSha256": "4c720cff3eadcc250acc7a0708b2a3ead163385361c54c6e334a4f2e04a3d11e" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g03-scotus-bio.careful.docx", "lines": 37, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 32, "found": 32, "exact": 28, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 35, "found": 35, "exact": 31, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 10, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Backpage.com, LLC v. Dart, 807 F.3d 229 (7th Cir. 2015)", "line": "Backpage.com, LLC v. Dart, 807 F.3d 229 (7th Cir. 2015)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Bantam Books, Inc. v. Sullivan, 372 U.S. 58 (1963)", "line": "Bantam Books, Inc. v. Sullivan, 372 U.S. 58 (1963)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "lacks 16,17 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 16,17" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Okwedy v. Molinari, 333 F.3d 339 (2d Cir. 2003) (per curiam)", "line": "Okwedy v. Molinari, 333 F.3d 339 (2d Cir. 2003)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 20,21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Rattner v. Netburn, 930 F.2d 204 (2d Cir. 1991)", "line": "Rattner v. Netburn, 930 F.2d 204 (2d Cir. 1991)", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "National Rifle Association of America v. Cuomo, No. 1:18-cv-00566 (Mar. 20, 2023)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 2, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1, "cosmetic": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 2, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g03-scotus-bio.careful.docx", "sha256": "9a8ce893641e490662fc8c079db5a03fb0bca1ee844b417e14dbb84690be98ab", "documentXmlSha256": "4c720cff3eadcc250acc7a0708b2a3ead163385361c54c6e334a4f2e04a3d11e" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g03-scotus-bio", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g03-scotus-bio.first.docx", "lines": 37, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 32, "found": 32, "exact": 28, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 35, "found": 35, "exact": 31, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 10, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Backpage.com, LLC v. Dart, 807 F.3d 229 (7th Cir. 2015)", "line": "Backpage.com, LLC v. Dart, 807 F.3d 229 (7th Cir. 2015)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Bantam Books, Inc. v. Sullivan, 372 U.S. 58 (1963)", "line": "Bantam Books, Inc. v. Sullivan, 372 U.S. 58 (1963)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "lacks 16,17 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 16,17" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Okwedy v. Molinari, 333 F.3d 339 (2d Cir. 2003) (per curiam)", "line": "Okwedy v. Molinari, 333 F.3d 339 (2d Cir. 2003)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 20,21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Rattner v. Netburn, 930 F.2d 204 (2d Cir. 1991)", "line": "Rattner v. Netburn, 930 F.2d 204 (2d Cir. 1991)", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "National Rifle Association of America v. Cuomo, No. 1:18-cv-00566 (Mar. 20, 2023)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 2, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1, "cosmetic": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 2, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g03-scotus-bio.first.docx", "sha256": "6e0282c30b899f33db78e328d24b7fc23b2ce465098ae7fcaa49e239bbef6605", "documentXmlSha256": "4c720cff3eadcc250acc7a0708b2a3ead163385361c54c6e334a4f2e04a3d11e" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g03-scotus-bio.careful.docx", "lines": 37, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 32, "found": 32, "exact": 28, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 35, "found": 35, "exact": 31, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 10, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Backpage.com, LLC v. Dart, 807 F.3d 229 (7th Cir. 2015)", "line": "Backpage.com, LLC v. Dart, 807 F.3d 229 (7th Cir. 2015)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Bantam Books, Inc. v. Sullivan, 372 U.S. 58 (1963)", "line": "Bantam Books, Inc. v. Sullivan, 372 U.S. 58 (1963)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "lacks 16,17 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 16,17" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Okwedy v. Molinari, 333 F.3d 339 (2d Cir. 2003) (per curiam)", "line": "Okwedy v. Molinari, 333 F.3d 339 (2d Cir. 2003)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 20,21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Rattner v. Netburn, 930 F.2d 204 (2d Cir. 1991)", "line": "Rattner v. Netburn, 930 F.2d 204 (2d Cir. 1991)", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "National Rifle Association of America v. Cuomo, No. 1:18-cv-00566 (Mar. 20, 2023)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 2, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1, "cosmetic": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 2, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g03-scotus-bio.careful.docx", "sha256": "69e2395ba63c81fd3b4da9fd459a309e2ded305967eb1df375fd883290bacc00", "documentXmlSha256": "4c720cff3eadcc250acc7a0708b2a3ead163385361c54c6e334a4f2e04a3d11e" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g03-scotus-bio", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } } }, { "id": "g04-scotus-amicus", "task": { "id": "g04-scotus-amicus", "source": "grow-scotus/scotus-22-1079-amicus.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "scotus", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "amicus" ], "why": "SCOTUS amicus, 67 entries, many secondary sources" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g04-scotus-amicus.first.docx", "lines": 67, "keyEntries": 67, "keyPieces": 67, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 44, "found": 44, "exact": 38, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 21, "found": 21, "exact": 21, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 67, "found": 66, "exact": 60, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 17, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Alton R. Co. v. United States, 315 U.S. 15 (1942)", "line": "Alton R. Co. v. United States, 315 U.S. 15 (1942)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "In re OGA Charters, L.L.C., 901 F.3d 599 (5th Cir. 2018)", "line": "In re OGA Charters, L.L.C., 901 F.3d 599 (5th Cir. 2018)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 17 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "L. Singer & Sons v. Union Pac. R. Co., 311 U.S. 295 (1940)", "line": "L. Singer & Sons v. Union Pac. R. Co., 311 U.S. 295 (1940)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 9 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Western Pac. Cal. R.R. v. Southern Pac. Co., 284 U.S. 47 (1931)", "line": "Western Pac. Cal. R.R. v. Southern Pac. Co., 284 U.S. 47 (1931)", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "lacks 7,9 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Sup. Ct. R. 37.6", "detail": "rules" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 2, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g04-scotus-amicus.first.docx", "sha256": "c99f222d7e1519de41aca797b894b1622dd3f477e80ed41c267380a37959e764", "documentXmlSha256": "c1093c6cce036b1eeb05bedb3e9525b5b35821efc31d2a843ff952ad8282b16b" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g04-scotus-amicus.careful.docx", "lines": 67, "keyEntries": 67, "keyPieces": 67, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 44, "found": 44, "exact": 38, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 21, "found": 21, "exact": 21, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 67, "found": 66, "exact": 60, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 17, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Alton R. Co. v. United States, 315 U.S. 15 (1942)", "line": "Alton R. Co. v. United States, 315 U.S. 15 (1942)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "In re OGA Charters, L.L.C., 901 F.3d 599 (5th Cir. 2018)", "line": "In re OGA Charters, L.L.C., 901 F.3d 599 (5th Cir. 2018)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 17 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "L. Singer & Sons v. Union Pac. R. Co., 311 U.S. 295 (1940)", "line": "L. Singer & Sons v. Union Pac. R. Co., 311 U.S. 295 (1940)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 9 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Western Pac. Cal. R.R. v. Southern Pac. Co., 284 U.S. 47 (1931)", "line": "Western Pac. Cal. R.R. v. Southern Pac. Co., 284 U.S. 47 (1931)", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "lacks 7,9 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Sup. Ct. R. 37.6", "detail": "rules" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 2, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g04-scotus-amicus.careful.docx", "sha256": "bafc6fcff89e485df0c5a29829e0dc5d9ea38fe05e1d0f80f6777e6c9ad32b12", "documentXmlSha256": "c1093c6cce036b1eeb05bedb3e9525b5b35821efc31d2a843ff952ad8282b16b" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g04-scotus-amicus", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g04-scotus-amicus.first.docx", "lines": 67, "keyEntries": 67, "keyPieces": 67, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 44, "found": 44, "exact": 38, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 21, "found": 21, "exact": 21, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 67, "found": 66, "exact": 60, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 17, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Alton R. Co. v. United States, 315 U.S. 15 (1942)", "line": "Alton R. Co. v. United States, 315 U.S. 15 (1942)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "In re OGA Charters, L.L.C., 901 F.3d 599 (5th Cir. 2018)", "line": "In re OGA Charters, L.L.C., 901 F.3d 599 (5th Cir. 2018)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 17 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "L. Singer & Sons v. Union Pac. R. Co., 311 U.S. 295 (1940)", "line": "L. Singer & Sons v. Union Pac. R. Co., 311 U.S. 295 (1940)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 9 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Western Pac. Cal. R.R. v. Southern Pac. Co., 284 U.S. 47 (1931)", "line": "Western Pac. Cal. R.R. v. Southern Pac. Co., 284 U.S. 47 (1931)", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "lacks 7,9 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Sup. Ct. R. 37.6", "detail": "rules" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 2, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g04-scotus-amicus.first.docx", "sha256": "8cc12108400ddaa1bedb9d9b20b64ca0dfeb4ef34a5ca748a874e88ed46d3024", "documentXmlSha256": "c1093c6cce036b1eeb05bedb3e9525b5b35821efc31d2a843ff952ad8282b16b" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g04-scotus-amicus.careful.docx", "lines": 67, "keyEntries": 67, "keyPieces": 67, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 44, "found": 44, "exact": 38, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 21, "found": 21, "exact": 21, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 67, "found": 66, "exact": 60, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 17, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Alton R. Co. v. United States, 315 U.S. 15 (1942)", "line": "Alton R. Co. v. United States, 315 U.S. 15 (1942)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "In re OGA Charters, L.L.C., 901 F.3d 599 (5th Cir. 2018)", "line": "In re OGA Charters, L.L.C., 901 F.3d 599 (5th Cir. 2018)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 17 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "L. Singer & Sons v. Union Pac. R. Co., 311 U.S. 295 (1940)", "line": "L. Singer & Sons v. Union Pac. R. Co., 311 U.S. 295 (1940)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 9 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Western Pac. Cal. R.R. v. Southern Pac. Co., 284 U.S. 47 (1931)", "line": "Western Pac. Cal. R.R. v. Southern Pac. Co., 284 U.S. 47 (1931)", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "lacks 7,9 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Sup. Ct. R. 37.6", "detail": "rules" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 2, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g04-scotus-amicus.careful.docx", "sha256": "aefade20194cef60c3e29047d7e5fe71a57a2252a3e1f581ad6c6f14a4e273fa", "documentXmlSha256": "c1093c6cce036b1eeb05bedb3e9525b5b35821efc31d2a843ff952ad8282b16b" }, "seconds": 6 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g04-scotus-amicus", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Ry. Co. v. United States, 350 U.S. 892 (1955)" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g05-ca11-stale", "task": { "id": "g05-ca11-stale", "source": "grow-fed-appeals/ca11-02-13168-us-appellee.pdf", "key": "gold", "keepTable": true, "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US-CA11", "tags": [ "stale table kept", "DOJ brief" ], "why": "printed table stale by +1 from p25 (confirmed on footers); kept in the input to see whether the app copies stale pages" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g05-ca11-stale.first.docx", "lines": 77, "keyEntries": 77, "keyPieces": 77, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 58, "found": 58, "exact": 51, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 6, "found": 6, "exact": 5, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 12, "found": 12, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 77, "found": 77, "exact": 69, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 14, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 5, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 10, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hartford Fire Ins. Co. v. California, 509 U.S. 764 (1993)", "line": "Hartford Fire Ins. Co. v. California, 509 U.S. 764 (1993)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 26,46,50,51,53,54 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "United States v. Caporale, 806 F.2d 1487 (11th Cir. 1986)", "line": "United States v. Caporale, 806 F.2d 1487 (11th Cir. 1986)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Coy, 19 F.3d 629 (11th Cir. 1994)", "line": "United States v. Coy, 19 F.3d 629 (11th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 33 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Nippon Paper Industries Co., 109 F.3d 1 (1st Cir. 1997)", "line": "United States v. Nippon Paper Industries Co., 109 F.3d 1", "lines": [ 45 ], "detail": "lacks 50,53 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Nippon Papers Industries Co., 62 F. Supp. 2d 173 (D. Mass, 1999)", "line": "Nippon Paper, 62 F. Supp.2d 173 (D. Mass. 1999)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 53 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "15 U.S.C. 6(a)", "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 6(a)", "lines": [ 59 ], "detail": "lacks 45,46,48,53 (name only there)" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g05-ca11-stale.first.docx", "sha256": "d91935eb6cf498932998b31c44970fdcb12a64187ba239e2854da2513bc0bf64", "documentXmlSha256": "6a82dc52baaa4870eb4e2efd6712ed1c2eba2a231bc28133552a2e1c729fbd77" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g05-ca11-stale.careful.docx", "lines": 77, "keyEntries": 77, "keyPieces": 77, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 58, "found": 58, "exact": 51, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 6, "found": 6, "exact": 5, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 12, "found": 12, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 77, "found": 77, "exact": 69, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 14, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 5, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 10, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hartford Fire Ins. Co. v. California, 509 U.S. 764 (1993)", "line": "Hartford Fire Ins. Co. v. California, 509 U.S. 764 (1993)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 26,46,50,51,53,54 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "United States v. Caporale, 806 F.2d 1487 (11th Cir. 1986)", "line": "United States v. Caporale, 806 F.2d 1487 (11th Cir. 1986)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Coy, 19 F.3d 629 (11th Cir. 1994)", "line": "United States v. Coy, 19 F.3d 629 (11th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 33 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Nippon Paper Industries Co., 109 F.3d 1 (1st Cir. 1997)", "line": "United States v. Nippon Paper Industries Co., 109 F.3d 1", "lines": [ 45 ], "detail": "lacks 50,53 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Nippon Papers Industries Co., 62 F. Supp. 2d 173 (D. Mass, 1999)", "line": "Nippon Paper, 62 F. Supp.2d 173 (D. Mass. 1999)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 53 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "15 U.S.C. 6(a)", "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 6(a)", "lines": [ 59 ], "detail": "lacks 45,46,48,53 (name only there)" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g05-ca11-stale.careful.docx", "sha256": "db5a4acd8c91109c81da3857878f21b20c5d8d794b11d6c95a98819ca823ee13", "documentXmlSha256": "6a82dc52baaa4870eb4e2efd6712ed1c2eba2a231bc28133552a2e1c729fbd77" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g05-ca11-stale", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g05-ca11-stale.first.docx", "lines": 77, "keyEntries": 77, "keyPieces": 77, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 58, "found": 58, "exact": 51, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 6, "found": 6, "exact": 5, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 12, "found": 12, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 77, "found": 77, "exact": 69, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 14, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 5, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 10, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hartford Fire Ins. Co. v. California, 509 U.S. 764 (1993)", "line": "Hartford Fire Ins. Co. v. California, 509 U.S. 764 (1993)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 26,46,50,51,53,54 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "United States v. Caporale, 806 F.2d 1487 (11th Cir. 1986)", "line": "United States v. Caporale, 806 F.2d 1487 (11th Cir. 1986)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Coy, 19 F.3d 629 (11th Cir. 1994)", "line": "United States v. Coy, 19 F.3d 629 (11th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 33 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Nippon Paper Industries Co., 109 F.3d 1 (1st Cir. 1997)", "line": "United States v. Nippon Paper Industries Co., 109 F.3d 1", "lines": [ 45 ], "detail": "lacks 50,53 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Nippon Papers Industries Co., 62 F. Supp. 2d 173 (D. Mass, 1999)", "line": "Nippon Paper, 62 F. Supp.2d 173 (D. Mass. 1999)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 53 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "15 U.S.C. 6(a)", "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 6(a)", "lines": [ 59 ], "detail": "lacks 45,46,48,53 (name only there)" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g05-ca11-stale.first.docx", "sha256": "62c2a9809e82cecfc34367973b268bd62cd3f1a3ad7490ceff237a73239505a3", "documentXmlSha256": "6a82dc52baaa4870eb4e2efd6712ed1c2eba2a231bc28133552a2e1c729fbd77" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g05-ca11-stale.careful.docx", "lines": 77, "keyEntries": 77, "keyPieces": 77, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 58, "found": 58, "exact": 51, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 6, "found": 6, "exact": 5, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 12, "found": 12, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 77, "found": 77, "exact": 69, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 14, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 5, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 10, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hartford Fire Ins. Co. v. California, 509 U.S. 764 (1993)", "line": "Hartford Fire Ins. Co. v. California, 509 U.S. 764 (1993)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 26,46,50,51,53,54 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "United States v. Caporale, 806 F.2d 1487 (11th Cir. 1986)", "line": "United States v. Caporale, 806 F.2d 1487 (11th Cir. 1986)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Coy, 19 F.3d 629 (11th Cir. 1994)", "line": "United States v. Coy, 19 F.3d 629 (11th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 33 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Nippon Paper Industries Co., 109 F.3d 1 (1st Cir. 1997)", "line": "United States v. Nippon Paper Industries Co., 109 F.3d 1", "lines": [ 45 ], "detail": "lacks 50,53 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Nippon Papers Industries Co., 62 F. Supp. 2d 173 (D. Mass, 1999)", "line": "Nippon Paper, 62 F. Supp.2d 173 (D. Mass. 1999)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 53 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "15 U.S.C. 6(a)", "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 6(a)", "lines": [ 59 ], "detail": "lacks 45,46,48,53 (name only there)" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 3, "suggestionClicks": 3 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g05-ca11-stale.careful.docx", "sha256": "2c5835ff6edf8fca742b2a6f2235f9a84d9715a05b91ee2206b362c8b5535223", "documentXmlSha256": "6a82dc52baaa4870eb4e2efd6712ed1c2eba2a231bc28133552a2e1c729fbd77" }, "seconds": 6 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g05-ca11-stale", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Bilhar\u0092s former United States v. ABB Middle East & Africa Participations AG, CR-01-N- 0135-S (N.D. Ala. April 11, 2001)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "United States v. American International Contractors, Inc., CR-00-N-1298-S (N.D. Ala. Aug. 11, 2000)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "United States v. Philipp Holzmann Aktiengesellschaft, CR-00-N-0285-S (N.D. Ala. Aug. 11, 2000)" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g06-ca3-amicus", "task": { "id": "g06-ca3-amicus", "source": "grow-fed-appeals/ca3-02-1243-us-amicus.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US-CA3", "tags": [ "amicus", "DOJ brief" ], "chatbot": true, "why": "U.S. amicus in a circuit, 49 entries" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g06-ca3-amicus.first.docx", "lines": 46, "keyEntries": 49, "keyPieces": 49, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 26, "found": 26, "exact": 24, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 10, "found": 10, "exact": 9, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 6, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 46, "found": 43, "exact": 39, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 5, "weightedScore": 30, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "American Dental Association v. Delta Dental Plans Association, 126 F.3d 977 (7th Cir. 1997", "line": "American Dental Association v. Delta Dental Plans Ass\u2019n, 126 F.3d 977 (7th Cir. 1997)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Baker v. Selden, 101 U.S. 99 (1880)", "line": "Baker v. Selden, 101 U.S. 99 (1879)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 21,22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "U.S. Const. art. I, \u00a7 8, cl. 8", "line": "U.S. Const. art. I, \u00a7 8, cl. 8", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 6 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "17 U.S.C. \u00a7 102(a)", "line": "17 U.S.C. \u00a7 102(a)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "lacks 21,22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Compendium of Copyright Office Practices, Compendium II, \u00a7 307.02", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Copyright Office, Examining Division, Literary Online Practices, chap. 20C.II. A.1.a. [2003]", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "W. Patry, Copyright (1994)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Southco, Inc. v. Kanebridge Corp., 324 F.3d 190 (3d Cir. 2003)", "lines": [ 21 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Nimmer on Copyright", "lines": [ 44 ], "detail": "a name or description only, no citation" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 6, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 3, "cosmetic": 1, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g06-ca3-amicus.first.docx", "sha256": "1f0f7efe008d076fc7754962283eaa5c35c7b820b911083d3de7744d8132cc9f", "documentXmlSha256": "116690cc29b2a7046b6d4af900589815238ed40b33ed5c5649fb75d5092d0da7" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g06-ca3-amicus.careful.docx", "lines": 46, "keyEntries": 49, "keyPieces": 49, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 26, "found": 26, "exact": 24, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 10, "found": 10, "exact": 9, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 6, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 46, "found": 43, "exact": 39, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 5, "weightedScore": 30, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "American Dental Association v. Delta Dental Plans Association, 126 F.3d 977 (7th Cir. 1997", "line": "American Dental Association v. Delta Dental Plans Ass\u2019n, 126 F.3d 977 (7th Cir. 1997)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Baker v. Selden, 101 U.S. 99 (1880)", "line": "Baker v. Selden, 101 U.S. 99 (1879)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 21,22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "U.S. Const. art. I, \u00a7 8, cl. 8", "line": "U.S. Const. art. I, \u00a7 8, cl. 8", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 6 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "17 U.S.C. \u00a7 102(a)", "line": "17 U.S.C. \u00a7 102(a)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "lacks 21,22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Compendium of Copyright Office Practices, Compendium II, \u00a7 307.02", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Copyright Office, Examining Division, Literary Online Practices, chap. 20C.II. A.1.a. [2003]", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "W. Patry, Copyright (1994)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Southco, Inc. v. Kanebridge Corp., 324 F.3d 190 (3d Cir. 2003)", "lines": [ 21 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Nimmer on Copyright", "lines": [ 44 ], "detail": "a name or description only, no citation" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 6, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 3, "cosmetic": 1, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g06-ca3-amicus.careful.docx", "sha256": "dd09c58438029ae43f9ae0a3219a089cafe81e2b5522cf9cbaab1cd22c51da89", "documentXmlSha256": "116690cc29b2a7046b6d4af900589815238ed40b33ed5c5649fb75d5092d0da7" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g06-ca3-amicus", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g06-ca3-amicus.first.docx", "lines": 46, "keyEntries": 49, "keyPieces": 49, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 26, "found": 26, "exact": 24, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 10, "found": 10, "exact": 9, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 6, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 46, "found": 43, "exact": 39, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 5, "weightedScore": 30, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "American Dental Association v. Delta Dental Plans Association, 126 F.3d 977 (7th Cir. 1997", "line": "American Dental Association v. Delta Dental Plans Ass\u2019n, 126 F.3d 977 (7th Cir. 1997)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Baker v. Selden, 101 U.S. 99 (1880)", "line": "Baker v. Selden, 101 U.S. 99 (1879)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 21,22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "U.S. Const. art. I, \u00a7 8, cl. 8", "line": "U.S. Const. art. I, \u00a7 8, cl. 8", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 6 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "17 U.S.C. \u00a7 102(a)", "line": "17 U.S.C. \u00a7 102(a)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "lacks 21,22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Compendium of Copyright Office Practices, Compendium II, \u00a7 307.02", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Copyright Office, Examining Division, Literary Online Practices, chap. 20C.II. A.1.a. [2003]", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "W. Patry, Copyright (1994)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Southco, Inc. v. Kanebridge Corp., 324 F.3d 190 (3d Cir. 2003)", "lines": [ 21 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Nimmer on Copyright", "lines": [ 44 ], "detail": "a name or description only, no citation" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1, "cosmetic": 1, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 9, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g06-ca3-amicus.first.docx", "sha256": "4f0068c1886ccaea749b3ac0aa763908699ec2d094356da988ec6930b2e5bdc1", "documentXmlSha256": "116690cc29b2a7046b6d4af900589815238ed40b33ed5c5649fb75d5092d0da7" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g06-ca3-amicus.careful.docx", "lines": 48, "keyEntries": 49, "keyPieces": 49, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 26, "found": 26, "exact": 24, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 10, "found": 10, "exact": 9, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 6, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 46, "found": 45, "exact": 41, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "American Dental Association v. Delta Dental Plans Association, 126 F.3d 977 (7th Cir. 1997", "line": "American Dental Association v. Delta Dental Plans Ass\u2019n, 126 F.3d 977 (7th Cir. 1997)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Baker v. Selden, 101 U.S. 99 (1880)", "line": "Baker v. Selden, 101 U.S. 99 (1879)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 21,22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "U.S. Const. art. I, \u00a7 8, cl. 8", "line": "U.S. Const. art. I, \u00a7 8, cl. 8", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 6 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "17 U.S.C. \u00a7 102(a)", "line": "17 U.S.C. \u00a7 102(a)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "lacks 21,22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "W. Patry, Copyright (1994)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Southco, Inc. v. Kanebridge Corp., 324 F.3d 190 (3d Cir. 2003)", "lines": [ 21 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Nimmer on Copyright", "lines": [ 44 ], "detail": "a name or description only, no citation" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1, "cosmetic": 1, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 9, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "trueAccepts": 2, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 3 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g06-ca3-amicus.careful.docx", "sha256": "9b375f36539dfc2417be9b064b384e92b71c4772655f1a4f068b53787e1dcde8", "documentXmlSha256": "50cfc735878194a3c659828de79da65e4668ed151c9a6077653b1b0d680fcf3c" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g06-ca3-amicus", "accept": [ "Compendium of Copyright Office Practices, Compendium II, \u00a7 307.02", "Copyright Office, Examining Division, Literary Online Practices, chap. 20 C.II. A.1.a." ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Compendium of Copyright Office Practices, Compendium II, \u00a7 307.02", "key": "Compendium of Copyright Office Practices, Compendium II, \u00a7 307.02" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Copyright Office, Examining Division, Literary Online Practices, chap. 20 C.II. A.1.a.", "key": "Copyright Office, Examining Division, Literary Online Practices, chap. 20C.II. A.1.a. [2003]" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "U.S.P.T.O. Trademark Manual of Examining Procedure, Model or Grade Designations, \u00a7 1202.10 (3rd Edition, rev. May 2003)" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g07-ca6-ftc", "task": { "id": "g07-ca6-ftc", "source": "grow-fed-appeals/ca6-04-5387-us-ftc-amicus.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US-CA6", "tags": [ "amicus" ], "why": "FTC amicus; two-column text layer interleaves an Id. (known engine miss)" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g07-ca6-ftc.first.docx", "lines": 35, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 22, "found": 22, "exact": 13, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 9, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 35, "found": 35, "exact": 25, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 26, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 5, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 16, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 10, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City of Columbia v. Omni Outdoor Advertising, Inc., 499 U.S. 365 (1991)", "line": "City of Columbia v. Omni Outdoor Adver., Inc., 499 U.S. 365 (1991)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 18 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City of Cookeville v. Humphrey, 126 S.W.3d 897 (Tenn. 2004)", "line": "City of Cookeville v. Humphrey, 126 S.W.3d 897 (Tenn. 2004)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Consolidated Television Cable Service, Inc. v. City of Frankfort, 857 F.2d 354 (6th Cir. 1", "line": "Consolidated Television Cable Serv., Inc. v. City of Frankfort, 857 F.2d 354 (6th Cir. 1988)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "FTC v. Hospital Board of Directors of Lee County, 38 F.3d 1184 (11th Cir. 1994)", "line": "FTC v. Hospital Board of Directors of Lee County, 38 F.3d 1184 (11th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Michigan Paytel Joint Venture v. City of Detroit, 287 F.3d 527 (6th Cir. 2002)", "line": "Michigan Paytel Joint Venture v. City of Detroit, 287 F.3d 527 (6th Cir. 2002)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "lacks 22,26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Parker v. Brown, 317 U.S. 341 (1943)", "line": "Parker v. Brown, 317 U.S. 341 (1943)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 23 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Riverview Investments, Inc. v. Ottawa Community Improvement Corp., 769 F.2d 324 (6th Cir. ", "line": "Riverview Invs., Inc. v. Ottawa Cmty. Improvement Corp., 769 F.2d 324 (6th Cir. 1985)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 15 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Town of Hallie v. City of Eau Claire, 471 U.S. 34 (1985)", "line": "Town of Hallie v. City of Eau Claire, 471 U.S. 34 (1985)", "lines": [ 21 ], "detail": "lacks 11 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Office of Policy Planning, Federal Trade Commission, Report of the State Action Task Force", "line": "Office of Policy Planning, Federal Trade Commission, Report of the State Action Task Force (September 2003)", "lines": [ 34 ], "detail": "lacks 12,13,23 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 4 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g07-ca6-ftc.first.docx", "sha256": "88f31e681ee7a9e928c90bde2f92c5ff8fb911c31b039ad55962f75fa2bcbc28", "documentXmlSha256": "9036a4f0fc11967d6448e53cf3afec6a6f089b3d97f0a5a76b3b737cf426cfa1" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g07-ca6-ftc.careful.docx", "lines": 35, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 22, "found": 22, "exact": 13, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 9, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 35, "found": 35, "exact": 25, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 26, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 5, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 16, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 10, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City of Columbia v. Omni Outdoor Advertising, Inc., 499 U.S. 365 (1991)", "line": "City of Columbia v. Omni Outdoor Adver., Inc., 499 U.S. 365 (1991)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 18 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City of Cookeville v. Humphrey, 126 S.W.3d 897 (Tenn. 2004)", "line": "City of Cookeville v. Humphrey, 126 S.W.3d 897 (Tenn. 2004)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Consolidated Television Cable Service, Inc. v. City of Frankfort, 857 F.2d 354 (6th Cir. 1", "line": "Consolidated Television Cable Serv., Inc. v. City of Frankfort, 857 F.2d 354 (6th Cir. 1988)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "FTC v. Hospital Board of Directors of Lee County, 38 F.3d 1184 (11th Cir. 1994)", "line": "FTC v. Hospital Board of Directors of Lee County, 38 F.3d 1184 (11th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Michigan Paytel Joint Venture v. City of Detroit, 287 F.3d 527 (6th Cir. 2002)", "line": "Michigan Paytel Joint Venture v. City of Detroit, 287 F.3d 527 (6th Cir. 2002)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "lacks 22,26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Parker v. Brown, 317 U.S. 341 (1943)", "line": "Parker v. Brown, 317 U.S. 341 (1943)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 23 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Riverview Investments, Inc. v. Ottawa Community Improvement Corp., 769 F.2d 324 (6th Cir. ", "line": "Riverview Invs., Inc. v. Ottawa Cmty. Improvement Corp., 769 F.2d 324 (6th Cir. 1985)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 15 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Town of Hallie v. City of Eau Claire, 471 U.S. 34 (1985)", "line": "Town of Hallie v. City of Eau Claire, 471 U.S. 34 (1985)", "lines": [ 21 ], "detail": "lacks 11 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Office of Policy Planning, Federal Trade Commission, Report of the State Action Task Force", "line": "Office of Policy Planning, Federal Trade Commission, Report of the State Action Task Force (September 2003)", "lines": [ 34 ], "detail": "lacks 12,13,23 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 4 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g07-ca6-ftc.careful.docx", "sha256": "e21ff6400ff71162cfe320ff4b882073e89cf6520c58e8114da3deb9f0de0ce7", "documentXmlSha256": "9036a4f0fc11967d6448e53cf3afec6a6f089b3d97f0a5a76b3b737cf426cfa1" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g07-ca6-ftc", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g07-ca6-ftc.first.docx", "lines": 35, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 22, "found": 22, "exact": 13, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 9, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 35, "found": 35, "exact": 25, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 26, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 5, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 16, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 10, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City of Columbia v. Omni Outdoor Advertising, Inc., 499 U.S. 365 (1991)", "line": "City of Columbia v. Omni Outdoor Adver., Inc., 499 U.S. 365 (1991)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 18 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City of Cookeville v. Humphrey, 126 S.W.3d 897 (Tenn. 2004)", "line": "City of Cookeville v. Humphrey, 126 S.W.3d 897 (Tenn. 2004)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Consolidated Television Cable Service, Inc. v. City of Frankfort, 857 F.2d 354 (6th Cir. 1", "line": "Consolidated Television Cable Serv., Inc. v. City of Frankfort, 857 F.2d 354 (6th Cir. 1988)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "FTC v. Hospital Board of Directors of Lee County, 38 F.3d 1184 (11th Cir. 1994)", "line": "FTC v. Hospital Board of Directors of Lee County, 38 F.3d 1184 (11th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Michigan Paytel Joint Venture v. City of Detroit, 287 F.3d 527 (6th Cir. 2002)", "line": "Michigan Paytel Joint Venture v. City of Detroit, 287 F.3d 527 (6th Cir. 2002)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "lacks 22,26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Parker v. Brown, 317 U.S. 341 (1943)", "line": "Parker v. Brown, 317 U.S. 341 (1943)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 23 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Riverview Investments, Inc. v. Ottawa Community Improvement Corp., 769 F.2d 324 (6th Cir. ", "line": "Riverview Invs., Inc. v. Ottawa Cmty. Improvement Corp., 769 F.2d 324 (6th Cir. 1985)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 15 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Town of Hallie v. City of Eau Claire, 471 U.S. 34 (1985)", "line": "Town of Hallie v. City of Eau Claire, 471 U.S. 34 (1985)", "lines": [ 21 ], "detail": "lacks 11 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Office of Policy Planning, Federal Trade Commission, Report of the State Action Task Force", "line": "Office of Policy Planning, Federal Trade Commission, Report of the State Action Task Force (September 2003)", "lines": [ 34 ], "detail": "lacks 12,13,23 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 4 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g07-ca6-ftc.first.docx", "sha256": "dba5c9315a0afa7771ca4dcab7fd3e0d129331abe9238544f4532e7779719ddb", "documentXmlSha256": "9036a4f0fc11967d6448e53cf3afec6a6f089b3d97f0a5a76b3b737cf426cfa1" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g07-ca6-ftc.careful.docx", "lines": 35, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 22, "found": 22, "exact": 13, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 9, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 35, "found": 35, "exact": 25, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 26, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 5, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 16, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 10, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City of Columbia v. Omni Outdoor Advertising, Inc., 499 U.S. 365 (1991)", "line": "City of Columbia v. Omni Outdoor Adver., Inc., 499 U.S. 365 (1991)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 18 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City of Cookeville v. Humphrey, 126 S.W.3d 897 (Tenn. 2004)", "line": "City of Cookeville v. Humphrey, 126 S.W.3d 897 (Tenn. 2004)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Consolidated Television Cable Service, Inc. v. City of Frankfort, 857 F.2d 354 (6th Cir. 1", "line": "Consolidated Television Cable Serv., Inc. v. City of Frankfort, 857 F.2d 354 (6th Cir. 1988)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "FTC v. Hospital Board of Directors of Lee County, 38 F.3d 1184 (11th Cir. 1994)", "line": "FTC v. Hospital Board of Directors of Lee County, 38 F.3d 1184 (11th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Michigan Paytel Joint Venture v. City of Detroit, 287 F.3d 527 (6th Cir. 2002)", "line": "Michigan Paytel Joint Venture v. City of Detroit, 287 F.3d 527 (6th Cir. 2002)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "lacks 22,26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Parker v. Brown, 317 U.S. 341 (1943)", "line": "Parker v. Brown, 317 U.S. 341 (1943)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 23 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Riverview Investments, Inc. v. Ottawa Community Improvement Corp., 769 F.2d 324 (6th Cir. ", "line": "Riverview Invs., Inc. v. Ottawa Cmty. Improvement Corp., 769 F.2d 324 (6th Cir. 1985)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 15 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Town of Hallie v. City of Eau Claire, 471 U.S. 34 (1985)", "line": "Town of Hallie v. City of Eau Claire, 471 U.S. 34 (1985)", "lines": [ 21 ], "detail": "lacks 11 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Office of Policy Planning, Federal Trade Commission, Report of the State Action Task Force", "line": "Office of Policy Planning, Federal Trade Commission, Report of the State Action Task Force (September 2003)", "lines": [ 34 ], "detail": "lacks 12,13,23 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 4 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g07-ca6-ftc.careful.docx", "sha256": "a49bed62153c9e6038d91168a160392d5cfd8ff2290be0e2fec439f50e0e1126", "documentXmlSha256": "9036a4f0fc11967d6448e53cf3afec6a6f089b3d97f0a5a76b3b737cf426cfa1" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g07-ca6-ftc", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } } }, { "id": "g08-cafc", "task": { "id": "g08-cafc", "source": "grow-fed-appeals/cafc-17-1475-arctic-cat-appellee.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US-CAFC", "tags": [], "why": "Federal Circuit patent brief; certificate-only rules in counsel's table" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g08-cafc.first.docx", "lines": 55, "keyEntries": 59, "keyPieces": 59, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 55, "found": 52, "exact": 47, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 59, "found": 55, "exact": 50, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 26, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Blitzsafe Texas, LLC v. Honda Motor Co., Case No. 2:15-cv-1274-JRG-RSP (E.D. Tex. Jan. 26, 2017)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Golden Bridge Tech. Inc. v. Apple, Inc., No. 5:12-cv-04882-PSG, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 67238 (N.D. Cal. May 14, 2014)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Graham v. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1 (1966)", "line": "Graham v. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1 (1966)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "lacks 20,23 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Halo Elecs., Inc. v. Pulse Elecs., 136 S.Ct. 1923, 195 L.Ed.2d 278 (2016)", "line": "Halo Elecs., Inc. v. Pulse Elecs., 136 S.Ct. 1923, 195 L.Ed.2d 278 (2016)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 72 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Hynix Semiconductor Inc. v. Rambus Inc., 609 F. Supp. 2d 951 (N.D. Cal. 2009)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "KSR Intern. Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398 (2007)", "line": "KSR Intern. Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398 (2007)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 38,40 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Fed. R. Civ. P. 50(a)", "detail": "rules" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3 }, "decisions": 7, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 2, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g08-cafc.first.docx", "sha256": "ea8f2288f7b983847b4e546c04606abfa16c7110bf194a8f31311b0741d111e0", "documentXmlSha256": "2e94bdd966b2feeca0e81a959fb9540ed78d0cc978c2488e269350b5a48aa743" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g08-cafc.careful.docx", "lines": 56, "keyEntries": 59, "keyPieces": 59, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 55, "found": 53, "exact": 48, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 59, "found": 56, "exact": 51, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 21, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Blitzsafe Texas, LLC v. Honda Motor Co., Case No. 2:15-cv-1274-JRG-RSP (E.D. Tex. Jan. 26, 2017)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Golden Bridge Tech. Inc. v. Apple, Inc., No. 5:12-cv-04882-PSG, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 67238 (N.D. Cal. May 14, 2014)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Graham v. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1 (1966)", "line": "Graham v. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1 (1966)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "lacks 20,23 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Halo Elecs., Inc. v. Pulse Elecs., 136 S.Ct. 1923, 195 L.Ed.2d 278 (2016)", "line": "Halo Elecs., Inc. v. Pulse Elecs., 136 S.Ct. 1923, 195 L.Ed.2d 278 (2016)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 72 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "KSR Intern. Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398 (2007)", "line": "KSR Intern. Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398 (2007)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks 38,40 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Fed. R. Civ. P. 50(a)", "detail": "rules" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3 }, "decisions": 7, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 2, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g08-cafc.careful.docx", "sha256": "cb1117e21f39045741975f5729e33c8d47e874f8adc729e3e29fe5594606789f", "documentXmlSha256": "072f4b6b4ee4127ebc8bd1a731398fd26fa10ea95c1d7463721a2965db81d5fc" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g08-cafc", "accept": [ "Hynix Semiconductor Inc. v. Rambus Inc., 609 F. Supp. 2d 951 (N.D. Cal. 2009)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Hynix Semiconductor Inc. v. Rambus Inc., 609 F. Supp. 2d 951 (N.D. Cal. 2009)", "key": "Hynix Semiconductor Inc. v. Rambus Inc., 609 F. Supp. 2d 951 (N.D. Cal. 2009)" } ], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g08-cafc.first.docx", "lines": 55, "keyEntries": 59, "keyPieces": 59, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 55, "found": 52, "exact": 47, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 59, "found": 55, "exact": 50, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 26, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Blitzsafe Texas, LLC v. Honda Motor Co., Case No. 2:15-cv-1274-JRG-RSP (E.D. Tex. Jan. 26, 2017)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Golden Bridge Tech. Inc. v. Apple, Inc., No. 5:12-cv-04882-PSG, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 67238 (N.D. Cal. May 14, 2014)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Graham v. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1 (1966)", "line": "Graham v. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1 (1966)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "lacks 20,23 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Halo Elecs., Inc. v. Pulse Elecs., 136 S.Ct. 1923, 195 L.Ed.2d 278 (2016)", "line": "Halo Elecs., Inc. v. Pulse Elecs., 136 S.Ct. 1923, 195 L.Ed.2d 278 (2016)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 72 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Hynix Semiconductor Inc. v. Rambus Inc., 609 F. Supp. 2d 951 (N.D. Cal. 2009)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "KSR Intern. Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398 (2007)", "line": "KSR Intern. Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398 (2007)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 38,40 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Fed. R. Civ. P. 50(a)", "detail": "rules" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 3, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 2, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 4, "modelShown": 3, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g08-cafc.first.docx", "sha256": "1ead9908157511618f590732f760ad53e696d59836ec6bf17305a66431d7f739", "documentXmlSha256": "2e94bdd966b2feeca0e81a959fb9540ed78d0cc978c2488e269350b5a48aa743" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g08-cafc.careful.docx", "lines": 58, "keyEntries": 59, "keyPieces": 59, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 55, "found": 54, "exact": 49, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 59, "found": 58, "exact": 53, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 11, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Golden Bridge Tech. Inc. v. Apple, Inc., No. 5:12-cv-04882-PSG, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 67238 (N.D. Cal. May 14, 2014)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Graham v. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1 (1966)", "line": "Graham v. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1 (1966)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 20,23 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Halo Elecs., Inc. v. Pulse Elecs., 136 S.Ct. 1923, 195 L.Ed.2d 278 (2016)", "line": "Halo Elecs., Inc. v. Pulse Elecs., 136 S.Ct. 1923, 195 L.Ed.2d 278 (2016)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 72 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "KSR Intern. Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398 (2007)", "line": "KSR Intern. Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398 (2007)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "lacks 38,40 (name only there)" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 2, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 4, "modelShown": 3, "trueAccepts": 3, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 4 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g08-cafc.careful.docx", "sha256": "78c48203d8e20672038ae5a2c60049def905b5e44ba2b676e3b585282956b3b7", "documentXmlSha256": "7ddf1a3670f97e0bd84e9718c7cd900582350c8e5f5dfd34d91017ea9b18ce40" }, "seconds": 6 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g08-cafc", "accept": [ "Hynix Semiconductor Inc. v. Rambus Inc., 609 F. Supp. 2d 951 (N.D. Cal. 2009)", "Rule 50", "Blitzsafe Texas, LLC v. Honda Motor Co., Case No. 2:15-cv-1274-JRG-RSP, at 3 (E.D. Tex. Jan. 26, 2017)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Hynix Semiconductor Inc. v. Rambus Inc., 609 F. Supp. 2d 951 (N.D. Cal. 2009)", "key": "Hynix Semiconductor Inc. v. Rambus Inc., 609 F. Supp. 2d 951 (N.D. Cal. 2009)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Rule 50", "key": "Fed. R. Civ. P. 50(a)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Blitzsafe Texas, LLC v. Honda Motor Co., Case No. 2:15-cv-1274-JRG-RSP, at 3 (E.D. Tex. Jan. 26, 2017)", "key": "Blitzsafe Texas, LLC v. Honda Motor Co., Case No. 2:15-cv-1274-JRG-RSP (E.D. Tex. Jan. 26, 2017)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Section 287" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g09-ca11-private", "task": { "id": "g09-ca11-private", "source": "grow-fed-appeals/ca11-20-10462-teleperformance-appellee.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US-CA11", "tags": [], "why": "private-party circuit brief, small table (20)" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g09-ca11-private.first.docx", "lines": 21, "keyEntries": 20, "keyPieces": 20, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 14, "found": 14, "exact": 14, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 20, "found": 20, "exact": 20, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 0, "weightedScore": 0, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 0, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 0, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g09-ca11-private.first.docx", "sha256": "e2d7512f8fe984865fe2e2b50b8d3fa0adaff5eddf3c8f64f78deb68b58997ce", "documentXmlSha256": "cc57896f56e5438c27305c05c75d93819bb5f222e05f2455d0d9adc36622c895" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g09-ca11-private.careful.docx", "lines": 21, "keyEntries": 20, "keyPieces": 20, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 14, "found": 14, "exact": 14, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 20, "found": 20, "exact": 20, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 0, "weightedScore": 0, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 0, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 0, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g09-ca11-private.careful.docx", "sha256": "2576f63db40b7a01cb4f6151a8e0b731dc236b39557cd8b28c2581ad42623e41", "documentXmlSha256": "cc57896f56e5438c27305c05c75d93819bb5f222e05f2455d0d9adc36622c895" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g09-ca11-private", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g09-ca11-private.first.docx", "lines": 21, "keyEntries": 20, "keyPieces": 20, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 14, "found": 14, "exact": 14, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 20, "found": 20, "exact": 20, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 0, "weightedScore": 0, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 0, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 0, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g09-ca11-private.first.docx", "sha256": "7a90b62ddfdca4bb888fdffe7bf1a95b604e9bc7a3a0a4ea288bc4b13b8e8ab6", "documentXmlSha256": "cc57896f56e5438c27305c05c75d93819bb5f222e05f2455d0d9adc36622c895" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g09-ca11-private.careful.docx", "lines": 21, "keyEntries": 20, "keyPieces": 20, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 14, "found": 14, "exact": 14, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 20, "found": 20, "exact": 20, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 0, "weightedScore": 0, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 0, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 0, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g09-ca11-private.careful.docx", "sha256": "54a04566d551c529a45aa3e74060c7345e7c8999a8bda8e7623d9544ba1c901c", "documentXmlSha256": "cc57896f56e5438c27305c05c75d93819bb5f222e05f2455d0d9adc36622c895" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g09-ca11-private", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } } }, { "id": "g10-ddc", "task": { "id": "g10-ddc", "source": "federal/ddc-epic-opp.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "federal-district", "jur": "US-DDC", "tags": [], "why": "district opposition, 86 entries, FOIA statutes and Fed. R. Crim. P. 6(e) missing from counsel's table" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g10-ddc.first.docx", "lines": 84, "keyEntries": 86, "keyPieces": 86, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 70, "found": 69, "exact": 66, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 6, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 85, "found": 82, "exact": 75, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 8, "weightedScore": 42, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 3 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 16, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 3 }, "corrections": 11, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Judicial Watch, Inc. v. Nat'l Archives & Records Admin., 876 F.3d 346 (D.C. Cir. 2017)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Nat\u2019l Archives & Records Admin. v. Favish, 541 U.S. 157 (2004)", "line": "Nat\u2019l Archives & Records Admin. v. Favish, 541 U.S. 157 (2004)", "lines": [ 50 ], "detail": "lacks 38 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "SafeCard Services, Inc. v. SEC, 926 F.2d 1197 (D.C. Cir. 1991)", "line": "SafeCard Services, Inc. v. SEC, 926 F.2d 1197 (D.C. Cir. 1991)", "lines": [ 57 ], "detail": "lacks 37 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69 ], "detail": "lacks 32 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Fed. R. Crim. P. 6(e)", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Exec. Order No. 11652, 37 Fed. Reg. 5209 (Mar. 8, 1972)", "detail": "regulations" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "DOJ Guide to the FOIA, Exemption 5", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69, 70 ], "detail": "lacks 47 (cited there) / adds 17,32 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "DOJ Guide to the FOIA, Exemption 7(A)", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69, 70 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (cited there) / adds 17,48,32 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "DOJ Guide to the FOIA, Litigation Considerations", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69, 70 ], "detail": "lacks 13,14 (cited there) / adds 17,48,32 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "RealClear Politics (May 1, 2019), https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2019/05/01/barr_mueller_letter_a_bit_snitty_probably_written_by_a_", "lines": [ 79 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Robert S. Mueller, III, Report on The Investigation Into Russian Interference In the 2016 Presidential Election (Mar. 2019), https://www.doc", "lines": [ 81 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Russia Investigation, N.Y. Times (May 29, 2019), https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/29/us/politics/mueller-transcript.html", "lines": [ 82 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "37 F.R. 5209", "lines": [ 71 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 8, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 11, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3, "wrongPage": 4, "cosmetic": 3, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 19, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 8, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 8, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g10-ddc.first.docx", "sha256": "42fe512db3ba2bf0f4052860cc71bb437b06d7e9c1d9c6fc82781667b461e505", "documentXmlSha256": "4c9724f07a34b5c7ca4edc976c2a55c44dd1f771a306c956e49b9c3d1a646c51" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g10-ddc.careful.docx", "lines": 84, "keyEntries": 86, "keyPieces": 86, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 70, "found": 69, "exact": 66, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 6, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 85, "found": 82, "exact": 75, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 8, "weightedScore": 42, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 3 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 16, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 3 }, "corrections": 11, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Judicial Watch, Inc. v. Nat'l Archives & Records Admin., 876 F.3d 346 (D.C. Cir. 2017)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Nat\u2019l Archives & Records Admin. v. Favish, 541 U.S. 157 (2004)", "line": "Nat\u2019l Archives & Records Admin. v. Favish, 541 U.S. 157 (2004)", "lines": [ 50 ], "detail": "lacks 38 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "SafeCard Services, Inc. v. SEC, 926 F.2d 1197 (D.C. Cir. 1991)", "line": "SafeCard Services, Inc. v. SEC, 926 F.2d 1197 (D.C. Cir. 1991)", "lines": [ 57 ], "detail": "lacks 37 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69 ], "detail": "lacks 32 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Fed. R. Crim. P. 6(e)", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Exec. Order No. 11652, 37 Fed. Reg. 5209 (Mar. 8, 1972)", "detail": "regulations" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "DOJ Guide to the FOIA, Exemption 5", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69, 70 ], "detail": "lacks 47 (cited there) / adds 17,32 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "DOJ Guide to the FOIA, Exemption 7(A)", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69, 70 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (cited there) / adds 17,48,32 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "DOJ Guide to the FOIA, Litigation Considerations", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69, 70 ], "detail": "lacks 13,14 (cited there) / adds 17,48,32 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "RealClear Politics (May 1, 2019), https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2019/05/01/barr_mueller_letter_a_bit_snitty_probably_written_by_a_", "lines": [ 79 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Robert S. Mueller, III, Report on The Investigation Into Russian Interference In the 2016 Presidential Election (Mar. 2019), https://www.doc", "lines": [ 81 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Russia Investigation, N.Y. Times (May 29, 2019), https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/29/us/politics/mueller-transcript.html", "lines": [ 82 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "37 F.R. 5209", "lines": [ 71 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 8, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 11, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3, "wrongPage": 4, "cosmetic": 3, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 19, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 8, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 8, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 8, "suggestionClicks": 8 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g10-ddc.careful.docx", "sha256": "d0f1dc2f3a5adda373510d26ba3baccde3e995d8b603ed8c018705413236f868", "documentXmlSha256": "4c9724f07a34b5c7ca4edc976c2a55c44dd1f771a306c956e49b9c3d1a646c51" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g10-ddc", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Letter from Sen. M. Hirono et al to DOJ Inspector General and Office of Professional Responsibility (April 30, 2019)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Kyle Cheney and Marianne Levine, Just 2 lawmakers have seen less-redacted Mueller report, Politico (Apr. 30, 2019)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Spencer S. Hsu, Andrew Miller, an Aide to Roger Stone, Will Testify Before Mueller Grand Jury After Months-Long Subpoena Fight, Wash. Post (May 29, 2019)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Manuel Roig-Franzia and Rosalind S. Helderman, Two More Associates of Roger Stone Testify Before Mueller Grand Jury, Wash. Post (Nov. 6, 2018)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Ronn Torossian, Grand Jury Witness: Mueller Probe Is a Witch Hunt, Newsmax (April 6, 2018)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Aaron Blake, Steve Bannon\u2019s mysterious grand jury subpoena, Wash. Post (Jan. 17, 2018)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Josh Gerstein, Manafort Real Estate Agent Testified Before Grand Jury in Russia Probe, Politico (Oct. 27, 2017)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Letter from Special Counsel Robert Mueller to Attorney General William Barr (March 27, 2019)" } ] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g10-ddc.first.docx", "lines": 84, "keyEntries": 86, "keyPieces": 86, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 70, "found": 69, "exact": 66, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 6, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 85, "found": 82, "exact": 75, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 8, "weightedScore": 42, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 3 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 16, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 3 }, "corrections": 11, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Judicial Watch, Inc. v. Nat'l Archives & Records Admin., 876 F.3d 346 (D.C. Cir. 2017)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Nat\u2019l Archives & Records Admin. v. Favish, 541 U.S. 157 (2004)", "line": "Nat\u2019l Archives & Records Admin. v. Favish, 541 U.S. 157 (2004)", "lines": [ 50 ], "detail": "lacks 38 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "SafeCard Services, Inc. v. SEC, 926 F.2d 1197 (D.C. Cir. 1991)", "line": "SafeCard Services, Inc. v. SEC, 926 F.2d 1197 (D.C. Cir. 1991)", "lines": [ 57 ], "detail": "lacks 37 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69 ], "detail": "lacks 32 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Fed. R. Crim. P. 6(e)", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Exec. Order No. 11652, 37 Fed. Reg. 5209 (Mar. 8, 1972)", "detail": "regulations" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "DOJ Guide to the FOIA, Exemption 5", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69, 70 ], "detail": "lacks 47 (cited there) / adds 17,32 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "DOJ Guide to the FOIA, Exemption 7(A)", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69, 70 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (cited there) / adds 17,48,32 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "DOJ Guide to the FOIA, Litigation Considerations", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69, 70 ], "detail": "lacks 13,14 (cited there) / adds 17,48,32 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "RealClear Politics (May 1, 2019), https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2019/05/01/barr_mueller_letter_a_bit_snitty_probably_written_by_a_", "lines": [ 79 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Robert S. Mueller, III, Report on The Investigation Into Russian Interference In the 2016 Presidential Election (Mar. 2019), https://www.doc", "lines": [ 81 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Russia Investigation, N.Y. Times (May 29, 2019), https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/29/us/politics/mueller-transcript.html", "lines": [ 82 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "37 F.R. 5209", "lines": [ 71 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 17, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2, "wrongPage": 4, "cosmetic": 3, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 27, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 8, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 9, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 17, "modelShown": 9, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g10-ddc.first.docx", "sha256": "90f71343b873ee5ab8ed93dda3834b772b4cf9afa892e90299ca66b6c4fc3382", "documentXmlSha256": "4c9724f07a34b5c7ca4edc976c2a55c44dd1f771a306c956e49b9c3d1a646c51" }, "seconds": 6 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g10-ddc.careful.docx", "lines": 85, "keyEntries": 86, "keyPieces": 86, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 70, "found": 69, "exact": 66, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 6, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 85, "found": 83, "exact": 76, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 7, "weightedScore": 37, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 3 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 16, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 3 }, "corrections": 10, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Judicial Watch, Inc. v. Nat'l Archives & Records Admin., 876 F.3d 346 (D.C. Cir. 2017)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Nat\u2019l Archives & Records Admin. v. Favish, 541 U.S. 157 (2004)", "line": "Nat\u2019l Archives & Records Admin. v. Favish, 541 U.S. 157 (2004)", "lines": [ 50 ], "detail": "lacks 38 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "SafeCard Services, Inc. v. SEC, 926 F.2d 1197 (D.C. Cir. 1991)", "line": "SafeCard Services, Inc. v. SEC, 926 F.2d 1197 (D.C. Cir. 1991)", "lines": [ 57 ], "detail": "lacks 37 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69 ], "detail": "lacks 32 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Exec. Order No. 11652, 37 Fed. Reg. 5209 (Mar. 8, 1972)", "detail": "regulations" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "DOJ Guide to the FOIA, Exemption 5", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69, 70 ], "detail": "lacks 47 (cited there) / adds 17,32 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "DOJ Guide to the FOIA, Exemption 7(A)", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69, 70 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (cited there) / adds 17,48,32 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "DOJ Guide to the FOIA, Litigation Considerations", "line": "5 U.S.C. \u00a7 552(a)(8)(A)(i)", "lines": [ 69, 70 ], "detail": "lacks 13,14 (cited there) / adds 17,48,32 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "RealClear Politics (May 1, 2019), https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2019/05/01/barr_mueller_letter_a_bit_snitty_probably_written_by_a_", "lines": [ 80 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Robert S. Mueller, III, Report on The Investigation Into Russian Interference In the 2016 Presidential Election (Mar. 2019), https://www.doc", "lines": [ 82 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Russia Investigation, N.Y. Times (May 29, 2019), https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/29/us/politics/mueller-transcript.html", "lines": [ 83 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "37 F.R. 5209", "lines": [ 71 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 17, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2, "wrongPage": 4, "cosmetic": 3, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 27, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 8, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 9, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 17, "modelShown": 9, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 16, "suggestionClicks": 17 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g10-ddc.careful.docx", "sha256": "9f58d341c8620416392ef15bf285a06f26145819d2a701c344824b1494b64b9d", "documentXmlSha256": "f0fdadf9f51dc83e4bbd6833c943d55c3be8abd8694fc156adbef60a3c42962c" }, "seconds": 14 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g10-ddc", "accept": [ "Rule 6(e)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Rule 6(e)", "key": "Fed. R. Crim. P. 6(e)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Letter from Sen. M. Hirono et al to DOJ Inspector General and Office of Professional Responsibility (April 30, 2019)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Kyle Cheney and Marianne Levine, Just 2 lawmakers have seen less-redacted Mueller report, Politico (Apr. 30, 2019)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Spencer S. Hsu, Andrew Miller, an Aide to Roger Stone, Will Testify Before Mueller Grand Jury After Months-Long Subpoena Fight, Wash. Post (May 29, 2019)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Manuel Roig-Franzia and Rosalind S. Helderman, Two More Associates of Roger Stone Testify Before Mueller Grand Jury, Wash. Post (Nov. 6, 2018)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Ronn Torossian, Grand Jury Witness: Mueller Probe Is a Witch Hunt, Newsmax (April 6, 2018)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Aaron Blake, Steve Bannon\u2019s mysterious grand jury subpoena, Wash. Post (Jan. 17, 2018)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Josh Gerstein, Manafort Real Estate Agent Testified Before Grand Jury in Russia Probe, Politico (Oct. 27, 2017)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Letter from Special Counsel Robert Mueller to Attorney General William Barr (March 27, 2019)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Jordyn Hermani, Trump calls Wray\u2019s anti-spying remarks William Barr\u2019s Testimony Before the Senate Appropriations Subcommittee on Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies, CNN Newsroom (Apr. 10, 2019, 10:30 AM)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "http://edition.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1904/10/cnr.04.html" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Richard L. Hansen, All the Mistakes Mueller Made in Declining to Prosecute Donald Trump Jr., Slate (Apr. 18, 2019, 1:55 PM)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Jessica Kwong, Why Mueller Didn\u2019t Indict Donald Trump Jr. is a \u2018Mystery,\u2019 Given \u2018Montage of Evidence Against Him\u2019: Democratic Senator, Newsweek (Apr. 19, 2019, 11:39 AM)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/oip/legacy/2014/07/23/litigation-considerations.pdf" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "U.S. v. Manafort, 17-cr-201, Dkt. # 460" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Paul Sperry, \u2018Scorched Earth\u2019: Mueller\u2019s Targets Speak Out, RealClear Investigations (June 6, 2019)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "BuzzFeed Inc. v. U.S. Dep\u2019t of Ed., 18-cv-01535-CRC, Dkt. # 24 (June 13, 2019) (same)." } ] } } } }, { "id": "g11-nysd-mdl", "task": { "id": "g11-nysd-mdl", "source": "grow-fed-district/nysd-03-md-01570-sj.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "federal-district", "jur": "US-SDNY", "tags": [], "why": "MDL summary-judgment brief; earlier decisions in the same MDL" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g11-nysd-mdl.first.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 36, "keyPieces": 36, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 29, "found": 28, "exact": 28, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 35, "found": 33, "exact": 33, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 14, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "In re Terrorist Attacks on Sept. 11, 2001, 714 F.3d 659 (2d Cir. 2013)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "J. Risen & B. Weiser, U.S. Officials Say Aid for Terrorists Came Through Two Persian Gulf Nations, N.Y. Times (July 8, 1999)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "718 F. Supp. 2d 456 (S.D.N.Y. 2010)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 2, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g11-nysd-mdl.first.docx", "sha256": "ebef34fd03da1501835104cc482bb60cd9b7bf609b8e2a880f040f1836b103c9", "documentXmlSha256": "c862c95b3c7b441adcc0a07a8e685ca37e818904f2154267958b509aa1ba0371" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g11-nysd-mdl.careful.docx", "lines": 34, "keyEntries": 36, "keyPieces": 36, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 29, "found": 28, "exact": 28, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 35, "found": 34, "exact": 34, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 9, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "In re Terrorist Attacks on Sept. 11, 2001, 714 F.3d 659 (2d Cir. 2013)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "718 F. Supp. 2d 456 (S.D.N.Y. 2010)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 2, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 2 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g11-nysd-mdl.careful.docx", "sha256": "85df4da9c4243197842026b87d94c45255e9bce5be11f7e729268d6a74096af9", "documentXmlSha256": "71f4f0beeab6631592fc85a3afd564b4d258f8456c68d8dcb59c1dc2ee189516" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g11-nysd-mdl", "accept": [ "J. Risen & B. Weiser, U.S. Officials Say Aid for Terrorists Came Through Two Persian Gulf Nations, N.Y. Times (July 8, 1999)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "J. Risen & B. Weiser, U.S. Officials Say Aid for Terrorists Came Through Two Persian Gulf Nations, N.Y. Times (July 8, 1999)", "key": "J. Risen & B. Weiser, U.S. Officials Say Aid for Terrorists Came Through Two Persian Gulf Nations, N.Y. Times (July 8, 1999)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Letter from S. Cottreau to S. Carter (Sept. 10, 2018)" } ] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g11-nysd-mdl.first.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 36, "keyPieces": 36, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 29, "found": 28, "exact": 28, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 35, "found": 33, "exact": 33, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 14, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "In re Terrorist Attacks on Sept. 11, 2001, 714 F.3d 659 (2d Cir. 2013)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "J. Risen & B. Weiser, U.S. Officials Say Aid for Terrorists Came Through Two Persian Gulf Nations, N.Y. Times (July 8, 1999)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "718 F. Supp. 2d 456 (S.D.N.Y. 2010)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 2, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g11-nysd-mdl.first.docx", "sha256": "9b7a64428b496c317b0c4316b20c1ad4da80882237c78c72227bce52b91582e7", "documentXmlSha256": "c862c95b3c7b441adcc0a07a8e685ca37e818904f2154267958b509aa1ba0371" }, "seconds": 5 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g11-nysd-mdl.careful.docx", "lines": 34, "keyEntries": 36, "keyPieces": 36, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 29, "found": 28, "exact": 28, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 35, "found": 34, "exact": 34, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 9, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "In re Terrorist Attacks on Sept. 11, 2001, 714 F.3d 659 (2d Cir. 2013)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "718 F. Supp. 2d 456 (S.D.N.Y. 2010)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 2, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 2 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g11-nysd-mdl.careful.docx", "sha256": "e4792d9c822c047682b8361f3b3987d42a90d9c164a54d9099ac88aa9707c8d6", "documentXmlSha256": "71f4f0beeab6631592fc85a3afd564b4d258f8456c68d8dcb59c1dc2ee189516" }, "seconds": 7 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g11-nysd-mdl", "accept": [ "J. Risen & B. Weiser, U.S. Officials Say Aid for Terrorists Came Through Two Persian Gulf Nations, N.Y. Times (July 8, 1999)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "J. Risen & B. Weiser, U.S. Officials Say Aid for Terrorists Came Through Two Persian Gulf Nations, N.Y. Times (July 8, 1999)", "key": "J. Risen & B. Weiser, U.S. Officials Say Aid for Terrorists Came Through Two Persian Gulf Nations, N.Y. Times (July 8, 1999)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Letter from S. Cottreau to S. Carter (Sept. 10, 2018)" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g12-vaed", "task": { "id": "g12-vaed", "source": "grow-fed-district/vaed-17-cv-00521-opposition.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "federal-district", "jur": "US-EDVA", "tags": [], "chatbot": true, "why": "district opposition, 51 entries, WL cites" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g12-vaed.first.docx", "lines": 53, "keyEntries": 51, "keyPieces": 51, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 45, "found": 45, "exact": 40, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 51, "found": 51, "exact": 45, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 5, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 24, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 3, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 12, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Baughman v. Walt Disney World Co., 685 F.3d 1132 (9th Cir. 2012)", "line": "Baughman v. Walt Disney World Co., 685 F.3d 1132 (9th Cir. 2012)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 2 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 2" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Daniels v. Arcade, L.P., 477 Fed. Appx. 125 (4th Cir. 2012)", "line": "Daniels v. Arcade, L.P., 477 Fed. Appx. 125 (4th Cir. 2012)", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Molski v. M.J. Cable, Inc., 481 F.3d 724 (9th Cir. 2007)", "line": "Molski v. M.J. Cable, Inc., 481 F.3d 724 (9th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 15" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Nanni v. Aberdeen Marketplace, Inc., No. 16-1638, 2017 WL 6521299 (4th Cir. Dec. 21, 2017)", "line": "Nanni v. Aberdeen Marketplace, Inc., No. 16-1638, 2017 WL 6521299 (4th Cir. Dec. 21, 2017)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "lacks 6,8 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Native American Arts, Inc. v. Peter Stone Co., U.S.A., Inc., 222 F. Supp. 3d 643 (N.D. Ill", "line": "Native American Arts, Inc. v. Peter Stone Co., U.S.A., Inc., 222 F. Supp. 3d 643 (N.D. Ill. 2016)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "lacks 12 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "42 U.S.C. \u00a7 12182(a)", "line": "42 U.S.C. \u00a7 12182(a)", "lines": [ 47 ], "detail": "lacks 13 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Blue Apron LLC No., 2017 WL 5186354 (D.N.H. Nov. 8, 2017)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "'No.,' fragment" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 3, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 3 }, "decisions": 7, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g12-vaed.first.docx", "sha256": "f79591afb815e72b408ce09e854c931eb27d76ebd7fada26c71dfa649a9c4f1f", "documentXmlSha256": "49b8a2bc8fec992fa3e6302e21ffe45cb327de29cfaa2b7f1f184fa4a27d9b15" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g12-vaed.careful.docx", "lines": 53, "keyEntries": 51, "keyPieces": 51, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 45, "found": 45, "exact": 40, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 51, "found": 51, "exact": 45, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 5, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 24, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 3, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 12, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Baughman v. Walt Disney World Co., 685 F.3d 1132 (9th Cir. 2012)", "line": "Baughman v. Walt Disney World Co., 685 F.3d 1132 (9th Cir. 2012)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 2 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 2" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Daniels v. Arcade, L.P., 477 Fed. Appx. 125 (4th Cir. 2012)", "line": "Daniels v. Arcade, L.P., 477 Fed. Appx. 125 (4th Cir. 2012)", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Molski v. M.J. Cable, Inc., 481 F.3d 724 (9th Cir. 2007)", "line": "Molski v. M.J. Cable, Inc., 481 F.3d 724 (9th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 15" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Nanni v. Aberdeen Marketplace, Inc., No. 16-1638, 2017 WL 6521299 (4th Cir. Dec. 21, 2017)", "line": "Nanni v. Aberdeen Marketplace, Inc., No. 16-1638, 2017 WL 6521299 (4th Cir. Dec. 21, 2017)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "lacks 6,8 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Native American Arts, Inc. v. Peter Stone Co., U.S.A., Inc., 222 F. Supp. 3d 643 (N.D. Ill", "line": "Native American Arts, Inc. v. Peter Stone Co., U.S.A., Inc., 222 F. Supp. 3d 643 (N.D. Ill. 2016)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "lacks 12 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "42 U.S.C. \u00a7 12182(a)", "line": "42 U.S.C. \u00a7 12182(a)", "lines": [ 47 ], "detail": "lacks 13 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Blue Apron LLC No., 2017 WL 5186354 (D.N.H. Nov. 8, 2017)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "'No.,' fragment" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 3, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 3 }, "decisions": 7, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g12-vaed.careful.docx", "sha256": "2bd5872a450b3217720bb01985c5b595abac1639cbbdca8f3a9498646719031a", "documentXmlSha256": "49b8a2bc8fec992fa3e6302e21ffe45cb327de29cfaa2b7f1f184fa4a27d9b15" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g12-vaed", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g12-vaed.first.docx", "lines": 53, "keyEntries": 51, "keyPieces": 51, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 45, "found": 45, "exact": 40, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 51, "found": 51, "exact": 45, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 5, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 24, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 3, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 12, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Baughman v. Walt Disney World Co., 685 F.3d 1132 (9th Cir. 2012)", "line": "Baughman v. Walt Disney World Co., 685 F.3d 1132 (9th Cir. 2012)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 2 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 2" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Daniels v. Arcade, L.P., 477 Fed. Appx. 125 (4th Cir. 2012)", "line": "Daniels v. Arcade, L.P., 477 Fed. Appx. 125 (4th Cir. 2012)", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Molski v. M.J. Cable, Inc., 481 F.3d 724 (9th Cir. 2007)", "line": "Molski v. M.J. Cable, Inc., 481 F.3d 724 (9th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 15" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Nanni v. Aberdeen Marketplace, Inc., No. 16-1638, 2017 WL 6521299 (4th Cir. Dec. 21, 2017)", "line": "Nanni v. Aberdeen Marketplace, Inc., No. 16-1638, 2017 WL 6521299 (4th Cir. Dec. 21, 2017)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "lacks 6,8 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Native American Arts, Inc. v. Peter Stone Co., U.S.A., Inc., 222 F. Supp. 3d 643 (N.D. Ill", "line": "Native American Arts, Inc. v. Peter Stone Co., U.S.A., Inc., 222 F. Supp. 3d 643 (N.D. Ill. 2016)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "lacks 12 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "42 U.S.C. \u00a7 12182(a)", "line": "42 U.S.C. \u00a7 12182(a)", "lines": [ 47 ], "detail": "lacks 13 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Blue Apron LLC No., 2017 WL 5186354 (D.N.H. Nov. 8, 2017)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "'No.,' fragment" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 3, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 3 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g12-vaed.first.docx", "sha256": "fa4291c9453d532b0aee4330565b03da29790275c38bc51d33ab9a03527913b4", "documentXmlSha256": "49b8a2bc8fec992fa3e6302e21ffe45cb327de29cfaa2b7f1f184fa4a27d9b15" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g12-vaed.careful.docx", "lines": 53, "keyEntries": 51, "keyPieces": 51, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 45, "found": 45, "exact": 40, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 51, "found": 51, "exact": 45, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 5, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 24, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 3, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 12, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Baughman v. Walt Disney World Co., 685 F.3d 1132 (9th Cir. 2012)", "line": "Baughman v. Walt Disney World Co., 685 F.3d 1132 (9th Cir. 2012)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 2 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 2" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Daniels v. Arcade, L.P., 477 Fed. Appx. 125 (4th Cir. 2012)", "line": "Daniels v. Arcade, L.P., 477 Fed. Appx. 125 (4th Cir. 2012)", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Molski v. M.J. Cable, Inc., 481 F.3d 724 (9th Cir. 2007)", "line": "Molski v. M.J. Cable, Inc., 481 F.3d 724 (9th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 15" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Nanni v. Aberdeen Marketplace, Inc., No. 16-1638, 2017 WL 6521299 (4th Cir. Dec. 21, 2017)", "line": "Nanni v. Aberdeen Marketplace, Inc., No. 16-1638, 2017 WL 6521299 (4th Cir. Dec. 21, 2017)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "lacks 6,8 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Native American Arts, Inc. v. Peter Stone Co., U.S.A., Inc., 222 F. Supp. 3d 643 (N.D. Ill", "line": "Native American Arts, Inc. v. Peter Stone Co., U.S.A., Inc., 222 F. Supp. 3d 643 (N.D. Ill. 2016)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "lacks 12 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "42 U.S.C. \u00a7 12182(a)", "line": "42 U.S.C. \u00a7 12182(a)", "lines": [ 47 ], "detail": "lacks 13 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Blue Apron LLC No., 2017 WL 5186354 (D.N.H. Nov. 8, 2017)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "'No.,' fragment" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 3, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 3 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g12-vaed.careful.docx", "sha256": "5874942d9cabd2475956a402045be2d0378c89553f7363bd5e61bcad2f3f2db8", "documentXmlSha256": "49b8a2bc8fec992fa3e6302e21ffe45cb327de29cfaa2b7f1f184fa4a27d9b15" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g12-vaed", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "4278 (7th Cir. Dec. 30, 2016)" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g13-mi-sc", "task": { "id": "g13-mi-sc", "source": "fmt-states/mi-sc-168159-appellant.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "MI", "tags": [ "state cite forms" ], "chatbot": true, "why": "Michigan forms (MCL, Const 1963, art 1, \u00a7 17) the engine does not key" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g13-mi-sc.first.docx", "lines": 61, "keyEntries": 66, "keyPieces": 66, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 45, "found": 35, "exact": 32, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 10, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 65, "found": 55, "exact": 48, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 10, "wrongPages": 5, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 16, "weightedScore": 78, "byType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 5, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 50, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 20, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 16, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Miller v Alabama, 567 US 460; 132 S Ct 2455; 183 L Ed 2d 407 (2012)", "line": "Miller v. Alabama, 567 US 460 (2012)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "lacks 8,9,18,33,36,38,39 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Abbatoy, unpublished opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued July 25, 2024 (Docket No. 364852)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Armour, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued September 20, 2018 (Docket No. 337434)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "People v Bennett, 335 Mich App 409; 966 NW2d 768 (2021)", "line": "People v Bennett, 335 Mich App 409; 966 NW2d 768 (2021)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks 8,39 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Granger, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued August 4, 2022 (Docket No. 355477)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Jackson, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued May 9, 2024 (Docket No. 361540)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Skinner, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued February 21, 2013 (Docket No. 306903)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "People v Taylor, 510 Mich 112; 987 NW2d 132 (2022)", "line": "People v Taylor, 510 Mich 112; 987 NW2d 132 (2022)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 19 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Taylor, ___ Mich ___; ___ NW3d ___ (2025) (Docket Nos. 166428 and 166654)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Taylor, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued September 22, 2016 (Docket No. 325834)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Washington, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued July 25, 2019 (Docket No. 343987)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Wheeler, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued December 26, 2024 (Docket Nos. 366696 and 370002)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v Wilson, opinion of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, issued August 2, 2022 (Case No. 16", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Const 1963, art 1, \u00a7 17", "line": "Const 1963, art 1, \u00a7 17", "lines": [ 39 ], "detail": "lacks 1 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "US Const, Am V", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. V", "lines": [ 36 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "US Const, Am XIV", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. XIV", "lines": [ 38 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "MCL 769.25", "line": "MCL 769.25", "lines": [ 49 ], "detail": "lacks 31 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "1985 PA 87", "lines": [ 35 ], "detail": "not readable as a citation" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 3, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 14, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 10, "wrongPage": 4 }, "decisions": 17, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 10, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g13-mi-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "f0423c7750f73fcadf10f74f16c3b40d8e7b14544b61b02d591c8e25ef8ed0f1", "documentXmlSha256": "5ac25f65314798000a498c9e827cb18332b26b194377a6e406250bf678b4d3f4" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g13-mi-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 61, "keyEntries": 66, "keyPieces": 66, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 45, "found": 35, "exact": 32, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 10, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 65, "found": 55, "exact": 48, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 10, "wrongPages": 5, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 16, "weightedScore": 78, "byType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 5, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 50, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 20, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 16, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Miller v Alabama, 567 US 460; 132 S Ct 2455; 183 L Ed 2d 407 (2012)", "line": "Miller v. Alabama, 567 US 460 (2012)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "lacks 8,9,18,33,36,38,39 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Abbatoy, unpublished opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued July 25, 2024 (Docket No. 364852)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Armour, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued September 20, 2018 (Docket No. 337434)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "People v Bennett, 335 Mich App 409; 966 NW2d 768 (2021)", "line": "People v Bennett, 335 Mich App 409; 966 NW2d 768 (2021)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks 8,39 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Granger, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued August 4, 2022 (Docket No. 355477)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Jackson, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued May 9, 2024 (Docket No. 361540)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Skinner, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued February 21, 2013 (Docket No. 306903)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "People v Taylor, 510 Mich 112; 987 NW2d 132 (2022)", "line": "People v Taylor, 510 Mich 112; 987 NW2d 132 (2022)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 19 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Taylor, ___ Mich ___; ___ NW3d ___ (2025) (Docket Nos. 166428 and 166654)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Taylor, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued September 22, 2016 (Docket No. 325834)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Washington, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued July 25, 2019 (Docket No. 343987)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Wheeler, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued December 26, 2024 (Docket Nos. 366696 and 370002)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v Wilson, opinion of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, issued August 2, 2022 (Case No. 16", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Const 1963, art 1, \u00a7 17", "line": "Const 1963, art 1, \u00a7 17", "lines": [ 39 ], "detail": "lacks 1 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "US Const, Am V", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. V", "lines": [ 36 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "US Const, Am XIV", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. XIV", "lines": [ 38 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "MCL 769.25", "line": "MCL 769.25", "lines": [ 49 ], "detail": "lacks 31 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "1985 PA 87", "lines": [ 35 ], "detail": "not readable as a citation" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 3, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 14, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 10, "wrongPage": 4 }, "decisions": 17, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 10, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g13-mi-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "b14b6ee1db996355dc320944e6ef49210ed2e89f315640ed73374591a85088fc", "documentXmlSha256": "5ac25f65314798000a498c9e827cb18332b26b194377a6e406250bf678b4d3f4" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g13-mi-sc", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g13-mi-sc.first.docx", "lines": 61, "keyEntries": 66, "keyPieces": 66, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 45, "found": 35, "exact": 32, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 10, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 65, "found": 55, "exact": 48, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 10, "wrongPages": 5, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 16, "weightedScore": 78, "byType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 5, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 50, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 20, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 16, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Miller v Alabama, 567 US 460; 132 S Ct 2455; 183 L Ed 2d 407 (2012)", "line": "Miller v. Alabama, 567 US 460 (2012)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "lacks 8,9,18,33,36,38,39 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Abbatoy, unpublished opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued July 25, 2024 (Docket No. 364852)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Armour, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued September 20, 2018 (Docket No. 337434)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "People v Bennett, 335 Mich App 409; 966 NW2d 768 (2021)", "line": "People v Bennett, 335 Mich App 409; 966 NW2d 768 (2021)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks 8,39 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Granger, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued August 4, 2022 (Docket No. 355477)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Jackson, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued May 9, 2024 (Docket No. 361540)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Skinner, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued February 21, 2013 (Docket No. 306903)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "People v Taylor, 510 Mich 112; 987 NW2d 132 (2022)", "line": "People v Taylor, 510 Mich 112; 987 NW2d 132 (2022)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 19 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Taylor, ___ Mich ___; ___ NW3d ___ (2025) (Docket Nos. 166428 and 166654)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Taylor, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued September 22, 2016 (Docket No. 325834)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Washington, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued July 25, 2019 (Docket No. 343987)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Wheeler, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued December 26, 2024 (Docket Nos. 366696 and 370002)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v Wilson, opinion of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, issued August 2, 2022 (Case No. 16", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Const 1963, art 1, \u00a7 17", "line": "Const 1963, art 1, \u00a7 17", "lines": [ 39 ], "detail": "lacks 1 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "US Const, Am V", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. V", "lines": [ 36 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "US Const, Am XIV", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. XIV", "lines": [ 38 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "MCL 769.25", "line": "MCL 769.25", "lines": [ 49 ], "detail": "lacks 31 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "1985 PA 87", "lines": [ 35 ], "detail": "not readable as a citation" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 3, "surfaced": 12, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 4 }, "decisions": 11, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 4, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 4, "modelShown": 4, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g13-mi-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "3859971cf7ae6938f0d091e6166ae9a147b1d6314874742b2327b0db88dd2324", "documentXmlSha256": "5ac25f65314798000a498c9e827cb18332b26b194377a6e406250bf678b4d3f4" }, "seconds": 6 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g13-mi-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 63, "keyEntries": 66, "keyPieces": 66, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 45, "found": 37, "exact": 33, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 10, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 65, "found": 57, "exact": 49, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 8, "wrongPages": 5, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 14, "weightedScore": 68, "byType": { "missing": 8, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 5, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 40, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 20, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 14, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Miller v Alabama, 567 US 460; 132 S Ct 2455; 183 L Ed 2d 407 (2012)", "line": "Miller v. Alabama, 567 US 460 (2012)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "lacks 8,9,18,33,36,38,39 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Abbatoy, unpublished opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued July 25, 2024 (Docket No. 364852)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Armour, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued September 20, 2018 (Docket No. 337434)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "People v Bennett, 335 Mich App 409; 966 NW2d 768 (2021)", "line": "People v Bennett, 335 Mich App 409; 966 NW2d 768 (2021)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks 8,39 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Granger, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued August 4, 2022 (Docket No. 355477)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Jackson, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued May 9, 2024 (Docket No. 361540)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Skinner, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued February 21, 2013 (Docket No. 306903)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "People v Taylor, 510 Mich 112; 987 NW2d 132 (2022)", "line": "People v Taylor, 510 Mich 112; 987 NW2d 132 (2022)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 19 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Taylor, ___ Mich ___; ___ NW3d ___ (2025) (Docket Nos. 166428 and 166654)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Washington, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued July 25, 2019 (Docket No. 343987)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Wheeler, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued December 26, 2024 (Docket Nos. 366696 and 370002)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Const 1963, art 1, \u00a7 17", "line": "Const 1963, art 1, \u00a7 17", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "lacks 1 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "US Const, Am V", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. V", "lines": [ 38 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "US Const, Am XIV", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. XIV", "lines": [ 40 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "MCL 769.25", "line": "MCL 769.25", "lines": [ 51 ], "detail": "lacks 31 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "1985 PA 87", "lines": [ 37 ], "detail": "not readable as a citation" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 3, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 12, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 8, "wrongPage": 4 }, "decisions": 19, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 4, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 8, "suggestions": 4, "modelShown": 4, "trueAccepts": 2, "falseDismisses": 2, "suggestionClicks": 4 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g13-mi-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "1919419e034f74bb29bdd3ac3079d52f61c94b58f9cb50cf2a0faacce350b09f", "documentXmlSha256": "f39e5c64c1acf69496ef7fd1585c4dd853fdf38a98b3521d75925f17cccb4c07" }, "seconds": 8 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g13-mi-sc", "accept": [ "People v Taylor, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued September 22, 2016 (Docket No. 325834)", "United States v Wilson, opinion of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, issued August 2, 2022 (Case No. 16-20460), p 11 (A-946);" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "People v Taylor, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued September 22, 2016 (Docket No. 325834)", "key": "People v Taylor, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued September 22, 2016 (Docket No. 325834)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "United States v Wilson, opinion of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, issued August 2, 2022 (Case No. 16-20460), p 11 (A-946);", "key": "United States v Wilson, opinion of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, issued August 2, 2022 (Case No. 16" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Evidence (8th ed.), \u00a7 336" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "People v Williams, 43 Cal 4th 584, 615" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g14-mt-stale", "task": { "id": "g14-mt-stale", "source": "grow-state-supreme-b/mt-sc-da22-0667-amicus-scholars.pdf", "key": "gold", "keepTable": true, "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "MT", "tags": [ "stale table kept", "amicus", "appendix" ], "why": "printed table stale by +1/+2, kept; the engine reads its appendix as body" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g14-mt-stale.first.docx", "lines": 66, "keyEntries": 69, "keyPieces": 69, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 46, "found": 45, "exact": 43, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 17, "found": 17, "exact": 17, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 6, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 69, "found": 66, "exact": 64, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 19, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Montana Democratic Party v. Jacobsen 2022 MT 184, 410 Mont. 114, 518 P.3d 58", "line": "Mont. Democratic Party v. Jacobsen, 2022 MT 184, 410 Mont. 114, 518 P.3d 58", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks 6,12,15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Pick v. Nelson 528 N.W.2d 309 (Neb. 1995)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Larry M. Elison & Fritz Snyder, The Montana State Constitution: A Reference Guide (2001)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Montana Constitutional Convention Proceedings, Volume III (1972)", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g14-mt-stale.first.docx", "sha256": "42743a33dd4b1bca5d5fbcfc4f665ccb3ad7d4742104fa900c8eb7e68d7e4896", "documentXmlSha256": "47aea7e93b851a0c97d4c7a066d578fad7da51f3f620fdfa746664b93a32636f" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g14-mt-stale.careful.docx", "lines": 67, "keyEntries": 69, "keyPieces": 69, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 46, "found": 45, "exact": 43, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 17, "found": 17, "exact": 17, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 6, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 69, "found": 67, "exact": 65, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 14, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Montana Democratic Party v. Jacobsen 2022 MT 184, 410 Mont. 114, 518 P.3d 58", "line": "Mont. Democratic Party v. Jacobsen, 2022 MT 184, 410 Mont. 114, 518 P.3d 58", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks 6,12,15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Pick v. Nelson 528 N.W.2d 309 (Neb. 1995)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Montana Constitutional Convention Proceedings, Volume III (1972)", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g14-mt-stale.careful.docx", "sha256": "3aea9a16786a71c3f30229399e5059253a540c852a26e8bd76eee30905e9c380", "documentXmlSha256": "ab0e097213cba58563047fd612e705dc9902ada8d1b3999ac3b643c4911ff613" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g14-mt-stale", "accept": [ "Larry M. Elison & Fritz Snyder, The Montana State Constitution: A Reference Guide (2001)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Larry M. Elison & Fritz Snyder, The Montana State Constitution: A Reference Guide (2001)", "key": "Larry M. Elison & Fritz Snyder, The Montana State Constitution: A Reference Guide (2001)" } ], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g14-mt-stale.first.docx", "lines": 66, "keyEntries": 69, "keyPieces": 69, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 46, "found": 45, "exact": 43, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 17, "found": 17, "exact": 17, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 6, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 69, "found": 66, "exact": 64, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 19, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Montana Democratic Party v. Jacobsen 2022 MT 184, 410 Mont. 114, 518 P.3d 58", "line": "Mont. Democratic Party v. Jacobsen, 2022 MT 184, 410 Mont. 114, 518 P.3d 58", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks 6,12,15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Pick v. Nelson 528 N.W.2d 309 (Neb. 1995)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Larry M. Elison & Fritz Snyder, The Montana State Constitution: A Reference Guide (2001)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Montana Constitutional Convention Proceedings, Volume III (1972)", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 1, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g14-mt-stale.first.docx", "sha256": "1af842b50421098dc799b9d5b8bffdbc0e0034241bee7535bdfa6c2d4c6ae82e", "documentXmlSha256": "47aea7e93b851a0c97d4c7a066d578fad7da51f3f620fdfa746664b93a32636f" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g14-mt-stale.careful.docx", "lines": 67, "keyEntries": 69, "keyPieces": 69, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 46, "found": 45, "exact": 43, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 17, "found": 17, "exact": 17, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 6, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 69, "found": 67, "exact": 65, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 14, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Montana Democratic Party v. Jacobsen 2022 MT 184, 410 Mont. 114, 518 P.3d 58", "line": "Mont. Democratic Party v. Jacobsen, 2022 MT 184, 410 Mont. 114, 518 P.3d 58", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks 6,12,15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Pick v. Nelson 528 N.W.2d 309 (Neb. 1995)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Montana Constitutional Convention Proceedings, Volume III (1972)", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 1, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 2 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g14-mt-stale.careful.docx", "sha256": "5fa0c299449cbcd0319e59e47283786c0dd21b69a032a87d71d4146a60240f73", "documentXmlSha256": "ab0e097213cba58563047fd612e705dc9902ada8d1b3999ac3b643c4911ff613" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g14-mt-stale", "accept": [ "Larry M. Elison & Fritz Snyder, The Montana State Constitution: A Reference Guide (2001)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Larry M. Elison & Fritz Snyder, The Montana State Constitution: A Reference Guide (2001)", "key": "Larry M. Elison & Fritz Snyder, The Montana State Constitution: A Reference Guide (2001)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Mont. Const. Conv. Proc. Vol. III 402 (1972) (statement of Delegate McKeon)." } ] } } } }, { "id": "g15-tx-sc", "task": { "id": "g15-tx-sc", "source": "grow-state-supreme-a/tx-sc-17-0527-westworth-respondent.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "TX", "tags": [], "why": "Texas Supreme Court respondent brief" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g15-tx-sc.first.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 27, "keyPieces": 27, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 17, "found": 17, "exact": 14, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 5, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 24, "found": 24, "exact": 21, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 3, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 3, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 3, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 15, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City of Krum v. Rice, No. 17-0081, 2017 WL 6390973 (Tex. Dec. 15, 2017)", "line": "City of Krum v. Rice, No. 17-0081, 2017 WL 6390973 (Tex. Dec. 15, 2017)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "lacks 12 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hunt v. Wash. State Apple Advert. Comm'n, 432 U.S. 333, 97 S. Ct. 2434, 53 L. Ed. 2d 383 (", "line": "Hunt v. Wash. State Apple Advertising Commission. 432 U.S. 333, 97 S. Ct. 2434, 53 L. Ed. 2d 383 (1977)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 17,19 (name only there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "City of Westworth Vill. v. Texas Voices for Reason & Justice, Inc., 520 S.W.3d 652 (Tex. App.\u2014Fort Worth 2017, pet. pending)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Act of May 27, 2011, 82d Leg., R.S., ch. 203", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Act of May 22, 2017, 85th Leg., R.S., ch. 150", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Act of May 29, 2017, 85th Leg., R.S., ch. 997", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "cosmetic": 1, "wrongAuthority": 3 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g15-tx-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "764d72bed5246305a5efc369fd972ab4d324050dfde8e8a40fbcafbdc3508fd2", "documentXmlSha256": "c97799056dd865d13e5fb6871aa786724c328e28c17227e54e0bd0ef1cc15a48" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g15-tx-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 27, "keyPieces": 27, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 17, "found": 17, "exact": 14, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 5, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 24, "found": 24, "exact": 21, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 3, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 3, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 3, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 15, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City of Krum v. Rice, No. 17-0081, 2017 WL 6390973 (Tex. Dec. 15, 2017)", "line": "City of Krum v. Rice, No. 17-0081, 2017 WL 6390973 (Tex. Dec. 15, 2017)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "lacks 12 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hunt v. Wash. State Apple Advert. Comm'n, 432 U.S. 333, 97 S. Ct. 2434, 53 L. Ed. 2d 383 (", "line": "Hunt v. Wash. State Apple Advertising Commission. 432 U.S. 333, 97 S. Ct. 2434, 53 L. Ed. 2d 383 (1977)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 17,19 (name only there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "City of Westworth Vill. v. Texas Voices for Reason & Justice, Inc., 520 S.W.3d 652 (Tex. App.\u2014Fort Worth 2017, pet. pending)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Act of May 27, 2011, 82d Leg., R.S., ch. 203", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Act of May 22, 2017, 85th Leg., R.S., ch. 150", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Act of May 29, 2017, 85th Leg., R.S., ch. 997", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "cosmetic": 1, "wrongAuthority": 3 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g15-tx-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "3236b0108a742356986d3ca41fafa714b553bd19279420e6524cd92a01d6a6d3", "documentXmlSha256": "c97799056dd865d13e5fb6871aa786724c328e28c17227e54e0bd0ef1cc15a48" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g15-tx-sc", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g15-tx-sc.first.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 27, "keyPieces": 27, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 17, "found": 17, "exact": 14, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 5, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 24, "found": 24, "exact": 21, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 3, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 3, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 3, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 15, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City of Krum v. Rice, No. 17-0081, 2017 WL 6390973 (Tex. Dec. 15, 2017)", "line": "City of Krum v. Rice, No. 17-0081, 2017 WL 6390973 (Tex. Dec. 15, 2017)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "lacks 12 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hunt v. Wash. State Apple Advert. Comm'n, 432 U.S. 333, 97 S. Ct. 2434, 53 L. Ed. 2d 383 (", "line": "Hunt v. Wash. State Apple Advertising Commission. 432 U.S. 333, 97 S. Ct. 2434, 53 L. Ed. 2d 383 (1977)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 17,19 (name only there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "City of Westworth Vill. v. Texas Voices for Reason & Justice, Inc., 520 S.W.3d 652 (Tex. App.\u2014Fort Worth 2017, pet. pending)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Act of May 27, 2011, 82d Leg., R.S., ch. 203", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Act of May 22, 2017, 85th Leg., R.S., ch. 150", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Act of May 29, 2017, 85th Leg., R.S., ch. 997", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "cosmetic": 1, "wrongAuthority": 3 }, "decisions": 11, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 7, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 7, "modelShown": 7, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g15-tx-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "fa850919302f2c99c7c722b48d049372e9286c8b18d2c4d7beecec42add8efdd", "documentXmlSha256": "c97799056dd865d13e5fb6871aa786724c328e28c17227e54e0bd0ef1cc15a48" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g15-tx-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 27, "keyPieces": 27, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 17, "found": 17, "exact": 14, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 5, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 24, "found": 24, "exact": 21, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 3, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 3, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 3, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 15, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City of Krum v. Rice, No. 17-0081, 2017 WL 6390973 (Tex. Dec. 15, 2017)", "line": "City of Krum v. Rice, No. 17-0081, 2017 WL 6390973 (Tex. Dec. 15, 2017)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "lacks 12 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hunt v. Wash. State Apple Advert. Comm'n, 432 U.S. 333, 97 S. Ct. 2434, 53 L. Ed. 2d 383 (", "line": "Hunt v. Wash. State Apple Advertising Commission. 432 U.S. 333, 97 S. Ct. 2434, 53 L. Ed. 2d 383 (1977)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 17,19 (name only there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "City of Westworth Vill. v. Texas Voices for Reason & Justice, Inc., 520 S.W.3d 652 (Tex. App.\u2014Fort Worth 2017, pet. pending)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Act of May 27, 2011, 82d Leg., R.S., ch. 203", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Act of May 22, 2017, 85th Leg., R.S., ch. 150", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Act of May 29, 2017, 85th Leg., R.S., ch. 997", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "cosmetic": 1, "wrongAuthority": 3 }, "decisions": 11, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 7, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 7, "modelShown": 7, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 7, "suggestionClicks": 7 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g15-tx-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "a32d0b6057b052bb9ec516395aac80ee7078e8dc7f019a1225573cfe09e0aa8c", "documentXmlSha256": "c97799056dd865d13e5fb6871aa786724c328e28c17227e54e0bd0ef1cc15a48" }, "seconds": 8 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g15-tx-sc", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Laws 2017 Tex. H.B. 1761)." }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Tex. Gov\u2019t Code Ann. \u00a7 4" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "House Bill 1761" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "2011 Tex. Gen Laws 2011 Tex. H.B. 274)." }, { "kind": "model", "title": "\u00a7 3.02" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "2017 Tex. Gen. Laws (2017 Tex. H.B. 1111)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "September 1, 2017. Id. \u00a7 5" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g16-wi-sc", "task": { "id": "g16-wi-sc", "source": "grow-state-supreme-b/wi-sc-2018ap319-response.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "WI", "tags": [], "why": "Wisconsin (Wis. Stat. forms)" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g16-wi-sc.first.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 30, "keyPieces": 30, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 27, "found": 27, "exact": 25, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 30, "found": 30, "exact": 28, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 5, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "State v. Mayo, 2007 WI 78, 301 Wis. 2d 642, 734 N.W.2d 115", "line": "State v. Mayo, 2007 WI 78, 301 Wis. 2d 642, 734 N.W.2d 115", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "lacks 38 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 38" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968)", "line": "Under Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks 35 (name only there)" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 5, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g16-wi-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "231722d4905a21a20954de1c3a7a8e35ce5b264dbb9eefb630d2be819751a60f", "documentXmlSha256": "4c6017f89e45a86d38160663cc126773b91570add935170ad600e49b289e64df" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g16-wi-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 30, "keyPieces": 30, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 27, "found": 27, "exact": 25, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 30, "found": 30, "exact": 28, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 5, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "State v. Mayo, 2007 WI 78, 301 Wis. 2d 642, 734 N.W.2d 115", "line": "State v. Mayo, 2007 WI 78, 301 Wis. 2d 642, 734 N.W.2d 115", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "lacks 38 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 38" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968)", "line": "Under Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks 35 (name only there)" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 5, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g16-wi-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "31e7fed73152892823ad34ad1164ece08cfa9912eee0c3ef4cb0912d280843e3", "documentXmlSha256": "4c6017f89e45a86d38160663cc126773b91570add935170ad600e49b289e64df" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g16-wi-sc", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g16-wi-sc.first.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 30, "keyPieces": 30, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 27, "found": 27, "exact": 25, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 30, "found": 30, "exact": 28, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 5, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "State v. Mayo, 2007 WI 78, 301 Wis. 2d 642, 734 N.W.2d 115", "line": "State v. Mayo, 2007 WI 78, 301 Wis. 2d 642, 734 N.W.2d 115", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "lacks 38 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 38" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968)", "line": "Under Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks 35 (name only there)" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 5, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g16-wi-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "908e12d657cd6ac6a26c95292d5ac0366ef47e8c1752d23f1511ef7441d7602c", "documentXmlSha256": "4c6017f89e45a86d38160663cc126773b91570add935170ad600e49b289e64df" }, "seconds": 5 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g16-wi-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 30, "keyPieces": 30, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 27, "found": 27, "exact": 25, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 30, "found": 30, "exact": 28, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 5, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "State v. Mayo, 2007 WI 78, 301 Wis. 2d 642, 734 N.W.2d 115", "line": "State v. Mayo, 2007 WI 78, 301 Wis. 2d 642, 734 N.W.2d 115", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "lacks 38 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 38" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968)", "line": "Under Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks 35 (name only there)" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 5, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g16-wi-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "5cb18128323741184f7c6cd5227b55894566e6e323af71a19e7badc05caf0837", "documentXmlSha256": "4c6017f89e45a86d38160663cc126773b91570add935170ad600e49b289e64df" }, "seconds": 7 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g16-wi-sc", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } } }, { "id": "g17-fl-stale", "task": { "id": "g17-fl-stale", "source": "grow-state-supreme-a/fl-sc-03-1245-ini.pdf", "key": "gold", "keepTable": true, "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "FL", "tags": [ "stale table kept" ], "why": "KEY_DISPUTES brief (stale table), kept in the input" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g17-fl-stale.first.docx", "lines": 39, "keyEntries": 38, "keyPieces": 38, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 30, "found": 28, "exact": 24, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 6, "found": 6, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 37, "found": 34, "exact": 29, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 8, "weightedScore": 38, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 2 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 2 }, "corrections": 10, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Bruner v. Caterpillar, Inc., 627 So. 2d 46 (Fla. 1st DCA 1993)", "line": "Bruner v. Caterpillar, Inc., 627 So. 2d 46 (Fla. 1st DCA 1993)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 26" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Chester v. Doig, 842 So. 2d 106 (Fla. 2003)", "line": "Court in Chester v. Doig, 842 So. 2d 106 (Fla. 2003)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "lacks 16 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "City of Gainesville v. State, 28 Fla. L. Weekly S665 (Fla. Sept. 4, 2003)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Hecht v. Staskiewicz, 2002 WL 442319 (Conn. Super. 2002)", "line": "Hecht v. Staskiewicz, 2002 WL 442319 (Conn. Super. 2002)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "lacks 18 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 18" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Holly v. Auld, 450 So. 2d 217 (Fla. 1984)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Paradis v. Thomas, 150 So. 2d 457 (Fla. 2d DCA 1963)", "line": "Paradis v. Thomas, 150 So. 2d 457 (Fla. 2d DCA 1963)", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "lacks 24 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "\u00a7 768.76, Florida Statutes (1999)", "line": "Fla. Stat. \u00a7 768.76", "lines": [ 35 ], "detail": "lacks 24,30,33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Restatement (Second) of Torts \u00a7 920 cmt. e", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Bay Anesthesia, Inc. v. Aldrich, 847 So. 2d 975 (Fla. 2003)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Goble v. Frohman, 848 So. 2d 406 (Fla. 2d DCA 2003)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "R. Regulating Fla. Bar 4-1.5(f)(4)(B)", "lines": [ 38 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 8, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 2, "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2, "cosmetic": 2, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 10, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 1, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g17-fl-stale.first.docx", "sha256": "4d4e181302933e0f85e666188771baf7d3be2e1112d0d7c2023caa3ea571e044", "documentXmlSha256": "452bd0510f4178f97301eb04e5d2b8e9fc1cf97c32f4473771fa1530b6829626" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g17-fl-stale.careful.docx", "lines": 39, "keyEntries": 38, "keyPieces": 38, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 30, "found": 28, "exact": 24, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 6, "found": 6, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 37, "found": 34, "exact": 29, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 8, "weightedScore": 38, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 2 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 2 }, "corrections": 10, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Bruner v. Caterpillar, Inc., 627 So. 2d 46 (Fla. 1st DCA 1993)", "line": "Bruner v. Caterpillar, Inc., 627 So. 2d 46 (Fla. 1st DCA 1993)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 26" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Chester v. Doig, 842 So. 2d 106 (Fla. 2003)", "line": "Court in Chester v. Doig, 842 So. 2d 106 (Fla. 2003)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "lacks 16 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "City of Gainesville v. State, 28 Fla. L. Weekly S665 (Fla. Sept. 4, 2003)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Hecht v. Staskiewicz, 2002 WL 442319 (Conn. Super. 2002)", "line": "Hecht v. Staskiewicz, 2002 WL 442319 (Conn. Super. 2002)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "lacks 18 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 18" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Holly v. Auld, 450 So. 2d 217 (Fla. 1984)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Paradis v. Thomas, 150 So. 2d 457 (Fla. 2d DCA 1963)", "line": "Paradis v. Thomas, 150 So. 2d 457 (Fla. 2d DCA 1963)", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "lacks 24 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "\u00a7 768.76, Florida Statutes (1999)", "line": "Fla. Stat. \u00a7 768.76", "lines": [ 35 ], "detail": "lacks 24,30,33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Restatement (Second) of Torts \u00a7 920 cmt. e", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Bay Anesthesia, Inc. v. Aldrich, 847 So. 2d 975 (Fla. 2003)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Goble v. Frohman, 848 So. 2d 406 (Fla. 2d DCA 2003)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "R. Regulating Fla. Bar 4-1.5(f)(4)(B)", "lines": [ 38 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 8, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 2, "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2, "cosmetic": 2, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 10, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 1, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g17-fl-stale.careful.docx", "sha256": "980ccadd262d49ad8ad5bb21322774c24808d48054e1ed5f78908a5b6ff9b285", "documentXmlSha256": "452bd0510f4178f97301eb04e5d2b8e9fc1cf97c32f4473771fa1530b6829626" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g17-fl-stale", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g17-fl-stale.first.docx", "lines": 39, "keyEntries": 38, "keyPieces": 38, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 30, "found": 28, "exact": 24, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 6, "found": 6, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 37, "found": 34, "exact": 29, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 8, "weightedScore": 38, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 2 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 2 }, "corrections": 10, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Bruner v. Caterpillar, Inc., 627 So. 2d 46 (Fla. 1st DCA 1993)", "line": "Bruner v. Caterpillar, Inc., 627 So. 2d 46 (Fla. 1st DCA 1993)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 26" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Chester v. Doig, 842 So. 2d 106 (Fla. 2003)", "line": "Court in Chester v. Doig, 842 So. 2d 106 (Fla. 2003)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "lacks 16 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "City of Gainesville v. State, 28 Fla. L. Weekly S665 (Fla. Sept. 4, 2003)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Hecht v. Staskiewicz, 2002 WL 442319 (Conn. Super. 2002)", "line": "Hecht v. Staskiewicz, 2002 WL 442319 (Conn. Super. 2002)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "lacks 18 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 18" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Holly v. Auld, 450 So. 2d 217 (Fla. 1984)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Paradis v. Thomas, 150 So. 2d 457 (Fla. 2d DCA 1963)", "line": "Paradis v. Thomas, 150 So. 2d 457 (Fla. 2d DCA 1963)", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "lacks 24 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "\u00a7 768.76, Florida Statutes (1999)", "line": "Fla. Stat. \u00a7 768.76", "lines": [ 35 ], "detail": "lacks 24,30,33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Restatement (Second) of Torts \u00a7 920 cmt. e", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Bay Anesthesia, Inc. v. Aldrich, 847 So. 2d 975 (Fla. 2003)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Goble v. Frohman, 848 So. 2d 406 (Fla. 2d DCA 2003)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "R. Regulating Fla. Bar 4-1.5(f)(4)(B)", "lines": [ 38 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 6, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 2, "wrongPage": 1, "cosmetic": 2, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 11, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 1, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g17-fl-stale.first.docx", "sha256": "690dd2bbec3911dd40c5a6f0d07e2effb0e17c21e00ef195d2b8261a0b2a9c1f", "documentXmlSha256": "452bd0510f4178f97301eb04e5d2b8e9fc1cf97c32f4473771fa1530b6829626" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g17-fl-stale.careful.docx", "lines": 41, "keyEntries": 38, "keyPieces": 38, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 30, "found": 29, "exact": 25, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 6, "found": 6, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 37, "found": 36, "exact": 31, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 4, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 2, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 7, "weightedScore": 32, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 2 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 2 }, "corrections": 9, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Bruner v. Caterpillar, Inc., 627 So. 2d 46 (Fla. 1st DCA 1993)", "line": "Bruner v. Caterpillar, Inc., 627 So. 2d 46 (Fla. 1st DCA 1993)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 26" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Chester v. Doig, 842 So. 2d 106 (Fla. 2003)", "line": "Court in Chester v. Doig, 842 So. 2d 106 (Fla. 2003)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 16 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Hecht v. Staskiewicz, 2002 WL 442319 (Conn. Super. 2002)", "line": "Hecht v. Staskiewicz, 2002 WL 442319 (Conn. Super. 2002)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 18 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 18" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Holly v. Auld, 450 So. 2d 217 (Fla. 1984)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Paradis v. Thomas, 150 So. 2d 457 (Fla. 2d DCA 1963)", "line": "Paradis v. Thomas, 150 So. 2d 457 (Fla. 2d DCA 1963)", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "lacks 24 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "\u00a7 768.76, Florida Statutes (1999)", "line": "Fla. Stat. \u00a7 768.76", "lines": [ 36 ], "detail": "lacks 24,30,33 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Bay Anesthesia, Inc. v. Aldrich, 847 So. 2d 975 (Fla. 2003)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "Goble v. Frohman, 848 So. 2d 406 (Fla. 2d DCA 2003)", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "R. Regulating Fla. Bar 4-1.5(f)(4)(B)", "lines": [ 39 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "City of Gainesville v. State, 28 Fla. L. Weekly S665 (Fla. September 4, 2003)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 7, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 2, "wrongPage": 1, "cosmetic": 2, "wrongAuthority": 1, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 12, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 1, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "trueAccepts": 2, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 3 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g17-fl-stale.careful.docx", "sha256": "c548c5f6d318fea33c45792f363cd5abe396a3e19a57d3ab89f898de93cb6e0b", "documentXmlSha256": "f4f3f4c3061eec2936faca8d270774fc8bdc4c666b15413a098ce55a1a6f7a2c" }, "seconds": 7 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g17-fl-stale", "accept": [ "City of Gainesville v. State, 28 Fla. L. Weekly S665 (Fla. September 4, 2003)", "Restatement of the Law, Torts, Ch. 47, \u00a7 920" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "City of Gainesville v. State, 28 Fla. L. Weekly S665 (Fla. September 4, 2003)", "key": "City of Gainesville v. State, 28 Fla. L. Weekly S665 (Fla. Sept. 4, 2003)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Restatement of the Law, Torts, Ch. 47, \u00a7 920", "key": "Restatement (Second) of Torts \u00a7 920 cmt. e" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "\u00a7 52-225b" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g18-ca-2dca", "task": { "id": "g18-ca-2dca", "source": "grow-state-appellate/ca-2dca-b262873-appellant.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "state-appellate", "jur": "CA", "tags": [ "state cite forms" ], "why": "California Court of Appeal, 88 entries, Civ. Code/CCP subsections, name-only judgment pages" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g18-ca-2dca.first.docx", "lines": 84, "keyEntries": 88, "keyPieces": 88, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 71, "found": 65, "exact": 51, "defensible": 9, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 12, "found": 9, "exact": 6, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 88, "found": 79, "exact": 61, "defensible": 9, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 9, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 19, "weightedScore": 101, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 7, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 9, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 28, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 18, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 19, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Aligo v. Time-Life Books, 1994 U.S. Dist. Lexis 21559 (N.D. Cal. Dec. 19, 1994)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Brown v. Electronic Arts, 2009 U.S. Dist. Lexis 131387 (C.D. Cal. Sept. 23, 2009)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "C.B.C. Distribution v. Major League Baseball Advanced Media, 505 F.3d 818 (8th Cir. 2007)", "line": "C.B.C. Distribution v. Major League Baseball Advanced Media, 505 F.3d 818 (8th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Comedy III Prods. v. Gary Saderup, Inc., 25 Cal. 4th 387 (2001)", "line": "Comedy III Prods. v. Gary Saderup, Inc., 25 Cal. 4th 387 (2001)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 26" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Dora v. Frontline Video, 15 Cal. App. 4th 536 (1993)", "line": "Dora v. Frontline Video, 15 Cal. App. 4th 536 (1993)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 45 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "ETW Corp. v. Jireh Publ., 332 F.3d 915 (6th Cir. 2003)", "line": "ETW Corp. v. Jireh Publ., 332 F.3d 915 (6th Cir. 2003)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 35 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Frazier v. Boomsma, 2007 U.S. Dist. Lexis 72427 (D. Ariz. Sept. 27, 2007)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Gionfriddo v. Major League Baseball, 94 Cal. App. 4th 400 (2001)", "line": "Gionfriddo v. Major League Baseball, 94 Cal. App. 4th 400 (2001)", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "lacks 43 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hart v. Electronic Arts, 717 F.3d 141 (3d Cir. 2013)", "line": "Keller and Hart v. Electronic Arts, 717 F.3d 141 (3d Cir. 2013)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks 32,34 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Keller v. Electronic Arts, 724 F.3d 1268 (9th Cir. 2013)", "line": "Keller v. Electronic Arts, 724 F.3d 1268 (9th Cir. 2013)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 41 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Lohan v. Perez, 924 F. Supp. 2d 447 (E.D.N.Y. 2013)", "line": "Lohan v. Perez, 924 F. Supp. 2d 447 (E.D.N.Y. 2013)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "lacks 54 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Montana v. San Jose Mercury News, 34 Cal. App. 4th 790 (1995)", "line": "Montana v. San Jose Mercury News, 34 Cal. App. 4th 790 (1995)", "lines": [ 34 ], "detail": "lacks 41 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "No Doubt v. Activision, 192 Cal. App. 4th 1018 (2011)", "line": "No Doubt v. Activision, 192 Cal. App. 4th 1018 (2011)", "lines": [ 40 ], "detail": "lacks 30 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Noriega v. Activision, BC 551747 (Los Angeles Super. Ct., Oct. 27, 2014)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Nygard v. Uusi-Kerttula, 159 Cal. App. 4th 1027 (2008)", "line": "Nygard v. Uusi-Kerttula, 159 Cal. App. 4th 1027 (2008)", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 15" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Rogers v. Grimaldi, 875 F.2d 994 (2d Cir. 1989)", "line": "Rogers v. Grimaldi, 875 F.2d 994 (2d Cir. 1989)", "lines": [ 50 ], "detail": "lacks 48,49 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Alvarez, 132 S. Ct. 2537 (2012)", "line": "United States v. Alvarez, 132 S. Ct. 2537 (2012)", "lines": [ 58 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Stevens, 559 U.S. 460 (2010)", "line": "United States v. Stevens, 559 U.S. 460 (2010)", "lines": [ 59 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Vijay v. Twentieth Century Fox, 2014 U.S. Dist. Lexis 152098 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 27, 2014)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Winter v. DC Comics, 30 Cal. 4th 881 (2003)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Civ. Code, \u00a7 3344", "line": "Civ. Code, \u00a7 3344", "lines": [ 66 ], "detail": "lacks 4,5,43,45,46,47 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "F. Dougherty, All The World\u2019s Not A Stooge: The \u2018Transformativeness\u2019 Test For Analyzing a ", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "lines": [ 65, 79, 83 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 1,2,3,5,14,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,31,32,33,34,36,37,41,42,44,47,49,51 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "M. Conrad, A New First Amendment Goal Line Defense \u2013 Stopping the Right of Publicity Offen", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "lines": [ 65, 79 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 1,2,3,5,14,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,31,32,33,34,36,37,41,42,44,47,49,51 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "M. Freeman, Jim Brown: The Fierce Life of an American Hero (2007)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Restatement (Third) of Unfair Competition \u00a7 47 cmt. c", "line": "Restatement (Third) of Unfair Competition, \u00a7 47, cmt. c", "lines": [ 82 ], "detail": "lacks 48 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "S. Comm. on Judiciary, Analysis of \u201cAB 826 (Vasconcellos) as amended October 20\u201d (Oct. 20, 1971) (on file in Cal. State Archives, 1971 reg. ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "T. Pluto, Browns Town 1964: Cleveland Browns and the 1964 Championship (1997)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Zacchini, 433 U.S. 562 (1977)", "lines": [ 64 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 9, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 5, "unsurfaced": 14, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 8, "idPage": 1, "wrongPage": 5 }, "decisions": 23, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 6, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 8, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g18-ca-2dca.first.docx", "sha256": "11c31ca6d84ebfb08e8d595a2b25b87ceee09253e2d7d533c29a18263aad503e", "documentXmlSha256": "7ae3862ffff2db7552c2e1f129fd0d6504184528d78bf7727339784401ec1ee9" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g18-ca-2dca.careful.docx", "lines": 85, "keyEntries": 88, "keyPieces": 88, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 71, "found": 65, "exact": 51, "defensible": 9, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 12, "found": 10, "exact": 7, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 88, "found": 80, "exact": 62, "defensible": 9, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 8, "wrongPages": 9, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 18, "weightedScore": 96, "byType": { "missing": 8, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 7, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 9, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 40, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 28, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 18, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 18, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Aligo v. Time-Life Books, 1994 U.S. Dist. Lexis 21559 (N.D. Cal. Dec. 19, 1994)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Brown v. Electronic Arts, 2009 U.S. Dist. Lexis 131387 (C.D. Cal. Sept. 23, 2009)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "C.B.C. Distribution v. Major League Baseball Advanced Media, 505 F.3d 818 (8th Cir. 2007)", "line": "C.B.C. Distribution v. Major League Baseball Advanced Media, 505 F.3d 818 (8th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Comedy III Prods. v. Gary Saderup, Inc., 25 Cal. 4th 387 (2001)", "line": "Comedy III Prods. v. Gary Saderup, Inc., 25 Cal. 4th 387 (2001)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 26" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Dora v. Frontline Video, 15 Cal. App. 4th 536 (1993)", "line": "Dora v. Frontline Video, 15 Cal. App. 4th 536 (1993)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 45 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "ETW Corp. v. Jireh Publ., 332 F.3d 915 (6th Cir. 2003)", "line": "ETW Corp. v. Jireh Publ., 332 F.3d 915 (6th Cir. 2003)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 35 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Frazier v. Boomsma, 2007 U.S. Dist. Lexis 72427 (D. Ariz. Sept. 27, 2007)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Gionfriddo v. Major League Baseball, 94 Cal. App. 4th 400 (2001)", "line": "Gionfriddo v. Major League Baseball, 94 Cal. App. 4th 400 (2001)", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "lacks 43 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hart v. Electronic Arts, 717 F.3d 141 (3d Cir. 2013)", "line": "Keller and Hart v. Electronic Arts, 717 F.3d 141 (3d Cir. 2013)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks 32,34 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Keller v. Electronic Arts, 724 F.3d 1268 (9th Cir. 2013)", "line": "Keller v. Electronic Arts, 724 F.3d 1268 (9th Cir. 2013)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 41 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Lohan v. Perez, 924 F. Supp. 2d 447 (E.D.N.Y. 2013)", "line": "Lohan v. Perez, 924 F. Supp. 2d 447 (E.D.N.Y. 2013)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "lacks 54 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Montana v. San Jose Mercury News, 34 Cal. App. 4th 790 (1995)", "line": "Montana v. San Jose Mercury News, 34 Cal. App. 4th 790 (1995)", "lines": [ 34 ], "detail": "lacks 41 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "No Doubt v. Activision, 192 Cal. App. 4th 1018 (2011)", "line": "No Doubt v. Activision, 192 Cal. App. 4th 1018 (2011)", "lines": [ 40 ], "detail": "lacks 30 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Noriega v. Activision, BC 551747 (Los Angeles Super. Ct., Oct. 27, 2014)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Nygard v. Uusi-Kerttula, 159 Cal. App. 4th 1027 (2008)", "line": "Nygard v. Uusi-Kerttula, 159 Cal. App. 4th 1027 (2008)", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 15" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Rogers v. Grimaldi, 875 F.2d 994 (2d Cir. 1989)", "line": "Rogers v. Grimaldi, 875 F.2d 994 (2d Cir. 1989)", "lines": [ 50 ], "detail": "lacks 48,49 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Alvarez, 132 S. Ct. 2537 (2012)", "line": "United States v. Alvarez, 132 S. Ct. 2537 (2012)", "lines": [ 58 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Stevens, 559 U.S. 460 (2010)", "line": "United States v. Stevens, 559 U.S. 460 (2010)", "lines": [ 59 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Vijay v. Twentieth Century Fox, 2014 U.S. Dist. Lexis 152098 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 27, 2014)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Winter v. DC Comics, 30 Cal. 4th 881 (2003)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Civ. Code, \u00a7 3344", "line": "Civ. Code, \u00a7 3344", "lines": [ 66 ], "detail": "lacks 4,5,43,45,46,47 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "F. Dougherty, All The World\u2019s Not A Stooge: The \u2018Transformativeness\u2019 Test For Analyzing a ", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "lines": [ 65, 79, 84 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 1,2,3,5,14,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,31,32,33,34,36,37,41,42,44,47,49,51 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "M. Conrad, A New First Amendment Goal Line Defense \u2013 Stopping the Right of Publicity Offen", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "lines": [ 65, 79 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 1,2,3,5,14,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,31,32,33,34,36,37,41,42,44,47,49,51 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "M. Freeman, Jim Brown: The Fierce Life of an American Hero (2007)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Restatement (Third) of Unfair Competition \u00a7 47 cmt. c", "line": "Restatement (Third) of Unfair Competition, \u00a7 47, cmt. c", "lines": [ 82 ], "detail": "lacks 48 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "S. Comm. on Judiciary, Analysis of \u201cAB 826 (Vasconcellos) as amended October 20\u201d (Oct. 20, 1971) (on file in Cal. State Archives, 1971 reg. ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Zacchini, 433 U.S. 562 (1977)", "lines": [ 64 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 9, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 14, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 8, "idPage": 1, "wrongPage": 5 }, "decisions": 23, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 6, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 8, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g18-ca-2dca.careful.docx", "sha256": "9bfccc981d1e1d97da72263ffdd53d0f600a6099dbd67227bb595f2c16a9e4a5", "documentXmlSha256": "35ff0eafe45da26ef8d0318141efb14942ee711f581e7d6a2709d92d1c238a7a" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g18-ca-2dca", "accept": [ "T. Pluto, Browns Town 1964: Cleveland Browns and the 1964 Championship (1997)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "T. Pluto, Browns Town 1964: Cleveland Browns and the 1964 Championship (1997)", "key": "T. Pluto, Browns Town 1964: Cleveland Browns and the 1964 Championship (1997)" } ], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g18-ca-2dca.first.docx", "lines": 84, "keyEntries": 88, "keyPieces": 88, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 71, "found": 65, "exact": 51, "defensible": 9, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 12, "found": 9, "exact": 6, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 88, "found": 79, "exact": 61, "defensible": 9, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 9, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 19, "weightedScore": 101, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 7, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 9, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 28, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 18, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 19, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Aligo v. Time-Life Books, 1994 U.S. Dist. Lexis 21559 (N.D. Cal. Dec. 19, 1994)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Brown v. Electronic Arts, 2009 U.S. Dist. Lexis 131387 (C.D. Cal. Sept. 23, 2009)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "C.B.C. Distribution v. Major League Baseball Advanced Media, 505 F.3d 818 (8th Cir. 2007)", "line": "C.B.C. Distribution v. Major League Baseball Advanced Media, 505 F.3d 818 (8th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Comedy III Prods. v. Gary Saderup, Inc., 25 Cal. 4th 387 (2001)", "line": "Comedy III Prods. v. Gary Saderup, Inc., 25 Cal. 4th 387 (2001)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 26" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Dora v. Frontline Video, 15 Cal. App. 4th 536 (1993)", "line": "Dora v. Frontline Video, 15 Cal. App. 4th 536 (1993)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 45 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "ETW Corp. v. Jireh Publ., 332 F.3d 915 (6th Cir. 2003)", "line": "ETW Corp. v. Jireh Publ., 332 F.3d 915 (6th Cir. 2003)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 35 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Frazier v. Boomsma, 2007 U.S. Dist. Lexis 72427 (D. Ariz. Sept. 27, 2007)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Gionfriddo v. Major League Baseball, 94 Cal. App. 4th 400 (2001)", "line": "Gionfriddo v. Major League Baseball, 94 Cal. App. 4th 400 (2001)", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "lacks 43 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hart v. Electronic Arts, 717 F.3d 141 (3d Cir. 2013)", "line": "Keller and Hart v. Electronic Arts, 717 F.3d 141 (3d Cir. 2013)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks 32,34 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Keller v. Electronic Arts, 724 F.3d 1268 (9th Cir. 2013)", "line": "Keller v. Electronic Arts, 724 F.3d 1268 (9th Cir. 2013)", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "lacks 41 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Lohan v. Perez, 924 F. Supp. 2d 447 (E.D.N.Y. 2013)", "line": "Lohan v. Perez, 924 F. Supp. 2d 447 (E.D.N.Y. 2013)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "lacks 54 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Montana v. San Jose Mercury News, 34 Cal. App. 4th 790 (1995)", "line": "Montana v. San Jose Mercury News, 34 Cal. App. 4th 790 (1995)", "lines": [ 34 ], "detail": "lacks 41 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "No Doubt v. Activision, 192 Cal. App. 4th 1018 (2011)", "line": "No Doubt v. Activision, 192 Cal. App. 4th 1018 (2011)", "lines": [ 40 ], "detail": "lacks 30 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Noriega v. Activision, BC 551747 (Los Angeles Super. Ct., Oct. 27, 2014)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Nygard v. Uusi-Kerttula, 159 Cal. App. 4th 1027 (2008)", "line": "Nygard v. Uusi-Kerttula, 159 Cal. App. 4th 1027 (2008)", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 15" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Rogers v. Grimaldi, 875 F.2d 994 (2d Cir. 1989)", "line": "Rogers v. Grimaldi, 875 F.2d 994 (2d Cir. 1989)", "lines": [ 50 ], "detail": "lacks 48,49 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Alvarez, 132 S. Ct. 2537 (2012)", "line": "United States v. Alvarez, 132 S. Ct. 2537 (2012)", "lines": [ 58 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Stevens, 559 U.S. 460 (2010)", "line": "United States v. Stevens, 559 U.S. 460 (2010)", "lines": [ 59 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Vijay v. Twentieth Century Fox, 2014 U.S. Dist. Lexis 152098 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 27, 2014)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Winter v. DC Comics, 30 Cal. 4th 881 (2003)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Civ. Code, \u00a7 3344", "line": "Civ. Code, \u00a7 3344", "lines": [ 66 ], "detail": "lacks 4,5,43,45,46,47 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "F. Dougherty, All The World\u2019s Not A Stooge: The \u2018Transformativeness\u2019 Test For Analyzing a ", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "lines": [ 65, 79, 83 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 1,2,3,5,14,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,31,32,33,34,36,37,41,42,44,47,49,51 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "M. Conrad, A New First Amendment Goal Line Defense \u2013 Stopping the Right of Publicity Offen", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "lines": [ 65, 79 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 1,2,3,5,14,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,31,32,33,34,36,37,41,42,44,47,49,51 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "M. Freeman, Jim Brown: The Fierce Life of an American Hero (2007)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Restatement (Third) of Unfair Competition \u00a7 47 cmt. c", "line": "Restatement (Third) of Unfair Competition, \u00a7 47, cmt. c", "lines": [ 82 ], "detail": "lacks 48 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "S. Comm. on Judiciary, Analysis of \u201cAB 826 (Vasconcellos) as amended October 20\u201d (Oct. 20, 1971) (on file in Cal. State Archives, 1971 reg. ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "T. Pluto, Browns Town 1964: Cleveland Browns and the 1964 Championship (1997)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Zacchini, 433 U.S. 562 (1977)", "lines": [ 64 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 13, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 9, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 4, "idPage": 1, "wrongPage": 5 }, "decisions": 23, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 6, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 4, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 5, "modelShown": 4, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g18-ca-2dca.first.docx", "sha256": "0610fbe0acd65eddafa4b603253d69fca90912c3db5b7cec3816c0a1798d77b4", "documentXmlSha256": "7ae3862ffff2db7552c2e1f129fd0d6504184528d78bf7727339784401ec1ee9" }, "seconds": 6 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g18-ca-2dca.careful.docx", "lines": 89, "keyEntries": 88, "keyPieces": 88, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 71, "found": 69, "exact": 52, "defensible": 9, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 12, "found": 10, "exact": 7, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 88, "found": 84, "exact": 63, "defensible": 9, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 12, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 18, "weightedScore": 92, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 10, "badLine": 2, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 9, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 40, "badLine": 8, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 18, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 18, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Aligo v. Time-Life Books, 1994 U.S. Dist. Lexis 21559 (N.D. Cal. Dec. 19, 1994)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "C.B.C. Distribution v. Major League Baseball Advanced Media, 505 F.3d 818 (8th Cir. 2007)", "line": "C.B.C. Distribution v. Major League Baseball Advanced Media, 505 F.3d 818 (8th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Comedy III Prods. v. Gary Saderup, Inc., 25 Cal. 4th 387 (2001)", "line": "Comedy III Prods. v. Gary Saderup, Inc., 25 Cal. 4th 387 (2001)", "lines": [ 15 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 26" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Dora v. Frontline Video, 15 Cal. App. 4th 536 (1993)", "line": "Dora v. Frontline Video, 15 Cal. App. 4th 536 (1993)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 45 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "ETW Corp. v. Jireh Publ., 332 F.3d 915 (6th Cir. 2003)", "line": "ETW Corp. v. Jireh Publ., 332 F.3d 915 (6th Cir. 2003)", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "lacks 35 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Frazier v. Boomsma, 2007 U.S. Dist. Lexis 72427 (D. Ariz. Sept. 27, 2007)", "line": "Frazier v. Boomsma, 2007 U.S. Dist. Lexis 72427 (D. Ariz. Sept. 27, 2007)", "lines": [ 21 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Gionfriddo v. Major League Baseball, 94 Cal. App. 4th 400 (2001)", "line": "Gionfriddo v. Major League Baseball, 94 Cal. App. 4th 400 (2001)", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "lacks 43 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hart v. Electronic Arts, 717 F.3d 141 (3d Cir. 2013)", "line": "Keller and Hart v. Electronic Arts, 717 F.3d 141 (3d Cir. 2013)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks 32,34 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Keller v. Electronic Arts, 724 F.3d 1268 (9th Cir. 2013)", "line": "Keller v. Electronic Arts, 724 F.3d 1268 (9th Cir. 2013)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "lacks 41 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Lohan v. Perez, 924 F. Supp. 2d 447 (E.D.N.Y. 2013)", "line": "Lohan v. Perez, 924 F. Supp. 2d 447 (E.D.N.Y. 2013)", "lines": [ 32 ], "detail": "lacks 54 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Montana v. San Jose Mercury News, 34 Cal. App. 4th 790 (1995)", "line": "Montana v. San Jose Mercury News, 34 Cal. App. 4th 790 (1995)", "lines": [ 36 ], "detail": "lacks 41 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "No Doubt v. Activision, 192 Cal. App. 4th 1018 (2011)", "line": "No Doubt v. Activision, 192 Cal. App. 4th 1018 (2011)", "lines": [ 42 ], "detail": "lacks 30 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Noriega v. Activision, BC 551747 (Los Angeles Super. Ct., Oct. 27, 2014)", "line": "Noriega v. Activision, BC 551747 (Los Angeles Super. Ct., Oct. 27, 2014)", "lines": [ 43 ], "detail": "lacks 23,35 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Nygard v. Uusi-Kerttula, 159 Cal. App. 4th 1027 (2008)", "line": "Nygard v. Uusi-Kerttula, 159 Cal. App. 4th 1027 (2008)", "lines": [ 44 ], "detail": "lacks 15 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 15" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Rogers v. Grimaldi, 875 F.2d 994 (2d Cir. 1989)", "line": "Rogers v. Grimaldi, 875 F.2d 994 (2d Cir. 1989)", "lines": [ 53 ], "detail": "lacks 48,49 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Alvarez, 132 S. Ct. 2537 (2012)", "line": "United States v. Alvarez, 132 S. Ct. 2537 (2012)", "lines": [ 61 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Stevens, 559 U.S. 460 (2010)", "line": "United States v. Stevens, 559 U.S. 460 (2010)", "lines": [ 62 ], "detail": "lacks 21 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Vijay v. Twentieth Century Fox, 2014 U.S. Dist. Lexis 152098 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 27, 2014)", "line": "Vijay v. Twentieth Century Fox, 2014 U.S. Dist. Lexis 152098 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 27, 2014)", "lines": [ 64 ], "detail": "lacks 23 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Winter v. DC Comics, 30 Cal. 4th 881 (2003)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Civ. Code, \u00a7 3344", "line": "Civ. Code, \u00a7 3344", "lines": [ 70 ], "detail": "lacks 4,5,43,45,46,47 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "F. Dougherty, All The World\u2019s Not A Stooge: The \u2018Transformativeness\u2019 Test For Analyzing a ", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "lines": [ 69, 83, 88 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 1,2,3,5,14,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,31,32,33,34,36,37,41,42,44,47,49,51 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "M. Conrad, A New First Amendment Goal Line Defense \u2013 Stopping the Right of Publicity Offen", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "lines": [ 69, 83 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 1,2,3,5,14,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,31,32,33,34,36,37,41,42,44,47,49,51 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "M. Freeman, Jim Brown: The Fierce Life of an American Hero (2007)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Restatement (Third) of Unfair Competition \u00a7 47 cmt. c", "line": "Restatement (Third) of Unfair Competition, \u00a7 47, cmt. c", "lines": [ 86 ], "detail": "lacks 48 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "S. Comm. on Judiciary, Analysis of \u201cAB 826 (Vasconcellos) as amended October 20\u201d (Oct. 20, 1971) (on file in Cal. State Archives, 1971 reg. ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Noriega v. Activision, BC 551747 (Los Angeles Super. Ct., Oct. 27, 2014)", "lines": [ 43 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Zacchini, 433 U.S. 562 (1977)", "lines": [ 68 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 13, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 14, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 4, "idPage": 1, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 27, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 6, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 4, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 5, "modelShown": 4, "trueAccepts": 5, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 5 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g18-ca-2dca.careful.docx", "sha256": "cc4c7faaf0ea904375343fd539c786f3620e2771aaaa78688985dc25cd08b728", "documentXmlSha256": "71b4df3c0f39b24e59a2c4042b7b9118af67af3b00e6f24a32bc98839a674e40" }, "seconds": 10 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g18-ca-2dca", "accept": [ "T. Pluto, Browns Town 1964: Cleveland Browns and the 1964 Championship (1997)", "Vijay v. Twentieth Century Fox, 2014 U.S. Dist. Lexis 152098 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 27, 2014)", "Noriega v. Activision, BC 551747 (Los Angeles Super. Ct., Oct. 27, 2014)", "Brown v. Electronic Arts, 2009 U.S. Dist. Lexis 131387 (C.D. Cal. Sept. 23, 2009)", "Frazier v. Boomsma, 2007 U.S. Dist. Lexis 72427 (D. Ariz. Sept. 27, 2007)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "T. Pluto, Browns Town 1964: Cleveland Browns and the 1964 Championship (1997)", "key": "T. Pluto, Browns Town 1964: Cleveland Browns and the 1964 Championship (1997)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Vijay v. Twentieth Century Fox, 2014 U.S. Dist. Lexis 152098 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 27, 2014)", "key": "Vijay v. Twentieth Century Fox, 2014 U.S. Dist. Lexis 152098 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 27, 2014)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Noriega v. Activision, BC 551747 (Los Angeles Super. Ct., Oct. 27, 2014)", "key": "Noriega v. Activision, BC 551747 (Los Angeles Super. Ct., Oct. 27, 2014)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Brown v. Electronic Arts, 2009 U.S. Dist. Lexis 131387 (C.D. Cal. Sept. 23, 2009)", "key": "Brown v. Electronic Arts, 2009 U.S. Dist. Lexis 131387 (C.D. Cal. Sept. 23, 2009)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Frazier v. Boomsma, 2007 U.S. Dist. Lexis 72427 (D. Ariz. Sept. 27, 2007)", "key": "Frazier v. Boomsma, 2007 U.S. Dist. Lexis 72427 (D. Ariz. Sept. 27, 2007)" } ], "wrong": [] } } } }, { "id": "g19-wa-coa", "task": { "id": "g19-wa-coa", "source": "grow-state-appellate/wa-coa1-65632-5-appellant.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "state-appellate", "jur": "WA", "tags": [ "state cite forms" ], "chatbot": true, "why": "Washington forms (RCW, RAP, Wn.2d); a leading case (Roberson) left out on load as garbled" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g19-wa-coa.first.docx", "lines": 35, "keyEntries": 40, "keyPieces": 40, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 28, "exact": 26, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 4, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 40, "found": 31, "exact": 29, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 2, "garbledNames": 6, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 19, "weightedScore": 87, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 2, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 6, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 10, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 24, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 19, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "City of Seattle v. City of Seattle, Pub. Safety Civil Serv. Comm'n, 155 Wash. App. 878, 230 P.3d 640 (2010)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Columbia Presbyterian Hosp., 79 LA 24 (Spencer, 1982)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Ezell v. Potter, 400 F.3d 1041, 1049-50 (7th Cir.2005)", "line": "Freeman v. Madison Metro. Sch. Dist., 231 F.3d 374,382-83 (7th Cir.2000\u00bb. 31 Id 400 F.3d 1041, 1049-50 (7th Cir. 2005)", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "lacks 21,24 (cited there) / adds 20 (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 24" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Freeman v. Madison Metro. Sch. Dist., 231 F.3d 374 (7th Cir.2000)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Hiatt v. Rockwell Int'l Corp., 26 F.3d 761 (7th Cir.1994)", "line": "26 F.3d 761 (7th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks 20 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Kitsap Cnty. Deputy Sheriff's Guild v. Kitsap Cnty., 140 Wash. App. 516 (2007)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Ruff v. County of King, 125 Wash.2d 697 (1995)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Summit Cty. Children Servs. Bd. v. Communication Workers ofAm., Local 4546, 113 Ohio St.3d 291,865 N.E.2d 31 (Ohio 2007)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Seattle Municipal Code 4.08.100", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Hill and Sinicropi, EVIDENCE IN ARBITRATION, (1987, 2d Ed.)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Smith, Elkouri & Elkouri, How Arbitration Works, (1995)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Ezell, 79 LA 24 (Spencer, 1982)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Local 4546, 113 Ohio St.3d 291", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Ill., 442 F.3d 611 (7th Cir. 2006)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Ind, 137 Wn.App. 592, 154 P 3d 287 (2007)", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "26 F.3d 761 (7th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "125 Wash.2d 697,703 (1995)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "144 Wn.2d 516,525,29 P.3d 689 (2001)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "474 F.3d 387 (7th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 16, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 8, "unsurfaced": 11, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 8, "wrongPage": 2, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 27, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 12, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 2, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 8, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g19-wa-coa.first.docx", "sha256": "2783f7c3a27be30ba59a91ed8330da3efde4ee2f796d63dde067a113c9283cd9", "documentXmlSha256": "8937b2f2d7e4f531d96cb4958e2cf73d5503d00da28d7e549081285d217cfa5e" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g19-wa-coa.careful.docx", "lines": 35, "keyEntries": 40, "keyPieces": 40, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 28, "exact": 26, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 4, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 40, "found": 31, "exact": 29, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 2, "garbledNames": 6, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 19, "weightedScore": 87, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 2, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 6, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 10, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 24, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 19, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "City of Seattle v. City of Seattle, Pub. Safety Civil Serv. Comm'n, 155 Wash. App. 878, 230 P.3d 640 (2010)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Columbia Presbyterian Hosp., 79 LA 24 (Spencer, 1982)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Ezell v. Potter, 400 F.3d 1041, 1049-50 (7th Cir.2005)", "line": "Freeman v. Madison Metro. Sch. Dist., 231 F.3d 374,382-83 (7th Cir.2000\u00bb. 31 Id 400 F.3d 1041, 1049-50 (7th Cir. 2005)", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "lacks 21,24 (cited there) / adds 20 (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 24" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Freeman v. Madison Metro. Sch. Dist., 231 F.3d 374 (7th Cir.2000)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Hiatt v. Rockwell Int'l Corp., 26 F.3d 761 (7th Cir.1994)", "line": "26 F.3d 761 (7th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks 20 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Kitsap Cnty. Deputy Sheriff's Guild v. Kitsap Cnty., 140 Wash. App. 516 (2007)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Ruff v. County of King, 125 Wash.2d 697 (1995)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Summit Cty. Children Servs. Bd. v. Communication Workers ofAm., Local 4546, 113 Ohio St.3d 291,865 N.E.2d 31 (Ohio 2007)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Seattle Municipal Code 4.08.100", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Hill and Sinicropi, EVIDENCE IN ARBITRATION, (1987, 2d Ed.)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Smith, Elkouri & Elkouri, How Arbitration Works, (1995)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Ezell, 79 LA 24 (Spencer, 1982)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Local 4546, 113 Ohio St.3d 291", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Ill., 442 F.3d 611 (7th Cir. 2006)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Ind, 137 Wn.App. 592, 154 P 3d 287 (2007)", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "26 F.3d 761 (7th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "125 Wash.2d 697,703 (1995)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "144 Wn.2d 516,525,29 P.3d 689 (2001)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "474 F.3d 387 (7th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 16, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 8, "unsurfaced": 11, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 8, "wrongPage": 2, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 27, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 12, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 2, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 8, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g19-wa-coa.careful.docx", "sha256": "e883c2844c21ff035b1bb9cb1c50c8d71d52c350f4840cece568c2579d09986e", "documentXmlSha256": "8937b2f2d7e4f531d96cb4958e2cf73d5503d00da28d7e549081285d217cfa5e" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g19-wa-coa", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g19-wa-coa.first.docx", "lines": 35, "keyEntries": 40, "keyPieces": 40, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 28, "exact": 26, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 4, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 40, "found": 31, "exact": 29, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 2, "garbledNames": 6, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 19, "weightedScore": 87, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 2, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 6, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 10, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 24, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 19, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "City of Seattle v. City of Seattle, Pub. Safety Civil Serv. Comm'n, 155 Wash. App. 878, 230 P.3d 640 (2010)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Columbia Presbyterian Hosp., 79 LA 24 (Spencer, 1982)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Ezell v. Potter, 400 F.3d 1041, 1049-50 (7th Cir.2005)", "line": "Freeman v. Madison Metro. Sch. Dist., 231 F.3d 374,382-83 (7th Cir.2000\u00bb. 31 Id 400 F.3d 1041, 1049-50 (7th Cir. 2005)", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "lacks 21,24 (cited there) / adds 20 (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 24" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Freeman v. Madison Metro. Sch. Dist., 231 F.3d 374 (7th Cir.2000)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Hiatt v. Rockwell Int'l Corp., 26 F.3d 761 (7th Cir.1994)", "line": "26 F.3d 761 (7th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks 20 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Kitsap Cnty. Deputy Sheriff's Guild v. Kitsap Cnty., 140 Wash. App. 516 (2007)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Ruff v. County of King, 125 Wash.2d 697 (1995)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Summit Cty. Children Servs. Bd. v. Communication Workers ofAm., Local 4546, 113 Ohio St.3d 291,865 N.E.2d 31 (Ohio 2007)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Seattle Municipal Code 4.08.100", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Hill and Sinicropi, EVIDENCE IN ARBITRATION, (1987, 2d Ed.)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Smith, Elkouri & Elkouri, How Arbitration Works, (1995)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Ezell, 79 LA 24 (Spencer, 1982)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Local 4546, 113 Ohio St.3d 291", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Ill., 442 F.3d 611 (7th Cir. 2006)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Ind, 137 Wn.App. 592, 154 P 3d 287 (2007)", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "26 F.3d 761 (7th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "125 Wash.2d 697,703 (1995)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "144 Wn.2d 516,525,29 P.3d 689 (2001)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "474 F.3d 387 (7th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 18, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 9, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 7, "wrongPage": 2, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 28, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 12, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 2, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 7, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 2, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g19-wa-coa.first.docx", "sha256": "7569f9b99c5350ff5543eccc6a144c0aebecc5b6322f6204eb8054a0ee057104", "documentXmlSha256": "8937b2f2d7e4f531d96cb4958e2cf73d5503d00da28d7e549081285d217cfa5e" }, "seconds": 5 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g19-wa-coa.careful.docx", "lines": 36, "keyEntries": 40, "keyPieces": 40, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 28, "exact": 26, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 4, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 40, "found": 32, "exact": 30, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 8, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 2, "garbledNames": 6, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 18, "weightedScore": 82, "byType": { "missing": 8, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 2, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 6, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 40, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 10, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 24, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 18, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "City of Seattle v. City of Seattle, Pub. Safety Civil Serv. Comm'n, 155 Wash. App. 878, 230 P.3d 640 (2010)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Columbia Presbyterian Hosp., 79 LA 24 (Spencer, 1982)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Ezell v. Potter, 400 F.3d 1041, 1049-50 (7th Cir.2005)", "line": "Freeman v. Madison Metro. Sch. Dist., 231 F.3d 374,382-83 (7th Cir.2000\u00bb. 31 Id 400 F.3d 1041, 1049-50 (7th Cir. 2005)", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "lacks 21,24 (cited there) / adds 20 (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 24" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Freeman v. Madison Metro. Sch. Dist., 231 F.3d 374 (7th Cir.2000)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Hiatt v. Rockwell Int'l Corp., 26 F.3d 761 (7th Cir.1994)", "line": "26 F.3d 761 (7th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks 20 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Kitsap Cnty. Deputy Sheriff's Guild v. Kitsap Cnty., 140 Wash. App. 516 (2007)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Ruff v. County of King, 125 Wash.2d 697 (1995)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Summit Cty. Children Servs. Bd. v. Communication Workers ofAm., Local 4546, 113 Ohio St.3d 291,865 N.E.2d 31 (Ohio 2007)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Seattle Municipal Code 4.08.100", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Smith, Elkouri & Elkouri, How Arbitration Works, (1995)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Ezell, 79 LA 24 (Spencer, 1982)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Local 4546, 113 Ohio St.3d 291", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Ill., 442 F.3d 611 (7th Cir. 2006)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Ind, 137 Wn.App. 592, 154 P 3d 287 (2007)", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "26 F.3d 761 (7th Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "125 Wash.2d 697,703 (1995)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "144 Wn.2d 516,525,29 P.3d 689 (2001)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "474 F.3d 387 (7th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 18, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 8, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 7, "wrongPage": 2, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 28, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 12, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 2, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 7, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 2, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 2 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g19-wa-coa.careful.docx", "sha256": "125d48767af6a0a6a6d33f744863b8bc9867c8d3aa6a620645fc2d50ff46f176", "documentXmlSha256": "28e5c1de854aa6bddcf7b9bd0c924aacf5807e56758783c8605830913829ef10" }, "seconds": 12 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g19-wa-coa", "accept": [ "38Hill and Sinicropi, EVIDENCE IN ARBITRATION, 32-36 (1987, 2d Ed.)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "38Hill and Sinicropi, EVIDENCE IN ARBITRATION, 32-36 (1987, 2d Ed.)", "key": "Hill and Sinicropi, EVIDENCE IN ARBITRATION, (1987, 2d Ed.)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "doing so, the Commission has consistently referenced the seven factors identified in Koven and Smith, Just Cause: The Seven Tests (2d ed. 1992)" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g20-ny-ad1", "task": { "id": "g20-ny-ad1", "source": "grow-state-appellate/ny-ad1-2023-00535-appellants.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "state-appellate", "jur": "NY", "tags": [], "why": "N.Y. Appellate Division, KEY_DISPUTES brief (counsel table disputed); gold key makes it usable" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g20-ny-ad1.first.docx", "lines": 37, "keyEntries": 37, "keyPieces": 37, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 30, "found": 30, "exact": 26, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 37, "found": 37, "exact": 33, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 13, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Paloma Frocks, Inc. v. Shamokin Sportswear Corp., 3 N.Y.2d 572 (1958)", "line": "Paloma Frocks, Inc. v. Shamokin Sportswear Corp., 3 N.Y.2d 572 (1958)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 26,27 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 27" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Simon v. Becherer, 7 A.D.3d 66 (1st Dep\u2019t 2004)", "line": "Simon v. Becherer, 7 A.D.3d 66 (1st Dep\u2019t 2004)", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "lacks 28 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 28" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Sterling Industries v. Ball Bearing Pen Corp., 298 N.Y. 483 (1949)", "line": "Sterling Industries v. Ball Bearing Pen Corp., 298 N.Y. 483 (1949)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "87 A.D.3d 174 (1st Dep\u2019t 2011)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 6, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 7, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 2, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 3, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g20-ny-ad1.first.docx", "sha256": "8947a04ec837a59e0f08d43a841b02024b8d5b688eb2549ccb727a16f64b83ed", "documentXmlSha256": "6df261794a350b1a3a295ef9bd55fc6036cc15e3198e074ab8371d2880c08c56" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g20-ny-ad1.careful.docx", "lines": 37, "keyEntries": 37, "keyPieces": 37, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 30, "found": 30, "exact": 26, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 37, "found": 37, "exact": 33, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 13, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Paloma Frocks, Inc. v. Shamokin Sportswear Corp., 3 N.Y.2d 572 (1958)", "line": "Paloma Frocks, Inc. v. Shamokin Sportswear Corp., 3 N.Y.2d 572 (1958)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 26,27 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 27" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Simon v. Becherer, 7 A.D.3d 66 (1st Dep\u2019t 2004)", "line": "Simon v. Becherer, 7 A.D.3d 66 (1st Dep\u2019t 2004)", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "lacks 28 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 28" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Sterling Industries v. Ball Bearing Pen Corp., 298 N.Y. 483 (1949)", "line": "Sterling Industries v. Ball Bearing Pen Corp., 298 N.Y. 483 (1949)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "87 A.D.3d 174 (1st Dep\u2019t 2011)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 6, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 7, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 2, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 3, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g20-ny-ad1.careful.docx", "sha256": "9e8c0d81d569e0182849c1a7f92f71b32bd4da4d4b1ebdad96718d5892cfd24a", "documentXmlSha256": "6df261794a350b1a3a295ef9bd55fc6036cc15e3198e074ab8371d2880c08c56" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g20-ny-ad1", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g20-ny-ad1.first.docx", "lines": 37, "keyEntries": 37, "keyPieces": 37, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 30, "found": 30, "exact": 26, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 37, "found": 37, "exact": 33, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 13, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Paloma Frocks, Inc. v. Shamokin Sportswear Corp., 3 N.Y.2d 572 (1958)", "line": "Paloma Frocks, Inc. v. Shamokin Sportswear Corp., 3 N.Y.2d 572 (1958)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 26,27 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 27" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Simon v. Becherer, 7 A.D.3d 66 (1st Dep\u2019t 2004)", "line": "Simon v. Becherer, 7 A.D.3d 66 (1st Dep\u2019t 2004)", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "lacks 28 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 28" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Sterling Industries v. Ball Bearing Pen Corp., 298 N.Y. 483 (1949)", "line": "Sterling Industries v. Ball Bearing Pen Corp., 298 N.Y. 483 (1949)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "87 A.D.3d 174 (1st Dep\u2019t 2011)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 2, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 3, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g20-ny-ad1.first.docx", "sha256": "ff3f9fd1ee60199748f832a9da56586bfff9d961b3121236a5b7ec92b649bf9c", "documentXmlSha256": "6df261794a350b1a3a295ef9bd55fc6036cc15e3198e074ab8371d2880c08c56" }, "seconds": 6 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g20-ny-ad1.careful.docx", "lines": 37, "keyEntries": 37, "keyPieces": 37, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 30, "found": 30, "exact": 26, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 37, "found": 37, "exact": 33, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 13, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Paloma Frocks, Inc. v. Shamokin Sportswear Corp., 3 N.Y.2d 572 (1958)", "line": "Paloma Frocks, Inc. v. Shamokin Sportswear Corp., 3 N.Y.2d 572 (1958)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 26,27 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 27" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Simon v. Becherer, 7 A.D.3d 66 (1st Dep\u2019t 2004)", "line": "Simon v. Becherer, 7 A.D.3d 66 (1st Dep\u2019t 2004)", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "lacks 28 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 28" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Sterling Industries v. Ball Bearing Pen Corp., 298 N.Y. 483 (1949)", "line": "Sterling Industries v. Ball Bearing Pen Corp., 298 N.Y. 483 (1949)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "87 A.D.3d 174 (1st Dep\u2019t 2011)", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 2, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 3, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g20-ny-ad1.careful.docx", "sha256": "ff9a92c963390c0d0db8401a96c27ab2a53863f9dbbf9c4e582b02a560d6a578", "documentXmlSha256": "6df261794a350b1a3a295ef9bd55fc6036cc15e3198e074ab8371d2880c08c56" }, "seconds": 12 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g20-ny-ad1", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "37 St. John\u2019s L. Rev. 29, 76 (1962)" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g21-wa-prose", "task": { "id": "g21-wa-prose", "source": "odd/prose-wa-glymph-pfr.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "WA", "tags": [ "pro se" ], "chatbot": true, "why": "pro se petition for review" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g21-wa-prose.first.docx", "lines": 14, "keyEntries": 15, "keyPieces": 15, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 12, "found": 10, "exact": 10, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 15, "found": 13, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 18, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Picking v. Pennsylvania R. Co., 151 F.2d 240", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Pucket v. Cox, 456 F.2d 233", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "CR 56(c)", "line": "CR 56", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "lacks 7 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "85 Wn.2d 151 (1975)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2, "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g21-wa-prose.first.docx", "sha256": "f046f029230058c49a1ce1225e7f123a8a1cf88b455047bf3102885bce6b3988", "documentXmlSha256": "4145b8ef3ce1ff633f57c01cbc1c2ac2008ec6b21bd1353cf37d0704b3190cc3" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g21-wa-prose.careful.docx", "lines": 14, "keyEntries": 15, "keyPieces": 15, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 12, "found": 10, "exact": 10, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 15, "found": 13, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 18, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Picking v. Pennsylvania R. Co., 151 F.2d 240", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Pucket v. Cox, 456 F.2d 233", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "CR 56(c)", "line": "CR 56", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "lacks 7 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "85 Wn.2d 151 (1975)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2, "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g21-wa-prose.careful.docx", "sha256": "d82e73ba972e4996e540c565405580e052374e2f133ec177e6f26dc017adf188", "documentXmlSha256": "4145b8ef3ce1ff633f57c01cbc1c2ac2008ec6b21bd1353cf37d0704b3190cc3" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g21-wa-prose", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g21-wa-prose.first.docx", "lines": 14, "keyEntries": 15, "keyPieces": 15, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 12, "found": 10, "exact": 10, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 15, "found": 13, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 18, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Picking v. Pennsylvania R. Co., 151 F.2d 240", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Pucket v. Cox, 456 F.2d 233", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "CR 56(c)", "line": "CR 56", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "lacks 7 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "85 Wn.2d 151 (1975)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1, "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 2, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g21-wa-prose.first.docx", "sha256": "c360726cdb56f97f9fad6c0ea3e1ee2912c0c272d0cc775511acc5e9e1ea0fff", "documentXmlSha256": "4145b8ef3ce1ff633f57c01cbc1c2ac2008ec6b21bd1353cf37d0704b3190cc3" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g21-wa-prose.careful.docx", "lines": 15, "keyEntries": 15, "keyPieces": 15, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 12, "found": 11, "exact": 10, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 15, "found": 14, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 19, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 2, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 8, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Picking v. Pennsylvania R. Co., 151 F.2d 240", "line": "Picking v. Pennsylvania R. Co., 151 Fed 2nd 240", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 9 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Pucket v. Cox, 456 F.2d 233", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "CR 56(c)", "line": "CR 56", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 7 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Picking v. Pennsylvania R. Co., 151 Fed 2nd 240", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "85 Wn.2d 151 (1975)", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 2, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 2 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g21-wa-prose.careful.docx", "sha256": "c4fe699885438f0b2633ae5746544d20db974b4c852c955e665f795a48437938", "documentXmlSha256": "33811b8ba30620ea5a9558ed7054eb04aae891e786a429bcff85da1288b75f31" }, "seconds": 6 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g21-wa-prose", "accept": [ "Picking v. Pennsylvania R. Co., 151 Fed 2nd 240" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Picking v. Pennsylvania R. Co., 151 Fed 2nd 240", "key": "Picking v. Pennsylvania R. Co., 151 F.2d 240" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Rule 56" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g22-ny-scan", "task": { "id": "g22-ny-scan", "source": "states/ny-coa-johnson-da-resp.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "NY", "tags": [ "scan (OCR layer)" ], "chatbot": true, "why": "scanned brief with an OCR text layer; counsel's second table page is lost by the corpus parser" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g22-ny-scan.first.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 32, "keyPieces": 32, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 28, "found": 25, "exact": 23, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 32, "found": 27, "exact": 25, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 5, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 33, "byType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 2 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 25, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 2 }, "corrections": 8, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "People v De Bour , 40 NY 2d 210", "line": "People v. De Bour, 40 NY2d 210 [1976]", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "lacks 10 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Howard, 50 NY2d 583 (1980)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Perez, 31 NY3d 964 (2018)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Sobotker, 43 NY2d 559 (1978)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "People v. Wideman, 192 AD3d 1384", "line": "People v. Wideman, 192 AD3d 1384 [3d Dept 2021]", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 18 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. Penal Law \u00a7 220.16", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. Penal Law \u00a7 221.05", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "People v. Johnson, 38 NY3d 1151 [2022]", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "People v. Sobotker, 43 NY 2", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 7, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 5, "wrongPage": 1, "cosmetic": 1 }, "decisions": 9, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 5, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g22-ny-scan.first.docx", "sha256": "87e79a5566f01d501a8634314f41cd79c49cf4cd02796b424a9667715a1680f6", "documentXmlSha256": "8be18a5095fca410790d15ea4f5e6dbdf15e57fbf48a5a946b28cb81fd5d6046" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g22-ny-scan.careful.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 32, "keyPieces": 32, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 28, "found": 25, "exact": 23, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 32, "found": 27, "exact": 25, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 5, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 33, "byType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 2 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 25, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 2 }, "corrections": 8, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "People v De Bour , 40 NY 2d 210", "line": "People v. De Bour, 40 NY2d 210 [1976]", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "lacks 10 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Howard, 50 NY2d 583 (1980)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Perez, 31 NY3d 964 (2018)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Sobotker, 43 NY2d 559 (1978)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "People v. Wideman, 192 AD3d 1384", "line": "People v. Wideman, 192 AD3d 1384 [3d Dept 2021]", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 18 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. Penal Law \u00a7 220.16", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. Penal Law \u00a7 221.05", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "People v. Johnson, 38 NY3d 1151 [2022]", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "People v. Sobotker, 43 NY 2", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 7, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 5, "wrongPage": 1, "cosmetic": 1 }, "decisions": 9, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 5, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g22-ny-scan.careful.docx", "sha256": "a8b2f02ac0c7c2f128fc9f59af14f1ac0e21c6f7107b4dbc3e867ce18ef2723b", "documentXmlSha256": "8be18a5095fca410790d15ea4f5e6dbdf15e57fbf48a5a946b28cb81fd5d6046" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g22-ny-scan", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g22-ny-scan.first.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 32, "keyPieces": 32, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 28, "found": 25, "exact": 23, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 32, "found": 27, "exact": 25, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 5, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 33, "byType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 2 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 25, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 2 }, "corrections": 8, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "People v De Bour , 40 NY 2d 210", "line": "People v. De Bour, 40 NY2d 210 [1976]", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "lacks 10 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Howard, 50 NY2d 583 (1980)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Perez, 31 NY3d 964 (2018)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Sobotker, 43 NY2d 559 (1978)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "People v. Wideman, 192 AD3d 1384", "line": "People v. Wideman, 192 AD3d 1384 [3d Dept 2021]", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 18 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. Penal Law \u00a7 220.16", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. Penal Law \u00a7 221.05", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "People v. Johnson, 38 NY3d 1151 [2022]", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "People v. Sobotker, 43 NY 2", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" } ], "asked": 6, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 6, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 4, "wrongPage": 1, "cosmetic": 1 }, "decisions": 12, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 4, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 4, "modelShown": 4, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g22-ny-scan.first.docx", "sha256": "b421b78e96e88bf444192737d5d9650e29ccb80c7e6f7e0cfc468c4fd52b448e", "documentXmlSha256": "8be18a5095fca410790d15ea4f5e6dbdf15e57fbf48a5a946b28cb81fd5d6046" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g22-ny-scan.careful.docx", "lines": 31, "keyEntries": 32, "keyPieces": 32, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 28, "found": 26, "exact": 24, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 32, "found": 28, "exact": 26, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 32, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 2 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 2 }, "corrections": 8, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "People v De Bour , 40 NY 2d 210", "line": "People v. De Bour, 40 NY2d 210 [1976]", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks 10 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Perez, 31 NY3d 964 (2018)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "People v Sobotker, 43 NY2d 559 (1978)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "People v. Wideman, 192 AD3d 1384", "line": "People v. Wideman, 192 AD3d 1384 [3d Dept 2021]", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks 18 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. Penal Law \u00a7 220.16", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. Penal Law \u00a7 221.05", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "People v. Johnson, 38 NY3d 1151 [2022]", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "People v. Sobotker, 43 NY 2", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "the gold readers excluded it as not an authority (decision in this case, record, brief\u2026)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "People v Howard, 50 NY 2d , [ ]) 583 592 1980", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" } ], "asked": 6, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 7, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 4, "wrongPage": 1, "cosmetic": 1, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 13, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 4, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 4, "modelShown": 4, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 3, "suggestionClicks": 4 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g22-ny-scan.careful.docx", "sha256": "98c0e80f54ce83a18fd3ab8d9ebc2fc80a8608616fa477b4c6954df580a6ce4a", "documentXmlSha256": "e57b0677d72e9561c44f0e2453937f125438404a1ae090ec85b59ef62904698a" }, "seconds": 8 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g22-ny-scan", "accept": [ "People v Howard, 50 NY 2d , [ ]) 583 592 1980" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "People v Howard, 50 NY 2d , [ ]) 583 592 1980", "key": "People v Howard, 50 NY2d 583 (1980)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "\u00a7 Degree PL 220.16" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Blandford v New York, , US 212 L Ed 2d 333 [2022] (emphasis in original)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "People v De Bour, 40 NY d at ) 2 223" } ] } } } }, { "id": "g23-nd-para", "task": { "id": "g23-nd-para", "source": "grow-state-supreme-b/nd-sc-20250341-state-amicus.pdf", "key": "gold", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "ND", "tags": [ "paragraph-numbered" ], "chatbot": true, "why": "paragraph-numbered (\u00b6) brief" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g23-nd-para.first.docx", "lines": 41, "keyEntries": 42, "keyPieces": 42, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 24, "exact": 21, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 7, "exact": 7, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 42, "found": 40, "exact": 37, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 3, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 7, "weightedScore": 30, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 8, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Allendale Mut. Ins. Co. v. Bull Data Sys., Inc., 10 F.3d 425 (7th Cir. 1993)", "line": "Allendale Mut. Ins. Co. v. Bull Data Sys., Inc., 10 F.3d 425 (7th Cir. 1993)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 50 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 50" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Goss Int\u2019l Corp. v. Man Roland Druckmaschinen Aktiengesellschaft, 491 F.3d 355 (8th Cir. 2", "line": "Goss Int\u2019l Corp. v. Man Roland Druckmaschinen Aktiengesellschaft, 491 F.3d 355 (8th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 47 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 47" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Microsoft Corp. v. Motorola, Inc., 696 F.3d 872 (9th Cir. 2012)", "line": "Microsoft Corp. v. Motorola, Inc., 696 F.3d 872 (9th Cir. 2012)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 27 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Mass. Gen. Laws Ann. ch. 231, \u00a7 59H (2022)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. Civ. Rights Law \u00a7 70-a", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "735 Ill. Comp. Stat. 110/20", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "N.Y. Civ. Rights Law \u00a7 70a", "lines": [ 35 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "735 Ill. Comp. Stat. 110/20", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 6, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2, "cosmetic": 1, "wrongAuthority": 1, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 9, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g23-nd-para.first.docx", "sha256": "20f3f8df62f22c6369250767a21fc3ca7d338492d02413a8e5590aeb84565db1", "documentXmlSha256": "a8ed8be5ea8f02e1901df2af09efd572079689c8452d22604aa9a5864fe33591" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/g23-nd-para.careful.docx", "lines": 41, "keyEntries": 42, "keyPieces": 42, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 24, "exact": 21, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 7, "exact": 7, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 42, "found": 40, "exact": 37, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 3, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 7, "weightedScore": 30, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 8, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Allendale Mut. Ins. Co. v. Bull Data Sys., Inc., 10 F.3d 425 (7th Cir. 1993)", "line": "Allendale Mut. Ins. Co. v. Bull Data Sys., Inc., 10 F.3d 425 (7th Cir. 1993)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 50 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 50" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Goss Int\u2019l Corp. v. Man Roland Druckmaschinen Aktiengesellschaft, 491 F.3d 355 (8th Cir. 2", "line": "Goss Int\u2019l Corp. v. Man Roland Druckmaschinen Aktiengesellschaft, 491 F.3d 355 (8th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 47 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 47" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Microsoft Corp. v. Motorola, Inc., 696 F.3d 872 (9th Cir. 2012)", "line": "Microsoft Corp. v. Motorola, Inc., 696 F.3d 872 (9th Cir. 2012)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 27 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Mass. Gen. Laws Ann. ch. 231, \u00a7 59H (2022)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. Civ. Rights Law \u00a7 70-a", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "735 Ill. Comp. Stat. 110/20", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "N.Y. Civ. Rights Law \u00a7 70a", "lines": [ 35 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "735 Ill. Comp. Stat. 110/20", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 6, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2, "cosmetic": 1, "wrongAuthority": 1, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 9, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/g23-nd-para.careful.docx", "sha256": "68a50ea75da2453240d8ae438896363285d689c6a543a263f480406678982fe4", "documentXmlSha256": "a8ed8be5ea8f02e1901df2af09efd572079689c8452d22604aa9a5864fe33591" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g23-nd-para", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g23-nd-para.first.docx", "lines": 41, "keyEntries": 42, "keyPieces": 42, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 24, "exact": 21, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 7, "exact": 7, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 42, "found": 40, "exact": 37, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 3, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 7, "weightedScore": 30, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 8, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Allendale Mut. Ins. Co. v. Bull Data Sys., Inc., 10 F.3d 425 (7th Cir. 1993)", "line": "Allendale Mut. Ins. Co. v. Bull Data Sys., Inc., 10 F.3d 425 (7th Cir. 1993)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 50 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 50" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Goss Int\u2019l Corp. v. Man Roland Druckmaschinen Aktiengesellschaft, 491 F.3d 355 (8th Cir. 2", "line": "Goss Int\u2019l Corp. v. Man Roland Druckmaschinen Aktiengesellschaft, 491 F.3d 355 (8th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 47 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 47" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Microsoft Corp. v. Motorola, Inc., 696 F.3d 872 (9th Cir. 2012)", "line": "Microsoft Corp. v. Motorola, Inc., 696 F.3d 872 (9th Cir. 2012)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 27 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Mass. Gen. Laws Ann. ch. 231, \u00a7 59H (2022)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. Civ. Rights Law \u00a7 70-a", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "735 Ill. Comp. Stat. 110/20", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "N.Y. Civ. Rights Law \u00a7 70a", "lines": [ 35 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "735 Ill. Comp. Stat. 110/20", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 6, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2, "cosmetic": 1, "wrongAuthority": 1, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 9, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g23-nd-para.first.docx", "sha256": "2a5b5ae3ea73b1b9b0955131b279fea4ef32e1287b624dca8665a65fc251bb20", "documentXmlSha256": "a8ed8be5ea8f02e1901df2af09efd572079689c8452d22604aa9a5864fe33591" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/g23-nd-para.careful.docx", "lines": 41, "keyEntries": 42, "keyPieces": 42, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 24, "exact": 21, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 7, "exact": 7, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 42, "found": 40, "exact": 37, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 3, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 7, "weightedScore": 30, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 2, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 1 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 6, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 1 }, "corrections": 8, "keyKind": "gold", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Allendale Mut. Ins. Co. v. Bull Data Sys., Inc., 10 F.3d 425 (7th Cir. 1993)", "line": "Allendale Mut. Ins. Co. v. Bull Data Sys., Inc., 10 F.3d 425 (7th Cir. 1993)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 50 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 50" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Goss Int\u2019l Corp. v. Man Roland Druckmaschinen Aktiengesellschaft, 491 F.3d 355 (8th Cir. 2", "line": "Goss Int\u2019l Corp. v. Man Roland Druckmaschinen Aktiengesellschaft, 491 F.3d 355 (8th Cir. 2007)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 47 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 47" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Microsoft Corp. v. Motorola, Inc., 696 F.3d 872 (9th Cir. 2012)", "line": "Microsoft Corp. v. Motorola, Inc., 696 F.3d 872 (9th Cir. 2012)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 27 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Mass. Gen. Laws Ann. ch. 231, \u00a7 59H (2022)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. Civ. Rights Law \u00a7 70-a", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "cosmetic", "weight": 1, "line": "735 Ill. Comp. Stat. 110/20", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "under the law heading" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "N.Y. Civ. Rights Law \u00a7 70a", "lines": [ 35 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "735 Ill. Comp. Stat. 110/20", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 6, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2, "cosmetic": 1, "wrongAuthority": 1, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 9, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 3, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/g23-nd-para.careful.docx", "sha256": "ee748af614f0888e0ffed7dedda1298c40b7bd85c564bc0a1a893e311d2f2690", "documentXmlSha256": "a8ed8be5ea8f02e1901df2af09efd572079689c8452d22604aa9a5864fe33591" }, "seconds": 6 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "g23-nd-para", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } } }, { "id": "f01-ut-coa-scan", "task": { "id": "f01-ut-coa-scan", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/ut-coa-20170221-appellee.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-appellate", "jur": "UT", "tags": [ "scan (copier)", "fresh" ], "why": "Utah appellate, produced on a copier (Canon); 10 unkeyed table lines" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f01-ut-coa-scan.first.docx", "lines": 23, "keyEntries": 31, "keyPieces": 31, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "rules": { "key": 6, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 20, "exact": 19, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 30, "found": 21, "exact": 19, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 4, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 14, "weightedScore": 66, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 16, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 14, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 30, Utah R. Civ. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 52, Utah R. Civ. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 56, Utah R. Civ. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 3.7 Utah R. Profl Conduct", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 33, Utah R. App. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Kaplan v. DaimlerChrysler, A.G., 331F.3d1251, 1255 (11th Cir. Fla. 2003)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Morse v. Packer, 1999 UT 5, ~ 10, 973 P.2d 422", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Valcarce v. Fitzgerald, 961P.2d305, 319 (Utah 1998)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Westv. Thomson Newspapers, 872 P.2d 999, 1004 (Utah 1994)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "K.F.K. v. T W, 2005 UT App 85", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "D, 196 P.3d 588", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Heartwood Home Health & Hospice v. Huber, 2016 UT App 183", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "IHC Health Servs., Inc. v. D & K Mgmt., Inc., 2008 UT 73", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Spencer Law Office, LLC v. Dept. of Workforce Services, 2013 UT App 138", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" } ], "asked": 6, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 9, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 16, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 5, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 9, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f01-ut-coa-scan.first.docx", "sha256": "7d8e2c18873ca5190a277fe30bebf86036fec161e883c49007a35e24247b3e6f", "documentXmlSha256": "63cfc381d3d075a817b7bbcaffb41805c652340b709a662a8792d6e625ebcba7" }, "seconds": 7 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f01-ut-coa-scan.careful.docx", "lines": 23, "keyEntries": 31, "keyPieces": 31, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "rules": { "key": 6, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 20, "exact": 19, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 30, "found": 21, "exact": 19, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 4, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 14, "weightedScore": 66, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 16, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 14, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 30, Utah R. Civ. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 52, Utah R. Civ. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 56, Utah R. Civ. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 3.7 Utah R. Profl Conduct", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 33, Utah R. App. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Kaplan v. DaimlerChrysler, A.G., 331F.3d1251, 1255 (11th Cir. Fla. 2003)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Morse v. Packer, 1999 UT 5, ~ 10, 973 P.2d 422", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Valcarce v. Fitzgerald, 961P.2d305, 319 (Utah 1998)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Westv. Thomson Newspapers, 872 P.2d 999, 1004 (Utah 1994)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "K.F.K. v. T W, 2005 UT App 85", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "D, 196 P.3d 588", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Heartwood Home Health & Hospice v. Huber, 2016 UT App 183", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "IHC Health Servs., Inc. v. D & K Mgmt., Inc., 2008 UT 73", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Spencer Law Office, LLC v. Dept. of Workforce Services, 2013 UT App 138", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" } ], "asked": 6, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 9, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 16, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 5, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 9, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f01-ut-coa-scan.careful.docx", "sha256": "3ebb1f5eb9139cb0f26557735861c7b1c143399a66ee20fd23a77542ada7c907", "documentXmlSha256": "63cfc381d3d075a817b7bbcaffb41805c652340b709a662a8792d6e625ebcba7" }, "seconds": 11 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f01-ut-coa-scan", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f01-ut-coa-scan.first.docx", "lines": 23, "keyEntries": 31, "keyPieces": 31, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "rules": { "key": 6, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 20, "exact": 19, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 30, "found": 21, "exact": 19, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 4, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 14, "weightedScore": 66, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 16, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 14, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 30, Utah R. Civ. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 52, Utah R. Civ. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 56, Utah R. Civ. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 3.7 Utah R. Profl Conduct", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 33, Utah R. App. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Kaplan v. DaimlerChrysler, A.G., 331F.3d1251, 1255 (11th Cir. Fla. 2003)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Morse v. Packer, 1999 UT 5, ~ 10, 973 P.2d 422", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Valcarce v. Fitzgerald, 961P.2d305, 319 (Utah 1998)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Westv. Thomson Newspapers, 872 P.2d 999, 1004 (Utah 1994)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "K.F.K. v. T W, 2005 UT App 85", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "D, 196 P.3d 588", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Heartwood Home Health & Hospice v. Huber, 2016 UT App 183", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "IHC Health Servs., Inc. v. D & K Mgmt., Inc., 2008 UT 73", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Spencer Law Office, LLC v. Dept. of Workforce Services, 2013 UT App 138", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" } ], "asked": 10, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 11, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 13, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 5, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 4, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 4, "modelShown": 4, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f01-ut-coa-scan.first.docx", "sha256": "cc11ae89664b9d7b40754e3951e08bdc7e06172d393376be8e6f5f955112e7be", "documentXmlSha256": "63cfc381d3d075a817b7bbcaffb41805c652340b709a662a8792d6e625ebcba7" }, "seconds": 8 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f01-ut-coa-scan.careful.docx", "lines": 27, "keyEntries": 31, "keyPieces": 31, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "rules": { "key": 6, "found": 3, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 22, "exact": 21, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 30, "found": 25, "exact": 22, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 5, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 4, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 11, "weightedScore": 50, "byType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 25, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 16, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 11, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Rule 30, Utah R. Civ. P", "line": "Rule 30", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks 12 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 56, Utah R. Civ. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 3.7 Utah R. Profl Conduct", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule 33, Utah R. App. P", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Morse v. Packer, 1999 UT 5, ~ 10, 973 P.2d 422", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Westv. Thomson Newspapers, 872 P.2d 999, 1004 (Utah 1994)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "K.F.K. v. T W, 2005 UT App 85", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "D, 196 P.3d 588", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Heartwood Home Health & Hospice v. Huber, 2016 UT App 183", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "IHC Health Servs., Inc. v. D & K Mgmt., Inc., 2008 UT 73", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Spencer Law Office, LLC v. Dept. of Workforce Services, 2013 UT App 138", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" } ], "asked": 10, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 7, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 5, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 17, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 5, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 4, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 5, "suggestions": 4, "modelShown": 4, "trueAccepts": 4, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 4 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f01-ut-coa-scan.careful.docx", "sha256": "ca4d53591b73dcce24ed72d263cb42963ee8398aac82fd76a11ff44263009d71", "documentXmlSha256": "099c54ee2c407997008791230ea8e422d895ec6095844dcc01392fbcaaa5b3fe" }, "seconds": 16 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f01-ut-coa-scan", "accept": [ "Utah R. Civ. P. 52", "Rule 30", "Kaplan v. DaimlerChrysler, A.G., 331 F.3d 1251, 1255 (11th Cir. Fla. 2003)", "Valcarce v. Fitzgerald, 961 P.2d 305, 319 (Utah 1998)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Utah R. Civ. P. 52", "key": "Rule 52, Utah R. Civ. P" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Rule 30", "key": "Rule 30, Utah R. Civ. P" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Kaplan v. DaimlerChrysler, A.G., 331 F.3d 1251, 1255 (11th Cir. Fla. 2003)", "key": "Kaplan v. DaimlerChrysler, A.G., 331F.3d1251, 1255 (11th Cir. Fla. 2003)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Valcarce v. Fitzgerald, 961 P.2d 305, 319 (Utah 1998)", "key": "Valcarce v. Fitzgerald, 961P.2d305, 319 (Utah 1998)" } ], "wrong": [] } } } }, { "id": "f02-ut-sc", "task": { "id": "f02-ut-sc", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/ut-sc-croft-appellees.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "UT", "tags": [ "fresh", "state cite forms" ], "why": "'Utah Code \u00a7' and 'Utah Code Ann.' in one brief" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f02-ut-sc.first.docx", "lines": 42, "keyEntries": 44, "keyPieces": 44, "keyHeadings": 1, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 23, "exact": 22, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 14, "found": 14, "exact": 13, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 43, "found": 39, "exact": 37, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 28, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "T.D.G. v. L.R. (In re A.T.I.G.), 2012 UT 88, 293 P.3d 276", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Utah Code Ann. \u00a7 20A-7-602.8", "line": "Utah Code Ann. \u00a7 20A-7-602.8", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "lacks 7 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Ballentine's Law Dictionary", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Black's Law Dictionary", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary 223", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Downs v. Thompson, 2019 UT 63", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 3, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 1, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f02-ut-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "43ebd184dbecc61f9d62f7ff5dc508fb46e405cbeceb2652c22e164da36f9671", "documentXmlSha256": "dd1d74525785d3c9f6ca15ff879773a7e22144c1e124fce633ed66afc31e1dd8" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f02-ut-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 42, "keyEntries": 44, "keyPieces": 44, "keyHeadings": 1, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 23, "exact": 22, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 14, "found": 14, "exact": 13, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 43, "found": 39, "exact": 37, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 28, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "T.D.G. v. L.R. (In re A.T.I.G.), 2012 UT 88, 293 P.3d 276", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Utah Code Ann. \u00a7 20A-7-602.8", "line": "Utah Code Ann. \u00a7 20A-7-602.8", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "lacks 7 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Ballentine's Law Dictionary", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Black's Law Dictionary", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary 223", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Downs v. Thompson, 2019 UT 63", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 3, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 1, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f02-ut-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "2b7ba661f5d8832f1d8ea50e01cbb4acf08147c2146441f8208c7aab401c9ded", "documentXmlSha256": "dd1d74525785d3c9f6ca15ff879773a7e22144c1e124fce633ed66afc31e1dd8" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f02-ut-sc", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f02-ut-sc.first.docx", "lines": 42, "keyEntries": 44, "keyPieces": 44, "keyHeadings": 1, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 23, "exact": 22, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 14, "found": 14, "exact": 13, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 43, "found": 39, "exact": 37, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 28, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "T.D.G. v. L.R. (In re A.T.I.G.), 2012 UT 88, 293 P.3d 276", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Utah Code Ann. \u00a7 20A-7-602.8", "line": "Utah Code Ann. \u00a7 20A-7-602.8", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "lacks 7 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Ballentine's Law Dictionary", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Black's Law Dictionary", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary 223", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Downs v. Thompson, 2019 UT 63", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 1, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f02-ut-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "60f460e8b514b95827f6db8dbf1bd801f35a0fee51825e41d996cfe055523e2e", "documentXmlSha256": "dd1d74525785d3c9f6ca15ff879773a7e22144c1e124fce633ed66afc31e1dd8" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f02-ut-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 43, "keyEntries": 44, "keyPieces": 44, "keyHeadings": 1, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 23, "exact": 22, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 14, "found": 14, "exact": 13, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 43, "found": 40, "exact": 38, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 1, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 5, "weightedScore": 23, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 5, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "T.D.G. v. L.R. (In re A.T.I.G.), 2012 UT 88, 293 P.3d 276", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Utah Code Ann. \u00a7 20A-7-602.8", "line": "Utah Code Ann. \u00a7 20A-7-602.8", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "lacks 7 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Ballentine's Law Dictionary", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Black's Law Dictionary", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Downs v. Thompson, 2019 UT 63", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2, "badLine": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 1, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 2, "suggestionClicks": 3 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f02-ut-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "57420cd314cc20b36580b68af684933f74bf4f353a67c677c28186fafc4f76ce", "documentXmlSha256": "f7cdd485cf265983b231dbc170a8eb9dd42f41764bede64d466d4e2348a51d3e" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f02-ut-sc", "accept": [ "Webster\u2019s Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary 223" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Webster\u2019s Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary 223", "key": "Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary 223" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "H.B. 119" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "H.B. 119, 2019 Gen. Sess. (Utah)." } ] } } } }, { "id": "f03-mn-coa", "task": { "id": "f03-mn-coa", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/mn-coa-a191877-respondent.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-appellate", "jur": "MN", "tags": [ "fresh" ], "chatbot": true, "why": "Minnesota appellate, 90 entries, quotation split across a page break (Evanson)" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f03-mn-coa.first.docx", "lines": 84, "keyEntries": 90, "keyPieces": 90, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 66, "found": 65, "exact": 50, "defensible": 10, "passim": 4 }, "statutes": { "key": 12, "found": 10, "exact": 5, "defensible": 3, "passim": 2 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 85, "found": 78, "exact": 56, "defensible": 14, "passim": 6 }, "missing": 7, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 10, "weightedScore": 61, "byType": { "missing": 7, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 5, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 35, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 10, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 11, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Edward Valves, Inc. v. Wake County, 343 N.C. 426, 471 S.E.2d 342 (1996)", "line": "Edward Valves, Inc. v. Wake County, 343 N.C. 426, 471 S.E.2d 342 (1996)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 42 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Evanson v. Comm'r of Taxation, 159 N.W.2d 259 (Minn. 1968)", "line": "Evanson v. Comm\u2019r of Taxation, 159 N.W.2d 259 (Minn. 1968)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 17 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Fichtner v. Schiller, 135 N.W.2d 877 (Minn. 1965)", "line": "Fichtner v. Schiller, 135 N.W.2d 877 (Minn. 1965)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 20,25 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hamm v. State, 95 N.W.2d 649 (Minn. 1959)", "line": "Hamm v. State, 95 N.W.2d 649 (Minn. 1959)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 48 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Patel v. City of San Bernardino, 310 F.3d 1138 (9th Cir. 2002)", "line": "Patel v. City of San Bernardino, 310 F.3d 1138 (9th Cir. 2002)", "lines": [ 52 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Programmed Land, Inc. v. O'Connor, 602 N.W.2d at 906 (aff'd in part, rev'd in part, 633 N.W.2d 517)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Elam, 84 N.W.2d 227 (Minn. 1957)", "line": "State v. Elam, 84 N.W.2d 227 (Minn. 1957)", "lines": [ 60 ], "detail": "lacks 15,16,20,25 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Civil Rights Act of 1871", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. Stat. Ch. 275", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. Stat. \u00a7 278.09", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "U.S. Constitution, Amend. XIV (Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses)", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. XIV", "lines": [ 69 ], "detail": "lacks 14,21 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 14" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minnesota Constitution, Article X, Section 1 (Uniformity Clause)", "detail": "constitution (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. R. Civ. P. 5A", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. Gen. Rules of Prac. 115.03", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Nat'l Private Truck Council, Inc. v. Okla. Tax Comm'n, 515 U.S. 582 (1995) .................................................................", "line": "New England Legal Found. v. City of Boston, 670 N.E.2d 152 (Mass. 1996)", "lines": [ 49 ], "detail": "also on: Nat\u2019l Private Truck Council, Inc. v. Okla. Tax Comm\u2019n, 515 U" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Minn. R. Civ. P. 5", "lines": [ 80 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 2, "missing": 6, "duplicate": 1, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 14, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 2, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 6, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f03-mn-coa.first.docx", "sha256": "d3bac6c76e14df4b2278a5e64d60c4af016749748f665e87dcf0278f4bdb179f", "documentXmlSha256": "059eeb6f18abf3a142edc12e331b81fab93c4b7aaec73461e92b1d1b7381d50e" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f03-mn-coa.careful.docx", "lines": 84, "keyEntries": 90, "keyPieces": 90, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 66, "found": 65, "exact": 50, "defensible": 10, "passim": 4 }, "statutes": { "key": 12, "found": 10, "exact": 5, "defensible": 3, "passim": 2 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 85, "found": 78, "exact": 56, "defensible": 14, "passim": 6 }, "missing": 7, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 10, "weightedScore": 61, "byType": { "missing": 7, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 5, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 35, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 10, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 11, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Edward Valves, Inc. v. Wake County, 343 N.C. 426, 471 S.E.2d 342 (1996)", "line": "Edward Valves, Inc. v. Wake County, 343 N.C. 426, 471 S.E.2d 342 (1996)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 42 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Evanson v. Comm'r of Taxation, 159 N.W.2d 259 (Minn. 1968)", "line": "Evanson v. Comm\u2019r of Taxation, 159 N.W.2d 259 (Minn. 1968)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 17 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Fichtner v. Schiller, 135 N.W.2d 877 (Minn. 1965)", "line": "Fichtner v. Schiller, 135 N.W.2d 877 (Minn. 1965)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 20,25 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hamm v. State, 95 N.W.2d 649 (Minn. 1959)", "line": "Hamm v. State, 95 N.W.2d 649 (Minn. 1959)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 48 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Patel v. City of San Bernardino, 310 F.3d 1138 (9th Cir. 2002)", "line": "Patel v. City of San Bernardino, 310 F.3d 1138 (9th Cir. 2002)", "lines": [ 52 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Programmed Land, Inc. v. O'Connor, 602 N.W.2d at 906 (aff'd in part, rev'd in part, 633 N.W.2d 517)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Elam, 84 N.W.2d 227 (Minn. 1957)", "line": "State v. Elam, 84 N.W.2d 227 (Minn. 1957)", "lines": [ 60 ], "detail": "lacks 15,16,20,25 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Civil Rights Act of 1871", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. Stat. Ch. 275", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. Stat. \u00a7 278.09", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "U.S. Constitution, Amend. XIV (Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses)", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. XIV", "lines": [ 69 ], "detail": "lacks 14,21 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 14" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minnesota Constitution, Article X, Section 1 (Uniformity Clause)", "detail": "constitution (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. R. Civ. P. 5A", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. Gen. Rules of Prac. 115.03", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Nat'l Private Truck Council, Inc. v. Okla. Tax Comm'n, 515 U.S. 582 (1995) .................................................................", "line": "New England Legal Found. v. City of Boston, 670 N.E.2d 152 (Mass. 1996)", "lines": [ 49 ], "detail": "also on: Nat\u2019l Private Truck Council, Inc. v. Okla. Tax Comm\u2019n, 515 U" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Minn. R. Civ. P. 5", "lines": [ 80 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 2, "missing": 6, "duplicate": 1, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 14, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 2, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 6, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f03-mn-coa.careful.docx", "sha256": "5197ebc118f5b88c109ed40d1a25185ed37c8f379910141154b38b5e370dbabb", "documentXmlSha256": "059eeb6f18abf3a142edc12e331b81fab93c4b7aaec73461e92b1d1b7381d50e" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f03-mn-coa", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f03-mn-coa.first.docx", "lines": 84, "keyEntries": 90, "keyPieces": 90, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 66, "found": 65, "exact": 50, "defensible": 10, "passim": 4 }, "statutes": { "key": 12, "found": 10, "exact": 5, "defensible": 3, "passim": 2 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 85, "found": 78, "exact": 56, "defensible": 14, "passim": 6 }, "missing": 7, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 10, "weightedScore": 61, "byType": { "missing": 7, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 5, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 35, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 10, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 11, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Edward Valves, Inc. v. Wake County, 343 N.C. 426, 471 S.E.2d 342 (1996)", "line": "Edward Valves, Inc. v. Wake County, 343 N.C. 426, 471 S.E.2d 342 (1996)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 42 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Evanson v. Comm'r of Taxation, 159 N.W.2d 259 (Minn. 1968)", "line": "Evanson v. Comm\u2019r of Taxation, 159 N.W.2d 259 (Minn. 1968)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 17 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Fichtner v. Schiller, 135 N.W.2d 877 (Minn. 1965)", "line": "Fichtner v. Schiller, 135 N.W.2d 877 (Minn. 1965)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 20,25 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hamm v. State, 95 N.W.2d 649 (Minn. 1959)", "line": "Hamm v. State, 95 N.W.2d 649 (Minn. 1959)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 48 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Patel v. City of San Bernardino, 310 F.3d 1138 (9th Cir. 2002)", "line": "Patel v. City of San Bernardino, 310 F.3d 1138 (9th Cir. 2002)", "lines": [ 52 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Programmed Land, Inc. v. O'Connor, 602 N.W.2d at 906 (aff'd in part, rev'd in part, 633 N.W.2d 517)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Elam, 84 N.W.2d 227 (Minn. 1957)", "line": "State v. Elam, 84 N.W.2d 227 (Minn. 1957)", "lines": [ 60 ], "detail": "lacks 15,16,20,25 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Civil Rights Act of 1871", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. Stat. Ch. 275", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. Stat. \u00a7 278.09", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "U.S. Constitution, Amend. XIV (Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses)", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. XIV", "lines": [ 69 ], "detail": "lacks 14,21 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 14" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minnesota Constitution, Article X, Section 1 (Uniformity Clause)", "detail": "constitution (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. R. Civ. P. 5A", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. Gen. Rules of Prac. 115.03", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Nat'l Private Truck Council, Inc. v. Okla. Tax Comm'n, 515 U.S. 582 (1995) .................................................................", "line": "New England Legal Found. v. City of Boston, 670 N.E.2d 152 (Mass. 1996)", "lines": [ 49 ], "detail": "also on: Nat\u2019l Private Truck Council, Inc. v. Okla. Tax Comm\u2019n, 515 U" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Minn. R. Civ. P. 5", "lines": [ 80 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 10, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 2, "missing": 6, "duplicate": 1, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 20, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 6, "short citation with no full one": 2, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 6, "suggestions": 6, "modelShown": 6, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f03-mn-coa.first.docx", "sha256": "f04bb580a8085cab9f787129d5fe5d81dc5e9de3b00a03c4087db178b42b3ee4", "documentXmlSha256": "059eeb6f18abf3a142edc12e331b81fab93c4b7aaec73461e92b1d1b7381d50e" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f03-mn-coa.careful.docx", "lines": 84, "keyEntries": 90, "keyPieces": 90, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 66, "found": 65, "exact": 50, "defensible": 10, "passim": 4 }, "statutes": { "key": 12, "found": 10, "exact": 5, "defensible": 3, "passim": 2 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 85, "found": 78, "exact": 56, "defensible": 14, "passim": 6 }, "missing": 7, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 10, "weightedScore": 61, "byType": { "missing": 7, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 5, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 35, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 10, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 11, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Edward Valves, Inc. v. Wake County, 343 N.C. 426, 471 S.E.2d 342 (1996)", "line": "Edward Valves, Inc. v. Wake County, 343 N.C. 426, 471 S.E.2d 342 (1996)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 42 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Evanson v. Comm'r of Taxation, 159 N.W.2d 259 (Minn. 1968)", "line": "Evanson v. Comm\u2019r of Taxation, 159 N.W.2d 259 (Minn. 1968)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 17 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Fichtner v. Schiller, 135 N.W.2d 877 (Minn. 1965)", "line": "Fichtner v. Schiller, 135 N.W.2d 877 (Minn. 1965)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 20,25 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Hamm v. State, 95 N.W.2d 649 (Minn. 1959)", "line": "Hamm v. State, 95 N.W.2d 649 (Minn. 1959)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "lacks 48 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Patel v. City of San Bernardino, 310 F.3d 1138 (9th Cir. 2002)", "line": "Patel v. City of San Bernardino, 310 F.3d 1138 (9th Cir. 2002)", "lines": [ 52 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Programmed Land, Inc. v. O'Connor, 602 N.W.2d at 906 (aff'd in part, rev'd in part, 633 N.W.2d 517)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Elam, 84 N.W.2d 227 (Minn. 1957)", "line": "State v. Elam, 84 N.W.2d 227 (Minn. 1957)", "lines": [ 60 ], "detail": "lacks 15,16,20,25 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Civil Rights Act of 1871", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. Stat. Ch. 275", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. Stat. \u00a7 278.09", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "U.S. Constitution, Amend. XIV (Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses)", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. XIV", "lines": [ 69 ], "detail": "lacks 14,21 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 14" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minnesota Constitution, Article X, Section 1 (Uniformity Clause)", "detail": "constitution (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. R. Civ. P. 5A", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Minn. Gen. Rules of Prac. 115.03", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Nat'l Private Truck Council, Inc. v. Okla. Tax Comm'n, 515 U.S. 582 (1995) .................................................................", "line": "New England Legal Found. v. City of Boston, 670 N.E.2d 152 (Mass. 1996)", "lines": [ 49 ], "detail": "also on: Nat\u2019l Private Truck Council, Inc. v. Okla. Tax Comm\u2019n, 515 U" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Minn. R. Civ. P. 5", "lines": [ 80 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 10, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 2, "missing": 6, "duplicate": 1, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 20, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 6, "short citation with no full one": 2, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 6, "suggestions": 6, "modelShown": 6, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 6, "suggestionClicks": 6 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f03-mn-coa.careful.docx", "sha256": "0e5995996c9c1f846415c17fde312aa1affe0f81eb2b2f71e1d3506dba11d09a", "documentXmlSha256": "059eeb6f18abf3a142edc12e331b81fab93c4b7aaec73461e92b1d1b7381d50e" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f03-mn-coa", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Minnesota Laws 1935" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Section 278" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Minn. Statutes Chapters 275" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Rule 115.03(c) of the Rules of General Practice" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Rule 115.03" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Rule 129.03 of the Minnesota Rules of Appellate Procedure" } ] } } } }, { "id": "f04-ct-sc", "task": { "id": "f04-ct-sc", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/ct-sc-20327-brief.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "CT", "tags": [ "fresh" ], "chatbot": true, "why": "Connecticut Supreme Court; quotation split across a page break (Krijger)" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f04-ct-sc.first.docx", "lines": 42, "keyEntries": 45, "keyPieces": 45, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 38, "found": 38, "exact": 31, "defensible": 5, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 44, "found": 39, "exact": 31, "defensible": 6, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 5, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 28, "byType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 25, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Maris v. McGrath, 269 Conn. 834, 850 A.2d 133 (2004)", "line": "Maris v. McGrath, 269 Conn. 834 (2004)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 22" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "60 H.R. Proc., Pt. 16, 2017 Sess., excerpted", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "FBI Intelligence Bulletin: \"Anti-Government, Identity Based, and Fringe Political Conspiracy Theories Very Likely Motivate Some Domestic Ext", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\"4Chan\" Wikipedia excerpt, accessed August 15, 2019", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/8chan Derek Hawkins, Sandy Hook hoaxer gets prison time for threatening 6-year-old victim's father, Wash. Post", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2017/06/08/sandy-hook-hoaxer- gets-prison-time-for-threatening-6-year-old-victims-father/", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 6, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 3, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3 }, "decisions": 9, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 4, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 2, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f04-ct-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "2e3e00da3d79117ee9e1336325506cb7a5bc1dfbba97ac6bb546148d322d9cdc", "documentXmlSha256": "8d993843f3d86ae6d2e9a4092883a23e4682c57f8586dc564cb9c5bdc811ca42" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f04-ct-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 43, "keyEntries": 45, "keyPieces": 45, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 38, "found": 38, "exact": 31, "defensible": 5, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 44, "found": 40, "exact": 32, "defensible": 6, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 5, "weightedScore": 23, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 5, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Maris v. McGrath, 269 Conn. 834, 850 A.2d 133 (2004)", "line": "Maris v. McGrath, 269 Conn. 834 (2004)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 22" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "60 H.R. Proc., Pt. 16, 2017 Sess., excerpted", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "FBI Intelligence Bulletin: \"Anti-Government, Identity Based, and Fringe Political Conspiracy Theories Very Likely Motivate Some Domestic Ext", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\"4Chan\" Wikipedia excerpt, accessed August 15, 2019", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2017/06/08/sandy-hook-hoaxer- gets-prison-time-for-threatening-6-year-old-victims-father/", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 6, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 4 }, "decisions": 10, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 4, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 2, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 2 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f04-ct-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "a13cc90836f4b1c3400612780f7a573fd96c878082fa4590b93a4c9a32fdd297", "documentXmlSha256": "1c6f499fcf8389d2d89049cb3d5a2c883ab29bda427d7e234770184c449df5bc" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f04-ct-sc", "accept": [ "PA498, Derek Hawkins, Sandy Hook hoaxer gets prison time for threatening 6-year-old victim\u2019s father, Wash. Post (June 8, 2017)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "PA498, Derek Hawkins, Sandy Hook hoaxer gets prison time for threatening 6-year-old victim\u2019s father, Wash. Post (June 8, 2017)", "key": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/8chan Derek Hawkins, Sandy Hook hoaxer gets prison time for threatening 6-year-old victim's father, Wash. Post" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "PA503, James Doubek, Conspiracy Theorist Alex Jones Apologizes For Promoting \u2018Pizzagate\u2019, NPR (Mar. 26, 2017)" } ] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f04-ct-sc.first.docx", "lines": 42, "keyEntries": 45, "keyPieces": 45, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 38, "found": 38, "exact": 31, "defensible": 5, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 44, "found": 39, "exact": 31, "defensible": 6, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 5, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 28, "byType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 25, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Maris v. McGrath, 269 Conn. 834, 850 A.2d 133 (2004)", "line": "Maris v. McGrath, 269 Conn. 834 (2004)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 22" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "60 H.R. Proc., Pt. 16, 2017 Sess., excerpted", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "FBI Intelligence Bulletin: \"Anti-Government, Identity Based, and Fringe Political Conspiracy Theories Very Likely Motivate Some Domestic Ext", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\"4Chan\" Wikipedia excerpt, accessed August 15, 2019", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/8chan Derek Hawkins, Sandy Hook hoaxer gets prison time for threatening 6-year-old victim's father, Wash. Post", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2017/06/08/sandy-hook-hoaxer- gets-prison-time-for-threatening-6-year-old-victims-father/", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 9, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 4, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 2, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 1, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f04-ct-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "5ef0eb8f11fc99a84fad35faadaf0b377b6add86149af315b5e6cea370111123", "documentXmlSha256": "8d993843f3d86ae6d2e9a4092883a23e4682c57f8586dc564cb9c5bdc811ca42" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f04-ct-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 44, "keyEntries": 45, "keyPieces": 45, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 38, "found": 38, "exact": 31, "defensible": 5, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 44, "found": 41, "exact": 33, "defensible": 6, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 18, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Maris v. McGrath, 269 Conn. 834, 850 A.2d 133 (2004)", "line": "Maris v. McGrath, 269 Conn. 834 (2004)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 22" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "FBI Intelligence Bulletin: \"Anti-Government, Identity Based, and Fringe Political Conspiracy Theories Very Likely Motivate Some Domestic Ext", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\"4Chan\" Wikipedia excerpt, accessed August 15, 2019", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2017/06/08/sandy-hook-hoaxer- gets-prison-time-for-threatening-6-year-old-victims-father/", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3 }, "decisions": 10, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 4, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 2, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 1, "trueAccepts": 2, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 3 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f04-ct-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "3139a3440c16585156ae5109478a0499b2a3591cd68c9409f7dcd4c69283ff7d", "documentXmlSha256": "efbd3f408602ce3cc6864df64c0f5d5a3cb9be9ddabf34b080ae1602fa0a9b22" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f04-ct-sc", "accept": [ "PA498, Derek Hawkins, Sandy Hook hoaxer gets prison time for threatening 6-year-old victim\u2019s father, Wash. Post (June 8, 2017)", "60 H.R. Proc., Pt. 16, 2017 sess. at 6894" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "PA498, Derek Hawkins, Sandy Hook hoaxer gets prison time for threatening 6-year-old victim\u2019s father, Wash. Post (June 8, 2017)", "key": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/8chan Derek Hawkins, Sandy Hook hoaxer gets prison time for threatening 6-year-old victim's father, Wash. Post" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "60 H.R. Proc., Pt. 16, 2017 sess. at 6894", "key": "60 H.R. Proc., Pt. 16, 2017 Sess., excerpted" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "PA503, James Doubek, Conspiracy Theorist Alex Jones Apologizes For Promoting \u2018Pizzagate\u2019, NPR (Mar. 26, 2017)" } ] } } } }, { "id": "f05-ct-app-scan", "task": { "id": "f05-ct-app-scan", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/ct-app-43042-jackson.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-appellate", "jur": "CT", "tags": [ "fresh", "scan (OCR layer)" ], "why": "scanned (RICOH) with an OCR layer, small table" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f05-ct-app-scan.first.docx", "lines": 8, "keyEntries": 8, "keyPieces": 8, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 5, "found": 5, "exact": 2, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 8, "found": 7, "exact": 2, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 9, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Connecticut General Statutes \u00a749-8", "line": "Conn. Gen. Stat. \u00a7 49-8", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Connecticut General Statutes \u00a742-110(b) efseq", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 3, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f05-ct-app-scan.first.docx", "sha256": "e1ff188d0104428303d05aa41fab55c31e2982f9561338943a69d166acbf1d11", "documentXmlSha256": "415053c25bec9426d2d3b8f7d53a689cb2d9eb5653f1bb6bbbc87ad17443e46d" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f05-ct-app-scan.careful.docx", "lines": 8, "keyEntries": 8, "keyPieces": 8, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 5, "found": 5, "exact": 2, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 8, "found": 7, "exact": 2, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 9, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Connecticut General Statutes \u00a749-8", "line": "Conn. Gen. Stat. \u00a7 49-8", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Connecticut General Statutes \u00a742-110(b) efseq", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 3, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f05-ct-app-scan.careful.docx", "sha256": "78eb6b5c5109843deafc2b8cb1998506a0380a42347b52a1c3edd90a8d8c76dd", "documentXmlSha256": "415053c25bec9426d2d3b8f7d53a689cb2d9eb5653f1bb6bbbc87ad17443e46d" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f05-ct-app-scan", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f05-ct-app-scan.first.docx", "lines": 8, "keyEntries": 8, "keyPieces": 8, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 5, "found": 5, "exact": 2, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 8, "found": 7, "exact": 2, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 9, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Connecticut General Statutes \u00a749-8", "line": "Conn. Gen. Stat. \u00a7 49-8", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Connecticut General Statutes \u00a742-110(b) efseq", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 3, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f05-ct-app-scan.first.docx", "sha256": "4f5c019344e5d09f2acae8ce07acb72424ce7f7bd7a26fe0d2a4b323f1216c8a", "documentXmlSha256": "415053c25bec9426d2d3b8f7d53a689cb2d9eb5653f1bb6bbbc87ad17443e46d" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f05-ct-app-scan.careful.docx", "lines": 8, "keyEntries": 8, "keyPieces": 8, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 5, "found": 5, "exact": 2, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 3, "found": 2, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 8, "found": 7, "exact": 2, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 9, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Connecticut General Statutes \u00a749-8", "line": "Conn. Gen. Stat. \u00a7 49-8", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Connecticut General Statutes \u00a742-110(b) efseq", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 3, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f05-ct-app-scan.careful.docx", "sha256": "16b18b025ae7c4cb7a618a530131fe265b35623583faf679a9e91206f667ff46", "documentXmlSha256": "415053c25bec9426d2d3b8f7d53a689cb2d9eb5653f1bb6bbbc87ad17443e46d" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f05-ct-app-scan", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } } }, { "id": "f06-de-sc", "task": { "id": "f06-de-sc", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/de-sc-oa5636-goldman.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "DE", "tags": [ "fresh" ], "chatbot": true, "why": "Delaware corporate law brief (Del. C.)" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f06-de-sc.first.docx", "lines": 42, "keyEntries": 56, "keyPieces": 56, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 33, "exact": 33, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 15, "found": 5, "exact": 3, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 7, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 56, "found": 42, "exact": 40, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 14, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 15, "weightedScore": 74, "byType": { "missing": 14, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 70, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 15, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Llamas v. Titus, C.A. No. 2018-0516-JTL (Del. Ch. Feb. 19, 2019) (TRANSCRIPT)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "1 Del. C. \u00a7 303", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 17-705", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-110", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-607(b)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-705", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-1101(b)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act \u00a7 504", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Uniform Limited Partnership Act \u00a7 21", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Uniform Limited Partnership Act \u00a7 704", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Antonin Scalia & Bryan A. Garner, Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts 214 (2012)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Carter G. Bishop & Daniel S. Kleinberger, Limited Liability Companies \u00a7 14.40 (2024)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Eugene A. Gilmore, Handbook on the Law of Partnerships (1911)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Webster's Third New Int'l Dictionary (1976)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "discussing Russello v. United States, 464 U.S. 16 (1983)", "lines": [ 32 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 3, "unsurfaced": 12, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 12 }, "decisions": 16, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 2, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 12, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f06-de-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "844033e5a83b1d5f09b43332f77e052ee0b3b9fe44160e8268b4a65fb607dd36", "documentXmlSha256": "1630072c886ca7eb586a174b122a53abd76e5967863ba19930e9eb76737b1004" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f06-de-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 44, "keyEntries": 56, "keyPieces": 56, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 33, "exact": 33, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 15, "found": 5, "exact": 3, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 7, "found": 6, "exact": 5, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 56, "found": 44, "exact": 41, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 12, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 13, "weightedScore": 64, "byType": { "missing": 12, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 60, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 13, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Llamas v. Titus, C.A. No. 2018-0516-JTL (Del. Ch. Feb. 19, 2019) (TRANSCRIPT)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "1 Del. C. \u00a7 303", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 17-705", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-110", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-607(b)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-705", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-1101(b)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act \u00a7 504", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Uniform Limited Partnership Act \u00a7 21", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Uniform Limited Partnership Act \u00a7 704", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Carter G. Bishop & Daniel S. Kleinberger, Limited Liability Companies \u00a7 14.40 (2024)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Webster's Third New Int'l Dictionary (1976)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "discussing Russello v. United States, 464 U.S. 16 (1983)", "lines": [ 32 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 12, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 12 }, "decisions": 16, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 2, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 12, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 2, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 2 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f06-de-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "920f43715c791379dadb3ffb94f9a0f966c463d670d1ca911da505f6a12e6660", "documentXmlSha256": "a9fa46adb4adc262d97c2415f8197ad38663eed898bd095b9099ee178f8c524b" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f06-de-sc", "accept": [ "Antonin Scalia & Bryan A. Garner, Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts (2012)", "Eugene A. Gilmore, Handbook on the Law of Partnerships (1911)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Antonin Scalia & Bryan A. Garner, Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts (2012)", "key": "Antonin Scalia & Bryan A. Garner, Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts 214 (2012)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Eugene A. Gilmore, Handbook on the Law of Partnerships (1911)", "key": "Eugene A. Gilmore, Handbook on the Law of Partnerships (1911)" } ], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f06-de-sc.first.docx", "lines": 42, "keyEntries": 56, "keyPieces": 56, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 33, "exact": 33, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 15, "found": 5, "exact": 3, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 7, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 56, "found": 42, "exact": 40, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 14, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 15, "weightedScore": 74, "byType": { "missing": 14, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 70, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 15, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Llamas v. Titus, C.A. No. 2018-0516-JTL (Del. Ch. Feb. 19, 2019) (TRANSCRIPT)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "1 Del. C. \u00a7 303", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 17-705", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-110", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-607(b)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-705", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-1101(b)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act \u00a7 504", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Uniform Limited Partnership Act \u00a7 21", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Uniform Limited Partnership Act \u00a7 704", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Antonin Scalia & Bryan A. Garner, Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts 214 (2012)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Carter G. Bishop & Daniel S. Kleinberger, Limited Liability Companies \u00a7 14.40 (2024)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Eugene A. Gilmore, Handbook on the Law of Partnerships (1911)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Webster's Third New Int'l Dictionary (1976)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "discussing Russello v. United States, 464 U.S. 16 (1983)", "lines": [ 32 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 16, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 14, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 17, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 2, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 12, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 14, "modelShown": 12, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f06-de-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "b57b9e6ecbe2e7fd544d514432c1d25c96a3234de1e7742199b8364c704df0f3", "documentXmlSha256": "1630072c886ca7eb586a174b122a53abd76e5967863ba19930e9eb76737b1004" }, "seconds": 6 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f06-de-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 54, "keyEntries": 56, "keyPieces": 56, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 34, "exact": 34, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 15, "found": 13, "exact": 7, "defensible": 3, "passim": 1 }, "other": { "key": 7, "found": 7, "exact": 6, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 56, "found": 54, "exact": 47, "defensible": 4, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 5, "weightedScore": 22, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 5, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-110", "line": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-110", "lines": [ 39 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 27 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-1101(b)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act \u00a7 504", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Carter G. Bishop & Daniel S. Kleinberger, Limited Liability Companies \u00a7 14.40 (2024)", "line": "Carter G. Bishop & Daniel S. Kleinberger, Limited Liability Companies \u00a7 14.40", "lines": [ 48 ], "detail": "lacks 31 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "discussing Russello v. United States, 464 U.S. 16 (1983)", "lines": [ 33 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 16, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 2, "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 20, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 2, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 12, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 14, "modelShown": 12, "trueAccepts": 13, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 14 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f06-de-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "1c80ee19860e70c4cebd0ca99e61c0c01ce53dcc53088c1690de23d9639e6449", "documentXmlSha256": "37e4838bfc2cfc090ff08bb70aa009ea4d819d2c544be47e6cbfb71cb6f327c8" }, "seconds": 10 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f06-de-sc", "accept": [ "Antonin Scalia & Bryan A. Garner, Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts (2012)", "Eugene A. Gilmore, Handbook on the Law of Partnerships (1911)", "Section 18-705 of the Delaware LLC Act", "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-110", "1 Del. C. \u00a7 303", "Webster\u2019s Third New Int\u2019l Dictionary (1976)", "Carter G. Bishop & Daniel S. Kleinberger, Limited Liability Companies \u00a7 14.40", "Section 18-607(b) of the Delaware Code", "Llamas v. Titus, C.A. No. 2018-0516-JTL (Del. Ch. Feb. 19, 2019)", "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-1101", "\u00a7 704", "ULPA \u00a7 21 (1916).", "6 Del. C. \u00a7 17-705" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Antonin Scalia & Bryan A. Garner, Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts (2012)", "key": "Antonin Scalia & Bryan A. Garner, Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts 214 (2012)" }, { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Eugene A. Gilmore, Handbook on the Law of Partnerships (1911)", "key": "Eugene A. Gilmore, Handbook on the Law of Partnerships (1911)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Section 18-705 of the Delaware LLC Act", "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-705" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-110", "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-110" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "1 Del. C. \u00a7 303", "key": "1 Del. C. \u00a7 303" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Webster\u2019s Third New Int\u2019l Dictionary (1976)", "key": "Webster's Third New Int'l Dictionary (1976)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Carter G. Bishop & Daniel S. Kleinberger, Limited Liability Companies \u00a7 14.40", "key": "Carter G. Bishop & Daniel S. Kleinberger, Limited Liability Companies \u00a7 14.40 (2024)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Section 18-607(b) of the Delaware Code", "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-607(b)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Llamas v. Titus, C.A. No. 2018-0516-JTL (Del. Ch. Feb. 19, 2019)", "key": "Llamas v. Titus, C.A. No. 2018-0516-JTL (Del. Ch. Feb. 19, 2019) (TRANSCRIPT)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-1101", "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 18-1101(b)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "\u00a7 704", "key": "Uniform Limited Partnership Act \u00a7 704" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "ULPA \u00a7 21 (1916).", "key": "Uniform Limited Partnership Act \u00a7 21" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 17-705", "key": "6 Del. C. \u00a7 17-705" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Section 702" } ] } } } }, { "id": "f07-nj-sc", "task": { "id": "f07-nj-sc", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/nj-sc-a-47-24-supp-respondent.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "NJ", "tags": [ "fresh" ], "why": "New Jersey; counsel's table software matched 'West' (a known key error)" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f07-nj-sc.first.docx", "lines": 28, "keyEntries": 34, "keyPieces": 34, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 6, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 27, "found": 27, "exact": 20, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 28, "found": 27, "exact": 20, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 16, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "State v. Alvarez, 318 N.J. Super. 137 (App. Div. 1999)", "line": "State v. Alvarez, 318 N.J. Super. 137 (App. Div. 1999)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 44 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 44" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Cain, 224 N.J. 410, 133 A.3d 619 (2016)", "line": "State v. Cain, 224 N.J. 410, 133 A.3d 619 (2016)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Marshall, 148 N.J. 89, 690 A.2d 1, cert. denied, 522 U.S. 850, 118 S. Ct. 140, 13", "line": "State v. Marshall, 148 N.J. 89, 690 A.2d 1", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks 43,44,45 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. McDonough, 337 N.J. Super. 27 (2001)", "line": "State v. McDonough, 337 N.J. Super. 27 (2001)", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "lacks 45,46 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Milton, 255 N.J. Super. 514 (App. Div. 1992)", "line": "State v. Milton, 255 N.J. Super. 514 (App. Div. 1992)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 43 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Statutes PAGE NOS. N.J.S.A. 2C:5-2(a)(1)", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 2, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f07-nj-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "bb8c467ae4e06fb87d6349b7594ec0022a126fea8921d232f24133e80ca438e9", "documentXmlSha256": "7f43801c2a2c5409647bed9e0c86e9a2c450dc2e4267d0a31ac048665072ee61" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f07-nj-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 28, "keyEntries": 34, "keyPieces": 34, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 6, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 27, "found": 27, "exact": 20, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 28, "found": 27, "exact": 20, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 16, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "State v. Alvarez, 318 N.J. Super. 137 (App. Div. 1999)", "line": "State v. Alvarez, 318 N.J. Super. 137 (App. Div. 1999)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 44 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 44" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Cain, 224 N.J. 410, 133 A.3d 619 (2016)", "line": "State v. Cain, 224 N.J. 410, 133 A.3d 619 (2016)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Marshall, 148 N.J. 89, 690 A.2d 1, cert. denied, 522 U.S. 850, 118 S. Ct. 140, 13", "line": "State v. Marshall, 148 N.J. 89, 690 A.2d 1", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks 43,44,45 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. McDonough, 337 N.J. Super. 27 (2001)", "line": "State v. McDonough, 337 N.J. Super. 27 (2001)", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "lacks 45,46 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Milton, 255 N.J. Super. 514 (App. Div. 1992)", "line": "State v. Milton, 255 N.J. Super. 514 (App. Div. 1992)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 43 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Statutes PAGE NOS. N.J.S.A. 2C:5-2(a)(1)", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 2, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f07-nj-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "1d090aaff1d39c1034aa75e914dcabdb4011fb2d4817d49b4408c9204bbb6900", "documentXmlSha256": "7f43801c2a2c5409647bed9e0c86e9a2c450dc2e4267d0a31ac048665072ee61" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f07-nj-sc", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f07-nj-sc.first.docx", "lines": 28, "keyEntries": 34, "keyPieces": 34, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 6, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 27, "found": 27, "exact": 20, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 28, "found": 27, "exact": 20, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 16, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "State v. Alvarez, 318 N.J. Super. 137 (App. Div. 1999)", "line": "State v. Alvarez, 318 N.J. Super. 137 (App. Div. 1999)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 44 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 44" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Cain, 224 N.J. 410, 133 A.3d 619 (2016)", "line": "State v. Cain, 224 N.J. 410, 133 A.3d 619 (2016)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Marshall, 148 N.J. 89, 690 A.2d 1, cert. denied, 522 U.S. 850, 118 S. Ct. 140, 13", "line": "State v. Marshall, 148 N.J. 89, 690 A.2d 1", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks 43,44,45 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. McDonough, 337 N.J. Super. 27 (2001)", "line": "State v. McDonough, 337 N.J. Super. 27 (2001)", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "lacks 45,46 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Milton, 255 N.J. Super. 514 (App. Div. 1992)", "line": "State v. Milton, 255 N.J. Super. 514 (App. Div. 1992)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 43 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Statutes PAGE NOS. N.J.S.A. 2C:5-2(a)(1)", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 2, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f07-nj-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "8585ae88a5e6d58221ec9b536eeebffe1a0a65d1544553cd2c9799b34b1cf2e1", "documentXmlSha256": "7f43801c2a2c5409647bed9e0c86e9a2c450dc2e4267d0a31ac048665072ee61" }, "seconds": 6 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f07-nj-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 28, "keyEntries": 34, "keyPieces": 34, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 6, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 27, "found": 27, "exact": 20, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 28, "found": 27, "exact": 20, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 16, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "State v. Alvarez, 318 N.J. Super. 137 (App. Div. 1999)", "line": "State v. Alvarez, 318 N.J. Super. 137 (App. Div. 1999)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 44 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 44" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Cain, 224 N.J. 410, 133 A.3d 619 (2016)", "line": "State v. Cain, 224 N.J. 410, 133 A.3d 619 (2016)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "lacks 42 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Marshall, 148 N.J. 89, 690 A.2d 1, cert. denied, 522 U.S. 850, 118 S. Ct. 140, 13", "line": "State v. Marshall, 148 N.J. 89, 690 A.2d 1", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks 43,44,45 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. McDonough, 337 N.J. Super. 27 (2001)", "line": "State v. McDonough, 337 N.J. Super. 27 (2001)", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "lacks 45,46 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Milton, 255 N.J. Super. 514 (App. Div. 1992)", "line": "State v. Milton, 255 N.J. Super. 514 (App. Div. 1992)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "lacks 43 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Statutes PAGE NOS. N.J.S.A. 2C:5-2(a)(1)", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 2, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 2, "suggestionClicks": 2 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f07-nj-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "ff886d28052360ddaacb1a46ef4318552de5d968595a31168090ddd465abc36d", "documentXmlSha256": "7f43801c2a2c5409647bed9e0c86e9a2c450dc2e4267d0a31ac048665072ee61" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f07-nj-sc", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "N.J.S.A. 2C:35-5(b)(2)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "N.J.S.A. 2C:35-10(a)(1)" } ] } } } }, { "id": "f08-wv-scan", "task": { "id": "f08-wv-scan", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/wv-sc-19-1018-petitioners.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "WV", "tags": [ "fresh", "scan (OCR layer)" ], "chatbot": true, "why": "West Virginia, scanned (ScandAll), glued 'W. Va. Code\u00a7'" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f08-wv-scan.first.docx", "lines": 29, "keyEntries": 25, "keyPieces": 25, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 8, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 8, "exact": 6, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 25, "found": 23, "exact": 18, "defensible": 2, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 24, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 2, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 6, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Constitutions, Statutes, and Ordinances Harpers Ferry Ordinances", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "W. Va. Code\u00a7 3-l-3", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "W. Va. Code\u00a7 3-7-7", "line": "W. Va. Code \u00a7 3-7-7", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 11 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Miller v. Cty. Comm'n of Boone Cty., 208 W. Va. 263, 539 S.E.2d 770 (2000) \u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7", "line": "Pridemore v. Fox, 134 W. Va. 456, 59 S.E.2d 899 (1950)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "also on: Miller v. Cty. Comm'n of Boone Cty., 208 W. Va. 263, 539 S.E" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "State ex rel. Daily Gazette Co. v. Bailey, 152 W. Va. 521, 164 S.E.2d 414 (1968)", "line": "State ex rel. Daily Gazette Co. v. Bailey, 152 W. Va. 521", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "also on: Bailey, 164 S.E.2d 414 (1968)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Bailey, 164 S.E.2d 414 (1968)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2, "wrongPage": 1, "duplicate": 2 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f08-wv-scan.first.docx", "sha256": "e825c6207b218907f40c27a177193a35c4eb8ccc4ea2dfb4e2e0fc4e4b4a8389", "documentXmlSha256": "85087eb23eb48dbb40d0f565387ff3b52fb179a1265ad7d0ed639ffc34e19c4f" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f08-wv-scan.careful.docx", "lines": 29, "keyEntries": 25, "keyPieces": 25, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 8, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 8, "exact": 6, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 25, "found": 23, "exact": 18, "defensible": 2, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 24, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 2, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 6, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Constitutions, Statutes, and Ordinances Harpers Ferry Ordinances", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "W. Va. Code\u00a7 3-l-3", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "W. Va. Code\u00a7 3-7-7", "line": "W. Va. Code \u00a7 3-7-7", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 11 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Miller v. Cty. Comm'n of Boone Cty., 208 W. Va. 263, 539 S.E.2d 770 (2000) \u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7", "line": "Pridemore v. Fox, 134 W. Va. 456, 59 S.E.2d 899 (1950)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "also on: Miller v. Cty. Comm'n of Boone Cty., 208 W. Va. 263, 539 S.E" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "State ex rel. Daily Gazette Co. v. Bailey, 152 W. Va. 521, 164 S.E.2d 414 (1968)", "line": "State ex rel. Daily Gazette Co. v. Bailey, 152 W. Va. 521", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "also on: Bailey, 164 S.E.2d 414 (1968)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Bailey, 164 S.E.2d 414 (1968)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2, "wrongPage": 1, "duplicate": 2 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f08-wv-scan.careful.docx", "sha256": "486ebb31ac2c21b547cf77535b8a019dd4b17f88131587783e04210e57666a95", "documentXmlSha256": "85087eb23eb48dbb40d0f565387ff3b52fb179a1265ad7d0ed639ffc34e19c4f" }, "seconds": 6 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f08-wv-scan", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f08-wv-scan.first.docx", "lines": 29, "keyEntries": 25, "keyPieces": 25, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 8, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 8, "exact": 6, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 25, "found": 23, "exact": 18, "defensible": 2, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 24, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 2, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 6, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Constitutions, Statutes, and Ordinances Harpers Ferry Ordinances", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "W. Va. Code\u00a7 3-l-3", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "W. Va. Code\u00a7 3-7-7", "line": "W. Va. Code \u00a7 3-7-7", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 11 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Miller v. Cty. Comm'n of Boone Cty., 208 W. Va. 263, 539 S.E.2d 770 (2000) \u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7", "line": "Pridemore v. Fox, 134 W. Va. 456, 59 S.E.2d 899 (1950)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "also on: Miller v. Cty. Comm'n of Boone Cty., 208 W. Va. 263, 539 S.E" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "State ex rel. Daily Gazette Co. v. Bailey, 152 W. Va. 521, 164 S.E.2d 414 (1968)", "line": "State ex rel. Daily Gazette Co. v. Bailey, 152 W. Va. 521", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "also on: Bailey, 164 S.E.2d 414 (1968)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Bailey, 164 S.E.2d 414 (1968)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2, "wrongPage": 1, "duplicate": 2 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f08-wv-scan.first.docx", "sha256": "f3fbf9e1b7d201299c8ba5149eac1e61982910b783238cdf2021dee77d253503", "documentXmlSha256": "85087eb23eb48dbb40d0f565387ff3b52fb179a1265ad7d0ed639ffc34e19c4f" }, "seconds": 9 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f08-wv-scan.careful.docx", "lines": 29, "keyEntries": 25, "keyPieces": 25, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 8, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 8, "exact": 6, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 25, "found": 23, "exact": 18, "defensible": 2, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 24, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 2, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 6, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Constitutions, Statutes, and Ordinances Harpers Ferry Ordinances", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "W. Va. Code\u00a7 3-l-3", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "W. Va. Code\u00a7 3-7-7", "line": "W. Va. Code \u00a7 3-7-7", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 11 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Miller v. Cty. Comm'n of Boone Cty., 208 W. Va. 263, 539 S.E.2d 770 (2000) \u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\u00b7", "line": "Pridemore v. Fox, 134 W. Va. 456, 59 S.E.2d 899 (1950)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "also on: Miller v. Cty. Comm'n of Boone Cty., 208 W. Va. 263, 539 S.E" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "State ex rel. Daily Gazette Co. v. Bailey, 152 W. Va. 521, 164 S.E.2d 414 (1968)", "line": "State ex rel. Daily Gazette Co. v. Bailey, 152 W. Va. 521", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "also on: Bailey, 164 S.E.2d 414 (1968)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Bailey, 164 S.E.2d 414 (1968)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2, "wrongPage": 1, "duplicate": 2 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f08-wv-scan.careful.docx", "sha256": "fd3671bebb687f11289b9af6642a56b8ff0b055c27a38b3dd3c9de5a4cb6b866", "documentXmlSha256": "85087eb23eb48dbb40d0f565387ff3b52fb179a1265ad7d0ed639ffc34e19c4f" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f08-wv-scan", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } } }, { "id": "f09-ak-sc-scan", "task": { "id": "f09-ak-sc-scan", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/ak-sc-dodge-appellees.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "AK", "tags": [ "fresh", "scan (copier)" ], "why": "Alaska, copier-produced, 28 unkeyed table lines (non-case law)" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f09-ak-sc-scan.first.docx", "lines": 19, "keyEntries": 45, "keyPieces": 45, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 24, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 19, "found": 18, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 4 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 21, "found": 18, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 4 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Fischer v. Stout, 741P.2d217 (Alaska 1987)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Rich v. Walker, 237 Ark. 586, 374 S.W.2d 476 (1964)", "line": "Rich v. Walker, 237 Ark. 586, 374 S.W.2d 476 (1964)", "lines": [ 15 ], "detail": "lacks 41 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 41" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Willis v. Thomas, 600 P.2d 1079 (Alaska 1979)", "line": "Willis v. Thomas, 600 P.2d 1079 (Alaska 1979)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Division of Elections, 2018 General Election Official Results, http://www.elections.alaska.gov/results/18GENR/data/results 18.pdf (No", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Division of Elections, House District 1 Candidate Barton LeBon Prevails By One Vote During Recount, http://www.elections.alaska.gov/d", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3, "idPage": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f09-ak-sc-scan.first.docx", "sha256": "2aacddaf289402f8a17c7bdd9aff2c23414bb4989f639f952d09528b0d1c0cc3", "documentXmlSha256": "06f4656c7d935eaa91475d8f89260fa1bceb2f44071c82ac8bf2ec47bfeca40e" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f09-ak-sc-scan.careful.docx", "lines": 19, "keyEntries": 45, "keyPieces": 45, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 24, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 19, "found": 18, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 4 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 21, "found": 18, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 4 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Fischer v. Stout, 741P.2d217 (Alaska 1987)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Rich v. Walker, 237 Ark. 586, 374 S.W.2d 476 (1964)", "line": "Rich v. Walker, 237 Ark. 586, 374 S.W.2d 476 (1964)", "lines": [ 15 ], "detail": "lacks 41 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 41" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Willis v. Thomas, 600 P.2d 1079 (Alaska 1979)", "line": "Willis v. Thomas, 600 P.2d 1079 (Alaska 1979)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Division of Elections, 2018 General Election Official Results, http://www.elections.alaska.gov/results/18GENR/data/results 18.pdf (No", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Division of Elections, House District 1 Candidate Barton LeBon Prevails By One Vote During Recount, http://www.elections.alaska.gov/d", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3, "idPage": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f09-ak-sc-scan.careful.docx", "sha256": "6a696a206157e56eef4b935d988eee3083b3cb9ce635419e59e1771a3117ec14", "documentXmlSha256": "06f4656c7d935eaa91475d8f89260fa1bceb2f44071c82ac8bf2ec47bfeca40e" }, "seconds": 7 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f09-ak-sc-scan", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f09-ak-sc-scan.first.docx", "lines": 19, "keyEntries": 45, "keyPieces": 45, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 24, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 19, "found": 18, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 4 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 21, "found": 18, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 4 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Fischer v. Stout, 741P.2d217 (Alaska 1987)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Rich v. Walker, 237 Ark. 586, 374 S.W.2d 476 (1964)", "line": "Rich v. Walker, 237 Ark. 586, 374 S.W.2d 476 (1964)", "lines": [ 15 ], "detail": "lacks 41 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 41" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Willis v. Thomas, 600 P.2d 1079 (Alaska 1979)", "line": "Willis v. Thomas, 600 P.2d 1079 (Alaska 1979)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Division of Elections, 2018 General Election Official Results, http://www.elections.alaska.gov/results/18GENR/data/results 18.pdf (No", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Division of Elections, House District 1 Candidate Barton LeBon Prevails By One Vote During Recount, http://www.elections.alaska.gov/d", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 9, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 5, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 5, "modelShown": 5, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f09-ak-sc-scan.first.docx", "sha256": "fbfec6c930943eeffc52f3373cdd09f2a4f2fadbb92e1232394f200e38d9dcd1", "documentXmlSha256": "06f4656c7d935eaa91475d8f89260fa1bceb2f44071c82ac8bf2ec47bfeca40e" }, "seconds": 9 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f09-ak-sc-scan.careful.docx", "lines": 22, "keyEntries": 45, "keyPieces": 45, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 24, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 19, "found": 19, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 5 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 21, "found": 21, "exact": 13, "defensible": 2, "passim": 5 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 5, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Rich v. Walker, 237 Ark. 586, 374 S.W.2d 476 (1964)", "line": "Rich v. Walker, 237 Ark. 586, 374 S.W.2d 476 (1964)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "lacks 41 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 41" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Willis v. Thomas, 600 P.2d 1079 (Alaska 1979)", "line": "Willis v. Thomas, 600 P.2d 1079 (Alaska 1979)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (name only there)" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 5, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 5, "modelShown": 5, "trueAccepts": 3, "falseDismisses": 2, "suggestionClicks": 5 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f09-ak-sc-scan.careful.docx", "sha256": "f8431c3beb18941ff58d14be0e9e50055c16d752f686a04b757687a5c9f5c711", "documentXmlSha256": "61297160329b5127c0a31ff0482e2ed3451d38ae1068672deaea870477fcc311" }, "seconds": 6 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f09-ak-sc-scan", "accept": [ "Alaska Division of Elections, 2018 General Election Official Results", "Alaska Division of Elections, Election Officials Certify House District 1 Race as a Tie, http://www.elections.alaska.gov/doc/info/HD lRacelsTie.pdf (November 26, 2018)", "Fischer v. Stout, 741 P.2d 217" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Alaska Division of Elections, 2018 General Election Official Results", "key": "Alaska Division of Elections, 2018 General Election Official Results, http://www.elections.alaska.gov/results/18GENR/data/results 18.pdf (No" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Alaska Division of Elections, Election Officials Certify House District 1 Race as a Tie, http://www.elections.alaska.gov/doc/info/HD lRacelsTie.pdf (November 26, 2018)", "key": "Alaska Division of Elections, House District 1 Candidate Barton LeBon Prevails By One Vote During Recount, http://www.elections.alaska.gov/d" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Fischer v. Stout, 741 P.2d 217", "key": "Fischer v. Stout, 741P.2d217 (Alaska 1987)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Cissna v. Stout, 931 P.2d 363, 364-65 (Alaska 1996)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "R. 41] Alaska Statute 15.05.020" } ] } } } }, { "id": "f10-ak-trial", "task": { "id": "f10-ak-trial", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/ak-sup-716-appellant.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-trial", "jur": "AK", "tags": [ "fresh", "odd page labels" ], "why": "'PAGE 1 OF 51' footers (known engine failure: every page label off by one)" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f10-ak-trial.first.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 45, "keyPieces": 45, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 6, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 29, "found": 26, "exact": 21, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 7, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 38, "found": 27, "exact": 22, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 11, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 3, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 6, "errorsInFile": 16, "weightedScore": 77, "byType": { "missing": 11, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 3, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 55, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 12, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 16, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Casey v. Semco Energy, Inc., 92 P.3d 379 (Alaska 2004)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City ofKenai v. Filler, 566 P.2d 670 (Alaska 1977)", "line": "Id., 566 P.2d 670 (Alaska 1977)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks 35 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Earthmovers of Fair banks, Inc. v. State, Department of Transportation, 765P.2d1360(Alaska1988)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Property Owners Association v. City of Ketchikan, 781P.2d567 (Alaska 1989)", "line": "Property Owners Ass 'n v. City of Ketchikan, 781 P.2d 567 (Alaska 1989)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 25 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "University ofAlaska v. Chauvin, 521P.2d1234 (Alaska 1974)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "White v. State, Dep 't ofNat. Res., 984 P.2d 1122 (Alaska 1999)", "line": "White v. State, Dep 't ofNat. Res., 984 P.2d 1122 (Alaska 1999)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 4 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 040(d)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 360", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 450", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 460", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 480", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "ALASKA CONST. art. II,\u00a7\u00a7 13, 15", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "ALASKA CONST. art. IX,\u00a7 13", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. CONST. amend. 1", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Benefits, 267 P.3d 624 (Alaska201 l)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "File No., 02841987 WL 121076 (Alaska A.G. Mar. 24, 1987)", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "'No.,' fragment" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Id., 566 P.2d 670 (Alaska 1977)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 10, "safeFixes": 3, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 12, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 11, "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 22, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 5, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 4, "line left out automatically": 1, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 11, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f10-ak-trial.first.docx", "sha256": "7e0f242e3e2f916323dd8db0051c957f1b665ba0ce7701685093df70d621556f", "documentXmlSha256": "31629123eeb7dc4eafe05e01e4988b38bf16f676f0a8e2b05b2a45e9e24ed7e4" }, "seconds": 5 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f10-ak-trial.careful.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 45, "keyPieces": 45, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 6, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 29, "found": 26, "exact": 21, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 7, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 38, "found": 27, "exact": 22, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 11, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 3, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 6, "errorsInFile": 16, "weightedScore": 77, "byType": { "missing": 11, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 3, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 55, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 12, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 16, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Casey v. Semco Energy, Inc., 92 P.3d 379 (Alaska 2004)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City ofKenai v. Filler, 566 P.2d 670 (Alaska 1977)", "line": "Id., 566 P.2d 670 (Alaska 1977)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks 35 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Earthmovers of Fair banks, Inc. v. State, Department of Transportation, 765P.2d1360(Alaska1988)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Property Owners Association v. City of Ketchikan, 781P.2d567 (Alaska 1989)", "line": "Property Owners Ass 'n v. City of Ketchikan, 781 P.2d 567 (Alaska 1989)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 25 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "University ofAlaska v. Chauvin, 521P.2d1234 (Alaska 1974)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "White v. State, Dep 't ofNat. Res., 984 P.2d 1122 (Alaska 1999)", "line": "White v. State, Dep 't ofNat. Res., 984 P.2d 1122 (Alaska 1999)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 4 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 040(d)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 360", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 450", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 460", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 480", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "ALASKA CONST. art. II,\u00a7\u00a7 13, 15", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "ALASKA CONST. art. IX,\u00a7 13", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. CONST. amend. 1", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Benefits, 267 P.3d 624 (Alaska201 l)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "File No., 02841987 WL 121076 (Alaska A.G. Mar. 24, 1987)", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "'No.,' fragment" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Id., 566 P.2d 670 (Alaska 1977)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 10, "safeFixes": 3, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 12, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 11, "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 22, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 5, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 4, "line left out automatically": 1, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 11, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f10-ak-trial.careful.docx", "sha256": "748ef3d983bf6107deb8b755a706769ff6413b9ba622b9c7f50d88e93d5617a6", "documentXmlSha256": "31629123eeb7dc4eafe05e01e4988b38bf16f676f0a8e2b05b2a45e9e24ed7e4" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f10-ak-trial", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f10-ak-trial.first.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 45, "keyPieces": 45, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 6, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 29, "found": 26, "exact": 21, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 7, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 38, "found": 27, "exact": 22, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 11, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 3, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 6, "errorsInFile": 16, "weightedScore": 77, "byType": { "missing": 11, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 3, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 55, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 12, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 16, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Casey v. Semco Energy, Inc., 92 P.3d 379 (Alaska 2004)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City ofKenai v. Filler, 566 P.2d 670 (Alaska 1977)", "line": "Id., 566 P.2d 670 (Alaska 1977)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks 35 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Earthmovers of Fair banks, Inc. v. State, Department of Transportation, 765P.2d1360(Alaska1988)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Property Owners Association v. City of Ketchikan, 781P.2d567 (Alaska 1989)", "line": "Property Owners Ass 'n v. City of Ketchikan, 781 P.2d 567 (Alaska 1989)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 25 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "University ofAlaska v. Chauvin, 521P.2d1234 (Alaska 1974)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "White v. State, Dep 't ofNat. Res., 984 P.2d 1122 (Alaska 1999)", "line": "White v. State, Dep 't ofNat. Res., 984 P.2d 1122 (Alaska 1999)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 4 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 040(d)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 360", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 450", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 460", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 480", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "ALASKA CONST. art. II,\u00a7\u00a7 13, 15", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "ALASKA CONST. art. IX,\u00a7 13", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. CONST. amend. 1", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Benefits, 267 P.3d 624 (Alaska201 l)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "File No., 02841987 WL 121076 (Alaska A.G. Mar. 24, 1987)", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "'No.,' fragment" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Id., 566 P.2d 670 (Alaska 1977)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 10, "safeFixes": 3, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 12, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 11, "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 22, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 5, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 4, "line left out automatically": 1, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 11, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f10-ak-trial.first.docx", "sha256": "ef4966aaff54f0b93939249b2dfc8cc075fa12094dd75ad3259502b516f902a4", "documentXmlSha256": "31629123eeb7dc4eafe05e01e4988b38bf16f676f0a8e2b05b2a45e9e24ed7e4" }, "seconds": 11 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f10-ak-trial.careful.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 45, "keyPieces": 45, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 6, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 29, "found": 26, "exact": 21, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 7, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 38, "found": 27, "exact": 22, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 11, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 3, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 6, "errorsInFile": 16, "weightedScore": 77, "byType": { "missing": 11, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 3, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 55, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 12, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 16, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Casey v. Semco Energy, Inc., 92 P.3d 379 (Alaska 2004)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "City ofKenai v. Filler, 566 P.2d 670 (Alaska 1977)", "line": "Id., 566 P.2d 670 (Alaska 1977)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "lacks 35 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Earthmovers of Fair banks, Inc. v. State, Department of Transportation, 765P.2d1360(Alaska1988)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Property Owners Association v. City of Ketchikan, 781P.2d567 (Alaska 1989)", "line": "Property Owners Ass 'n v. City of Ketchikan, 781 P.2d 567 (Alaska 1989)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 25 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "University ofAlaska v. Chauvin, 521P.2d1234 (Alaska 1974)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "White v. State, Dep 't ofNat. Res., 984 P.2d 1122 (Alaska 1999)", "line": "White v. State, Dep 't ofNat. Res., 984 P.2d 1122 (Alaska 1999)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 4 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 040(d)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 360", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 450", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 460", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Alaska Legislative Procurement Procedures Section 480", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "ALASKA CONST. art. II,\u00a7\u00a7 13, 15", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "ALASKA CONST. art. IX,\u00a7 13", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. CONST. amend. 1", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Benefits, 267 P.3d 624 (Alaska201 l)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "File No., 02841987 WL 121076 (Alaska A.G. Mar. 24, 1987)", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "'No.,' fragment" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Id., 566 P.2d 670 (Alaska 1977)", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 10, "safeFixes": 3, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 12, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 11, "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 22, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 5, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 4, "line left out automatically": 1, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 11, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f10-ak-trial.careful.docx", "sha256": "616cfa2ba2b9ace1402b5bfb38b19b71e4a347a0c836d8106d84bbc6a4d66590", "documentXmlSha256": "31629123eeb7dc4eafe05e01e4988b38bf16f676f0a8e2b05b2a45e9e24ed7e4" }, "seconds": 8 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f10-ak-trial", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } } }, { "id": "f11-co-sc", "task": { "id": "f11-co-sc", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/co-sc-26sa126-petitioner.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "CO", "tags": [ "fresh" ], "why": "Colorado original proceeding, small table" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f11-co-sc.first.docx", "lines": 13, "keyEntries": 15, "keyPieces": 15, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 10, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 14, "found": 12, "exact": 11, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 13, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a7 1-40-106(3)(b), C.R.S. (2025)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a7 1-40-106.5(1)(e)(II), C.R.S. (2025)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "In re Proposed Initiative for an Amendment to the Constitution of the State of Colorado Adding Section 2 to Article VII (Petitions), 907 P.2", "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause, & Summary with Regard to a Proposed Petition for an Amendment to the Const. of State Adding S", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "also on: In re Proposed Initiative for an Amendment to the Constituti" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2, "duplicate": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f11-co-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "ec67a59e34f93440f160bb420419d764729b43632ae2a3713d92fcc667f10fde", "documentXmlSha256": "de8abd748beab095488d8c6b63bc181d2040b84e9078c8b02c0dc1cf9c079f86" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f11-co-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 13, "keyEntries": 15, "keyPieces": 15, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 10, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 14, "found": 12, "exact": 11, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 13, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a7 1-40-106(3)(b), C.R.S. (2025)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a7 1-40-106.5(1)(e)(II), C.R.S. (2025)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "In re Proposed Initiative for an Amendment to the Constitution of the State of Colorado Adding Section 2 to Article VII (Petitions), 907 P.2", "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause, & Summary with Regard to a Proposed Petition for an Amendment to the Const. of State Adding S", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "also on: In re Proposed Initiative for an Amendment to the Constituti" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2, "duplicate": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f11-co-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "bd6e92e40acc9bef4081c510bd25a4a9efbb6f14f1482075d5c6e95b0b2ebd98", "documentXmlSha256": "de8abd748beab095488d8c6b63bc181d2040b84e9078c8b02c0dc1cf9c079f86" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f11-co-sc", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f11-co-sc.first.docx", "lines": 13, "keyEntries": 15, "keyPieces": 15, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 10, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 14, "found": 12, "exact": 11, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 13, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a7 1-40-106(3)(b), C.R.S. (2025)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a7 1-40-106.5(1)(e)(II), C.R.S. (2025)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "In re Proposed Initiative for an Amendment to the Constitution of the State of Colorado Adding Section 2 to Article VII (Petitions), 907 P.2", "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause, & Summary with Regard to a Proposed Petition for an Amendment to the Const. of State Adding S", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "also on: In re Proposed Initiative for an Amendment to the Constituti" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1, "duplicate": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f11-co-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "8ef01750d5c7c8a8079bb00593325937cbf00b21d6d9acf8e44d1bdeecffe3ea", "documentXmlSha256": "de8abd748beab095488d8c6b63bc181d2040b84e9078c8b02c0dc1cf9c079f86" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f11-co-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 14, "keyEntries": 15, "keyPieces": 15, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 10, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 14, "found": 13, "exact": 11, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 12, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "\u00a7 1-40-106(3)(b), C.R.S. (2025)", "line": "\u00a7 1-40-106", "lines": [ 13 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 4 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a7 1-40-106.5(1)(e)(II), C.R.S. (2025)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "In re Proposed Initiative for an Amendment to the Constitution of the State of Colorado Adding Section 2 to Article VII (Petitions), 907 P.2", "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause, & Summary with Regard to a Proposed Petition for an Amendment to the Const. of State Adding S", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "also on: In re Proposed Initiative for an Amendment to the Constituti" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1, "duplicate": 1 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f11-co-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "28e724bc9c46e0c3a25772b5b78433504cee6306eca5a1bc44afdec0425c2f21", "documentXmlSha256": "4b0b8a5038f5d2565bb37e6ec5edd7f2760e01731bfaec813498bd99f2b91d7b" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f11-co-sc", "accept": [ "\u00a7 1-40-106" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "\u00a7 1-40-106", "key": "\u00a7 1-40-106(3)(b), C.R.S. (2025)" } ], "wrong": [] } } } }, { "id": "f12-md-sc", "task": { "id": "f12-md-sc", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/md-sc-2023-syed-crosspet-reply.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "MD", "tags": [ "fresh" ], "why": "Maryland; 18 unkeyed (non-case) table lines" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f12-md-sc.first.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 46, "keyPieces": 46, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 29, "found": 28, "exact": 27, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 10, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 4, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 46, "found": 28, "exact": 27, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 18, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 3, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 21, "weightedScore": 105, "byType": { "missing": 18, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 3, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 90, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 12, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 22, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "In re Tyrell A., 442 Md. 354 (2015)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 7-104", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 8-301.1", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 8-301.1(a)(2)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 8-301.1(e)(2)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-103", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-103(e)(2)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-403", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-403(d)(1)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-503(a)(7)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-1002(b)(1)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Const. Decl. of Rts. art 47(a)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule 1-104(a)(2)(B)", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule 1-201", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule 2-327(c)", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule 4-333(h)", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule Judges 18-102.11(a)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Joseph F. Murphy, Jr., Maryland Evidence Handbook \u00a7 400, at 150 (2d ed.1993)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469 (2007)", "line": "quoting Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469, 493 (2007))", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "also on: Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469 (2007)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Lee, 257 Md. App. 481 (2023)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 2700 Sept. Term 2018, 2019 WL 5581520 (App. Ct. Oct. 29, 2019)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "quoting Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469, 493 (2007))", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 18, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 18 }, "decisions": 21, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 3, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 18, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f12-md-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "e67977e9600ea343a258ed8038da166b9b385df1269dd172392ae300a1e50974", "documentXmlSha256": "e0a57f99466f1191f97b6fded3ade1130cf578a1ee965ae87fd8ddde7f5687f2" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f12-md-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 46, "keyPieces": 46, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 29, "found": 28, "exact": 27, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 10, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 4, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 46, "found": 28, "exact": 27, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 18, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 3, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 21, "weightedScore": 105, "byType": { "missing": 18, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 3, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 90, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 12, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 22, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "In re Tyrell A., 442 Md. 354 (2015)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 7-104", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 8-301.1", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 8-301.1(a)(2)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 8-301.1(e)(2)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-103", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-103(e)(2)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-403", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-403(d)(1)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-503(a)(7)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-1002(b)(1)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Const. Decl. of Rts. art 47(a)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule 1-104(a)(2)(B)", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule 1-201", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule 2-327(c)", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule 4-333(h)", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule Judges 18-102.11(a)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Joseph F. Murphy, Jr., Maryland Evidence Handbook \u00a7 400, at 150 (2d ed.1993)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469 (2007)", "line": "quoting Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469, 493 (2007))", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "also on: Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469 (2007)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Lee, 257 Md. App. 481 (2023)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 2700 Sept. Term 2018, 2019 WL 5581520 (App. Ct. Oct. 29, 2019)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "quoting Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469, 493 (2007))", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 18, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 18 }, "decisions": 21, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 3, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 18, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f12-md-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "b1fd80d1a80fb5288da6908eb4a63b16032d6fc2646f77ce0e84091b8e67c2bd", "documentXmlSha256": "e0a57f99466f1191f97b6fded3ade1130cf578a1ee965ae87fd8ddde7f5687f2" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f12-md-sc", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f12-md-sc.first.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 46, "keyPieces": 46, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 29, "found": 28, "exact": 27, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 10, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 4, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 46, "found": 28, "exact": 27, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 18, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 3, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 21, "weightedScore": 105, "byType": { "missing": 18, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 3, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 90, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 12, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 22, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "In re Tyrell A., 442 Md. 354 (2015)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 7-104", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 8-301.1", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 8-301.1(a)(2)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 8-301.1(e)(2)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-103", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-103(e)(2)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-403", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-403(d)(1)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-503(a)(7)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-1002(b)(1)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Const. Decl. of Rts. art 47(a)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule 1-104(a)(2)(B)", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule 1-201", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule 2-327(c)", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule 4-333(h)", "detail": "rules" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Rule Judges 18-102.11(a)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Joseph F. Murphy, Jr., Maryland Evidence Handbook \u00a7 400, at 150 (2d ed.1993)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469 (2007)", "line": "quoting Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469, 493 (2007))", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "also on: Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469 (2007)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Lee, 257 Md. App. 481 (2023)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 2700 Sept. Term 2018, 2019 WL 5581520 (App. Ct. Oct. 29, 2019)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "quoting Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469, 493 (2007))", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 15, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 17, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 5 }, "decisions": 20, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 3, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 12, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 5, "suggestions": 12, "modelShown": 12, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f12-md-sc.first.docx", "sha256": "97d36b861c4ceeff9c781ad332365bb9f3a2309d3d4445a1b5ae5e92eac2ea61", "documentXmlSha256": "e0a57f99466f1191f97b6fded3ade1130cf578a1ee965ae87fd8ddde7f5687f2" }, "seconds": 5 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f12-md-sc.careful.docx", "lines": 41, "keyEntries": 46, "keyPieces": 46, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 29, "found": 28, "exact": 27, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 10, "found": 7, "exact": 4, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 46, "found": 40, "exact": 36, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 6, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 3, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 9, "weightedScore": 45, "byType": { "missing": 6, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 3, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 30, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 12, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 10, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "In re Tyrell A., 442 Md. 354 (2015)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 8-301.1", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 8-301.1(a)(2)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 8-301.1(e)(2)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Md. Const. Decl. of Rts. art 47(a)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Joseph F. Murphy, Jr., Maryland Evidence Handbook \u00a7 400, at 150 (2d ed.1993)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469 (2007)", "line": "quoting Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469, 493 (2007))", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "also on: Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469 (2007)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Lee, 257 Md. App. 481 (2023)", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 2700 Sept. Term 2018, 2019 WL 5581520 (App. Ct. Oct. 29, 2019)", "lines": [ 16 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "quoting Haas v. Lockheed Martin Corp., 396 Md. 469, 493 (2007))", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 15, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 6, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 6 }, "decisions": 21, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 3, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 12, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 6, "suggestions": 12, "modelShown": 12, "trueAccepts": 11, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 12 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f12-md-sc.careful.docx", "sha256": "be289b366edf753884b0b7082e346d92d2758a6613d9ba62c7836308c8c2ee0f", "documentXmlSha256": "77f99e931fc8c68772df04e7974df8bfd19e8940048c255820331e97a7a32764" }, "seconds": 7 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f12-md-sc", "accept": [ "Rule 4-333", "CP \u00a7 11-403", "Rule 1-201", "JOSEPH F. MURPHY, JR., MARYLAND EVIDENCE HANDBOOK \u00a7 400", "Rule 2-327", "CP \u00a7 7-104", "Rule 1-104", "CP \u00a7 11-103", "CP \u00a7 11-1002(b)(1).", "Rule Judges 18-102.11", "CP \u00a7 11-503" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Rule 4-333", "key": "Md. Rule 4-333(h)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "CP \u00a7 11-403", "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-403" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Rule 1-201", "key": "Md. Rule 1-201" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "JOSEPH F. MURPHY, JR., MARYLAND EVIDENCE HANDBOOK \u00a7 400", "key": "Joseph F. Murphy, Jr., Maryland Evidence Handbook \u00a7 400, at 150 (2d ed.1993)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Rule 2-327", "key": "Md. Rule 2-327(c)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "CP \u00a7 7-104", "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 7-104" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Rule 1-104", "key": "Md. Rule 1-104(a)(2)(B)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "CP \u00a7 11-103", "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-103" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "CP \u00a7 11-1002(b)(1).", "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-1002(b)(1)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Rule Judges 18-102.11", "key": "Md. Rule Judges 18-102.11(a)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "CP \u00a7 11-503", "key": "Maryland Code, Criminal Procedure \u00a7 11-503(a)(7)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 47(b)" } ] } } } }, { "id": "f13-scotus-merits", "task": { "id": "f13-scotus-merits", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/scotus-25-6-keathley.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "scotus", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "fresh" ], "why": "SCOTUS merits brief (Aspose-produced), 87 entries" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f13-scotus-merits.first.docx", "lines": 79, "keyEntries": 87, "keyPieces": 87, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 54, "found": 54, "exact": 52, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 20, "found": 20, "exact": 17, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 8, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 85, "found": 81, "exact": 75, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 5, "weightedScore": 28, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Flugence v. Axis Surplus Insurance Co. (In re Flugence), 738 F.3d 126 (5th Cir. 2013)", "line": "Flugence v. Axis Surplus Ins. Co. (In re Flugence), 738 F.3d 126 (5th Cir. 2013)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Martineau v. Wier, 934 F.3d 385 (4th Cir. 2019)", "line": "Martineau v. Wier, 934 F.3d 385 (4th Cir. 2019)", "lines": [ 32 ], "detail": "lacks 25 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 25" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Chapter 13 Practice & Procedure (2025, Westlaw)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. Courts, Chapter 7 - Bankruptcy Basics, https://www.uscourts.gov/court- programs/bankruptcy/bankruptcy- basics/chapter-7-bankruptcy-basi", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. Department of Justice, Executive Office for United States Trustees, Handbook for Chapter 13 Standing Trustees (Jan. 31, 2025 update), h", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "18B Charles Alan Wright & Arthur R. Miller, Federal Practice and Procedure (3d ed. 2025, Westlaw)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Slater v. United States Steel Corp., 820 F.3d 1193 (11th Cir. 2016), on reh'g en banc, 871 F.3d 1174 (11th Cir. 2017)", "line": "Slater v. United States Steel Corp., 871 F.3d 1174 (11th Cir. 2017)", "lines": [ 47 ], "detail": "also on: Slater v. United States Steel Corp., 820 F.3d 1193 (11th Cir" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 4, "duplicate": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f13-scotus-merits.first.docx", "sha256": "75d0b25c021a72761077a47ea60cf67fc697e46d9d717a35014c621e8a763be2", "documentXmlSha256": "cb8d25a960b0b67cacff3b5b4f0c111a2b0e315f3edda226e8ad202e85e6a065" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f13-scotus-merits.careful.docx", "lines": 79, "keyEntries": 87, "keyPieces": 87, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 54, "found": 54, "exact": 52, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 20, "found": 20, "exact": 17, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 8, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 85, "found": 81, "exact": 75, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 5, "weightedScore": 28, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Flugence v. Axis Surplus Insurance Co. (In re Flugence), 738 F.3d 126 (5th Cir. 2013)", "line": "Flugence v. Axis Surplus Ins. Co. (In re Flugence), 738 F.3d 126 (5th Cir. 2013)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Martineau v. Wier, 934 F.3d 385 (4th Cir. 2019)", "line": "Martineau v. Wier, 934 F.3d 385 (4th Cir. 2019)", "lines": [ 32 ], "detail": "lacks 25 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 25" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Chapter 13 Practice & Procedure (2025, Westlaw)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. Courts, Chapter 7 - Bankruptcy Basics, https://www.uscourts.gov/court- programs/bankruptcy/bankruptcy- basics/chapter-7-bankruptcy-basi", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. Department of Justice, Executive Office for United States Trustees, Handbook for Chapter 13 Standing Trustees (Jan. 31, 2025 update), h", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "18B Charles Alan Wright & Arthur R. Miller, Federal Practice and Procedure (3d ed. 2025, Westlaw)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Slater v. United States Steel Corp., 820 F.3d 1193 (11th Cir. 2016), on reh'g en banc, 871 F.3d 1174 (11th Cir. 2017)", "line": "Slater v. United States Steel Corp., 871 F.3d 1174 (11th Cir. 2017)", "lines": [ 47 ], "detail": "also on: Slater v. United States Steel Corp., 820 F.3d 1193 (11th Cir" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 4, "duplicate": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f13-scotus-merits.careful.docx", "sha256": "134f615912dbf3d178541fae909b538a5a6f6aacf7135661652b7df7fbeac352", "documentXmlSha256": "cb8d25a960b0b67cacff3b5b4f0c111a2b0e315f3edda226e8ad202e85e6a065" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f13-scotus-merits", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f13-scotus-merits.first.docx", "lines": 79, "keyEntries": 87, "keyPieces": 87, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 54, "found": 54, "exact": 52, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 20, "found": 20, "exact": 17, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 8, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 85, "found": 81, "exact": 75, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 5, "weightedScore": 28, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Flugence v. Axis Surplus Insurance Co. (In re Flugence), 738 F.3d 126 (5th Cir. 2013)", "line": "Flugence v. Axis Surplus Ins. Co. (In re Flugence), 738 F.3d 126 (5th Cir. 2013)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Martineau v. Wier, 934 F.3d 385 (4th Cir. 2019)", "line": "Martineau v. Wier, 934 F.3d 385 (4th Cir. 2019)", "lines": [ 32 ], "detail": "lacks 25 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 25" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Chapter 13 Practice & Procedure (2025, Westlaw)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. Courts, Chapter 7 - Bankruptcy Basics, https://www.uscourts.gov/court- programs/bankruptcy/bankruptcy- basics/chapter-7-bankruptcy-basi", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. Department of Justice, Executive Office for United States Trustees, Handbook for Chapter 13 Standing Trustees (Jan. 31, 2025 update), h", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "18B Charles Alan Wright & Arthur R. Miller, Federal Practice and Procedure (3d ed. 2025, Westlaw)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Slater v. United States Steel Corp., 820 F.3d 1193 (11th Cir. 2016), on reh'g en banc, 871 F.3d 1174 (11th Cir. 2017)", "line": "Slater v. United States Steel Corp., 871 F.3d 1174 (11th Cir. 2017)", "lines": [ 47 ], "detail": "also on: Slater v. United States Steel Corp., 820 F.3d 1193 (11th Cir" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1, "duplicate": 1 }, "decisions": 7, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 4, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 4, "modelShown": 4, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f13-scotus-merits.first.docx", "sha256": "a2cb0826613adea9fe8b8cb508fd227c4221f74b912a72bd996c7420b6fadce8", "documentXmlSha256": "cb8d25a960b0b67cacff3b5b4f0c111a2b0e315f3edda226e8ad202e85e6a065" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f13-scotus-merits.careful.docx", "lines": 82, "keyEntries": 87, "keyPieces": 87, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 54, "found": 54, "exact": 52, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 20, "found": 20, "exact": 17, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 8, "found": 6, "exact": 5, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 85, "found": 83, "exact": 77, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 18, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Flugence v. Axis Surplus Insurance Co. (In re Flugence), 738 F.3d 126 (5th Cir. 2013)", "line": "Flugence v. Axis Surplus Ins. Co. (In re Flugence), 738 F.3d 126 (5th Cir. 2013)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "lacks 5 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Martineau v. Wier, 934 F.3d 385 (4th Cir. 2019)", "line": "Martineau v. Wier, 934 F.3d 385 (4th Cir. 2019)", "lines": [ 32 ], "detail": "lacks 25 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 25" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Chapter 13 Practice & Procedure (2025, Westlaw)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. Courts, Chapter 7 - Bankruptcy Basics, https://www.uscourts.gov/court- programs/bankruptcy/bankruptcy- basics/chapter-7-bankruptcy-basi", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Slater v. United States Steel Corp., 820 F.3d 1193 (11th Cir. 2016), on reh'g en banc, 871 F.3d 1174 (11th Cir. 2017)", "line": "Slater v. United States Steel Corp., 871 F.3d 1174 (11th Cir. 2017)", "lines": [ 47 ], "detail": "also on: Slater v. United States Steel Corp., 820 F.3d 1193 (11th Cir" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2, "duplicate": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 4, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 4, "modelShown": 4, "trueAccepts": 3, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 4 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f13-scotus-merits.careful.docx", "sha256": "aa0ea260f7e60bdb01d66bed1ba93b3973e5026e11724e8eb816164cebeb3cc3", "documentXmlSha256": "df4d45a5e69a7fff6c167b539838be6800db11f9b666db7f1e3dbba87036a4a8" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f13-scotus-merits", "accept": [ "Chapter 13 Practice & Procedure \u00a7 16:7 (2025, Westlaw)", "18B Charles Alan Wright & Arthur R. Miller", "U.S. Department of Justice, Executive Office for United States Trustees, Handbook for Chapter 13 Standing Trustees, at 5-1 to 5-4 (Jan. 31, 2025 update)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Chapter 13 Practice & Procedure \u00a7 16:7 (2025, Westlaw)", "key": "Chapter 13 Practice & Procedure (2025, Westlaw)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "18B Charles Alan Wright & Arthur R. Miller", "key": "18B Charles Alan Wright & Arthur R. Miller, Federal Practice and Procedure (3d ed. 2025, Westlaw)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "U.S. Department of Justice, Executive Office for United States Trustees, Handbook for Chapter 13 Standing Trustees, at 5-1 to 5-4 (Jan. 31, 2025 update)", "key": "U.S. Department of Justice, Executive Office for United States Trustees, Handbook for Chapter 13 Standing Trustees (Jan. 31, 2025 update), h" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Chapter 13" } ] } } } }, { "id": "f14-scotus-appl", "task": { "id": "f14-scotus-appl", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/scotus-25a97-response.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "scotus", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "fresh" ], "why": "SCOTUS application response (Microsoft Print to PDF)" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f14-scotus-appl.first.docx", "lines": 32, "keyEntries": 36, "keyPieces": 36, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 23, "exact": 18, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 6, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 36, "found": 30, "exact": 24, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 6, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 8, "weightedScore": 44, "byType": { "missing": 6, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 30, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 8, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Free Speech Coalition, Inc. v. Paxton, 145 S. Ct. 2291 (2025)", "line": "Free Speech Coalition, Inc. v. Paxton, 145 S. Ct. 2291 (2025)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 33 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Moody v. NetChoice, LLC, 603 U.S. 707 (2024)", "line": "Moody v. NetChoice, LLC, 603 U.S. 707 (2024)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 12,19 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "NetChoice, LLC v. Fitch, 134 F.4th 799 (5th Cir. 2025)", "line": "NetChoice, LLC v. Fitch, 134 F.4th 799 (5th Cir. 2025)", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "lacks 15,18 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks 1,2,4,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,17,19,20,21,22,23,25,26,35,36,37 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "2024 H.B. 1126", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Miss. Code Ann. \u00a7 75-24-20", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Facebook, How video selfie age verification works on Facebook Dating", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Instagram, Confirming your age on Instagram", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Instagram, How does video selfie age verification work on Instagram?", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Starkville father speaks out on 'sextortion' and his son's suicide, Mississippi Clarion Ledger (Feb. 22, 2023)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "145 S. Ct. 2308", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 7, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 6 }, "decisions": 9, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 6, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f14-scotus-appl.first.docx", "sha256": "5455fdf71878fee0a7279077692757d6924d751b7f1d24ca768024b36949faab", "documentXmlSha256": "42e6d29d3a64ca243bb20ef72d9274ce4e2ba288d2aa9e4403543762788066c7" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f14-scotus-appl.careful.docx", "lines": 32, "keyEntries": 36, "keyPieces": 36, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 23, "exact": 18, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 6, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 36, "found": 30, "exact": 24, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 6, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 8, "weightedScore": 44, "byType": { "missing": 6, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 30, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 8, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Free Speech Coalition, Inc. v. Paxton, 145 S. Ct. 2291 (2025)", "line": "Free Speech Coalition, Inc. v. Paxton, 145 S. Ct. 2291 (2025)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 33 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Moody v. NetChoice, LLC, 603 U.S. 707 (2024)", "line": "Moody v. NetChoice, LLC, 603 U.S. 707 (2024)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 12,19 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "NetChoice, LLC v. Fitch, 134 F.4th 799 (5th Cir. 2025)", "line": "NetChoice, LLC v. Fitch, 134 F.4th 799 (5th Cir. 2025)", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "lacks 15,18 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks 1,2,4,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,17,19,20,21,22,23,25,26,35,36,37 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "2024 H.B. 1126", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Miss. Code Ann. \u00a7 75-24-20", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Facebook, How video selfie age verification works on Facebook Dating", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Instagram, Confirming your age on Instagram", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Instagram, How does video selfie age verification work on Instagram?", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Starkville father speaks out on 'sextortion' and his son's suicide, Mississippi Clarion Ledger (Feb. 22, 2023)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "145 S. Ct. 2308", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 7, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 6 }, "decisions": 9, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 6, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f14-scotus-appl.careful.docx", "sha256": "d540f77429e306bd66e5bce946e2f0ddac40e923807cf68fe1ae4487816dfa74", "documentXmlSha256": "42e6d29d3a64ca243bb20ef72d9274ce4e2ba288d2aa9e4403543762788066c7" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f14-scotus-appl", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f14-scotus-appl.first.docx", "lines": 32, "keyEntries": 36, "keyPieces": 36, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 23, "exact": 18, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 6, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 36, "found": 30, "exact": 24, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 6, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 8, "weightedScore": 44, "byType": { "missing": 6, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 30, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 8, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Free Speech Coalition, Inc. v. Paxton, 145 S. Ct. 2291 (2025)", "line": "Free Speech Coalition, Inc. v. Paxton, 145 S. Ct. 2291 (2025)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 33 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Moody v. NetChoice, LLC, 603 U.S. 707 (2024)", "line": "Moody v. NetChoice, LLC, 603 U.S. 707 (2024)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 12,19 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "NetChoice, LLC v. Fitch, 134 F.4th 799 (5th Cir. 2025)", "line": "NetChoice, LLC v. Fitch, 134 F.4th 799 (5th Cir. 2025)", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "lacks 15,18 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks 1,2,4,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,17,19,20,21,22,23,25,26,35,36,37 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "2024 H.B. 1126", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Miss. Code Ann. \u00a7 75-24-20", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Facebook, How video selfie age verification works on Facebook Dating", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Instagram, Confirming your age on Instagram", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Instagram, How does video selfie age verification work on Instagram?", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Starkville father speaks out on 'sextortion' and his son's suicide, Mississippi Clarion Ledger (Feb. 22, 2023)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "145 S. Ct. 2308", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 8, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 3, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 4 }, "decisions": 13, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 6, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 6, "modelShown": 6, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f14-scotus-appl.first.docx", "sha256": "8ea6d5db0583ce310ff9201cdfbe3fec47fb714c3b0321c3ff867df9ee89fd7f", "documentXmlSha256": "42e6d29d3a64ca243bb20ef72d9274ce4e2ba288d2aa9e4403543762788066c7" }, "seconds": 9 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f14-scotus-appl.careful.docx", "lines": 34, "keyEntries": 36, "keyPieces": 36, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 24, "found": 23, "exact": 18, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 6, "found": 5, "exact": 5, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 36, "found": 32, "exact": 26, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 34, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 3, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 6, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Free Speech Coalition, Inc. v. Paxton, 145 S. Ct. 2291 (2025)", "line": "Free Speech Coalition, Inc. v. Paxton, 145 S. Ct. 2291 (2025)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "lacks 33 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Moody v. NetChoice, LLC, 603 U.S. 707 (2024)", "line": "Moody v. NetChoice, LLC, 603 U.S. 707 (2024)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 12,19 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "NetChoice, LLC v. Fitch, 134 F.4th 799 (5th Cir. 2025)", "line": "NetChoice, LLC v. Fitch, 134 F.4th 799 (5th Cir. 2025)", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "lacks 15,18 (name only there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "line": "U.S. Const. amend. I", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks 1,2,4,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,17,19,20,21,22,23,25,26,35,36,37 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "2024 H.B. 1126", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Miss. Code Ann. \u00a7 75-24-20", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Instagram, How does video selfie age verification work on Instagram?", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Starkville father speaks out on 'sextortion' and his son's suicide, Mississippi Clarion Ledger (Feb. 22, 2023)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "145 S. Ct. 2308", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 8, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 4 }, "decisions": 13, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 6, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 6, "modelShown": 6, "trueAccepts": 2, "falseDismisses": 4, "suggestionClicks": 6 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f14-scotus-appl.careful.docx", "sha256": "9d01aea2b37289ed1bdffc7b2fef25ae8f88a63a9a02d9aa0c575e6147fe8267", "documentXmlSha256": "e06ef5190e2ee22885158d2f01927274fd3feab37007b02b6885dd9ba4ec7991" }, "seconds": 10 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f14-scotus-appl", "accept": [ "Instagram, Confirming your age on Instagram, https://bit.ly/4keM2H0", "Facebook, How video selfie age verification works on Facebook Dating, https://bit.ly/43j4mIa" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Instagram, Confirming your age on Instagram, https://bit.ly/4keM2H0", "key": "Instagram, Confirming your age on Instagram" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Facebook, How video selfie age verification works on Facebook Dating, https://bit.ly/43j4mIa", "key": "Facebook, How video selfie age verification works on Facebook Dating" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Mississippi\u2019s Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act, H.B. 1126 (2024)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "\u00a7\u00a7 4(1)," }, { "kind": "model", "title": "\u00a7 6(1)(a)-(f)." }, { "kind": "model", "title": "the Attorney General, \u00a7 8." } ] } } } }, { "id": "f15-ca9-doj", "task": { "id": "f15-ca9-doj", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/ca9-23-35153-us-answering.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US-CA9", "tags": [ "fresh", "DOJ brief" ], "why": "U.S. answering brief, 92 entries; Berger short cites on pp43-45 not attached" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f15-ca9-doj.first.docx", "lines": 85, "keyEntries": 92, "keyPieces": 93, "keyHeadings": 1, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 49, "found": 47, "exact": 46, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 31, "found": 31, "exact": 12, "defensible": 18, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 2, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 92, "found": 90, "exact": 63, "defensible": 26, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 7, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 18, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Bannister v. Davis, 140 S. Ct. 1698 (2020)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "N.C. Gen Stat. \u00a7 120-32.6(b)", "line": "N.C. Gen. Stat. \u00a7 120-32.6(b)", "lines": [ 71 ], "detail": "lacks 31 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 99-241, pt. 3 (1985)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "See, 142 S. Ct. 2201", "lines": [ 37 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 2, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f15-ca9-doj.first.docx", "sha256": "41b81a21b3c3e94183aef96ac648339c896511d535c57643eeac4dded661a1e5", "documentXmlSha256": "6618949abf02ee6080fb3d21e942f3bca93d6745822e6a9de2a046d7fce4d557" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f15-ca9-doj.careful.docx", "lines": 85, "keyEntries": 92, "keyPieces": 93, "keyHeadings": 1, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 49, "found": 47, "exact": 46, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 31, "found": 31, "exact": 12, "defensible": 18, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 2, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 92, "found": 90, "exact": 63, "defensible": 26, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 7, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 18, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Bannister v. Davis, 140 S. Ct. 1698 (2020)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "N.C. Gen Stat. \u00a7 120-32.6(b)", "line": "N.C. Gen. Stat. \u00a7 120-32.6(b)", "lines": [ 71 ], "detail": "lacks 31 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 99-241, pt. 3 (1985)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "See, 142 S. Ct. 2201", "lines": [ 37 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 2, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f15-ca9-doj.careful.docx", "sha256": "4a2e952108186fedcd44911f38e296980eb805e46a6e6d03e806e9830d8addad", "documentXmlSha256": "6618949abf02ee6080fb3d21e942f3bca93d6745822e6a9de2a046d7fce4d557" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f15-ca9-doj", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f15-ca9-doj.first.docx", "lines": 85, "keyEntries": 92, "keyPieces": 93, "keyHeadings": 1, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 49, "found": 47, "exact": 46, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 31, "found": 31, "exact": 12, "defensible": 18, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 2, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 92, "found": 90, "exact": 63, "defensible": 26, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 7, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 18, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Bannister v. Davis, 140 S. Ct. 1698 (2020)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "N.C. Gen Stat. \u00a7 120-32.6(b)", "line": "N.C. Gen. Stat. \u00a7 120-32.6(b)", "lines": [ 71 ], "detail": "lacks 31 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 99-241, pt. 3 (1985)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "See, 142 S. Ct. 2201", "lines": [ 37 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 2, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 7, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f15-ca9-doj.first.docx", "sha256": "94ce776d96a873c1ec4cc7a7dff3eef922ce47cd69b0407ae40e87758544d5b9", "documentXmlSha256": "6618949abf02ee6080fb3d21e942f3bca93d6745822e6a9de2a046d7fce4d557" }, "seconds": 5 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f15-ca9-doj.careful.docx", "lines": 85, "keyEntries": 92, "keyPieces": 93, "keyHeadings": 1, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 49, "found": 47, "exact": 46, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 31, "found": 31, "exact": 12, "defensible": 18, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 2, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 92, "found": 90, "exact": 63, "defensible": 26, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 7, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 18, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Bannister v. Davis, 140 S. Ct. 1698 (2020)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "N.C. Gen Stat. \u00a7 120-32.6(b)", "line": "N.C. Gen. Stat. \u00a7 120-32.6(b)", "lines": [ 71 ], "detail": "lacks 31 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 99-241, pt. 3 (1985)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "See, 142 S. Ct. 2201", "lines": [ 37 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 2, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 7, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f15-ca9-doj.careful.docx", "sha256": "50764b432a4f2991bfbe8bf7db6e668a77dda264257e4961b35ae91060ceb3b3", "documentXmlSha256": "6618949abf02ee6080fb3d21e942f3bca93d6745822e6a9de2a046d7fce4d557" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f15-ca9-doj", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "H.R. 326" } ] } } } }, { "id": "f16-ca4", "task": { "id": "f16-ca4", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/ca4-08-4215-jefferson-appellant.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US-CA4", "tags": [ "fresh" ], "why": "criminal appeal, 73 pages" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f16-ca4.first.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 29, "keyPieces": 29, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 22, "found": 22, "exact": 15, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 } }, "total": { "key": 29, "found": 29, "exact": 20, "defensible": 8, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 15, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Durenberger, 1993 WL 738477 (D. Minn. Dec. 3, 1993)", "line": "United States v. Durenberger, 1993 WL 738477 (D. Minn. Dec. 3, 1993)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 43 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. McDade, 28 F.3d 283 (3d Cir. 1994)", "line": "United States v. McDade, 28 F.3d 283 (3d Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 50 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Rostenkowski, 59 F.3d 1291 (D.C. Cir. 1995)", "line": "United States v. Rostenkowski, 59 F.3d 1291 (D.C. Cir. 1995)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 61 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Swindall, 971 F.2d 1531 (11th Cir. 1992)", "line": "United States v. Swindall, 971 F.2d 1531 (11th Cir. 1992)", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "lacks 41,53 (name only there)" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "United States v. Rayburn House Office Building, 497 F.3d 654 (D.C. Cir. 2007), cert. den., 2008 WL 833305 (Mar. 31, 2008)", "line": "cert. den., 2008 WL 833305 (Mar. 31, 2008)", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "also on: United States v. Rayburn House Office Building, 497 F.3d 654" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "cert. den., 2008 WL 833305 (Mar. 31, 2008)", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 1, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f16-ca4.first.docx", "sha256": "7ca1dad70508b34330d36027764784ddbb723f82ef451992019b70478d13e9ae", "documentXmlSha256": "fe0eddf419b26896ffc03391e0b2cd09f6ccb11e093a86c6275f2709c4c2db06" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f16-ca4.careful.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 29, "keyPieces": 29, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 22, "found": 22, "exact": 15, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 } }, "total": { "key": 29, "found": 29, "exact": 20, "defensible": 8, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 15, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Durenberger, 1993 WL 738477 (D. Minn. Dec. 3, 1993)", "line": "United States v. Durenberger, 1993 WL 738477 (D. Minn. Dec. 3, 1993)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 43 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. McDade, 28 F.3d 283 (3d Cir. 1994)", "line": "United States v. McDade, 28 F.3d 283 (3d Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 50 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Rostenkowski, 59 F.3d 1291 (D.C. Cir. 1995)", "line": "United States v. Rostenkowski, 59 F.3d 1291 (D.C. Cir. 1995)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 61 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Swindall, 971 F.2d 1531 (11th Cir. 1992)", "line": "United States v. Swindall, 971 F.2d 1531 (11th Cir. 1992)", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "lacks 41,53 (name only there)" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "United States v. Rayburn House Office Building, 497 F.3d 654 (D.C. Cir. 2007), cert. den., 2008 WL 833305 (Mar. 31, 2008)", "line": "cert. den., 2008 WL 833305 (Mar. 31, 2008)", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "also on: United States v. Rayburn House Office Building, 497 F.3d 654" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "cert. den., 2008 WL 833305 (Mar. 31, 2008)", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 1, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f16-ca4.careful.docx", "sha256": "3a697d9859b4a23da56f73d7b9d504d1c1d41ae5b2f9824fd3ee58baf0dfd9b9", "documentXmlSha256": "fe0eddf419b26896ffc03391e0b2cd09f6ccb11e093a86c6275f2709c4c2db06" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f16-ca4", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f16-ca4.first.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 29, "keyPieces": 29, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 22, "found": 22, "exact": 15, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 } }, "total": { "key": 29, "found": 29, "exact": 20, "defensible": 8, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 15, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Durenberger, 1993 WL 738477 (D. Minn. Dec. 3, 1993)", "line": "United States v. Durenberger, 1993 WL 738477 (D. Minn. Dec. 3, 1993)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 43 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. McDade, 28 F.3d 283 (3d Cir. 1994)", "line": "United States v. McDade, 28 F.3d 283 (3d Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 50 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Rostenkowski, 59 F.3d 1291 (D.C. Cir. 1995)", "line": "United States v. Rostenkowski, 59 F.3d 1291 (D.C. Cir. 1995)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 61 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Swindall, 971 F.2d 1531 (11th Cir. 1992)", "line": "United States v. Swindall, 971 F.2d 1531 (11th Cir. 1992)", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "lacks 41,53 (name only there)" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "United States v. Rayburn House Office Building, 497 F.3d 654 (D.C. Cir. 2007), cert. den., 2008 WL 833305 (Mar. 31, 2008)", "line": "cert. den., 2008 WL 833305 (Mar. 31, 2008)", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "also on: United States v. Rayburn House Office Building, 497 F.3d 654" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "cert. den., 2008 WL 833305 (Mar. 31, 2008)", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 1, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f16-ca4.first.docx", "sha256": "92ee1390a6c0ed48ec980ec4df99e6228e926b35eaa3ae3a283f098648afbfa4", "documentXmlSha256": "fe0eddf419b26896ffc03391e0b2cd09f6ccb11e093a86c6275f2709c4c2db06" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f16-ca4.careful.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 29, "keyPieces": 29, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 22, "found": 22, "exact": 15, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 } }, "total": { "key": 29, "found": 29, "exact": 20, "defensible": 8, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 15, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Durenberger, 1993 WL 738477 (D. Minn. Dec. 3, 1993)", "line": "United States v. Durenberger, 1993 WL 738477 (D. Minn. Dec. 3, 1993)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 43 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. McDade, 28 F.3d 283 (3d Cir. 1994)", "line": "United States v. McDade, 28 F.3d 283 (3d Cir. 1994)", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 50 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Rostenkowski, 59 F.3d 1291 (D.C. Cir. 1995)", "line": "United States v. Rostenkowski, 59 F.3d 1291 (D.C. Cir. 1995)", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 61 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Swindall, 971 F.2d 1531 (11th Cir. 1992)", "line": "United States v. Swindall, 971 F.2d 1531 (11th Cir. 1992)", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "lacks 41,53 (name only there)" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "United States v. Rayburn House Office Building, 497 F.3d 654 (D.C. Cir. 2007), cert. den., 2008 WL 833305 (Mar. 31, 2008)", "line": "cert. den., 2008 WL 833305 (Mar. 31, 2008)", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "also on: United States v. Rayburn House Office Building, 497 F.3d 654" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "cert. den., 2008 WL 833305 (Mar. 31, 2008)", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 1, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f16-ca4.careful.docx", "sha256": "c5a30e1ca0c0922d85be9d038ff548cd350e8e25c06d91a306e6af92690683dd", "documentXmlSha256": "fe0eddf419b26896ffc03391e0b2cd09f6ccb11e093a86c6275f2709c4c2db06" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f16-ca4", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } } }, { "id": "f17-sdny", "task": { "id": "f17-sdny", "source": "fresh-2026-09-28/sdny-apple-monitor-opp.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-district", "jur": "US-SDNY", "tags": [ "fresh" ], "why": "S.D.N.Y. opposition, 54 keyed cases" }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f17-sdny.first.docx", "lines": 59, "keyEntries": 58, "keyPieces": 58, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 57, "found": 56, "exact": 47, "defensible": 8, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 58, "found": 57, "exact": 48, "defensible": 8, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 13, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Local 28 of Sheet Metal Workers' Int'l Ass'n v. E.E.O.C., 478 U.S. 421 (1986) (Sheet Metal", "line": "Local 28 of Sheet Metal Workers\u2019 Int\u2019l Ass\u2019n v. E.E.O.C., 478 U.S. 421 (1986)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 18 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. AU Optronics Corp., No. 3:09-00110, (N.D. Cal. Oct. 2, 2012)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "126 S.Ct. 1837", "lines": [ 56 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f17-sdny.first.docx", "sha256": "70d125e8af214b31ef4b3e192131cde1daaba0f5f76079dd23051dfe663de2b2", "documentXmlSha256": "eeb9c0748b8e8dbbdca58896cad3ab3a88a58561fe3847ebc86ba1c68cd73eaf" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-off/f17-sdny.careful.docx", "lines": 59, "keyEntries": 58, "keyPieces": 58, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 57, "found": 56, "exact": 47, "defensible": 8, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 58, "found": 57, "exact": 48, "defensible": 8, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 13, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Local 28 of Sheet Metal Workers' Int'l Ass'n v. E.E.O.C., 478 U.S. 421 (1986) (Sheet Metal", "line": "Local 28 of Sheet Metal Workers\u2019 Int\u2019l Ass\u2019n v. E.E.O.C., 478 U.S. 421 (1986)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 18 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. AU Optronics Corp., No. 3:09-00110, (N.D. Cal. Oct. 2, 2012)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "126 S.Ct. 1837", "lines": [ 56 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/off/f17-sdny.careful.docx", "sha256": "197249807ac3b0efaf5e8141909f378e3e8dadf24dc446eb573eef87ef9a3506", "documentXmlSha256": "eeb9c0748b8e8dbbdca58896cad3ab3a88a58561fe3847ebc86ba1c68cd73eaf" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f17-sdny", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Sherman Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1 et seq." } ] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f17-sdny.first.docx", "lines": 59, "keyEntries": 58, "keyPieces": 58, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 57, "found": 56, "exact": 47, "defensible": 8, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 58, "found": 57, "exact": 48, "defensible": 8, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 13, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Local 28 of Sheet Metal Workers' Int'l Ass'n v. E.E.O.C., 478 U.S. 421 (1986) (Sheet Metal", "line": "Local 28 of Sheet Metal Workers\u2019 Int\u2019l Ass\u2019n v. E.E.O.C., 478 U.S. 421 (1986)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 18 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. AU Optronics Corp., No. 3:09-00110, (N.D. Cal. Oct. 2, 2012)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "126 S.Ct. 1837", "lines": [ 56 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 6, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 7, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 2, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f17-sdny.first.docx", "sha256": "fd6305dee6e42e534d122e4cd7b3f29fb27fddaae72de811a678161203ae2b68", "documentXmlSha256": "eeb9c0748b8e8dbbdca58896cad3ab3a88a58561fe3847ebc86ba1c68cd73eaf" }, "seconds": 5 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-outcome-v2-20261003/release-20261007-on/f17-sdny.careful.docx", "lines": 60, "keyEntries": 58, "keyPieces": 58, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 57, "found": 57, "exact": 48, "defensible": 8, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 58, "found": 58, "exact": 49, "defensible": 8, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 2, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 8, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Local 28 of Sheet Metal Workers' Int'l Ass'n v. E.E.O.C., 478 U.S. 421 (1986) (Sheet Metal", "line": "Local 28 of Sheet Metal Workers\u2019 Int\u2019l Ass\u2019n v. E.E.O.C., 478 U.S. 421 (1986)", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 18 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "126 S.Ct. 1837", "lines": [ 57 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 6, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 7, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 2, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 2, "suggestionClicks": 3 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "regression/on/f17-sdny.careful.docx", "sha256": "058dcc1699e68d56db755379e03becb9fe4ea5fa01ae056d8304f7bf7c9279d3", "documentXmlSha256": "c2f830d71fc36cfc35af548c44e06af9ce1a01d2315373e6f6fdffcb68f62ca2" }, "seconds": 6 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "f17-sdny", "accept": [ "United States v. AU Optronics Corp., No. 3:09-00110" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "United States v. AU Optronics Corp., No. 3:09-00110", "key": "United States v. AU Optronics Corp., No. 3:09-00110, (N.D. Cal. Oct. 2, 2012)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "Sherman Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1 et seq." }, { "kind": "model", "title": "\u00a7 VI.G.2-3" } ] } } } } ] }, "fresh": { "documents": 20, "role": "frozen counsel-key transfer sample", "measuredAt": { "off": "2026-10-07T08:27:17.424Z", "on": "2026-10-07T08:29:05.177Z" }, "firstExportXmlIdentical": 20, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "files": 20, "errors": 112, "weighted": 541, "byType": { "missing": 66, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 6, "wrongPage": 9, "badLine": 27, "idPage": 4, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 330, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 30, "wrongPage": 36, "badLine": 108, "idPage": 12, "duplicate": 9, "nameOnly": 16, "cosmetic": 0 }, "total": { "key": 692, "found": 626, "exact": 505, "defensible": 88, "passim": 20 }, "split": { "hunt": 64, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "decisions": 135, "asked": 40, "unsurfaced": 95 }, "careful": { "files": 20, "errors": 111, "weighted": 536, "byType": { "missing": 65, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 6, "wrongPage": 9, "badLine": 27, "idPage": 4, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 325, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 30, "wrongPage": 36, "badLine": 108, "idPage": 12, "duplicate": 9, "nameOnly": 16, "cosmetic": 0 }, "total": { "key": 692, "found": 627, "exact": 505, "defensible": 89, "passim": 20 }, "split": { "hunt": 64, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "decisions": 135, "asked": 40, "unsurfaced": 95 } }, "on": { "first": { "files": 20, "errors": 112, "weighted": 541, "byType": { "missing": 66, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 6, "wrongPage": 9, "badLine": 27, "idPage": 4, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 330, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 30, "wrongPage": 36, "badLine": 108, "idPage": 12, "duplicate": 9, "nameOnly": 16, "cosmetic": 0 }, "total": { "key": 692, "found": 626, "exact": 505, "defensible": 88, "passim": 20 }, "split": { "hunt": 41, "suggestions": 68, "modelShown": 67, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "decisions": 179, "asked": 107, "unsurfaced": 72 }, "careful": { "files": 20, "errors": 90, "weighted": 430, "byType": { "missing": 43, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 6, "wrongPage": 10, "badLine": 27, "idPage": 4, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 8, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 215, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 30, "wrongPage": 40, "badLine": 108, "idPage": 12, "duplicate": 9, "nameOnly": 16, "cosmetic": 0 }, "total": { "key": 692, "found": 649, "exact": 522, "defensible": 91, "passim": 22 }, "split": { "hunt": 42, "suggestions": 68, "modelShown": 67, "trueAccepts": 25, "falseDismisses": 43, "suggestionClicks": 68 }, "decisions": 181, "asked": 107, "unsurfaced": 74 } } }, "suggestions": { "modelAcceptedByKeyReviewer": 24, "modelNotAcceptedByKeyReviewer": 43, "note": "Not accepted means absent from the missing-key recovery plan, not proven false or nonexistent in the brief." }, "rows": [ { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0206", "task": { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0206", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-24-0206.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "secondary", "dictionaries", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-24-0206.first.docx", "lines": 34, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 23, "found": 23, "exact": 18, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 5, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 33, "found": 29, "exact": 24, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "10 U.S.C. \u00a7 866 (2019)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Manual for Courts-Martial, United States (2019 ed.), pt. IV, \u00b6 4.b", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule for Courts-Martial 307(c)(3)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "By, THE AMERICAN HERITAGE DICTIONARY (Margery S. Berube et. al. eds., 2d College Edition, 1991)", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 4 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 4, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-24-0206.first.docx", "sha256": "9856967a5f18e3cf878d0e44d28e42a156aee784139a3fc319c7992a12dd2bf8", "documentXmlSha256": "f63caf866fd15e679f037facab1896d7f172217afbbe92b4db4d38ed2521c4be" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-24-0206.careful.docx", "lines": 34, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 23, "found": 23, "exact": 18, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 5, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 33, "found": 29, "exact": 24, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "10 U.S.C. \u00a7 866 (2019)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Manual for Courts-Martial, United States (2019 ed.), pt. IV, \u00b6 4.b", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule for Courts-Martial 307(c)(3)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "By, THE AMERICAN HERITAGE DICTIONARY (Margery S. Berube et. al. eds., 2d College Edition, 1991)", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 4 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 4, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-24-0206.careful.docx", "sha256": "6bbddca849a38460ca248c2587f164b709a940a46edb98023125587937744dd4", "documentXmlSha256": "f63caf866fd15e679f037facab1896d7f172217afbbe92b4db4d38ed2521c4be" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0206", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-24-0206.first.docx", "lines": 34, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 23, "found": 23, "exact": 18, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 5, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 33, "found": 29, "exact": 24, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "10 U.S.C. \u00a7 866 (2019)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Manual for Courts-Martial, United States (2019 ed.), pt. IV, \u00b6 4.b", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule for Courts-Martial 307(c)(3)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "By, THE AMERICAN HERITAGE DICTIONARY (Margery S. Berube et. al. eds., 2d College Edition, 1991)", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3 }, "decisions": 10, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 4, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-24-0206.first.docx", "sha256": "5c54b1e61265dae55c923ba52483ecbc7a4073f82ef1183585e425b3e73b2bd5", "documentXmlSha256": "f63caf866fd15e679f037facab1896d7f172217afbbe92b4db4d38ed2521c4be" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-24-0206.careful.docx", "lines": 35, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 23, "found": 23, "exact": 18, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 5, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 5, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 33, "found": 30, "exact": 25, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 3, "weightedScore": 15, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 3, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "10 U.S.C. \u00a7 866 (2019)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Manual for Courts-Martial, United States (2019 ed.), pt. IV, \u00b6 4.b", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule for Courts-Martial 307(c)(3)", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3 }, "decisions": 10, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 4, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 2, "suggestionClicks": 3 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-24-0206.careful.docx", "sha256": "1f111fca0d46a6ef1c9ed5abcdeb39ed8893cf30a3c06ca76235c1acf86563f0", "documentXmlSha256": "e3535764faf9d18e9fbba3df0bce5b68aedcf87f8880c79e7be51234530c36c6" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0206", "accept": [ "Heritage Dictionary similarly defines \u201cby\u201d as \u201c[t]hrough the agency or action of.\u201d By, T HE AMERICAN HERITAGE DICTIONARY (Margery S. Berube et. al. eds., 2d College Edition, 1991)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Heritage Dictionary similarly defines \u201cby\u201d as \u201c[t]hrough the agency or action of.\u201d By, T HE AMERICAN HERITAGE DICTIONARY (Margery S. Berube et. al. eds., 2d College Edition, 1991)", "key": "By, THE AMERICAN HERITAGE DICTIONARY (Margery S. Berube et. al. eds., 2d College Edition, 1991)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 80" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 1151, U.S. Navy Regulations" } ] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0206", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-24-0206.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/briefs/2024Term/George240206AppellantBrief.pdf", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/newcaaf/calendar/202412.htm", "sourceSha256": "9aabc6722feca73080844017cc14b5deb8b6767527359867088330fd23c1a99a", "inputSha256": "0e7786067313e0d797c049bde80ea5e841de0a8442605bd203fd74547b79cce3", "keySha256": "bb548a08d2f19faaefac751a19f07704ba81a09114dd93d3c26b743137e1cfc3", "rawPrepKeySha256": "663246e4d7f22c1565adbfb9fd16745be6324e120e49712a92417b6b17d8068a", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces", "caseFamily": "CAAF 24-0206: United States v. George", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "24-0206" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:04:55.418832+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 22, "inputPages": 20, "keyEntries": 35, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "secondary", "dictionaries" ], "keyNormalization": [ { "before": "Supreme Court of the United States Davis v. United States, 160 U.S. 469 (1895)", "after": "Davis v. United States, 160 U.S. 469 (1895)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" }, { "before": "Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces and Court of Military Appeals United States v. Bennitt, 72 M.J. 266 (C.A.A.F. 2019)", "after": "United States v. Bennitt, 72 M.J. 266 (C.A.A.F. 2019)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" }, { "before": "Service Courts of Criminal Appeals United States v. Silvas, 11 M.J. 510 (N-M.C.M.R. 1981)", "after": "United States v. Silvas, 11 M.J. 510 (N-M.C.M.R. 1981)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" }, { "before": "Constitutional Provisions, Statutes, Rules, and Other Authorities 10 U.S.C. \u00a7 866 (2019)", "after": "10 U.S.C. \u00a7 866 (2019)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" } ], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 3, 4 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 3, "textSha256": "caa56f5945e1ce1923b89adc5a552a74c5177b5c3c2a682b285b6dc2c154b562", "start": "Table of Authorities\n\n Cases\nSupreme Court of the United States\nDavis v. United States, 160 U.S. 469 (1895) ...................", "end": "............................9\nManual for Courts-Martial, United States (2019 ed.), pt. IV, \u00b6 4.b ......................8\n iii" }, { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "a40196166f259bb02a34b6deb9e2618ed7a763b2763849c981c4976bc9682d15", "start": "Manual for Courts-Martial, United States (2019 ed.), pt. IV, \u00b6 62.a.(a)(2) ..........9\nManual for Courts-Martial, United States (2019 ed.), pt. IV, \u00b6 77.e.(1) ..............10\nRule", "end": "................................. 9\nBy, MERRIAM-WEBSTER\u2019S COLLEGIATE DICTIONARY (11th ed. 2020) ................... 8\n\n\n\n\n iv" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "E OF FILING AND SERVICE .......................................................\n\nCERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE WITH RULES 24(b) AND 37 ....................\n\n\n\n\n ii", "followingRetainedPageStart": "Issue Presented\n\n WHETHER APPELLANT\u2019S CONVICTION FOR ATTEMPTED\n SEXUAL ASSAULT WAS LEGALLY INSUFFICIENT\n BECAUSE THE GOVERNMENT DID NOT PROVE THE\n ALLEGED OVERT ACT.\n\n Statement of Statutory Jurisdiction\n\n The Air Force Court of Criminal Appeals (Air Fo", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0172", "task": { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0172", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-24-0172.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-24-0172.first.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 31, "keyPieces": 31, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 26, "found": 25, "exact": 22, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 31, "found": 29, "exact": 26, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 10, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. Hennis, 79 M.J. 370 (C.A.A.F. 2020)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule for Courts-Martial 912", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 3, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-24-0172.first.docx", "sha256": "afbf77731a7d2cb4446defdd2034fb90d0084b619b32c398bf8435d478636131", "documentXmlSha256": "afc0e6b4399cd296e7d3108b5c0f422f90fe4da0856559145b3107b6492817b2" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-24-0172.careful.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 31, "keyPieces": 31, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 26, "found": 25, "exact": 22, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 31, "found": 29, "exact": 26, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 10, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. Hennis, 79 M.J. 370 (C.A.A.F. 2020)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule for Courts-Martial 912", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 3, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-24-0172.careful.docx", "sha256": "ed365143216de970bc12b7d0a5777d31ae575f178a369c54c66250a3f181b33a", "documentXmlSha256": "afc0e6b4399cd296e7d3108b5c0f422f90fe4da0856559145b3107b6492817b2" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0172", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-24-0172.first.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 31, "keyPieces": 31, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 26, "found": 25, "exact": 22, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 31, "found": 29, "exact": 26, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 10, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. Hennis, 79 M.J. 370 (C.A.A.F. 2020)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule for Courts-Martial 912", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-24-0172.first.docx", "sha256": "2e2e6d3293f8caffd6d8dd91fd6a544e976d566808c9544f459871e91f9e51a9", "documentXmlSha256": "afc0e6b4399cd296e7d3108b5c0f422f90fe4da0856559145b3107b6492817b2" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-24-0172.careful.docx", "lines": 30, "keyEntries": 31, "keyPieces": 31, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 26, "found": 25, "exact": 22, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 4, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 31, "found": 29, "exact": 26, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 10, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 2, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. Hennis, 79 M.J. 370 (C.A.A.F. 2020)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule for Courts-Martial 912", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 2, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-24-0172.careful.docx", "sha256": "1fec628bdefcfc202571a5a06b45c175ba0bb2004031cf3f900c6b9556ddbed4", "documentXmlSha256": "afc0e6b4399cd296e7d3108b5c0f422f90fe4da0856559145b3107b6492817b2" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0172", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "79 M.J. R.C.M. citations are to the Manual for Courts-Martial, United States (2019 ed.)" } ] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0172", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-24-0172.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/briefs/2024Term/Urieta240172AppelleeBrief.pdf", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/newcaaf/calendar/202412.htm", "sourceSha256": "1e471071553c9bf0660861ee71fa927fc3621929e688af8851db338e9bef9e76", "inputSha256": "82c5669d0c4dbb9c3e352f1c40d5dbedfa5e0f8c3bfca680e6dfd5b0969c87e1", "keySha256": "32c11507da6420945402155da57d5e682413b265306eb4467ac2d0cb7811cdda", "rawPrepKeySha256": "c6d054fdde5aaccef7458ceda2ecd741e2119a708425cdac3c871fca1770f777", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces", "caseFamily": "CAAF 24-0172: United States v. Urieta", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "24-0172" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:05:00.330397+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 37, "inputPages": 35, "keyEntries": 31, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules" ], "keyNormalization": [ { "before": "Supreme Court of the United States Gonzalez v. United States, 553 U.S. 242 (2008)", "after": "Gonzalez v. United States, 553 U.S. 242 (2008)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" }, { "before": "United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces (and predecessor court) United States v. Armstrong, 54 M.J. 51 (C.A.A.F. 2000)", "after": "United States v. Armstrong, 54 M.J. 51 (C.A.A.F. 2000)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" }, { "before": "United States Courts of Appeals Fields v. Brown, 503 F.3d 755 (9th Cir. 2007)", "after": "Fields v. Brown, 503 F.3d 755 (9th Cir. 2007)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" } ], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 4, 5 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "1dd67f3ac74954228ea39b2446f31b08be60a853d1ca81347419a73de44ac713", "start": "Table of Authorities\n\n Supreme Court of the United States\nGonzalez v. United States, 553 U.S. 242 (2008)..........................................................27\nLink v. Wabash", "end": "......................2\nArticle 120, Uniform Code of Military Justice, 10 U.S.C. \u00a7 920 ..................................2\n\n iv" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "e494a0c7989bda9f8a786829e4f169f71d94d79f45b9fc3d1cb390683a7e9149", "start": "Rules\nRule for Courts-Martial 912.................................................................................. 11, 12\n\n\n\n\n ", "end": "Rule for Courts-Martial 912.................................................................................. 11, 12\n\n\n\n\n v" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": ".......................25\nConclusion ...............................................................................................................30\n\n\n\n\n iii", "followingRetainedPageStart": "IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS\n FOR THE ARMED FORCES\n\n UNITED STATES, ) FINAL BRIEF ON BEHALF OF\n Appellee ) APPELLEE\n )\n v. )\n ", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0212", "task": { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0212", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-24-0212.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-24-0212.first.docx", "lines": 34, "keyEntries": 38, "keyPieces": 38, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 2, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 31, "found": 31, "exact": 27, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 33, "found": 31, "exact": 27, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 17, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "United States v. Timmreck 441 U.S. 780 (1979)", "line": "United States v. Timmreck, 441 U.S. 780 (1979)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 22" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "United States v. Malacara 71 M.J. 380 (C.A.A.F. 2012)", "line": "United States v. Malacara, 71 M.J. 380 (C.A.A.F. 2012)", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks 17 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Article 66, UCMJ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Manual for Courts-Martial", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-24-0212.first.docx", "sha256": "fa6e22e07136fa4e6785454d44805ce94234e55c306101d81a6ff05c76e0f888", "documentXmlSha256": "fc823189cd0b66e2ae82934f9e80d6283a33c83755c3739d69e437624b0918ce" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-24-0212.careful.docx", "lines": 34, "keyEntries": 38, "keyPieces": 38, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 2, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 31, "found": 31, "exact": 27, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 33, "found": 31, "exact": 27, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 17, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "United States v. Timmreck 441 U.S. 780 (1979)", "line": "United States v. Timmreck, 441 U.S. 780 (1979)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 22" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "United States v. Malacara 71 M.J. 380 (C.A.A.F. 2012)", "line": "United States v. Malacara, 71 M.J. 380 (C.A.A.F. 2012)", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks 17 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Article 66, UCMJ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Manual for Courts-Martial", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-24-0212.careful.docx", "sha256": "28e592da200681a88b0d28e2b3c34fe667b283baff072ec87bea955f0af5485a", "documentXmlSha256": "fc823189cd0b66e2ae82934f9e80d6283a33c83755c3739d69e437624b0918ce" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0212", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-24-0212.first.docx", "lines": 34, "keyEntries": 38, "keyPieces": 38, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 2, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 31, "found": 31, "exact": 27, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 33, "found": 31, "exact": 27, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 17, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "United States v. Timmreck 441 U.S. 780 (1979)", "line": "United States v. Timmreck, 441 U.S. 780 (1979)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 22" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "United States v. Malacara 71 M.J. 380 (C.A.A.F. 2012)", "line": "United States v. Malacara, 71 M.J. 380 (C.A.A.F. 2012)", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks 17 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Article 66, UCMJ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Manual for Courts-Martial", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-24-0212.first.docx", "sha256": "aa2abd5467285c92b838e30cc2f2639344b0cd9ed627165326d28f351adccef0", "documentXmlSha256": "fc823189cd0b66e2ae82934f9e80d6283a33c83755c3739d69e437624b0918ce" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-24-0212.careful.docx", "lines": 34, "keyEntries": 38, "keyPieces": 38, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 2, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 31, "found": 31, "exact": 27, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 33, "found": 31, "exact": 27, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 2, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 17, "byType": { "missing": 2, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 10, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "United States v. Timmreck 441 U.S. 780 (1979)", "line": "United States v. Timmreck, 441 U.S. 780 (1979)", "lines": [ 30 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 22" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "United States v. Malacara 71 M.J. 380 (C.A.A.F. 2012)", "line": "United States v. Malacara, 71 M.J. 380 (C.A.A.F. 2012)", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks 17 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Article 66, UCMJ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Manual for Courts-Martial", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 2 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 2, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-24-0212.careful.docx", "sha256": "bb60de20f7c2920abccccc015fa29511d57d07057399fea8d38a84693e08dceb", "documentXmlSha256": "fc823189cd0b66e2ae82934f9e80d6283a33c83755c3739d69e437624b0918ce" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0212", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Law & Analysis Article 66(d)," } ] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-caaf-24-0212", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-24-0212.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/briefs/2024Term/Arroyo240212AppelleeBrief.pdf", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/", "sourceSha256": "9c0257ff943a401bc5313e4833b5f769c2915cc0cc9d434dcd86e867e8625b1f", "inputSha256": "cd7dd518904c176a0dd47485dbed2388397fbcf08bbef04a971c7f7b8e0e8047", "keySha256": "bf8ded16fa5d7b0c6b802dde7bfec500e405c1774c577700a96840486b31411b", "rawPrepKeySha256": "df5fad3232dfca13ad09a802be6fabfb31074b4c890c3fcae6fa632f523cb211", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces", "caseFamily": "CAAF 24-0212: United States v. Arroyo", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "24-0212" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:05:05.968104+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 33, "inputPages": 29, "keyEntries": 38, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules" ], "keyNormalization": [ { "before": "SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES Bordenkircher v. Hayes 434 U.S. 357 (1978)", "after": "Bordenkircher v. Hayes 434 U.S. 357 (1978)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" }, { "before": "COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE ARMED FORCES United States v. Atkins 23 C.M.R. 301 (C.M.A. 1957)", "after": "United States v. Atkins 23 C.M.R. 301 (C.M.A. 1957)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" }, { "before": "AIR FORCE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS United States v. Joyner 39 M.J. 965 (A.F.C.M.R. 1994)", "after": "United States v. Joyner 39 M.J. 965 (A.F.C.M.R. 1994)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" } ], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 4, 7 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "83a7288340724fb18474b6b1fad395429f6d872c91dec001deef82805d717cb5", "start": "TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\n SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES\n\nBordenkircher v. Hayes\n 434 U.S. 357 (1978) ........................................................", "end": "Behunin\n 83 M.J. 158 (C.A.A.F. 2023) ............................................................................ 11\n\n\n iii" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "1e749eb5404d423cd40199679fa3ebc11c103322dea862b3e4fe39804c3541a4", "start": "United States v. Bethea\n 46 C.M.R. 223 (C.M.A. 1973) .......................................................................... 12\n\nUnited States v. Bradley\n 71 M.J. 13 (C.A.A.F.", "end": "6 (C.A.A.F. 1999) ............................................................................ 10\n\nUnited States v. Malacara\n iv" }, { "pdfPage": 6, "textSha256": "e70be4c25421f89ba17f59bbb70fa81185381d35bd5e4cfd702b04fcb0347b0a", "start": "71 M.J. 380 (C.A.A.F. 2012) ...................................................................... 16-17\n\nUnited States v. Olinger\n 12 M.J. 458 (C.M.A. 1982) .....................", "end": "le 128, UCMJ .....................................................................................................3\n\n\n\n\n v" }, { "pdfPage": 7, "textSha256": "b27e77b4804ec5134551db1a2217639bb8c9debf0a5e0db592f94429c61ff291", "start": "OTHER AUTHORITIES\n\n\nR.C.M. 1001(d)(B) ...................................................................................................22\n\nR.C.M. 1112 ...........................", "end": "\nManual for Courts-Martial .............................................................................3, 13, 15\n\n\n\n\n vi" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "ND SERVICE ..........................................................25\n\nCERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE WITH RULE 24(b)........................................26\n\n\n\n\n ii", "followingRetainedPageStart": "17 December 2024\n\n IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS\n FOR THE ARMED FORCES\n\nUNITED STATES, )\n Appellee ) BRIEF ON BEHALF OF\n ) THE UNITED STATES\nv. ", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-co-26sa150", "task": { "id": "fresh-co-26sa150", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-co-26sa150.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "CO", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "constitution", "secondary", "counsel-record-references", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-co-26sa150.first.docx", "lines": 20, "keyEntries": 22, "keyPieces": 22, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 11, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 1, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 4, "found": 3, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 21, "found": 20, "exact": 14, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 3, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 7, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 11, "weightedScore": 45, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 3, "badLine": 7, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 12, "badLine": 28, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 11, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "R.S \u00a7 1-40-106(3)(b)", "line": "C.R.S. \u00a7 1-40-106(3)(b)", "lines": [ 15 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Release: Conservation Colorado holds polluters accountable, new ballot measures would make fossil fuel polluters pay for the damage they cau", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Review & Comment Hearing (April 2, 2026)", "line": "Review & Comment Hearing (April 2, 2026), https://tinyurl.com/38jxc3xa", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 14 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Title Board Rehearing (April 23, 2026)", "line": "Title Board Rehearing (April 23, 2026), https://csos.granicus.com/player/clip/570", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 45, 234 P.3d 642 (Colo. 2010)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 91, 235 P.3d 1071 (Colo. 2010)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 109, 962 P.2d 252 (Colo. 1998)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 258(A, 4 P.3d 1094 (Colo. 2000)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "12 P.3d 246 (Colo. 2000)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "184 P.3d 52 (Colo. 2008)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "369 P.3d 565 (Colo. 2016)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 8, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 7, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 3, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 12, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 8, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-co-26sa150.first.docx", "sha256": "a3f417d0f34c895559e92e625cdb1889cc9d3c560aa7c4de64cf6e68502a983f", "documentXmlSha256": "1bb30eec8c591d959c73b0f4c954d2a46b98e0b3a5cfc3cf222dd171337a5028" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-co-26sa150.careful.docx", "lines": 20, "keyEntries": 22, "keyPieces": 22, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 11, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 1, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 4, "found": 3, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 21, "found": 20, "exact": 14, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 3, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 7, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 11, "weightedScore": 45, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 3, "badLine": 7, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 12, "badLine": 28, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 11, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "R.S \u00a7 1-40-106(3)(b)", "line": "C.R.S. \u00a7 1-40-106(3)(b)", "lines": [ 15 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Release: Conservation Colorado holds polluters accountable, new ballot measures would make fossil fuel polluters pay for the damage they cau", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Review & Comment Hearing (April 2, 2026)", "line": "Review & Comment Hearing (April 2, 2026), https://tinyurl.com/38jxc3xa", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 14 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Title Board Rehearing (April 23, 2026)", "line": "Title Board Rehearing (April 23, 2026), https://csos.granicus.com/player/clip/570", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 45, 234 P.3d 642 (Colo. 2010)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 91, 235 P.3d 1071 (Colo. 2010)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 109, 962 P.2d 252 (Colo. 1998)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 258(A, 4 P.3d 1094 (Colo. 2000)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "12 P.3d 246 (Colo. 2000)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "184 P.3d 52 (Colo. 2008)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "369 P.3d 565 (Colo. 2016)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 8, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 7, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 3, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 12, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 8, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-co-26sa150.careful.docx", "sha256": "3321e0f983217354d578e47a79c0a715cafb2443b4d2ba977829114676b3b5c7", "documentXmlSha256": "1bb30eec8c591d959c73b0f4c954d2a46b98e0b3a5cfc3cf222dd171337a5028" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-co-26sa150", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-co-26sa150.first.docx", "lines": 20, "keyEntries": 22, "keyPieces": 22, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 11, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 1, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 4, "found": 3, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 21, "found": 20, "exact": 14, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 3, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 7, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 11, "weightedScore": 45, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 3, "badLine": 7, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 12, "badLine": 28, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 11, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "R.S \u00a7 1-40-106(3)(b)", "line": "C.R.S. \u00a7 1-40-106(3)(b)", "lines": [ 15 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Release: Conservation Colorado holds polluters accountable, new ballot measures would make fossil fuel polluters pay for the damage they cau", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Review & Comment Hearing (April 2, 2026)", "line": "Review & Comment Hearing (April 2, 2026), https://tinyurl.com/38jxc3xa", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 14 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Title Board Rehearing (April 23, 2026)", "line": "Title Board Rehearing (April 23, 2026), https://csos.granicus.com/player/clip/570", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 45, 234 P.3d 642 (Colo. 2010)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 91, 235 P.3d 1071 (Colo. 2010)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 109, 962 P.2d 252 (Colo. 1998)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 258(A, 4 P.3d 1094 (Colo. 2000)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "12 P.3d 246 (Colo. 2000)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "184 P.3d 52 (Colo. 2008)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "369 P.3d 565 (Colo. 2016)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 8, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 7, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 3, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 12, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 8, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-co-26sa150.first.docx", "sha256": "1fe43e287fa2e43ff6d5066599609ec24bb064fcc9961c058e73aaa0dc667685", "documentXmlSha256": "1bb30eec8c591d959c73b0f4c954d2a46b98e0b3a5cfc3cf222dd171337a5028" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-co-26sa150.careful.docx", "lines": 20, "keyEntries": 22, "keyPieces": 22, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 11, "found": 11, "exact": 11, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 1, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 4, "found": 3, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 21, "found": 20, "exact": 14, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 3, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 7, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 11, "weightedScore": 45, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 3, "badLine": 7, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 12, "badLine": 28, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 11, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "R.S \u00a7 1-40-106(3)(b)", "line": "C.R.S. \u00a7 1-40-106(3)(b)", "lines": [ 15 ], "detail": "lacks 8 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Release: Conservation Colorado holds polluters accountable, new ballot measures would make fossil fuel polluters pay for the damage they cau", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Review & Comment Hearing (April 2, 2026)", "line": "Review & Comment Hearing (April 2, 2026), https://tinyurl.com/38jxc3xa", "lines": [ 17 ], "detail": "lacks 14 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Title Board Rehearing (April 23, 2026)", "line": "Title Board Rehearing (April 23, 2026), https://csos.granicus.com/player/clip/570", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 45, 234 P.3d 642 (Colo. 2010)", "lines": [ 2 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 91, 235 P.3d 1071 (Colo. 2010)", "lines": [ 3 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 109, 962 P.2d 252 (Colo. 1998)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "No. 258(A, 4 P.3d 1094 (Colo. 2000)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "starts with a docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "12 P.3d 246 (Colo. 2000)", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "184 P.3d 52 (Colo. 2008)", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "369 P.3d 565 (Colo. 2016)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 8, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 7, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 3, "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 12, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 8, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-co-26sa150.careful.docx", "sha256": "f345e60eed3fee2ebd826e4e7e0d1fd466127237c98856ccf5598eef8b720ac9", "documentXmlSha256": "1bb30eec8c591d959c73b0f4c954d2a46b98e0b3a5cfc3cf222dd171337a5028" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-co-26sa150", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-co-26sa150", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-co-26sa150.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.coloradojudicial.gov/sites/default/files/2026-05/26SA150%20Petitioner's%20Opening%20Brief.pdf", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.coloradojudicial.gov/taxonomy/term/580", "sourceSha256": "cec5e17fa5ede22e7757e64b88e6952a62d1d12bcc3c01a5e4cc64ee23a7c59d", "inputSha256": "6c235d5ad6446d802e88ccc50f4874003a1120f18f83137246768a089ef51fec", "keySha256": "ed679ab8af703a11dd78cbe7c449edb20e0aa6cc0e59b933352878d070b13b5f", "rawPrepKeySha256": "6ab0645438916025f8cf5025830ed4f8d2258f2e29a5953c8073d40404888364", "court": "Colorado Supreme Court", "caseFamily": "Colorado 2026SA150: Granger / West v. Aghababian / Arhontoulis, Proposed Initiative 2025-2026 (polluter liability)", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "26SA150", "2026SA150", "Lynn Granger", "Jessica Arhontoulis" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:05:13.603459+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 30, "inputPages": 28, "keyEntries": 22, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "constitution", "secondary", "counsel-record-references" ], "keyNormalization": [], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel lists Title Board hearing/memorandum records as Other Authorities. These are counsel truth, not independently verified legal authorities; a disagreement need not be a model error.", "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 4, 5 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "332aff4f806d209c9c67fbe25fa18ede20e4d37eee7c48fd61b1bd8043628265", "start": "TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\n\n Page(s)\n\nCases\n\nIn re Ballot Title 1997\u20131998 # 62,\n 961 P.2d 1077 (", "end": "ause for 2015\u20132016 #73,\n 369 P.3d 565 (Colo. 2016) ...................................................................... 9\n\n\n\n\n iv" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "03a8a39bf728ba2e4d585f192c93f1e99a3edfac09e052cd52465c31208379c8", "start": "Matter of Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause, & Summary for 1997-\n 98 No. 109,\n 962 P.2d 252 (Colo. 1998) .................................................................... ", "end": "............................. 9\n\nTitle Board Rehearing (April 23, 2026) ........................................ 9, 20, 22\n\n\n\n\n v" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "ould mislead voters. .................................... 18\nCONCLUSION ....................................................................................... 22\n\n\n\n\n iii", "followingRetainedPageStart": "Pursuant to section 1-40-107(2), Petitioners Lynn Granger and\n\nCarly West (collectively, \u201cPetitioners\u201d), through undersigned counsel,\n\nrespectfully petition this Court to review the title, ballot title, and\n\nsubmission clause set by the Colorado Ballot Title Setting Board (the\n\n\u201cTitle Board\u201d) for Pr", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-co-26sa159", "task": { "id": "fresh-co-26sa159", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-co-26sa159.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "CO", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "constitution", "counsel-record-references", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-co-26sa159.first.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 37, "keyPieces": 37, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 15, "found": 15, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 1, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 7, "found": 7, "exact": 4, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 27, "found": 26, "exact": 18, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 12, "legitimateExtras": 10, "errorsInFile": 17, "weightedScore": 69, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 13, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 52, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 17, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2013-2014 #90, 2014 CO 63", "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #90, 2014 CO 63", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "lacks 13,14,15,7,9,8,11,12 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Parrish v. Lamm, 758 P.2d 1356 (Colo. 1988)", "line": "Parrish v. Lamm, 758 P.2d 1356 (Colo. 1988)", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "lacks 16 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 16" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rehearing Before Title Board on Proposed Initiative 2025-2026 #416 (Apr. 24, 2026), https://csos.granicus.com/player/clip/572", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Colo. Const. art. V, \u00a7 1-40-106.5", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Breene, 24 P. 3 (Colo. 1890)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #90, 2014 CO 63", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2015\u20132016 #73, 2016 CO 24", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2015\u20132016 #156, 2016 CO 56", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2019-2020 #3, 2019 CO 107", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2019\u20132020 #315, 2020 CO 61", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2021\u20132022 #16, 2021 CO 55", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2011\u20132012 #3, 2012 CO 25", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2011\u20132012 #45, 2012 CO 26", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #76, 2014 CO 52", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #89, 2014 CO 66", "lines": [ 21 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #129, 2014 CO 53", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "992 P.2d 27 (Colo. 2000)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 15, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1, "wrongAuthority": 1, "badLine": 12 }, "decisions": 17, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-co-26sa159.first.docx", "sha256": "a7708fe79d3c09135e67fd126673216a495be8ddbf78357d2e42154cb20f1fd7", "documentXmlSha256": "9e21ee397c0332868137bdaf00a541b490945e419721600ef5bea2ad28faf9bf" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-co-26sa159.careful.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 37, "keyPieces": 37, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 15, "found": 15, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 1, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 7, "found": 7, "exact": 4, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 27, "found": 26, "exact": 18, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 12, "legitimateExtras": 10, "errorsInFile": 17, "weightedScore": 69, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 13, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 52, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 17, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2013-2014 #90, 2014 CO 63", "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #90, 2014 CO 63", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "lacks 13,14,15,7,9,8,11,12 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Parrish v. Lamm, 758 P.2d 1356 (Colo. 1988)", "line": "Parrish v. Lamm, 758 P.2d 1356 (Colo. 1988)", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "lacks 16 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 16" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rehearing Before Title Board on Proposed Initiative 2025-2026 #416 (Apr. 24, 2026), https://csos.granicus.com/player/clip/572", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Colo. Const. art. V, \u00a7 1-40-106.5", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Breene, 24 P. 3 (Colo. 1890)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #90, 2014 CO 63", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2015\u20132016 #73, 2016 CO 24", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2015\u20132016 #156, 2016 CO 56", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2019-2020 #3, 2019 CO 107", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2019\u20132020 #315, 2020 CO 61", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2021\u20132022 #16, 2021 CO 55", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2011\u20132012 #3, 2012 CO 25", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2011\u20132012 #45, 2012 CO 26", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #76, 2014 CO 52", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #89, 2014 CO 66", "lines": [ 21 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #129, 2014 CO 53", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "992 P.2d 27 (Colo. 2000)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 15, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1, "wrongAuthority": 1, "badLine": 12 }, "decisions": 17, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-co-26sa159.careful.docx", "sha256": "3dcb95abfc6cc550f4f25a374552b41d37ffacb618d24b5c74ac271966ddee79", "documentXmlSha256": "9e21ee397c0332868137bdaf00a541b490945e419721600ef5bea2ad28faf9bf" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-co-26sa159", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-co-26sa159.first.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 37, "keyPieces": 37, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 15, "found": 15, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 1, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 7, "found": 7, "exact": 4, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 27, "found": 26, "exact": 18, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 12, "legitimateExtras": 10, "errorsInFile": 17, "weightedScore": 69, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 13, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 52, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 17, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2013-2014 #90, 2014 CO 63", "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #90, 2014 CO 63", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "lacks 13,14,15,7,9,8,11,12 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Parrish v. Lamm, 758 P.2d 1356 (Colo. 1988)", "line": "Parrish v. Lamm, 758 P.2d 1356 (Colo. 1988)", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "lacks 16 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 16" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rehearing Before Title Board on Proposed Initiative 2025-2026 #416 (Apr. 24, 2026), https://csos.granicus.com/player/clip/572", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Colo. Const. art. V, \u00a7 1-40-106.5", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Breene, 24 P. 3 (Colo. 1890)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #90, 2014 CO 63", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2015\u20132016 #73, 2016 CO 24", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2015\u20132016 #156, 2016 CO 56", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2019-2020 #3, 2019 CO 107", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2019\u20132020 #315, 2020 CO 61", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2021\u20132022 #16, 2021 CO 55", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2011\u20132012 #3, 2012 CO 25", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2011\u20132012 #45, 2012 CO 26", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #76, 2014 CO 52", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #89, 2014 CO 66", "lines": [ 21 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #129, 2014 CO 53", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "992 P.2d 27 (Colo. 2000)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 15, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1, "wrongAuthority": 1, "badLine": 12 }, "decisions": 17, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-co-26sa159.first.docx", "sha256": "65bbe883f3283f846be02aa25821629a707a334060d5840919d882a118164ab9", "documentXmlSha256": "9e21ee397c0332868137bdaf00a541b490945e419721600ef5bea2ad28faf9bf" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-co-26sa159.careful.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 37, "keyPieces": 37, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 15, "found": 15, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "constitution": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 1, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 7, "found": 7, "exact": 4, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 27, "found": 26, "exact": 18, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 12, "legitimateExtras": 10, "errorsInFile": 17, "weightedScore": 69, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 13, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 52, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 17, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2013-2014 #90, 2014 CO 63", "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #90, 2014 CO 63", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "lacks 13,14,15,7,9,8,11,12 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Parrish v. Lamm, 758 P.2d 1356 (Colo. 1988)", "line": "Parrish v. Lamm, 758 P.2d 1356 (Colo. 1988)", "lines": [ 23 ], "detail": "lacks 16 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 16" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rehearing Before Title Board on Proposed Initiative 2025-2026 #416 (Apr. 24, 2026), https://csos.granicus.com/player/clip/572", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "Colo. Const. art. V, \u00a7 1-40-106.5", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Breene, 24 P. 3 (Colo. 1890)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #90, 2014 CO 63", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2015\u20132016 #73, 2016 CO 24", "lines": [ 8 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2015\u20132016 #156, 2016 CO 56", "lines": [ 9 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2019-2020 #3, 2019 CO 107", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2019\u20132020 #315, 2020 CO 61", "lines": [ 11 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2021\u20132022 #16, 2021 CO 55", "lines": [ 12 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2011\u20132012 #3, 2012 CO 25", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2011\u20132012 #45, 2012 CO 26", "lines": [ 19 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #76, 2014 CO 52", "lines": [ 20 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #89, 2014 CO 66", "lines": [ 21 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #129, 2014 CO 53", "lines": [ 22 ], "detail": "case without a reporter, database cite or docket number" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "992 P.2d 27 (Colo. 2000)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 15, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 1, "wrongAuthority": 1, "badLine": 12 }, "decisions": 17, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-co-26sa159.careful.docx", "sha256": "f58bf98e384c6e3988fef2a1864d267d04fb2a136d3359c5480866d1189280cc", "documentXmlSha256": "9e21ee397c0332868137bdaf00a541b490945e419721600ef5bea2ad28faf9bf" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-co-26sa159", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-co-26sa159", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-co-26sa159.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.coloradojudicial.gov/sites/default/files/2026-05/26SA159%20Title%20Board%27s%20Opening%20Brief.pdf", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.coloradojudicial.gov/taxonomy/term/580", "sourceSha256": "7e64316c8cba106c8651484a981761cb3715d92f993266c3f45dd9b65263480a", "inputSha256": "28251e17177f484da243efc60c41165cca75cc585b19028fdfa2edd45e44a808", "keySha256": "d1563b08a55140dc48a26630149a12eb428bd9ee398173af97c7bb5830e0a633", "rawPrepKeySha256": "1928f5d3b20504c4e8fe14cb0a260e25e0fcf2db8c25a4a5b91033b867a48b2c", "court": "Colorado Supreme Court", "caseFamily": "Colorado 2026SA159: Kammerzell v. Taheri / Robnett / Title Board, Proposed Initiative 2025-2026 #416 (Limited Gaming Expansion and Local Control)", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "26SA159", "2026SA159", "Ronald R. Kammerzell" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:13:52.929473+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 26, "inputPages": 23, "keyEntries": 37, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "constitution", "counsel-record-references" ], "keyNormalization": [], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel lists Title Board hearing/memorandum records as Other Authorities. These are counsel truth, not independently verified legal authorities; a disagreement need not be a model error.", "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 4, 6 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "dd08f1983bae5a18a279a71dfb7023ecdb69466f165eef39006f55d55c5535c4", "start": "TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\n PAGE\n\nCases\n\nIn re Breene,\n 24 P. 3 (Colo. 1890). ......", "end": "for 2019-2020 #3,\n 2019 CO 107 .................................................................................... 14\n\n iii" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "a96d3cdfb6185cd2dd7afc92b722782f459180ed58ded751293e84a949dc2235", "start": "In re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2019\u20132020 #315,\n 2020 CO 61 ................................................................................ 7, 8, 9\n\nIn re T", "end": " 2013\u20132014 #129,\n 2014 CO 53 .................................................................................. 8, 13\n\n\n\n iv" }, { "pdfPage": 6, "textSha256": "ef5e06e5eabb4dc45a6acef7868d40228c8df791e99fe51d27f02e4655d35d1d", "start": "In re Title, Ballot Title, & Submission Clause for 2013\u20132014 #76,\n 2014 CO 52 ........................................................................................ 8\n\nIn re", "end": "Board on Proposed Initiative 2025-2026 #416\n (Apr. 24, 2026), https://csos.granicus.com/player/clip/572........... 3, 4\n\n\n\n v" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "......................................................18\nCONCLUSION ......................................................................................... 19\n\n\n\n\n ii", "followingRetainedPageStart": "STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES PRESENTED FOR REVIEW\n\n Whether the Proposed Initiative 2025-2026 #416 (\u201cInitiative\n\n#416\u201d) contains a single subject: local control over limited gaming?\n\n Whether the title for Initiative #416 is clear?\n\n STATEMENT OF THE CASE\n\n Proponent-Respo", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-co-24sa65", "task": { "id": "fresh-co-24sa65", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-co-24sa65.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "state-supreme", "jur": "CO", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-co-24sa65.first.docx", "lines": 4, "keyEntries": 8, "keyPieces": 8, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 8, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a71-40-106(3)(b), C.R.S. (2023)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a712-315-104(11), C.R.S. (2023)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a712-315-105(1), C.R.S. (2023)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Title 12, Article 315, C.R.S. (2023) (Colorado Veterinary Practice Act)", "detail": "statutes" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 4 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-co-24sa65.first.docx", "sha256": "3b8d2b8f367772bcad5c8ad5bc61f50e4519677aba94aaa8a7a14cb806f984a9", "documentXmlSha256": "3ea59b1baad5bdcf515885c160fb1fa6711d50a9db87b90b95e2d7fbc1566f8f" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-co-24sa65.careful.docx", "lines": 4, "keyEntries": 8, "keyPieces": 8, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 8, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a71-40-106(3)(b), C.R.S. (2023)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a712-315-104(11), C.R.S. (2023)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a712-315-105(1), C.R.S. (2023)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Title 12, Article 315, C.R.S. (2023) (Colorado Veterinary Practice Act)", "detail": "statutes" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 4 }, "decisions": 5, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-co-24sa65.careful.docx", "sha256": "3f0ff0d12a3e2e75c1cb27f5cfe0dd7603a1060e35423299222528969b6f6bd2", "documentXmlSha256": "3ea59b1baad5bdcf515885c160fb1fa6711d50a9db87b90b95e2d7fbc1566f8f" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-co-24sa65", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-co-24sa65.first.docx", "lines": 4, "keyEntries": 8, "keyPieces": 8, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 8, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a71-40-106(3)(b), C.R.S. (2023)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a712-315-104(11), C.R.S. (2023)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a712-315-105(1), C.R.S. (2023)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Title 12, Article 315, C.R.S. (2023) (Colorado Veterinary Practice Act)", "detail": "statutes" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 2, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-co-24sa65.first.docx", "sha256": "67e3b698dc6ddf74b555fd791b7d484b634b37d156be0ba542f5b5f5f2a4efb0", "documentXmlSha256": "3ea59b1baad5bdcf515885c160fb1fa6711d50a9db87b90b95e2d7fbc1566f8f" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-co-24sa65.careful.docx", "lines": 5, "keyEntries": 8, "keyPieces": 8, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 8, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 4, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 4, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 20, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a71-40-106(3)(b), C.R.S. (2023)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a712-315-104(11), C.R.S. (2023)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "\u00a712-315-105(1), C.R.S. (2023)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Title 12, Article 315, C.R.S. (2023) (Colorado Veterinary Practice Act)", "detail": "statutes" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 4, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 4 }, "decisions": 7, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 2, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 2 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-co-24sa65.careful.docx", "sha256": "edea259c2f759be377b68c6e0ec62ba4a3b9e0f2df41976d5310c70a042a90cf", "documentXmlSha256": "c5464b78769acbaaaf69d7a3b10b9905b0d0225896dd1035462f301362d17208" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-co-24sa65", "accept": [ "article 315 of Title 12 of the Colorado Revised Statutes" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "article 315 of Title 12 of the Colorado Revised Statutes", "key": "Title 12, Article 315, C.R.S. (2023) (Colorado Veterinary Practice Act)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "\u00a712-315-127(7), C.R.S. (2023)" } ] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-co-24sa65", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-co-24sa65.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.coloradojudicial.gov/sites/default/files/2024-03/Respondents'%20Opening%20Brief.pdf", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.coloradojudicial.gov/taxonomy/term/580", "sourceSha256": "b167355016bc09cbdb5200ee56df157002ed479d6175200926dc405aac373474", "inputSha256": "4fc97b94cd29554d2f9e7724102bc4e0ca7aabb1f05cbfe3d55b51619390d6bd", "keySha256": "d88c59c9f526d721be397dc10103cab7a50d67c218625065544b97894fbef915", "rawPrepKeySha256": "558f15c220bf1c2450de79cbf8a45663102d60bc3886ae9774f458334f19566d", "court": "Colorado Supreme Court", "caseFamily": "Colorado 2024SA65: French / Matt v. Steele / Mickelson, Proposed Initiative 2023-2024 #144 (Veterinary Telehealth)", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "24SA65", "2024SA65", "Veterinary Telehealth", "Will French" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:05:22.249220+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 12, "inputPages": 11, "keyEntries": 8, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes" ], "keyNormalization": [], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 4, 4 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "05d6a9e4400115c005cb812c7a6f7790ef7afb113aff3a092cc2e4dd604cdb9e", "start": "TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\n Page(s)\n\n\nCases:\nIn re Title, Ballot Title & Submission Clause for 2019-2020 #315,\n2020", "end": "\u00a712-315-105(1), C.R.S. (2023)\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026..\u2026\u20264\n\nTitle 12, Article 315, C.R.S. (2023) (Colorado Veterinary Practice Act)...passim\n\n\n\n\n iv" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "available\n prescription drugs and controlled substances. [Petitioners\u2019 4th\n and 5th \u201cadvisory issues\u201d]\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u20266\n\nConclusion\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u20267\n\n\n\n\n iii", "followingRetainedPageStart": "Respondents Apryl Steele and Ali Mickelson, the designated representatives\n\nof the proponents of Proposed Initiative 2023-2024 #144 (\u201cVeterinary Telehealth\u201d),\n\nrespectfully submit their Opening Brief.\n\n STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES PRESENTED FOR REVIEW\n\n The Petitioners have submitted the ", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-kaur-singh", "task": { "id": "fresh-kaur-singh", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-kaur-singh.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "constitution", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-kaur-singh.first.docx", "lines": 63, "keyEntries": 65, "keyPieces": 65, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 47, "found": 47, "exact": 44, "defensible": 1, "passim": 2 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 8, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 8, "found": 8, "exact": 5, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 65, "found": 65, "exact": 58, "defensible": 5, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 0, "weightedScore": 0, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 0, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 0, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-kaur-singh.first.docx", "sha256": "2505e228583bcba51b48a12e5ffe957ce19ce779840a1d86adc18352875d3d37", "documentXmlSha256": "bddb76c9afc407f51804ffa2a312b43d2d3ca37cefee2bf5d5cd676994e69931" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-kaur-singh.careful.docx", "lines": 63, "keyEntries": 65, "keyPieces": 65, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 47, "found": 47, "exact": 44, "defensible": 1, "passim": 2 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 8, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 8, "found": 8, "exact": 5, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 65, "found": 65, "exact": 58, "defensible": 5, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 0, "weightedScore": 0, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 0, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 0, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-kaur-singh.careful.docx", "sha256": "f5338eba9dc018e11dc93e678ea65333c85499cd0c58669ce52701b94f375cf1", "documentXmlSha256": "bddb76c9afc407f51804ffa2a312b43d2d3ca37cefee2bf5d5cd676994e69931" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-kaur-singh", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-kaur-singh.first.docx", "lines": 63, "keyEntries": 65, "keyPieces": 65, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 47, "found": 47, "exact": 44, "defensible": 1, "passim": 2 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 8, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 8, "found": 8, "exact": 5, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 65, "found": 65, "exact": 58, "defensible": 5, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 0, "weightedScore": 0, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 0, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 0, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-kaur-singh.first.docx", "sha256": "12c90cd860960186296a49d9dc12ef391b70b0016389ba502642795b55026aa6", "documentXmlSha256": "bddb76c9afc407f51804ffa2a312b43d2d3ca37cefee2bf5d5cd676994e69931" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-kaur-singh.careful.docx", "lines": 63, "keyEntries": 65, "keyPieces": 65, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 47, "found": 47, "exact": 44, "defensible": 1, "passim": 2 }, "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 8, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 8, "found": 8, "exact": 5, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 65, "found": 65, "exact": 58, "defensible": 5, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 0, "errorsInFile": 0, "weightedScore": 0, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 0, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 0, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-kaur-singh.careful.docx", "sha256": "2445fb92849404f36f31704b2dcac78502845baebc4d1d30076f58490c979ea6", "documentXmlSha256": "bddb76c9afc407f51804ffa2a312b43d2d3ca37cefee2bf5d5cd676994e69931" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-kaur-singh", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-kaur-singh", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-kaur-singh.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/crt/media/1380911/dl", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/crt/case-document/brief-appellee-united-states-v-kaur-and-singh", "sourceSha256": "b7eed4213123131b87bbcf61c8003f539f6903dcc0fe0c4c666bd526e0f29d1e", "inputSha256": "c48ab439b145e9c54bf56cc184b7e63341346b56f2090bad6c256ac8993705fe", "keySha256": "97b5dd7176b3057391d9770425ab232a5c51b1c0e8363d203655bd98a66c8a52", "rawPrepKeySha256": "b1aefc565764d3ff5ff4563208204bb083222516daec9c8859b26107fdac6693", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit", "caseFamily": "CA4 24-4354 / 24-4356: United States v. Kulbir Kaur / Harmanpreet Singh", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "24-4354", "24-4356", "Kulbir Kaur", "Harmanpreet Singh" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:05:24.356980+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 58, "inputPages": 54, "keyEntries": 65, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "constitution" ], "keyNormalization": [ { "before": "STATUTES (continued): PAGE 18 U.S.C. 1592", "after": "18 U.S.C. 1592", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" } ], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 5, 8 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "aa2bdcaa2fc55467fa13c5246c110bce8688e1acac009403e4618c62431ab128", "start": "TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\nCASES: PAGE\n\nAnderson v. United States, 417 U.S. 211 (1974) .......................", "end": "7 (3d Cir. 2014) .........................36\n\nUnited States v. Davis, 726 F.3d 434 (3d Cir. 2013)...............................36\n\n - iv -" }, { "pdfPage": 6, "textSha256": "2081f8a2947ae8057b70a1ed99d3a686ee57dddcabcc0b7fe68a2ac7075dff2d", "start": "CASES (continued): PAGE\n\nUnited States v. Dinkins, 691 F.3d 358 (4th Cir. 2012) ............. 14, 29, 32\n\nUnited States v.", "end": "17 (4th Cir. 2009).............................35\n\nUnited States v. Najjar, 300 F.3d 466 (4th Cir. 2002)............................32\n\n\n -v-" }, { "pdfPage": 7, "textSha256": "42912e17fedcdf539a04df4fef96392035e4b9c8a85b4d3d9c6de0b2243269cf", "start": "CASES (continued): PAGE\n\nUnited States v. Olano, 507 U.S. 725 (1993) ................................", "end": "..........8\n\n18 U.S.C. 1589 ....................................................................................... 1, 8\n\n\n - vi -" }, { "pdfPage": 8, "textSha256": "9acf909f6fc4f654d2a4d079193cb6c2b98c311607a83e476e638d5abe79fb27", "start": "STATUTES (continued): PAGE\n\n18 U.S.C. 1592 ..............................................................", "end": "................. 16\n\nFed. R. Evid. 801(d)(2)(E)......................................................... 9-10, 19, 31\n\n\n\n\n - vii -" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued):\n\nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n\n\n\n\n - iii -", "followingRetainedPageStart": "STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION\n\n This is an appeal from a district court\u2019s final judgment in a\n\ncriminal case. The district court had jurisdiction under 18 U.S.C. 3231\n\nand entered final judgment against defendants-appellants Kulbir Kaur\n\nand Harmanpreet Singh (collectively, defendants) on June 27, 2", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-ca11-braggs", "task": { "id": "fresh-ca11-braggs", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-ca11-braggs.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-ca11-braggs.first.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 29, "keyPieces": 29, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 21, "found": 21, "exact": 17, "defensible": 2, "passim": 2 }, "statutes": { "key": 7, "found": 7, "exact": 1, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 29, "found": 29, "exact": 19, "defensible": 8, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 7, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 6, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Georgia Advoc. Off. v. Jackson, 4 F.4th 1200 (11th Cir. 2021), vacated as moot, 33 F.4th 1", "line": "Georgia Advoc. Off. v. Jackson, 4 F.4th 1200 (11th Cir. 2021)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 23 (name only there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "33 F.4th 1325 (11th Cir. 2022)", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 2, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 2, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-ca11-braggs.first.docx", "sha256": "afe122eeed049d7f9326f551a5a8eee71021848ace66df2adf26a35cf84a68f0", "documentXmlSha256": "eed3ec8ba57c90da8caff0ce232e8054dfe9cc4358acec8141351d25e7370876" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-ca11-braggs.careful.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 29, "keyPieces": 29, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 21, "found": 21, "exact": 17, "defensible": 2, "passim": 2 }, "statutes": { "key": 7, "found": 7, "exact": 1, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 29, "found": 29, "exact": 19, "defensible": 8, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 7, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 6, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Georgia Advoc. Off. v. Jackson, 4 F.4th 1200 (11th Cir. 2021), vacated as moot, 33 F.4th 1", "line": "Georgia Advoc. Off. v. Jackson, 4 F.4th 1200 (11th Cir. 2021)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 23 (name only there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "33 F.4th 1325 (11th Cir. 2022)", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 2, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 2, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-ca11-braggs.careful.docx", "sha256": "03c66328ca6f551bf2763ea4e2d61eb31e6a46c585963e1f687fd8f00da2002a", "documentXmlSha256": "eed3ec8ba57c90da8caff0ce232e8054dfe9cc4358acec8141351d25e7370876" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-ca11-braggs", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-ca11-braggs.first.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 29, "keyPieces": 29, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 21, "found": 21, "exact": 17, "defensible": 2, "passim": 2 }, "statutes": { "key": 7, "found": 7, "exact": 1, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 29, "found": 29, "exact": 19, "defensible": 8, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 7, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 6, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Georgia Advoc. Off. v. Jackson, 4 F.4th 1200 (11th Cir. 2021), vacated as moot, 33 F.4th 1", "line": "Georgia Advoc. Off. v. Jackson, 4 F.4th 1200 (11th Cir. 2021)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 23 (name only there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "33 F.4th 1325 (11th Cir. 2022)", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 2, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 2, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-ca11-braggs.first.docx", "sha256": "95ef1e7652e72434533fabe7b61a04406a8ed23eb05ee0fd1bc3edc38e0eb477", "documentXmlSha256": "eed3ec8ba57c90da8caff0ce232e8054dfe9cc4358acec8141351d25e7370876" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-ca11-braggs.careful.docx", "lines": 33, "keyEntries": 29, "keyPieces": 29, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 21, "found": 21, "exact": 17, "defensible": 2, "passim": 2 }, "statutes": { "key": 7, "found": 7, "exact": 1, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 29, "found": 29, "exact": 19, "defensible": 8, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 7, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 6, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Georgia Advoc. Off. v. Jackson, 4 F.4th 1200 (11th Cir. 2021), vacated as moot, 33 F.4th 1", "line": "Georgia Advoc. Off. v. Jackson, 4 F.4th 1200 (11th Cir. 2021)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 23 (name only there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "33 F.4th 1325 (11th Cir. 2022)", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 2, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 2, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-ca11-braggs.careful.docx", "sha256": "e127c8dcbaa34bb1162edb21e1c7310220a2b5eed721fe60edb4969c39786852", "documentXmlSha256": "eed3ec8ba57c90da8caff0ce232e8054dfe9cc4358acec8141351d25e7370876" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-ca11-braggs", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-ca11-braggs", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-ca11-braggs.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/d9/case-documents/attachments/2022/12/19/braggs_v._commissioner_alabama_department_of_corrections_nos._22-10292_22-10294_11th_cir._12.19.22.pdf", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/crt", "sourceSha256": "62b0a2db6bee61fa24d4f95c2c04e29887e329ecfe3b08858391a2827727c2ce", "inputSha256": "f7f4187f41ab6210d8b1937d4d3f6a307b86d08203428453c216b466cd180d1e", "keySha256": "1c583a8b2f50f9d4e0a44ff02b9721bf47f518f5ba0538a70b20bda9687509fb", "rawPrepKeySha256": "4c69d3492fef0290da8d36379bff911f4ae0e03df3dc1494f9796653d79dfe2c", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit", "caseFamily": "CA11 22-10292 / 22-10294: Braggs v. Commissioner, Alabama Department of Corrections", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "22-10292", "22-10294" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:05:34.854352+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 38, "inputPages": 36, "keyEntries": 29, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules" ], "keyNormalization": [ { "before": "CASES (continued): PAGE *Porter v. Clarke, 923 F.3d 348 (4th Cir. 2019)", "after": "*Porter v. Clarke, 923 F.3d 348 (4th Cir. 2019)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" } ], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 5, 6 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "ba454f28b4a4e1861d841ac794520bb195b80bfbe0d08b83dc72e4979bb59b14", "start": "TABLE OF CITATIONS\n\nCASES: PAGE\n\nAmos v. Cain, No. 4:20-cv-7,\n 2021 WL 1080518 (N.D. ", "end": " Cir. 2016),\n cert. denied, 137 S. Ct. 1578 (2017) ..............................................................26\n\n - iii -" }, { "pdfPage": 6, "textSha256": "e2861095544a8cc033f70bd7141c9fe0351222a3c09cac9bc84c143eef43d1bf", "start": "CASES (continued): PAGE\n\n*Porter v. Clarke, 923 F.3d 348 (4th Cir. 2019) ................", "end": " App. P. 29(a) .................................................................................................2\n\n\n\n\n - iv -" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": ".....................................................................................................30\n\nCERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE\n\nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\n\n\n\n\n - ii -", "followingRetainedPageStart": "IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS\n FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT\n _________________\n\n Nos. 22-10292 & 22-10294\n\n EDWARD BRAGGS, et al.,\n\n Plaintiffs-Appel", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0224", "task": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0224", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-26-0224.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0224.first.docx", "lines": 19, "keyEntries": 19, "keyPieces": 19, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 16, "found": 16, "exact": 9, "defensible": 6, "passim": 1 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 19, "found": 18, "exact": 11, "defensible": 6, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 5, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule for Courts-Martial (R.C.M.) 1001", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 3, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0224.first.docx", "sha256": "18627af9f96107d74e036d030e795e244cf221f12ec82a47a287e895c682fef5", "documentXmlSha256": "bd5c3127884ee3fbdc15de7f65aa488ab637b9e68cc46bf66ad3a7df67d5ea1d" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0224.careful.docx", "lines": 19, "keyEntries": 19, "keyPieces": 19, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 16, "found": 16, "exact": 9, "defensible": 6, "passim": 1 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 19, "found": 18, "exact": 11, "defensible": 6, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 5, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule for Courts-Martial (R.C.M.) 1001", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 3, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0224.careful.docx", "sha256": "ddf770d5f409df697c9e51557846bf6d063a0523b0fab5bd1853ee775f548a8c", "documentXmlSha256": "bd5c3127884ee3fbdc15de7f65aa488ab637b9e68cc46bf66ad3a7df67d5ea1d" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0224", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0224.first.docx", "lines": 19, "keyEntries": 19, "keyPieces": 19, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 16, "found": 16, "exact": 9, "defensible": 6, "passim": 1 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 19, "found": 18, "exact": 11, "defensible": 6, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 5, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule for Courts-Martial (R.C.M.) 1001", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 5, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 5, "modelShown": 5, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0224.first.docx", "sha256": "1b5d9337144111a095656fbd9e80eccdac3c6fa00f61b83eb98ca56d37a76342", "documentXmlSha256": "bd5c3127884ee3fbdc15de7f65aa488ab637b9e68cc46bf66ad3a7df67d5ea1d" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0224.careful.docx", "lines": 19, "keyEntries": 19, "keyPieces": 19, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 16, "found": 16, "exact": 9, "defensible": 6, "passim": 1 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 19, "found": 18, "exact": 11, "defensible": 6, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 5, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Rule for Courts-Martial (R.C.M.) 1001", "detail": "other (not found in the brief's text either)" } ], "asked": 7, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 5, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 1, "suggestions": 5, "modelShown": 5, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 5, "suggestionClicks": 5 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0224.careful.docx", "sha256": "ab030303a257d68bec0efd7f7f70feab284c462006dbfeffb6013f643eebd4cf", "documentXmlSha256": "bd5c3127884ee3fbdc15de7f65aa488ab637b9e68cc46bf66ad3a7df67d5ea1d" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0224", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "All references in this brief to the Rules for Courts-Martial are to the Manual for Courts-Martial, United States (2019 ed.)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "RCM 1001(c)(3)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 92, Uniform Code of Military Justice" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 112(a)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Tapia v. United States, 564, U.S. 319, 335 (2011)" } ] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0224", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-26-0224.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/briefs/2026Term/Szabo260224AppellantBrief.pdf", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/GrantedCasesBriefs.htm", "sourceSha256": "b52792493cd179a8a1ff39bece6d96f4a0cbc0f568892bc7ae76d9bebcd8deba", "inputSha256": "b2ffe35d0ce5376fcd490ce1f7cef4cb01e59066161c7679ae9203fed444b379", "keySha256": "1e7791f0ad268a015c6fdf06a4b58f40a43b533dcb7390c83626f78ae3e19d76", "rawPrepKeySha256": "df1da524bc830ed9b99f95f0f513b9fec573af148e5f10a4d7a5735c5cd53df0", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces", "caseFamily": "CAAF 26-0224: United States v. Szabo", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "26-0224" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:07:24.871238+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 33, "inputPages": 32, "keyEntries": 19, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules" ], "keyNormalization": [ { "before": "Service Courts of Criminal Appeals Cases United States v.Goldsmith, No. ACM 40148, 2023 CCA LEXIS 8 (A.F. Ct. Crim. App. January 11, 2023)", "after": "United States v.Goldsmith, No. ACM 40148, 2023 CCA LEXIS 8 (A.F. Ct. Crim. App. January 11, 2023)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" } ], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 5, 5 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "315df5b58106392dc848301d28fac4773f00ff6dd790cd448c2e373d4d9b7782", "start": "Table of Authorities\n\n Statutes\n10 U.S.C. \u00a7 866 ..................................................................................", "end": "...... passim\nPalsgraf v. Long Island R. Co., 248 N.Y. 339 (1928) ..............................................13\n\n\n\n\n v" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "....................................... 27\n\nCertificate of Compliance ..................................................................................... 28\n\n\n\n\n iv", "followingRetainedPageStart": "Issue Presented\n\n WHETHER THE MILITARY JUDGE ABUSED HER DISCRE-\n TION WHEN SHE OVERRULED THE DEFENSE\u2019S OBJEC-\n TION AND ALLOWED THE COMPLAINANT TO RECITE\n MULTIPLE ALLEGATIONS OF UNCHARGED MISCONDUCT\n DURING HER R.C.M. 1001(c) UNSWORN STATEMENT.\n\n State", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0237", "task": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0237", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-26-0237.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "constitution", "regulations", "secondary", "web-sources", "scientific-articles", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0237.first.docx", "lines": 40, "keyEntries": 67, "keyPieces": 67, "keyHeadings": 1, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "other": { "key": 31, "found": 12, "exact": 11, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 20, "found": 19, "exact": 15, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 6, "exact": 5, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 62, "found": 39, "exact": 33, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 23, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 24, "weightedScore": 121, "byType": { "missing": 23, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 115, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 24, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. CONST. amend. V", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Ford, 23 M.J. 331 (C.A.A.F. 1987)", "line": "United States v. Ford, 23 M.J. 331 (C.A.A.F. 1987)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "560 R.I.C.R. 10-10-2.7.2.E.4.a. (LexisNexis 2026)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "CAL. CODE REGS. tit. 4, \u00a7 17410 (2022)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "MINN. STAT. \u00a7 342.39 (2025)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. CANNABIS LAW \u00a7 130-A (Consol. 2026)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Dep't of the Army, Pam. 27-9, Military Judges' Benchbook (Jan. 26, 2026)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Department of the Air Force Manual 44-197, Military Drug Demand Reduction Program (Sep. 5, 2023)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Manual for Courts-Martial, United States (2024 ed.)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Christian Giroud et al., E-Cigarettes: A Review of New Trends in Cannabis Use, 12 INT'L. J. ENV'TRSCH. PUB. HEALTH 9988 (2015)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Danielle C. Ompad et al., Copycat and lookalike edible cannabis product packaging in the United States, DRUG AND ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE, June 20", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Ellen Meier & Dorothy K. Hatsukami, A review of the additive health risk of cannabis and tobacco co-use, 166 DRUG AND ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE 6 (", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Jonathan P. Caulkins, Changes in Self-Reported Cannabis Use in the United States from 1979 to 2022, 119 ADDICTION 1648 (2024)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Mahmoud A. ElSohly et al., Changes in Cannabis Potency over the Last Two Decades (1995-2014) - Analysis of Current Data in the United States", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Robert G. Hendrickson et al., Acute cannabis toxicity in older adults, 4 TOXICOLOGY COMMUNICATIONS 67 (2020)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Adult-Use Cannabis FAQs, MARYLAND CANNABIS ADMINISTRATION", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Blue Dream Disposable Distillate Vape 2g, LAZY RIVER PRODUCTS, https://lazyriverproducts.com/stores/lazy-river- products-tewksbury-llc/produ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "David Carpenter et al., The Evolution of Marijuana as a Controlled Substance and the Federal-State Policy Gap (2022)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Jeffrey M. Jones, Nearly Half of U.S. Adults Have Tried Marijuana, GALLUP (Aug. 17, 2021)", "line": "Half of U.S. Adults Have Tried Marijuana, GALLUP (Aug. 17, 2021), https://news.gallup.com/poll/353645/nearly-half-adults-tried-marijuana.asp", "lines": [ 32 ], "detail": "lacks 20 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Memorandum from the Attorney General of the United States to All United States Attorneys (Aug. 29, 2013)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Memorandum from the Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness of the United States to Senior Pentagon Leadership and Defense Ag", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "RISE CANNABIS, https://risecannabis.com/", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Tombstone V2, HAMILTON DEVICES, https://hamiltondevices.com/product/tombstone-v2/", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "What is a 510 Battery and Vape Cartridge?, GPEN", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "WISHING WELLNESS, https://wishingwellnessdc.com/", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 23, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 22, "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 25, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 22, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0237.first.docx", "sha256": "5fb1dbc94ef7b9e4901513573d14527b724b61131173bb8372752db5854bbb44", "documentXmlSha256": "9082936edbc25eedda1980678a114188c451d89f7729bf1c7aa27c38c707d3b2" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0237.careful.docx", "lines": 41, "keyEntries": 67, "keyPieces": 67, "keyHeadings": 1, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "other": { "key": 31, "found": 13, "exact": 11, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 20, "found": 19, "exact": 15, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 6, "exact": 5, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 62, "found": 40, "exact": 33, "defensible": 6, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 22, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 23, "weightedScore": 116, "byType": { "missing": 22, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 110, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 23, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. CONST. amend. V", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Ford, 23 M.J. 331 (C.A.A.F. 1987)", "line": "United States v. Ford, 23 M.J. 331 (C.A.A.F. 1987)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "560 R.I.C.R. 10-10-2.7.2.E.4.a. (LexisNexis 2026)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "CAL. CODE REGS. tit. 4, \u00a7 17410 (2022)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "MINN. STAT. \u00a7 342.39 (2025)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. CANNABIS LAW \u00a7 130-A (Consol. 2026)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Dep't of the Army, Pam. 27-9, Military Judges' Benchbook (Jan. 26, 2026)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Department of the Air Force Manual 44-197, Military Drug Demand Reduction Program (Sep. 5, 2023)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Manual for Courts-Martial, United States (2024 ed.)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Christian Giroud et al., E-Cigarettes: A Review of New Trends in Cannabis Use, 12 INT'L. J. ENV'TRSCH. PUB. HEALTH 9988 (2015)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Danielle C. Ompad et al., Copycat and lookalike edible cannabis product packaging in the United States, DRUG AND ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE, June 20", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Ellen Meier & Dorothy K. Hatsukami, A review of the additive health risk of cannabis and tobacco co-use, 166 DRUG AND ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE 6 (", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Jonathan P. Caulkins, Changes in Self-Reported Cannabis Use in the United States from 1979 to 2022, 119 ADDICTION 1648 (2024)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Mahmoud A. ElSohly et al., Changes in Cannabis Potency over the Last Two Decades (1995-2014) - Analysis of Current Data in the United States", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Robert G. Hendrickson et al., Acute cannabis toxicity in older adults, 4 TOXICOLOGY COMMUNICATIONS 67 (2020)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Adult-Use Cannabis FAQs, MARYLAND CANNABIS ADMINISTRATION", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Blue Dream Disposable Distillate Vape 2g, LAZY RIVER PRODUCTS, https://lazyriverproducts.com/stores/lazy-river- products-tewksbury-llc/produ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Jeffrey M. Jones, Nearly Half of U.S. Adults Have Tried Marijuana, GALLUP (Aug. 17, 2021)", "line": "Half of U.S. Adults Have Tried Marijuana, GALLUP (Aug. 17, 2021), https://news.gallup.com/poll/353645/nearly-half-adults-tried-marijuana.asp", "lines": [ 33 ], "detail": "lacks 20 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Memorandum from the Attorney General of the United States to All United States Attorneys (Aug. 29, 2013)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Memorandum from the Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness of the United States to Senior Pentagon Leadership and Defense Ag", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "RISE CANNABIS, https://risecannabis.com/", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Tombstone V2, HAMILTON DEVICES, https://hamiltondevices.com/product/tombstone-v2/", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "What is a 510 Battery and Vape Cartridge?, GPEN", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "WISHING WELLNESS, https://wishingwellnessdc.com/", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 23, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 22, "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 25, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 22, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 1, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0237.careful.docx", "sha256": "0fc459f95eaad8adeedb8051b1458b67169d2d9782b4b3bb0e0302321b258222", "documentXmlSha256": "f85299697a5cb93e5f606479ea59fd7ac3a8242dc165b0dde054bd3cca8e6081" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0237", "accept": [ "David Carpenter et al., The Evolution of Marijuana as a Controlled Substance and the Federal-State Policy Gap (2022)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "David Carpenter et al., The Evolution of Marijuana as a Controlled Substance and the Federal-State Policy Gap (2022)", "key": "David Carpenter et al., The Evolution of Marijuana as a Controlled Substance and the Federal-State Policy Gap (2022)" } ], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0237.first.docx", "lines": 40, "keyEntries": 67, "keyPieces": 67, "keyHeadings": 1, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "other": { "key": 31, "found": 12, "exact": 11, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 20, "found": 19, "exact": 15, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 6, "exact": 5, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 62, "found": 39, "exact": 33, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 23, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 24, "weightedScore": 121, "byType": { "missing": 23, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 115, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 24, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. CONST. amend. V", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Ford, 23 M.J. 331 (C.A.A.F. 1987)", "line": "United States v. Ford, 23 M.J. 331 (C.A.A.F. 1987)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "560 R.I.C.R. 10-10-2.7.2.E.4.a. (LexisNexis 2026)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "CAL. CODE REGS. tit. 4, \u00a7 17410 (2022)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "MINN. STAT. \u00a7 342.39 (2025)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "N.Y. CANNABIS LAW \u00a7 130-A (Consol. 2026)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Dep't of the Army, Pam. 27-9, Military Judges' Benchbook (Jan. 26, 2026)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Department of the Air Force Manual 44-197, Military Drug Demand Reduction Program (Sep. 5, 2023)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Manual for Courts-Martial, United States (2024 ed.)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Christian Giroud et al., E-Cigarettes: A Review of New Trends in Cannabis Use, 12 INT'L. J. ENV'TRSCH. PUB. HEALTH 9988 (2015)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Danielle C. Ompad et al., Copycat and lookalike edible cannabis product packaging in the United States, DRUG AND ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE, June 20", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Ellen Meier & Dorothy K. Hatsukami, A review of the additive health risk of cannabis and tobacco co-use, 166 DRUG AND ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE 6 (", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Jonathan P. Caulkins, Changes in Self-Reported Cannabis Use in the United States from 1979 to 2022, 119 ADDICTION 1648 (2024)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Mahmoud A. ElSohly et al., Changes in Cannabis Potency over the Last Two Decades (1995-2014) - Analysis of Current Data in the United States", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Robert G. Hendrickson et al., Acute cannabis toxicity in older adults, 4 TOXICOLOGY COMMUNICATIONS 67 (2020)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Adult-Use Cannabis FAQs, MARYLAND CANNABIS ADMINISTRATION", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Blue Dream Disposable Distillate Vape 2g, LAZY RIVER PRODUCTS, https://lazyriverproducts.com/stores/lazy-river- products-tewksbury-llc/produ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "David Carpenter et al., The Evolution of Marijuana as a Controlled Substance and the Federal-State Policy Gap (2022)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Jeffrey M. Jones, Nearly Half of U.S. Adults Have Tried Marijuana, GALLUP (Aug. 17, 2021)", "line": "Half of U.S. Adults Have Tried Marijuana, GALLUP (Aug. 17, 2021), https://news.gallup.com/poll/353645/nearly-half-adults-tried-marijuana.asp", "lines": [ 32 ], "detail": "lacks 20 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Memorandum from the Attorney General of the United States to All United States Attorneys (Aug. 29, 2013)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Memorandum from the Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness of the United States to Senior Pentagon Leadership and Defense Ag", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "RISE CANNABIS, https://risecannabis.com/", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Tombstone V2, HAMILTON DEVICES, https://hamiltondevices.com/product/tombstone-v2/", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "What is a 510 Battery and Vape Cartridge?, GPEN", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "WISHING WELLNESS, https://wishingwellnessdc.com/", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 27, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 15, "unsurfaced": 9, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 8, "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 36, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 25, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 8, "suggestions": 26, "modelShown": 25, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0237.first.docx", "sha256": "c905d115396ba81ccb0ef7f0c67e86252bde366aed2fc23ed5a771cf25db6b90", "documentXmlSha256": "9082936edbc25eedda1980678a114188c451d89f7729bf1c7aa27c38c707d3b2" }, "seconds": 7 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0237.careful.docx", "lines": 55, "keyEntries": 67, "keyPieces": 67, "keyHeadings": 1, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 3, "byCategory": { "other": { "key": 31, "found": 24, "exact": 20, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 20, "found": 19, "exact": 15, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 9, "found": 9, "exact": 8, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 2, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 62, "found": 54, "exact": 45, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 8, "wrongPages": 2, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 10, "weightedScore": 50, "byType": { "missing": 8, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 2, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 40, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 8, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 10, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "U.S. CONST. amend. V", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "United States v. Ford, 23 M.J. 331 (C.A.A.F. 1987)", "line": "United States v. Ford, 23 M.J. 331 (C.A.A.F. 1987)", "lines": [ 10 ], "detail": "lacks 26 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "560 R.I.C.R. 10-10-2.7.2.E.4.a. (LexisNexis 2026)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Danielle C. Ompad et al., Copycat and lookalike edible cannabis product packaging in the United States, DRUG AND ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE, June 20", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Adult-Use Cannabis FAQs, MARYLAND CANNABIS ADMINISTRATION", "line": "Adult-Use Cannabis FAQs, MARYLAND CANNABIS ADMINISTRATION (last visited Sep. 10, 2026)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 8,20 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Blue Dream Disposable Distillate Vape 2g, LAZY RIVER PRODUCTS, https://lazyriverproducts.com/stores/lazy-river- products-tewksbury-llc/produ", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "Jeffrey M. Jones, Nearly Half of U.S. Adults Have Tried Marijuana, GALLUP (Aug. 17, 2021)", "line": "Half of U.S. Adults Have Tried Marijuana, GALLUP (Aug. 17, 2021), https://news.gallup.com/poll/353645/nearly-half-adults-tried-marijuana.asp", "lines": [ 40 ], "detail": "lacks 20 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Memorandum from the Attorney General of the United States to All United States Attorneys (Aug. 29, 2013)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Memorandum from the Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness of the United States to Senior Pentagon Leadership and Defense Ag", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "RISE CANNABIS, https://risecannabis.com/", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "WISHING WELLNESS, https://wishingwellnessdc.com/", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 27, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 8, "wrongPage": 2 }, "decisions": 37, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 1, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 25, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 8, "suggestions": 26, "modelShown": 25, "trueAccepts": 15, "falseDismisses": 11, "suggestionClicks": 26 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0237.careful.docx", "sha256": "b1a34faa6f7dafc24b2e7ac68c2f08d3ee5a26a194c58f3ca189d786dfbefbe3", "documentXmlSha256": "68496193d2353257f500fae4865ae9d87c8d4077c0df009684c728616be2fc3e" }, "seconds": 16 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0237", "accept": [ "David Carpenter et al., The Evolution of Marijuana as a Controlled Substance and the Federal-State Policy Gap (2022)", "Manual for Courts-Martial, United States (2024 ed.)", "Jonathan P. Caulkins, Changes in Self-Reported Cannabis Use in the United States from 1979 to 2022, 119 ADDICTION 1648 (2024)", "Adult-Use Cannabis FAQs, MARYLAND CANNABIS ADMINISTRATION (last visited Sep. 10, 2026)", "MINN. STAT. \u00a7 342.39", "N.Y. CANNABIS LAW \u00a7 130-A", "Christian Giroud et al., E-Cigarettes: A Review of New Trends in Cannabis Use, 12 INT\u2019L. J. ENV\u2019T RSCH. PUB. HEALTH 9988", "Ellen Meier & Dorothy K. Hatsukami, A review of the additive health risk of cannabis and tobacco co-use, 166 DRUG AND ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE 6 (2016)", "What is a 510 Battery and Vape Cartridge?, G PEN, https://gpen.com/pages/vapecartridge-and-510-battery-guide [https://perma.cc/S5K2-GQ5Y", "Tombstone V2, HAMILTON DEVICES", "CAL. CODE REGS. tit. 4, \u00a7 17410", "Robert G. Hendrickson et al., Acute cannabis toxicity in older adults, 4 TOXICOLOGY COMMUNICATIONS 67, 67-70 (2020)", "Mahmoud A. ElSohly et al., Changes in Cannabis Potency over the Last Two Decades (1995-2014)", "Article 112a, UCMJ.\u201d Department of the Air Force Manual 44-197, Military Drug Demand Reduction Program", "Dep\u2019t of the Army, Pam. 27-9, Military Judges\u2019 Benchbook" ], "right": [ { "kind": "uncovered", "title": "David Carpenter et al., The Evolution of Marijuana as a Controlled Substance and the Federal-State Policy Gap (2022)", "key": "David Carpenter et al., The Evolution of Marijuana as a Controlled Substance and the Federal-State Policy Gap (2022)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Manual for Courts-Martial, United States (2024 ed.)", "key": "Manual for Courts-Martial, United States (2024 ed.)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Jonathan P. Caulkins, Changes in Self-Reported Cannabis Use in the United States from 1979 to 2022, 119 ADDICTION 1648 (2024)", "key": "Jonathan P. Caulkins, Changes in Self-Reported Cannabis Use in the United States from 1979 to 2022, 119 ADDICTION 1648 (2024)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Adult-Use Cannabis FAQs, MARYLAND CANNABIS ADMINISTRATION (last visited Sep. 10, 2026)", "key": "Adult-Use Cannabis FAQs, MARYLAND CANNABIS ADMINISTRATION" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "MINN. STAT. \u00a7 342.39", "key": "MINN. STAT. \u00a7 342.39 (2025)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "N.Y. CANNABIS LAW \u00a7 130-A", "key": "N.Y. CANNABIS LAW \u00a7 130-A (Consol. 2026)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Christian Giroud et al., E-Cigarettes: A Review of New Trends in Cannabis Use, 12 INT\u2019L. J. ENV\u2019T RSCH. PUB. HEALTH 9988", "key": "Christian Giroud et al., E-Cigarettes: A Review of New Trends in Cannabis Use, 12 INT'L. J. ENV'TRSCH. PUB. HEALTH 9988 (2015)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Ellen Meier & Dorothy K. Hatsukami, A review of the additive health risk of cannabis and tobacco co-use, 166 DRUG AND ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE 6 (2016)", "key": "Ellen Meier & Dorothy K. Hatsukami, A review of the additive health risk of cannabis and tobacco co-use, 166 DRUG AND ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE 6 (" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "What is a 510 Battery and Vape Cartridge?, G PEN, https://gpen.com/pages/vapecartridge-and-510-battery-guide [https://perma.cc/S5K2-GQ5Y", "key": "What is a 510 Battery and Vape Cartridge?, GPEN" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Tombstone V2, HAMILTON DEVICES", "key": "Tombstone V2, HAMILTON DEVICES, https://hamiltondevices.com/product/tombstone-v2/" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "CAL. CODE REGS. tit. 4, \u00a7 17410", "key": "CAL. CODE REGS. tit. 4, \u00a7 17410 (2022)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Robert G. Hendrickson et al., Acute cannabis toxicity in older adults, 4 TOXICOLOGY COMMUNICATIONS 67, 67-70 (2020)", "key": "Robert G. Hendrickson et al., Acute cannabis toxicity in older adults, 4 TOXICOLOGY COMMUNICATIONS 67 (2020)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Mahmoud A. ElSohly et al., Changes in Cannabis Potency over the Last Two Decades (1995-2014)", "key": "Mahmoud A. ElSohly et al., Changes in Cannabis Potency over the Last Two Decades (1995-2014) - Analysis of Current Data in the United States" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 112a, UCMJ.\u201d Department of the Air Force Manual 44-197, Military Drug Demand Reduction Program", "key": "Department of the Air Force Manual 44-197, Military Drug Demand Reduction Program (Sep. 5, 2023)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Dep\u2019t of the Army, Pam. 27-9, Military Judges\u2019 Benchbook", "key": "Dep't of the Army, Pam. 27-9, Military Judges' Benchbook (Jan. 26, 2026)" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 112a" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "https://perma.cc/VK3D-BMP5" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "https://perma.cc/R22W-YTW3" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "EAZE, https://www.eaze.com/ [https://perma.cc/UE2C-8ZDX" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "LEAFLY, https://www.leafly.com/delivery/ [https://perma.cc/NJA4-VNDL" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "DON FUEGO, https://donfuegocannabis.com/ [https://perma.cc/5SME-P2JF] (last visited Sep. 10, 2026)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "https://perma.cc/UVT3- 6S8Y" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "https://perma.cc/2G2C-R6WM" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Kelly Fong et al., Unwitting adult marijuana poisoning: a case series, 59 CLINICAL TOXICOLOGY 913, 913 (2021)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "79 BIOLOGICAL PSYCHIATRY JOURNAL 613 (2016)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "https://perma.cc/B7LE-7HRM" } ] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0237", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-26-0237.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/briefs/2025Term/Lawrence260237AppellantBrief.pdf", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/GrantedCasesBriefs.htm", "sourceSha256": "d4c7d00f0319e379693c9ac2ecb2988edebee68866cbae815fff4456be4fbc47", "inputSha256": "cafd470a562a288fad1fd67ee4be4ef9baf23cf7a7b435015e1f9a8a04353081", "keySha256": "2a0360d5456b7725cd606e8173a6d045f01aff9147d567e4d46396434f65ce84", "rawPrepKeySha256": "3659730bab09011f1ce8a4e366127f16d08aa604c94955cffd03862c0b3f61e8", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces", "caseFamily": "CAAF 26-0237: United States v. Lawrence", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "26-0237" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:07:27.687733+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 46, "inputPages": 41, "keyEntries": 67, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "constitution", "regulations", "secondary", "web-sources", "scientific-articles" ], "keyNormalization": [], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 3, 7 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 3, "textSha256": "7d560c03986a4411456dcd644e9f2906b0431735490fe711395ad652483da957", "start": "TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\nConstitutional Provisions\nU.S. CONST. amend. V. ............................................................................................28\n\nCases\nAgostini", "end": "ni,\n 146 S. Ct. 1677 (2026) ........................................................................ 6, 19, 20, 21\n\n\n\n ii" }, { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "7049911f3c51bbf95c9e97dadb934aba6328a39b594ee9c6e9635d346f7ff067", "start": "United States v. King,\n 78 M.J. 218 (C.A.A.F. 2019) ...............................................................................31\nUnited States v. Quick,\n 74 M.J. 332 (C.A.A.", "end": "........ 3, 16, 27\nManual for Courts-Martial, United States Army (1949 ed.) .....................................5\n\n\n iii" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "026a055ddd68115c3b8ff8b4c9492a6a1cc81514f53476ea5179cf5d12a857a2", "start": "Periodical Materials\nChristian Giroud et al., E-Cigarettes:\n A Review of New Trends in Cannabis Use,\n 12 INT\u2019L. J. ENV\u2019T RSCH. PUB. HEALTH 9988 (2015)............................", "end": "al Studies,\n 182 AM. J. PSYCHIATRY 616 (2025) .....................................................................12\n\n\n\n\n iv" }, { "pdfPage": 6, "textSha256": "b15a264e568ec2c7a08a5e26f781e486906842765886ffc17a3af0b3ec0a9478", "start": "Other Authorities\nAbout E-Cigarettes (Vapes),\n U.S. CENTERS FOR DISEASE CONTROL AND PREVENTION (Oct. 24, 2024) .............8\nAdult-Use Cannabis FAQs,\n MARYLAND CANNABIS ADMINIST", "end": "............7\nRISE CANNABIS, https://risecannabis.com/ .........................................................8, 20\n\n\n\n v" }, { "pdfPage": 7, "textSha256": "82dce7395cc69920b6c5ed1f3119bfbeef231cb957c62902341e2563f42856d9", "start": "State Medical Cannabis Laws,\n NAT. CONF. OF STATE LEGISLATURES (Sep. 2, 2026)................................ 5, 19, 21\nThomas Novelly,\n Protein Shakes Pulled from Military Base ", "end": "..........................9\nWISHING WELLNESS, https://wishingwellnessdc.com/.........................................8, 20\n\n\n\n\n vi" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "........................ 35\nConclusion ............................................................................................................... 36\n\n\n\n i", "followingRetainedPageStart": "ISSUES PRESENTED\n\nI. Whether the permissive inference is unconstitutional for marijuana cases,\n both facially and as applied to this case.\n\nII. Whether Appellant\u2019s conviction for marijuana use is legally insufficient.\n\n INTRODUCTION\n\n For decades, military", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0225", "task": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0225", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-26-0225.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "constitution", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0225.first.docx", "lines": 18, "keyEntries": 21, "keyPieces": 21, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 6, "byCategory": { "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 14, "found": 14, "exact": 11, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 15, "found": 15, "exact": 11, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 8, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36 (2004)", "line": "Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36 (2004)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 12 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Waddell, 2006 Kan. App. Unpub. LEXIS 348, (Kan. Ct. App. May 19, 2006)", "line": "State v. Waddell, 2006 Kan. App. Unpub. LEXIS 348 (Kan. Ct. App. May 19, 2006)", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "lacks 15,16 (name only there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Waddell, 2006 Kan. App. LEXIS 348", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 1, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0225.first.docx", "sha256": "43e795095ae4b1600bfeea4aa5188239b4983034535056df02cc79a8f8593987", "documentXmlSha256": "3278bdd767b7967f4759bbff25db07034688fd30ddecac831f1fac1d2b720cf7" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0225.careful.docx", "lines": 18, "keyEntries": 21, "keyPieces": 21, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 6, "byCategory": { "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 14, "found": 14, "exact": 11, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 15, "found": 15, "exact": 11, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 8, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36 (2004)", "line": "Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36 (2004)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 12 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Waddell, 2006 Kan. App. Unpub. LEXIS 348, (Kan. Ct. App. May 19, 2006)", "line": "State v. Waddell, 2006 Kan. App. Unpub. LEXIS 348 (Kan. Ct. App. May 19, 2006)", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "lacks 15,16 (name only there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Waddell, 2006 Kan. App. LEXIS 348", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 1, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0225.careful.docx", "sha256": "f7341a38d083bc430337e51c8af018559f2d75e343632c3a9a7fe49cbc95079d", "documentXmlSha256": "3278bdd767b7967f4759bbff25db07034688fd30ddecac831f1fac1d2b720cf7" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0225", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0225.first.docx", "lines": 18, "keyEntries": 21, "keyPieces": 21, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 6, "byCategory": { "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 14, "found": 14, "exact": 11, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 15, "found": 15, "exact": 11, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 8, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36 (2004)", "line": "Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36 (2004)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 12 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Waddell, 2006 Kan. App. Unpub. LEXIS 348, (Kan. Ct. App. May 19, 2006)", "line": "State v. Waddell, 2006 Kan. App. Unpub. LEXIS 348 (Kan. Ct. App. May 19, 2006)", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "lacks 15,16 (name only there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Waddell, 2006 Kan. App. LEXIS 348", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0225.first.docx", "sha256": "22d5df43ce42ca11f328d29454e6ba2cd6788485416ade8cfff54bae9518e8d3", "documentXmlSha256": "3278bdd767b7967f4759bbff25db07034688fd30ddecac831f1fac1d2b720cf7" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0225.careful.docx", "lines": 18, "keyEntries": 21, "keyPieces": 21, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 6, "byCategory": { "constitution": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "cases": { "key": 14, "found": 14, "exact": 11, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 15, "found": 15, "exact": 11, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 8, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 4, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36 (2004)", "line": "Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36 (2004)", "lines": [ 1 ], "detail": "lacks 12 (name only there)" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "State v. Waddell, 2006 Kan. App. Unpub. LEXIS 348, (Kan. Ct. App. May 19, 2006)", "line": "State v. Waddell, 2006 Kan. App. Unpub. LEXIS 348 (Kan. Ct. App. May 19, 2006)", "lines": [ 7 ], "detail": "lacks 15,16 (name only there)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Waddell, 2006 Kan. App. LEXIS 348", "lines": [ 14 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 4, "safeFixes": 1, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 3, "suggestionClicks": 3 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0225.careful.docx", "sha256": "eb33f85be5ab54493c62a9e426ef889069544c3fe0290250d3154a4148aff65d", "documentXmlSha256": "3278bdd767b7967f4759bbff25db07034688fd30ddecac831f1fac1d2b720cf7" }, "seconds": 7 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0225", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Mil. R. Evid. 807" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Mil. R. Evid. 603" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Mil. R. Evid. 611" } ] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0225", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-26-0225.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/briefs/2026Term/Pinkerton260225AppellantBrief.pdf", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/GrantedCasesBriefs.htm", "sourceSha256": "2fa1a97b8f0972918a431b705bab4443719eb19251d5f50131bf3b437c064d1d", "inputSha256": "8235e5d78d1681272ed8faf1c5313e08c80d21165bdc96e42f1b453184ddb246", "keySha256": "7ef87b9b3022ce4593f193ed26c2b8c6d3d817555383f600a699fd62d0ac0fff", "rawPrepKeySha256": "f4db39ef312aeba36e7906242b18181180990e9ee02b4508d88f721488c9fc11", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces", "caseFamily": "CAAF 26-0225: United States v. Pinkerton", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "26-0225" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:07:31.033427+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 26, "inputPages": 24, "keyEntries": 21, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "constitution" ], "keyNormalization": [ { "before": "SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES California v. Green, 399 U.S. 149 (1970)", "after": "California v. Green, 399 U.S. 149 (1970)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" }, { "before": "COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE ARMED FORCES/COURT OF MILITARY CASES United States v. Blazier, 68 M.J. 439 (C.A.A.F. 2010)", "after": "United States v. Blazier, 68 M.J. 439 (C.A.A.F. 2010)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" }, { "before": "SERVICE COURTS OF CRIMINAL APPEALS United States v. Pinkerton, ARMY 20240353, 2026 CCA LEXIS 197 (Army Ct. Crim. App. Apr. 20, 2026)", "after": "United States v. Pinkerton, ARMY 20240353, 2026 CCA LEXIS 197 (Army Ct. Crim. App. Apr. 20, 2026)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" } ], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 3, 4 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 3, "textSha256": "1fffa74d7a05a73baca724de0952328796b4d71aa04733f44a75a1b1142f8bcf", "start": "Table of Authorities\n\n\nCONSTITUTIONAL PROVISIONS\n\nU.S. Const. Amend. VI (Confrontation Clause)\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026..\u2026\u2026\u20269, 10, 16, 20\n\nSUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES\n\nCalifornia v. Green, 399", "end": "OF MILITARY JUSTICE\n\nArticle 66\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026.................. 1\nArticle 67(a)(3)\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026..1\n\n ii" }, { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "8d0e623ad26a91954090799efbfcd7774a2b16d80459da8a4a40175d01e3256e", "start": "Article 120b\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026.............. 2\n\nMILITARY RULES OF EVIDENCE\n\nMil. R. Evid. 603 ................................................................................", "end": ". R. Evid. 807 ............................................................................................6, 8, 14\n\n\n\n\n iii" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "............................18\nConclusion...............................................................................................................19\n\n\n\n i", "followingRetainedPageStart": "IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS\n FOR THE ARMED FORCES\n\nUNITED STATES BRIEF ON BEHALF OF APPELLANT\n Appellee\n\n v.\n\nSpecialist (E-4) Crim. App. Dkt. No. 20240353\nJONATHAN R. PINKERTON\nUnited Sta", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-atr-verax", "task": { "id": "fresh-atr-verax", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-verax.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "secondary", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-verax.first.docx", "lines": 46, "keyEntries": 47, "keyPieces": 47, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 23, "found": 22, "exact": 16, "defensible": 5, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 21, "found": 12, "exact": 8, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 47, "found": 35, "exact": 25, "defensible": 8, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 12, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 2, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 15, "weightedScore": 76, "byType": { "missing": 12, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 2, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 60, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 10, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 15, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Department of Employment v. United States, 385 U.S. 355 (1966)", "line": "Dep\u2019t of Emp. v. United States, 385 U.S. 355 (1966)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "lacks 13 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "10 U.S.C \u00a7 2602", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 2", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 3", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 4", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 5", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 6", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 7", "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 7", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "lacks 1 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "36 U.S.C. \u00a7 300103", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "36 U.S.C. \u00a7 300107", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Board of Governors, Red Cross, https://www.redcross.org/about-us/ who-we-are/leadership/board-of-governors.html", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 110-87 (2007)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Statutes of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, The International Red Cross & Red Crescent Movement, (as amended in 2006)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1-2", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1-7", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 15, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 12, "wrongPage": 1, "wrongAuthority": 2 }, "decisions": 15, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 12, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-verax.first.docx", "sha256": "615f7e64d054c60836c859e2b308957a78bfedf8d3e23cac696e9bacbe0eede2", "documentXmlSha256": "c5a596abaa7b55e1fdfcb2c4f960eea617e5d267aeb0bcebda14b0e12651205f" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-verax.careful.docx", "lines": 46, "keyEntries": 47, "keyPieces": 47, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 23, "found": 22, "exact": 16, "defensible": 5, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 21, "found": 12, "exact": 8, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 47, "found": 35, "exact": 25, "defensible": 8, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 12, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 2, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 15, "weightedScore": 76, "byType": { "missing": 12, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 2, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 60, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 10, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 15, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Department of Employment v. United States, 385 U.S. 355 (1966)", "line": "Dep\u2019t of Emp. v. United States, 385 U.S. 355 (1966)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "lacks 13 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "10 U.S.C \u00a7 2602", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 2", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 3", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 4", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 5", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 6", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 7", "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 7", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "lacks 1 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "36 U.S.C. \u00a7 300103", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "36 U.S.C. \u00a7 300107", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Board of Governors, Red Cross, https://www.redcross.org/about-us/ who-we-are/leadership/board-of-governors.html", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 110-87 (2007)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Statutes of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, The International Red Cross & Red Crescent Movement, (as amended in 2006)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1-2", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1-7", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 15, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 12, "wrongPage": 1, "wrongAuthority": 2 }, "decisions": 15, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 12, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-verax.careful.docx", "sha256": "d4c770a0afcb233e455ca4498d1808d3a97c80281f4ba72ba60717f3636ac037", "documentXmlSha256": "c5a596abaa7b55e1fdfcb2c4f960eea617e5d267aeb0bcebda14b0e12651205f" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-verax", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-verax.first.docx", "lines": 46, "keyEntries": 47, "keyPieces": 47, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 23, "found": 22, "exact": 16, "defensible": 5, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 21, "found": 12, "exact": 8, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 47, "found": 35, "exact": 25, "defensible": 8, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 12, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 2, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 15, "weightedScore": 76, "byType": { "missing": 12, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 2, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 60, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 10, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 15, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Department of Employment v. United States, 385 U.S. 355 (1966)", "line": "Dep\u2019t of Emp. v. United States, 385 U.S. 355 (1966)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "lacks 13 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "10 U.S.C \u00a7 2602", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 2", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 3", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 4", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 5", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 6", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 7", "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 7", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "lacks 1 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "36 U.S.C. \u00a7 300103", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "36 U.S.C. \u00a7 300107", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Board of Governors, Red Cross, https://www.redcross.org/about-us/ who-we-are/leadership/board-of-governors.html", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 110-87 (2007)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Statutes of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, The International Red Cross & Red Crescent Movement, (as amended in 2006)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1-2", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1-7", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 2, "unsurfaced": 13, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 10, "wrongPage": 1, "wrongAuthority": 2 }, "decisions": 16, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 10, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-verax.first.docx", "sha256": "c4f4805404bb6656818f757a9ee0e260cfdcfc2fa70b8f2417b3947296b97778", "documentXmlSha256": "c5a596abaa7b55e1fdfcb2c4f960eea617e5d267aeb0bcebda14b0e12651205f" }, "seconds": 5 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-verax.careful.docx", "lines": 49, "keyEntries": 47, "keyPieces": 47, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 23, "found": 22, "exact": 16, "defensible": 5, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 21, "found": 13, "exact": 9, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 3, "found": 3, "exact": 3, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 47, "found": 38, "exact": 28, "defensible": 8, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 2, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 12, "weightedScore": 61, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 2, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 10, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 12, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Department of Employment v. United States, 385 U.S. 355 (1966)", "line": "Dep\u2019t of Emp. v. United States, 385 U.S. 355 (1966)", "lines": [ 4 ], "detail": "lacks 13 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 2", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 3", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 4", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 5", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 6", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 7", "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 7", "lines": [ 29 ], "detail": "lacks 1 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "36 U.S.C. \u00a7 300103", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "36 U.S.C. \u00a7 300107", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 110-87 (2007)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1-2", "lines": [ 27 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1-7", "lines": [ 28 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 12, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 9, "wrongPage": 1, "wrongAuthority": 2 }, "decisions": 15, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 3, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 9, "suggestions": 3, "modelShown": 3, "trueAccepts": 3, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 3 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-verax.careful.docx", "sha256": "97ec6b70587bf89b30cadadb58652b6e92df3586eefdec07d429f62259f4f97a", "documentXmlSha256": "480a2a9385421ede2c4035bb6f1170ffc7ccc69ee301e613a80ceb0c923c69a5" }, "seconds": 10 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-verax", "accept": [ "Board of Governers, Red Cross, https://www.redcross.org/about-us/who-weare/leadership/board-of-governors.html (last visited Aug. 21, 2026)", "Statutes of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, The Int\u2019l Red Cross & Red Crescent Movement, Preamble & Art. 4", "10 U.S.C \u00a7\u00a7 2602" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Board of Governers, Red Cross, https://www.redcross.org/about-us/who-weare/leadership/board-of-governors.html (last visited Aug. 21, 2026)", "key": "Board of Governors, Red Cross, https://www.redcross.org/about-us/ who-we-are/leadership/board-of-governors.html" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Statutes of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, The Int\u2019l Red Cross & Red Crescent Movement, Preamble & Art. 4", "key": "Statutes of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, The International Red Cross & Red Crescent Movement, (as amended in 2006)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "10 U.S.C \u00a7\u00a7 2602", "key": "10 U.S.C \u00a7 2602" } ], "wrong": [] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-atr-verax", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-verax.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/media/1459956/dl?inline", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/appellate-briefs", "sourceSha256": "ca7af729acdc4c13ebe62ee806c0ef4317f72cc85346824ffdc9f51cae779a2f", "inputSha256": "9327dc9d0c91b92bb5b221c646caf83662eebe3f795bdb845652e9ccfd750a15", "keySha256": "b2c786e7f1d26f1ad07f9db819116a3f9a9fb35478d64de8710e70c192149cec", "rawPrepKeySha256": "51a8193c18d2a797b3f5ef8e5a9ab8da8a6e1885aec865a07b893eb0a93fc1b5", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit", "caseFamily": "CA1 26-1511 / D. Mass. 23-cv-10335: Verax Biomedical v. American National Red Cross", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "26-1511", "23-cv-10335", "Verax Biomedical" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:07:43.684976+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 39, "inputPages": 35, "keyEntries": 47, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "secondary" ], "keyNormalization": [], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 3, 6 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 3, "textSha256": "ba5de284447b3c5002cc4351e9275f23d61c26c067274602b27770d6efe8a68a", "start": "Case: 26-1511 Document: 00118495834 Page: 3 Date Filed: 08/21/2026 Entry ID: 6836553\n\n\n\n\n TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\n ", "end": "ndywine Hospital,\n 47 F.3d 618 (3d Cir. 1995) ........................................................ 10, 22, 25\n\n\n ii" }, { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "20261793b3a3eb492927bd62056f97f9c0de20528c600d2388de47d121d780a2", "start": "Case: 26-1511 Document: 00118495834 Page: 4 Date Filed: 08/21/2026 Entry ID: 6836553\n\n\n\n\n McCarthy v. Middle Tennessee Electric Membership Corp", "end": "5, 9\n\n 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 2 .................................................................................. 1, 2, 5, 9\n iii" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "41044ab7d681ec335a916674762013ed03bf4bba95f84500998513d1535f2d03", "start": "Case: 26-1511 Document: 00118495834 Page: 5 Date Filed: 08/21/2026 Entry ID: 6836553\n\n\n\n\n 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 3 .....................................", "end": "ss-Audited-\n Financial-Statement.pdf ......................................................................30\n\n\n\n iv" }, { "pdfPage": 6, "textSha256": "47bcf4a61b1de5041709265a38c463ec2f2950b640ef476d5d87427d93f73119", "start": "Case: 26-1511 Document: 00118495834 Page: 6 Date Filed: 08/21/2026 Entry ID: 6836553\n\n\n\n\n Statutes of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Mov", "end": "/assets/files/\n other/statutes-en-a5.pdf ................................................................... 4, 25\n\n\n\n\n v" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "NCE........................................................32\n CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE.................................................................33\n\n\n\n\n i", "followingRetainedPageStart": "Case: 26-1511 Document: 00118495834 Page: 7 Date Filed: 08/21/2026 Entry ID: 6836553\n\n\n\n\n INTEREST OF THE UNITED STATES\n\n The United States enforces the federal antitrust laws, including the\n\n Sherman Act, 15 U.S.C. \u00a7\u00a7 1-7, and has a strong interest in th", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-atr-x-mars", "task": { "id": "fresh-atr-x-mars", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-x-mars.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "regulations", "rules", "secondary", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-x-mars.first.docx", "lines": 47, "keyEntries": 43, "keyPieces": 43, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 38, "found": 38, "exact": 26, "defensible": 11, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 43, "found": 43, "exact": 30, "defensible": 12, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 5, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Klor's, Inc. v. Broadway-Hale Stores, Inc., 359 U.S. 207 (1959)", "line": "Klor\u2019s, Inc. v. Broadway-Hale Stores, Inc., 359 U.S. 207 (1959)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Northwest Wholesale Stationers, Inc. v. Pacific Stationery & Printing Co., 472 U.S. 284 (1", "line": "Northwest Wholesale Stationers, Inc. v. Pacific Stationery & Printing Co., 472 U.S. 284 (1985)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks 23 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 23" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 3, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-x-mars.first.docx", "sha256": "5457244f9f70a072c96ed59d36f70ad16bcac02fb374d78bcd11b7f3d3736dfc", "documentXmlSha256": "be6dcb3a6436ee59ef3c42f45aea0590b4780608d3e93f04fb7ad925a11e8eca" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-x-mars.careful.docx", "lines": 47, "keyEntries": 43, "keyPieces": 43, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 38, "found": 38, "exact": 26, "defensible": 11, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 43, "found": 43, "exact": 30, "defensible": 12, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 5, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Klor's, Inc. v. Broadway-Hale Stores, Inc., 359 U.S. 207 (1959)", "line": "Klor\u2019s, Inc. v. Broadway-Hale Stores, Inc., 359 U.S. 207 (1959)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Northwest Wholesale Stationers, Inc. v. Pacific Stationery & Printing Co., 472 U.S. 284 (1", "line": "Northwest Wholesale Stationers, Inc. v. Pacific Stationery & Printing Co., 472 U.S. 284 (1985)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks 23 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 23" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 3, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-x-mars.careful.docx", "sha256": "31f6e3fbcc3b4e0d54098bee216f099f1edf07286fe4554bfe7c87b0fee5de42", "documentXmlSha256": "be6dcb3a6436ee59ef3c42f45aea0590b4780608d3e93f04fb7ad925a11e8eca" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-x-mars", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-x-mars.first.docx", "lines": 47, "keyEntries": 43, "keyPieces": 43, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 38, "found": 38, "exact": 26, "defensible": 11, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 43, "found": 43, "exact": 30, "defensible": 12, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 5, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Klor's, Inc. v. Broadway-Hale Stores, Inc., 359 U.S. 207 (1959)", "line": "Klor\u2019s, Inc. v. Broadway-Hale Stores, Inc., 359 U.S. 207 (1959)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Northwest Wholesale Stationers, Inc. v. Pacific Stationery & Printing Co., 472 U.S. 284 (1", "line": "Northwest Wholesale Stationers, Inc. v. Pacific Stationery & Printing Co., 472 U.S. 284 (1985)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks 23 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 23" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 3, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-x-mars.first.docx", "sha256": "00477f3f17d961fa00a1e194749175997c350dd6351ceaa39464feb5d68e92ed", "documentXmlSha256": "be6dcb3a6436ee59ef3c42f45aea0590b4780608d3e93f04fb7ad925a11e8eca" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-x-mars.careful.docx", "lines": 47, "keyEntries": 43, "keyPieces": 43, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 38, "found": 38, "exact": 26, "defensible": 11, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 2, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 43, "found": 43, "exact": 30, "defensible": 12, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 5, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Klor's, Inc. v. Broadway-Hale Stores, Inc., 359 U.S. 207 (1959)", "line": "Klor\u2019s, Inc. v. Broadway-Hale Stores, Inc., 359 U.S. 207 (1959)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Northwest Wholesale Stationers, Inc. v. Pacific Stationery & Printing Co., 472 U.S. 284 (1", "line": "Northwest Wholesale Stationers, Inc. v. Pacific Stationery & Printing Co., 472 U.S. 284 (1985)", "lines": [ 26 ], "detail": "lacks 23 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 23" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "idPage": 1 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 3, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-x-mars.careful.docx", "sha256": "57159d433cdc8ac0f866845d5c109a149b4d37fbf73328850c826f3bb1fa5fe9", "documentXmlSha256": "be6dcb3a6436ee59ef3c42f45aea0590b4780608d3e93f04fb7ad925a11e8eca" }, "seconds": 4 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-x-mars", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-atr-x-mars", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-x-mars.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/media/1458686/dl?inline", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/appellate-briefs", "sourceSha256": "cc68e2eaf80e9067fe704b8e1de83a8a0963d492c287d726e07d94c2f43d8fcc", "inputSha256": "299ff906d53decabc459d3c99a549b76a3478adf10fc9db3bf0dfd3dce075c19", "keySha256": "cc4a8850ed8dc6a73ddd9a0d22f7923c52b3f81ea74e921855427567d41d47fa", "rawPrepKeySha256": "4dd473a7cfa11f74c93813bb036364d0e728b56ecd376c1bc4a8978cc7198dee", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit", "caseFamily": "CA5 26-10394: X Corp. v. Mars et al.", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "26-10394", "X Corp." ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:07:54.188922+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 34, "inputPages": 29, "keyEntries": 43, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "regulations", "rules", "secondary" ], "keyNormalization": [], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 3, 7 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 3, "textSha256": "f5513910244df6eb3d8df65bf54ad169e71c5c7b24b22b6009539d46e7721ed8", "start": "Case: 26-10394 Document: 126 Page: 3 Date Filed: 08/12/2026\n\n\n\n\n TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\n ", "end": ".................................................................................................... 17\n\n\n\n ii" }, { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "4d1641fc141c1bcab615b1eaf75c6050911fe2f7d2a4ca8ec01e197fc1736c9f", "start": "Case: 26-10394 Document: 126 Page: 4 Date Filed: 08/12/2026\n\n\n\n\n TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\u2014Continued\n\n ", "end": "................................................................................................. 15, 21\n\n iii" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "365d96d54b2cc176c74ac5f43fb1c23f7b5fc036542c39faba2fbeb56e3a3cb3", "start": "Case: 26-10394 Document: 126 Page: 5 Date Filed: 08/12/2026\n\n\n\n\n TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\u2014Continued\n\n ", "end": ")..................................................................................................... 14\n\n iv" }, { "pdfPage": 6, "textSha256": "ab462576337b464dad6549b35e2e262206631d5558fe0cc62d81e573c7cb31c6", "start": "Case: 26-10394 Document: 126 Page: 6 Date Filed: 08/12/2026\n\n\n\n\n TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\u2014Continued\n\n", "end": "............................................................................................. 5, 8, 14\n\n v" }, { "pdfPage": 7, "textSha256": "df53abc5ce1cb6afcb2ffbb2d0f6242c145d2e877fa4f78fdac309421d1cf584", "start": "Case: 26-10394 Document: 126 Page: 7 Date Filed: 08/12/2026\n\n\n\n\n TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\u2014Continued", "end": "ntitrust Principles and Their Application (5th ed. 2021) ........................ 11, 12, 13, 15\n\n\n\n\n vi" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "6\n\nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE .............................................................................................................. 27\n\n\n\n\n i", "followingRetainedPageStart": "Case: 26-10394 Document: 126 Page: 8 Date Filed: 08/12/2026\n\n\n\n\n STATEMENT OF INTEREST\n\n The United States Department of Justice has primary responsibility for\n\nenforcing the federal antitrust laws and a strong interest in their correct\n\napplication. The De", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen", "task": { "id": "fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen.first.docx", "lines": 45, "keyEntries": 37, "keyPieces": 37, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 33, "exact": 28, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 36, "found": 35, "exact": 28, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 7, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 18, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 2, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 6, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 1", "line": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "lines": [ 23, 24, 25 ], "detail": "lacks 9,12,18,19,22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Zenith Radio Corp. v. Hazeltine Research, Inc., 395 U.S. 100 (1969)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "line": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5174825 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "also on: Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 20" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "line": "Steves and Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545 (E.D. Va. May 9, 2022)", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "also on: Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 20" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "United States v. Microsemi Corp., No. 8:09-cv-00275 (C.D. Cal. Jan. 29, 2010)", "lines": [ 33 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "duplicate": 2, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen.first.docx", "sha256": "2c4209e50aa394ea42ef71855c9eddbb5353f656214715db2140c1631937231d", "documentXmlSha256": "48902eb30dcd12b32432d2262d7bbb5e93fcb79451e73c35d77897f23354d66d" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen.careful.docx", "lines": 45, "keyEntries": 37, "keyPieces": 37, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 33, "exact": 28, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 36, "found": 35, "exact": 28, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 7, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 18, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 2, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 6, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 1", "line": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "lines": [ 23, 24, 25 ], "detail": "lacks 9,12,18,19,22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Zenith Radio Corp. v. Hazeltine Research, Inc., 395 U.S. 100 (1969)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "line": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5174825 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "also on: Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 20" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "line": "Steves and Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545 (E.D. Va. May 9, 2022)", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "also on: Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 20" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "United States v. Microsemi Corp., No. 8:09-cv-00275 (C.D. Cal. Jan. 29, 2010)", "lines": [ 33 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "duplicate": 2, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen.careful.docx", "sha256": "e904f5909f147f80f3b0d1cea48dcc29a4567cabbe205c94c3783eb86852d0fc", "documentXmlSha256": "48902eb30dcd12b32432d2262d7bbb5e93fcb79451e73c35d77897f23354d66d" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen.first.docx", "lines": 45, "keyEntries": 37, "keyPieces": 37, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 33, "exact": 28, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 36, "found": 35, "exact": 28, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 7, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 18, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 2, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 6, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 1", "line": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "lines": [ 23, 24, 25 ], "detail": "lacks 9,12,18,19,22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Zenith Radio Corp. v. Hazeltine Research, Inc., 395 U.S. 100 (1969)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "line": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5174825 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "also on: Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 20" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "line": "Steves and Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545 (E.D. Va. May 9, 2022)", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "also on: Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 20" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "United States v. Microsemi Corp., No. 8:09-cv-00275 (C.D. Cal. Jan. 29, 2010)", "lines": [ 33 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "duplicate": 2, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 2, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen.first.docx", "sha256": "b88b788d9dd6665a988c757a4504a628779ee3cb5d08379686029469536b551e", "documentXmlSha256": "48902eb30dcd12b32432d2262d7bbb5e93fcb79451e73c35d77897f23354d66d" }, "seconds": 5 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen.careful.docx", "lines": 45, "keyEntries": 37, "keyPieces": 37, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 34, "found": 33, "exact": 28, "defensible": 5, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 36, "found": 35, "exact": 28, "defensible": 7, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 1, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 1, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 7, "errorsInFile": 2, "weightedScore": 18, "byType": { "missing": 1, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 1, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 2, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 5, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 6, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 1", "line": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "lines": [ 23, 24, 25 ], "detail": "lacks 9,12,18,19,22 (name only there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Zenith Radio Corp. v. Hazeltine Research, Inc., 395 U.S. 100 (1969)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "line": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5174825 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "lines": [ 24 ], "detail": "also on: Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 20" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 2024 WL 5171177 (E.D. Va. Dec. 19, 2024)", "line": "Steves and Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545 (E.D. Va. May 9, 2022)", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "also on: Steves & Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00545, 20" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "United States v. Microsemi Corp., No. 8:09-cv-00275 (C.D. Cal. Jan. 29, 2010)", "lines": [ 33 ], "detail": "not in the brief" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "duplicate": 2, "wrongAuthority": 1 }, "decisions": 8, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 2, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 1, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 2, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 2, "suggestionClicks": 2 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen.careful.docx", "sha256": "ec1cc3542122e7b9f713694bec8fb0df002d22b4076f1913ffba371d7337f5fb", "documentXmlSha256": "48902eb30dcd12b32432d2262d7bbb5e93fcb79451e73c35d77897f23354d66d" }, "seconds": 5 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "United States v. Bazaarvoice, 13-cv-00133 (N.D. Cal. Apr. 25, 2014)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "\u00a7 16 of the Clayton Act" } ] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-steves-jeldwen.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/media/1408666/dl?inline", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/appellate-briefs", "sourceSha256": "60e435d58d351fbb828b2c631d6db1f549cc4e1104b93e1ad67a58b449fbf992", "inputSha256": "0684d447eed750b221b9c206705274ce0c1dba6107dae85b98236297b08b873c", "keySha256": "121a7a7cf7949b4ab3659c3fc9055f8039e8b8dd443f2a9fb7f0ab0d0eff8651", "rawPrepKeySha256": "b8bb9d07bb4fe440f774cfc2d8b4a80bcfdf5780f2c9e6bbe51e7a9e354757eb", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit", "caseFamily": "CA4 25-1127 / E.D. Va. 16-cv-00545: Steves and Sons v. Jeld-Wen", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "25-1127", "16-cv-00545", "Steves and Sons", "Steves & Sons", "Jeld-Wen" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:08:15.352725+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 32, "inputPages": 29, "keyEntries": 37, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules" ], "keyNormalization": [ { "before": "P AGE( S) C ASES Brown Shoe Co. v. United States, 370 U.S. 294 (1962)", "after": "Brown Shoe Co. v. United States, 370 U.S. 294 (1962)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" }, { "before": "STATUTES 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 26", "after": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 26", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" } ], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 3, 5 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 3, "textSha256": "fdd767e2726c419e94a882a4b91e0de2076ca61c455d415e4ff47604545eb256", "start": "USCA4 Appeal: 25-1127 Doc: 46 Filed: 07/21/2025 Pg: 3 of 32\n\n\n\n\n TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\n ", "end": "Flores,\n 557 U.S. 433 (2009)..............................................................................14\n\n\n\n ii" }, { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "3d24bf0dcd317ebefe234c052c74766c2bfd853ae4c2f49b3ea736a6a67849a9", "start": "USCA4 Appeal: 25-1127 Doc: 46 Filed: 07/21/2025 Pg: 4 of 32\n\n\n\n\n International Boxing Club of New York, Inc. v. United States,\n 358 U.S. 242", "end": "JELD-WEN, Inc.,\n 345 F. Supp. 3d 614 (E.D. Va. 2018) ...................................................23\n\n\n\n\n iii" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "75df9cd6d39d29a23d1cb35e77cabe4924e7dc746c55cc3d22f7f4a54a4c1893", "start": "USCA4 Appeal: 25-1127 Doc: 46 Filed: 07/21/2025 Pg: 5 of 32\n\n\n\n\n Trump v. CASA, Inc.,\n No. 24A884, 606 U.S. __, 2025 WL 1773631\n ", "end": " RULES\n\n Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(5) ................................................13\n\n\n\n\n iv" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "lic Interest ..............................21\n CONCLUSION ........................................................................................25\n\n\n\n\n i", "followingRetainedPageStart": "USCA4 Appeal: 25-1127 Doc: 46 Filed: 07/21/2025 Pg: 6 of 32\n\n\n\n\n INTEREST OF THE UNITED STATES\n\n The United States enforces the federal antitrust laws and has a\n\n strong interest in their correct application. The United States also has a\n\n si", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-atr-ninth-inning", "task": { "id": "fresh-atr-ninth-inning", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-ninth-inning.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "secondary", "web-sources", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-ninth-inning.first.docx", "lines": 35, "keyEntries": 34, "keyPieces": 34, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 28, "found": 26, "exact": 22, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 34, "found": 31, "exact": 26, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Board of Regents of University of Oklahoma v. NCAA, 707 F.2d 1147 (10th Cir. 1983)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Datagate, Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Co., 941 F.2d 864 (9th Cir. 1991)", "line": "Datagate, Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Co., 941 F.2d 864 (9th Cir. 1991)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "lacks 19 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Northern Pacific Railway Co. v. United States, 356 U.S. 1 (1958)", "line": "N. Pac. Ry. Co. v. United States, 356 U.S. 1 (1958)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 14 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 14" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc., 659 F.2d 1063 (2d Cir. 1981)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "NFL fans in US must pay $1,600 a year to watch every game after Netflix addition, THE GUARDIAN (May 15, 2024), https://www.theguardian.com/s", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-ninth-inning.first.docx", "sha256": "d92ee019f851252bff2c3653c4dc373d7039f7ee1ab9f86d375936014173a6f1", "documentXmlSha256": "de5cb8ecdcbb21ab5e83a28a7e7bfc64cd3f00b90f0afa1dce952c2c88bc38a7" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-ninth-inning.careful.docx", "lines": 35, "keyEntries": 34, "keyPieces": 34, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 28, "found": 26, "exact": 22, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 34, "found": 31, "exact": 26, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Board of Regents of University of Oklahoma v. NCAA, 707 F.2d 1147 (10th Cir. 1983)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Datagate, Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Co., 941 F.2d 864 (9th Cir. 1991)", "line": "Datagate, Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Co., 941 F.2d 864 (9th Cir. 1991)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "lacks 19 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Northern Pacific Railway Co. v. United States, 356 U.S. 1 (1958)", "line": "N. Pac. Ry. Co. v. United States, 356 U.S. 1 (1958)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 14 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 14" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc., 659 F.2d 1063 (2d Cir. 1981)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "NFL fans in US must pay $1,600 a year to watch every game after Netflix addition, THE GUARDIAN (May 15, 2024), https://www.theguardian.com/s", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3 }, "decisions": 4, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-ninth-inning.careful.docx", "sha256": "15ddae8b4754d8203914dd7d56309e122c1db174179449ce520dcd4a81bb0a9c", "documentXmlSha256": "de5cb8ecdcbb21ab5e83a28a7e7bfc64cd3f00b90f0afa1dce952c2c88bc38a7" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-ninth-inning", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-ninth-inning.first.docx", "lines": 35, "keyEntries": 34, "keyPieces": 34, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 28, "found": 26, "exact": 22, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 34, "found": 31, "exact": 26, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Board of Regents of University of Oklahoma v. NCAA, 707 F.2d 1147 (10th Cir. 1983)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Datagate, Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Co., 941 F.2d 864 (9th Cir. 1991)", "line": "Datagate, Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Co., 941 F.2d 864 (9th Cir. 1991)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "lacks 19 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Northern Pacific Railway Co. v. United States, 356 U.S. 1 (1958)", "line": "N. Pac. Ry. Co. v. United States, 356 U.S. 1 (1958)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 14 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 14" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc., 659 F.2d 1063 (2d Cir. 1981)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "NFL fans in US must pay $1,600 a year to watch every game after Netflix addition, THE GUARDIAN (May 15, 2024), https://www.theguardian.com/s", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 2, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-ninth-inning.first.docx", "sha256": "07dec923d29bc7481e60e67bc38ef21710583a6fb2091e5a10d4907100629d26", "documentXmlSha256": "de5cb8ecdcbb21ab5e83a28a7e7bfc64cd3f00b90f0afa1dce952c2c88bc38a7" }, "seconds": 5 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-ninth-inning.careful.docx", "lines": 35, "keyEntries": 34, "keyPieces": 34, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 28, "found": 26, "exact": 22, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 4, "exact": 3, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 2, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 34, "found": 31, "exact": 26, "defensible": 4, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 4, "weightedScore": 20, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 1, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 1, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 3, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 2, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 4, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Board of Regents of University of Oklahoma v. NCAA, 707 F.2d 1147 (10th Cir. 1983)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "nameOnly", "weight": 2, "key": "Datagate, Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Co., 941 F.2d 864 (9th Cir. 1991)", "line": "Datagate, Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Co., 941 F.2d 864 (9th Cir. 1991)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "lacks 19 (name only there)" }, { "type": "idPage", "weight": 3, "key": "Northern Pacific Railway Co. v. United States, 356 U.S. 1 (1958)", "line": "N. Pac. Ry. Co. v. United States, 356 U.S. 1 (1958)", "lines": [ 18 ], "detail": "lacks 14 (cited there) / adds - (not cited there); Id./short-form only: 14" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc., 659 F.2d 1063 (2d Cir. 1981)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "NFL fans in US must pay $1,600 a year to watch every game after Netflix addition, THE GUARDIAN (May 15, 2024), https://www.theguardian.com/s", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 3, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 3, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3 }, "decisions": 6, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 2, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 2, "modelShown": 2, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 2, "suggestionClicks": 2 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-ninth-inning.careful.docx", "sha256": "1f1be2a1f724182ae6cd3f10a36c280d692e23c8d6660a3c6689d4f4a2ab693b", "documentXmlSha256": "de5cb8ecdcbb21ab5e83a28a7e7bfc64cd3f00b90f0afa1dce952c2c88bc38a7" }, "seconds": 11 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-ninth-inning", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "United States v. Google LLC, 1:23cv108 (E.D.V.A. Jan. 24, 2023)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "\u00a7 16" } ] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-atr-ninth-inning", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-ninth-inning.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/media/1386026/dl?inline", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/appellate-briefs", "sourceSha256": "663ac7e51e283ceb9fd65482bcce9644f1bc1d280ec262daa364ef3f8e937615", "inputSha256": "5845ae9c03035653bda9ec0ee8f259092442d927c220d6a18138f79dce70a45f", "keySha256": "c58ffb309243a575067aa14defb248a7e84526bb57d21b6226d91f2be172db91", "rawPrepKeySha256": "31c9725d591c269e5157c0953a32e1eecdf5b4ab0da0154efb2082a16f61125b", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit", "caseFamily": "CA9 24-5493 / 24-5691 / C.D. Cal. 15-ml-02668: Ninth Inning v. NFL", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "24-5493", "24-5691", "15-ml-02668", "Ninth Inning" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:08:25.920709+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 33, "inputPages": 30, "keyEntries": 34, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "secondary", "web-sources" ], "keyNormalization": [], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 3, 5 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 3, "textSha256": "57b6324c434fdd96298bba4742237a5f0708604aa09139db218df0168291db1d", "start": "Case: 24-5493, 01/17/2025, DktEntry: 45.1, Page 3 of 33\n\n\n\n\n TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\n\nCases ", "end": "...... 10, 14\n\nfuboTV Inc. v. Walt Disney Co.,\n No. 24-cv-01363, 2024 WL 3842116 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 16, 2024) .............. 5\n\n\n iii" }, { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "2196ec4a28c447601246250e4c4d37b55d3f1384325bd900ba9eaae24b2f4b7c", "start": "Case: 24-5493, 01/17/2025, DktEntry: 45.1, Page 4 of 33\n\n\n\n\nIllinois Brick Co. v. Illinois,\n 431 U.S. 720 (1977) ..................................................................", "end": "y Electronics Co., Ltd.,\n 20 F.4th 466 (9th Cir. 2021) ............................................................ 15, 17\n\n\n\n\n iv" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "03137ffe8742a9e50f5443ff15fd74fc4e9170239bc46fee28c75b1a8a91d294", "start": "Case: 24-5493, 01/17/2025, DktEntry: 45.1, Page 5 of 33\n\n\n\n\nUnited States Gypsum Co. v. Indiana Gas Co.,\n 350 F.3d 623 (7th Cir. 2003)..............................................", "end": "icle/2024/may/15/nfl-netflix\n steaming-exclusive-games-price.......................................................24-25\n\n\n\n\n v" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "g Threatened Loss .......................................17\nCONCLUSION .........................................................................................25\n\n\n\n\n ii", "followingRetainedPageStart": "Case: 24-5493, 01/17/2025, DktEntry: 45.1, Page 6 of 33\n\n\n\n\n INTEREST OF THE UNITED STATES\n\n The United States enforces the federal antitrust laws and has a\n\nstrong interest in their correct application. The United States also has a\n\nsignificant interest in ensuring the availabili", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-atr-malheur", "task": { "id": "fresh-atr-malheur", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-malheur.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "regulations", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-malheur.first.docx", "lines": 37, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 20, "found": 20, "exact": 18, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 13, "found": 13, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 34, "found": 34, "exact": 30, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 4, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "36 C.F.R. \u00a7 223.61", "line": "36 C.F.R. \u00a7 223.61", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 7 (not cited there)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 2, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-malheur.first.docx", "sha256": "4e45841d28b154f16b79161033675f54881db5a35c82286c1fd5c4d9960a5215", "documentXmlSha256": "96e4b6883af46d711f666cbce32cd2c84b9d9aa763303d2a6e75602e49e4d530" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-malheur.careful.docx", "lines": 37, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 20, "found": 20, "exact": 18, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 13, "found": 13, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 34, "found": 34, "exact": 30, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 4, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "36 C.F.R. \u00a7 223.61", "line": "36 C.F.R. \u00a7 223.61", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 7 (not cited there)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 2, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-malheur.careful.docx", "sha256": "10da0a5efa65646628764517b8f5712ba862099fd245920cee78382547b33297", "documentXmlSha256": "96e4b6883af46d711f666cbce32cd2c84b9d9aa763303d2a6e75602e49e4d530" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-malheur", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-malheur.first.docx", "lines": 37, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 20, "found": 20, "exact": 18, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 13, "found": 13, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 34, "found": 34, "exact": 30, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 4, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "36 C.F.R. \u00a7 223.61", "line": "36 C.F.R. \u00a7 223.61", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 7 (not cited there)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 2, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-malheur.first.docx", "sha256": "d8261ea0bd9555506eb7b8a5126386e04ca0c8f9e2202a6f99e33bfab5c2eb3f", "documentXmlSha256": "96e4b6883af46d711f666cbce32cd2c84b9d9aa763303d2a6e75602e49e4d530" }, "seconds": 6 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-malheur.careful.docx", "lines": 37, "keyEntries": 35, "keyPieces": 35, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 20, "found": 20, "exact": 18, "defensible": 2, "passim": 0 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "regulations": { "key": 13, "found": 13, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 34, "found": 34, "exact": 30, "defensible": 3, "passim": 0 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 3, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 4, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "36 C.F.R. \u00a7 223.61", "line": "36 C.F.R. \u00a7 223.61", "lines": [ 25 ], "detail": "lacks - (cited there) / adds 7 (not cited there)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 1, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1 }, "decisions": 2, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-malheur.careful.docx", "sha256": "b8175331d757c23249ea7b024923c58c388b8cc74dc518ec0ac29efe031dae44", "documentXmlSha256": "96e4b6883af46d711f666cbce32cd2c84b9d9aa763303d2a6e75602e49e4d530" }, "seconds": 6 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-malheur", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-atr-malheur", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-malheur.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/media/1385911/dl?inline", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/appellate-briefs", "sourceSha256": "dd106f7a2ebf4d9f32566060234bb65d7895c094f101a72e827442a43a14fd6f", "inputSha256": "a706b2956dee25edb9d5d9839241c29c7abe859bcb466a7a51d32fc9915ffcac", "keySha256": "b52566f42ff5d021a5bdb1996de28ba0073b0d8c7269f378bd804c74aad1cfc0", "rawPrepKeySha256": "817da22b432761b419fdc352637cdb7b458a1e3d1546fdbe43bf262cd966eeac", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit", "caseFamily": "CA9 24-6366: Malheur Forest Fairness Coalition v. Iron Triangle", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "24-6366", "Malheur Forest Fairness Coalition", "Iron Triangle" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:08:36.492390+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 29, "inputPages": 26, "keyEntries": 35, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "regulations" ], "keyNormalization": [], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 3, 5 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 3, "textSha256": "e8abd10ddce1946dbd64b5c60b8cd74f805906b4c1f18de2eaf03fafa56a33ea", "start": "Case: 24-6366, 01/16/2025, DktEntry: 15.1, Page 3 of 29\n\n\n\n\n TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\n\nCases ", "end": "ell Douglas Corp.,\n 705 F.2d 1030 (9th Cir. 1983).......................................................................20\n\n\n ii" }, { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "2bc10390ae1ac0a6cd8184b15f21cc57467d13f7fa7965f2d54360969fc1e2b7", "start": "Case: 24-6366, 01/16/2025, DktEntry: 15.1, Page 4 of 29\n\n\n\n\nPlanetSpace Inc. v. United States,\n 96 Fed. Cl. 119 (2010) .............................................................", "end": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 2.......................................................................................................3\n\n\n iii" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "18745b2d50ec22e9d81009c15a5845d366550b0cbb14583fdeec0464e1574991", "start": "Case: 24-6366, 01/16/2025, DktEntry: 15.1, Page 5 of 29\n\n\n\n\nRegulations\n\n36 C.F.R. \u00a7 223.300(b)(1) .................................................................................", "end": "...12\n\n48 C.F.R. \u00a7 52.203-2.........................................................................................21\n\n\n\n\n iv" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "ICATE OF COMPLIANCE FOR BRIEFS........................23\n\nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE.........................................................................24\n\n\n\n\n i", "followingRetainedPageStart": "Case: 24-6366, 01/16/2025, DktEntry: 15.1, Page 6 of 29\n\n\n\n\n STATEMENTOF INTEREST\n\n The United States has primary responsibility for enforcing the federal\n\nantitrust laws and a strong interest in their correct application. The United\n\nStates has a significant interest in e", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0077", "task": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0077", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-26-0077.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "secondary", "legislative-materials", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0077.first.docx", "lines": 21, "keyEntries": 26, "keyPieces": 26, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 17, "found": 15, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 2 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 4, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 25, "found": 16, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 10, "weightedScore": 49, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 10, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "United States v. Downum, __ M.J.___, 2025 CAAF LEXIS 828 (C.A.A.F. 23 October 2025)", "line": "United States v. Downum, __ M.J.___, 2025 CAAF LEXIS 828 (C.A.A.F. 23 October 2025)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "lacks 50 (cited there) / adds 49 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "UCMJ Article 66, 10 U.S.C \u00a7 866 (Supp. II 2019-2021)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "UCMJ Article 67, 10 U.S.C \u00a7 867 (Supp. II 2019-2021)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "UCMJ Article 120, 10 U.S.C. \u00a7 920 (2018)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Defense Advisory Committee on Investigation, Prosecution, and Defense of Sexual Assault in the Armed Forces, Appellate Review Study (March 2", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "John M. Donnelly, NDAA envisions new military policies on sexual assaults, Roll Call (8 December 2020)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 116-457 (2020)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 116-617 (2020)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Letter to Chairman Smith, Ranking Member Thornberry, Chairman Inhofe, and Ranking Member Reed, 14 September 2020", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Office of the General Counsel, Dep't of Defense, Report of the Military Justice Review Group (22 December 2015)", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 9 }, "decisions": 10, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 9, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0077.first.docx", "sha256": "a50699f22c6d4b5d29ffc719fc91dc1bf499aaa540767b41931f72a070053250", "documentXmlSha256": "125e3829cf071c2e4da691b89e9b9620fb86e5898cff74711b8c1a5053942244" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0077.careful.docx", "lines": 21, "keyEntries": 26, "keyPieces": 26, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 17, "found": 15, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 2 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 4, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 25, "found": 16, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 10, "weightedScore": 49, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 10, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "United States v. Downum, __ M.J.___, 2025 CAAF LEXIS 828 (C.A.A.F. 23 October 2025)", "line": "United States v. Downum, __ M.J.___, 2025 CAAF LEXIS 828 (C.A.A.F. 23 October 2025)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "lacks 50 (cited there) / adds 49 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "UCMJ Article 66, 10 U.S.C \u00a7 866 (Supp. II 2019-2021)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "UCMJ Article 67, 10 U.S.C \u00a7 867 (Supp. II 2019-2021)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "UCMJ Article 120, 10 U.S.C. \u00a7 920 (2018)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Defense Advisory Committee on Investigation, Prosecution, and Defense of Sexual Assault in the Armed Forces, Appellate Review Study (March 2", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "John M. Donnelly, NDAA envisions new military policies on sexual assaults, Roll Call (8 December 2020)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 116-457 (2020)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 116-617 (2020)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Letter to Chairman Smith, Ranking Member Thornberry, Chairman Inhofe, and Ranking Member Reed, 14 September 2020", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Office of the General Counsel, Dep't of Defense, Report of the Military Justice Review Group (22 December 2015)", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 0, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 10, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 9 }, "decisions": 10, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 9, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-caaf-26-0077.careful.docx", "sha256": "efae98506a634b94f70c99350285e68537a9e1060d1c059bdac18c9fd4ce64c6", "documentXmlSha256": "125e3829cf071c2e4da691b89e9b9620fb86e5898cff74711b8c1a5053942244" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0077", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0077.first.docx", "lines": 21, "keyEntries": 26, "keyPieces": 26, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 17, "found": 15, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 2 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 4, "found": 0, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 25, "found": 16, "exact": 12, "defensible": 1, "passim": 2 }, "missing": 9, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 5, "errorsInFile": 10, "weightedScore": 49, "byType": { "missing": 9, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 45, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 10, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "United States v. Downum, __ M.J.___, 2025 CAAF LEXIS 828 (C.A.A.F. 23 October 2025)", "line": "United States v. Downum, __ M.J.___, 2025 CAAF LEXIS 828 (C.A.A.F. 23 October 2025)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "lacks 50 (cited there) / adds 49 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "UCMJ Article 66, 10 U.S.C \u00a7 866 (Supp. II 2019-2021)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "UCMJ Article 67, 10 U.S.C \u00a7 867 (Supp. II 2019-2021)", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "UCMJ Article 120, 10 U.S.C. \u00a7 920 (2018)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Defense Advisory Committee on Investigation, Prosecution, and Defense of Sexual Assault in the Armed Forces, Appellate Review Study (March 2", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "John M. Donnelly, NDAA envisions new military policies on sexual assaults, Roll Call (8 December 2020)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 116-457 (2020)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 116-617 (2020)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Letter to Chairman Smith, Ranking Member Thornberry, Chairman Inhofe, and Ranking Member Reed, 14 September 2020", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Office of the General Counsel, Dep't of Defense, Report of the Military Justice Review Group (22 December 2015)", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 18, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 5, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 4 }, "decisions": 23, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 18, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 4, "suggestions": 18, "modelShown": 18, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0077.first.docx", "sha256": "121cbcb384a344f20673a8829634ceb7d22268401b410a0ac3c8b4b01dd9ab29", "documentXmlSha256": "125e3829cf071c2e4da691b89e9b9620fb86e5898cff74711b8c1a5053942244" }, "seconds": 9 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0077.careful.docx", "lines": 26, "keyEntries": 26, "keyPieces": 26, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 1, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 17, "found": 15, "exact": 12, "defensible": 0, "passim": 2 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 3, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 2 }, "other": { "key": 4, "found": 2, "exact": 1, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 25, "found": 20, "exact": 13, "defensible": 2, "passim": 4 }, "missing": 5, "wrongPages": 1, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 0, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 6, "errorsInFile": 6, "weightedScore": 29, "byType": { "missing": 5, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 1, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 25, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 4, "badLine": 0, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 6, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "wrongPage", "weight": 4, "key": "United States v. Downum, __ M.J.___, 2025 CAAF LEXIS 828 (C.A.A.F. 23 October 2025)", "line": "United States v. Downum, __ M.J.___, 2025 CAAF LEXIS 828 (C.A.A.F. 23 October 2025)", "lines": [ 5 ], "detail": "lacks 50 (cited there) / adds 49 (not cited there)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "UCMJ Article 120, 10 U.S.C. \u00a7 920 (2018)", "detail": "statutes (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "John M. Donnelly, NDAA envisions new military policies on sexual assaults, Roll Call (8 December 2020)", "detail": "other" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 116-457 (2020)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "R. Rep. No. 116-617 (2020)", "detail": "cases (not found in the brief's text either)" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "Letter to Chairman Smith, Ranking Member Thornberry, Chairman Inhofe, and Ranking Member Reed, 14 September 2020", "detail": "other" } ], "asked": 18, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 0, "unsurfaced": 6, "unsurfacedByType": { "wrongPage": 1, "missing": 5 }, "decisions": 24, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 0, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 18, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 5, "suggestions": 18, "modelShown": 18, "trueAccepts": 5, "falseDismisses": 13, "suggestionClicks": 18 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-caaf-26-0077.careful.docx", "sha256": "350077b951300a1e169cfffa1cfef9580afef187ff36463dfa09be00dd657f53", "documentXmlSha256": "b373ec6c0a310117fdf24a86f6b0a8ec0cf0e5dddbf732d14ccdeb460c5e76b0" }, "seconds": 11 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0077", "accept": [ "10 U.S.C \u00a7 866", "10 U.S.C \u00a7 867", "Article 120(g)(7), UCMJ", "Article 66, UCMJ. Office of the General Counsel, Dep\u2019t of Defense, Report of the Military Justice Review Group 605-20 (22 December 2015) (MJRG Report).", "Defense Advisory Committee on Investigation, Prosecution, and Defense of Sexual Assault in the Armed Forces, Appellate Review Study 10 (March 2023)" ], "right": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "10 U.S.C \u00a7 866", "key": "UCMJ Article 66, 10 U.S.C \u00a7 866 (Supp. II 2019-2021)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "10 U.S.C \u00a7 867", "key": "UCMJ Article 67, 10 U.S.C \u00a7 867 (Supp. II 2019-2021)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 120(g)(7), UCMJ", "key": "UCMJ Article 120, 10 U.S.C. \u00a7 920 (2018)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 66, UCMJ. Office of the General Counsel, Dep\u2019t of Defense, Report of the Military Justice Review Group 605-20 (22 December 2015) (MJRG Report).", "key": "Office of the General Counsel, Dep't of Defense, Report of the Military Justice Review Group (22 December 2015)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Defense Advisory Committee on Investigation, Prosecution, and Defense of Sexual Assault in the Armed Forces, Appellate Review Study 10 (March 2023)", "key": "Defense Advisory Committee on Investigation, Prosecution, and Defense of Sexual Assault in the Armed Forces, Appellate Review Study (March 2" } ], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 66(d)(1)(B)(ii)(I)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 66" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 120(b)(2)(A)," }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 66(d)(1)(B)(i)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "United States v. Moore, ___ M.J. ____, 25-0110/AF, slip op. at 5 (C.A.A.F. 23 January 2026)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 67" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 67(c)(1)(C)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 66(d)(1)," }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 67(c)(4)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 120" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 120(b)(2)(B)" }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 120(g)(7)." }, { "kind": "model", "title": "Article 66(d)(1)(B)" } ] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-caaf-26-0077", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-caaf-26-0077.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/briefs/2025Term/Slayton260077AppellantBrief.pdf", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.armfor.uscourts.gov/GrantedCasesBriefs.htm", "sourceSha256": "f17fe62b9ea0e494e51979bc1de5202d3a8df7690445b435ff676a4ff040bca4", "inputSha256": "e367e56a42e5466bc21a60cde29b1d6d72194042bc273156a27eb7302f53d85e", "keySha256": "c1566b1ead0b01c6477c2d337b940b8a944456dc73d061f6bfafa3918fbccf54", "rawPrepKeySha256": "87e5817b6e696b8e5d61a15b41593887d872453d26e65f07231e2bdbe55c9e23", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces", "caseFamily": "CAAF 26-0077: United States v. Slayton", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "26-0077" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:08:12.303212+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 66, "inputPages": 63, "keyEntries": 26, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "secondary", "legislative-materials" ], "keyNormalization": [ { "before": "COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE ARMED FORCES United States v. Casillas, 86 M.J. 94 (C.A.A.F. 2025)", "after": "United States v. Casillas, 86 M.J. 94 (C.A.A.F. 2025)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" }, { "before": "COURTS OF CRIMINAL APPEALS United States v. Slayton, 2025 CCA LEXIS 427 (A.F. Ct. Crim. App. 8 September 2024) (unpub. op.)", "after": "United States v. Slayton, 2025 CCA LEXIS 427 (A.F. Ct. Crim. App. 8 September 2024) (unpub. op.)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" }, { "before": "FEDERAL COURTS OF APPEALS United States v. Husband, 312 F.3d 247 (7th Cir. 2002)", "after": "United States v. Husband, 312 F.3d 247 (7th Cir. 2002)", "reason": "Printed TOA section/header prefix only; authority wording/page list unchanged" } ], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 4, 6 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "00d7641fd48c829024a783e437802801207e1d96391c387eb6d26b4752af9438", "start": "TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\n Page(s)\n SUPREME ", "end": ". Jean,\n 83 M.J. 109 (C.A.A.F. 2023)............................................................................... 44\n\n\n\n iv" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "ccc5ce02c65ceaac77771a6e2b4f637e4c9573e54d61117189ab93608130cb82", "start": "United States v. Thompson,\n 83 M.J. 1 (C.A.A.F. 2022) ............................................................................30, 43\nUnited States v. Washington,\n 57 M.J. 394", "end": "7\n\nH.R. Rep. No. 116-457 (2020)................................................................................. 27\n\n v" }, { "pdfPage": 6, "textSha256": "8ad5ffd7b2068948791dd20a9acd5b3e53f551c7bf5963b2b4c209b5dd14c553", "start": "H.R. Rep. No. 116-617 (2020)...........................................................................28, 29\n\nLetter to Chairman Smith, Ranking Member Thornberry, Chairman Inhofe,", "end": " Report of the Military\n Justice Review Group (22 December 2015) ...........................................26, 27, 42\n\n\n\n\n vi" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "G AND SERVICE ............................................. 59\n\nCERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE ............................................................ 60\n\n\n\n\n iii", "followingRetainedPageStart": "9 February 2026\n IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS\n FOR THE ARMED FORCES\n\n UNITED STATES, ) UNITED STATES\u2019\n Appellant ) BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF\n ) THE CERTIFIED ISSUES\n v. ", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn", "task": { "id": "fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn.first.docx", "lines": 49, "keyEntries": 40, "keyPieces": 40, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 39, "found": 39, "exact": 32, "defensible": 3, "passim": 4 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 } }, "total": { "key": 40, "found": 40, "exact": 32, "defensible": 3, "passim": 5 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 9, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 4, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "295 F.3d 651 (7th Cir. 2002)", "lines": [ 45 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 1, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn.first.docx", "sha256": "232a4682db8979bc6d4aa816a9fc189b5730013a6e6a26fe21ae92adcf162331", "documentXmlSha256": "8f600d12f6584d11472d7dd4d85b965b397b386d67763be0bc5c297cd3ee6634" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn.careful.docx", "lines": 49, "keyEntries": 40, "keyPieces": 40, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 39, "found": 39, "exact": 32, "defensible": 3, "passim": 4 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 } }, "total": { "key": 40, "found": 40, "exact": 32, "defensible": 3, "passim": 5 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 9, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 4, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "295 F.3d 651 (7th Cir. 2002)", "lines": [ 45 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 1, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn.careful.docx", "sha256": "c65f231d31a38501e4dede7e6fd5022b57d6a8cf31c28f9cad05734e600c2be0", "documentXmlSha256": "8f600d12f6584d11472d7dd4d85b965b397b386d67763be0bc5c297cd3ee6634" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn.first.docx", "lines": 49, "keyEntries": 40, "keyPieces": 40, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 39, "found": 39, "exact": 32, "defensible": 3, "passim": 4 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 } }, "total": { "key": 40, "found": 40, "exact": 32, "defensible": 3, "passim": 5 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 9, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 4, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "295 F.3d 651 (7th Cir. 2002)", "lines": [ 45 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 2, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn.first.docx", "sha256": "7795416507d2179a1dd6320f2c790a9675afebdb60b6f327d8491536be7c15cc", "documentXmlSha256": "8f600d12f6584d11472d7dd4d85b965b397b386d67763be0bc5c297cd3ee6634" }, "seconds": 5 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn.careful.docx", "lines": 49, "keyEntries": 40, "keyPieces": 40, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 39, "found": 39, "exact": 32, "defensible": 3, "passim": 4 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 } }, "total": { "key": 40, "found": 40, "exact": 32, "defensible": 3, "passim": 5 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 9, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 4, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "295 F.3d 651 (7th Cir. 2002)", "lines": [ 45 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" } ], "asked": 2, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 2, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn.careful.docx", "sha256": "ea2443fa48cdd391b1ddb0bee03f145e5de5fd4cd2581d59c78893cfc72740e8", "documentXmlSha256": "8f600d12f6584d11472d7dd4d85b965b397b386d67763be0bc5c297cd3ee6634" }, "seconds": 6 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "United States, Cornish-Adebiyi v. Caesar\u2019s Ent., Inc. No. 1:23-cv-2536 (D.N.J. Mar. 28, 2024)" } ] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-gibson-cendyn.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/media/1376121/dl?inline", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/appellate-briefs", "sourceSha256": "f58972a59f0d3492ee751f08f9baf9929fbf76d133a6ac8dccb187344bf05963", "inputSha256": "7120ed0eebd225d5c0be3777284a4826777f38fde8e2293ce12b52c82aac44fd", "keySha256": "465837de7971b2981138fc7a6df66dbfec44c89416a5edbf75fae30409d4356b", "rawPrepKeySha256": "73b543fbfd0a2f7c31addd5d38e00f633ff1f25e10219e96600ff9d5d4941dac", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit", "caseFamily": "CA9 24-3576: Richard Gibson v. Cendyn Group", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "24-3576", "Richard Gibson", "Cendyn Group" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:09:38.074468+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 45, "inputPages": 42, "keyEntries": 40, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes" ], "keyNormalization": [], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 3, 5 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 3, "textSha256": "9b9186ef0df87922d576c906fa6d57ec11000c00edf3bbada077e944d14aa4aa", "start": "Case: 24-3576, 10/24/2024, DktEntry: 28.1, Page 3 of 45\n\n\n\n\n TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\nCases: ", "end": "0\n Gelboim v. Bank of Am. Corp.,\n 823 F.3d 759 (2d Cir. 2016) ................................................. 25, 26, 27\n\n\n\n ii" }, { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "92f71356d6a592396762976d8248a78d20d46c472ca385736fca8fee9aba081a", "start": "Case: 24-3576, 10/24/2024, DktEntry: 28.1, Page 4 of 45\n\n\n\n\nIn re Domestic Airline Travel Antitrust Litig.,\n 221 F. Supp. 3d 46 (D.D.C. 2016) ....................................", "end": "\nSkilstaf, Inc. v. CVS Caremark Corp.,\n 669 F.3d 1005 (9th Cir. 2012) ............................................... 4, 14, 37\n\n\n iii" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "0344e251343ea130c0125d00c1926ee1742c91b1a49637f13519f26646c24b84", "start": "Case: 24-3576, 10/24/2024, DktEntry: 28.1, Page 5 of 45\n\n\n\n\n Standard Oil Co. of New Jersey v. United States,\n 221 U.S. 1 (1911) ...............................................", "end": "..... 19\n\nStatute:\n\n 15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1 ................................................................................. passim\n\n\n\n\n iv" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "OF COMPLIANCE ........................................................39\nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE..................................................................40\n\n\n\n\n i", "followingRetainedPageStart": "Case: 24-3576, 10/24/2024, DktEntry: 28.1, Page 6 of 45\n\n\n\n\n INTEREST OF THE UNITED STATES\n\n The United States enforces Section 1 of the Sherman Act, 15\n\nU.S.C. \u00a7 1, and has a strong interest in its correct application. The joint\n\nuse of pricing algorithms by competitors presents n", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-atr-fubo-disney", "task": { "id": "fresh-atr-fubo-disney", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-fubo-disney.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "secondary", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-fubo-disney.first.docx", "lines": 47, "keyEntries": 43, "keyPieces": 43, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 37, "found": 35, "exact": 32, "defensible": 1, "passim": 2 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 3, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 2 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 } }, "total": { "key": 43, "found": 40, "exact": 34, "defensible": 1, "passim": 5 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 2, "garbledNames": 3, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 8, "weightedScore": 40, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 2, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 3, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 10, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 12, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 9, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "American Needle, Inc. v. NFL, 560 U.S. 183 (2010)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc., 659 F.2d 1063 (2d Cir. 1981)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Copperweld Corp. v. Independence Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752 (1984)", "line": "quoting Copperweld Corp. v. Indep. Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752, 768-69 (1984))", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "also on: Copperweld Corp. v. Indep. Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752 (1984)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "United States v. AT&T Inc., No. 18-5214 (D.C. Cir. Oct. 18, 2018)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "United States v. U.S. Sugar Corp., No. 22-2806 (3d Cir. Nov. 1, 2022)", "lines": [ 37 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Commc\u2019ns, Inc., 555 U.S. 438 (2009)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "507 F. Supp. 412 (S.D.N.Y. 1980)", "lines": [ 40 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "quoting Copperweld Corp. v. Indep. Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752, 768-69 (1984))", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3, "wrongAuthority": 2 }, "decisions": 10, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 4, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-fubo-disney.first.docx", "sha256": "114a3c3fa26c8446caeeddee5e2525740e1ba6e4529f7827b121f5f468f0af8f", "documentXmlSha256": "a8842c477477bc094f44fe2ce3cf576d43cd6fa893cd3578d8debc5db64ec3e2" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-fubo-disney.careful.docx", "lines": 47, "keyEntries": 43, "keyPieces": 43, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 37, "found": 35, "exact": 32, "defensible": 1, "passim": 2 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 3, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 2 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 } }, "total": { "key": 43, "found": 40, "exact": 34, "defensible": 1, "passim": 5 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 2, "garbledNames": 3, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 8, "weightedScore": 40, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 2, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 3, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 10, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 12, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 9, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "American Needle, Inc. v. NFL, 560 U.S. 183 (2010)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc., 659 F.2d 1063 (2d Cir. 1981)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Copperweld Corp. v. Independence Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752 (1984)", "line": "quoting Copperweld Corp. v. Indep. Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752, 768-69 (1984))", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "also on: Copperweld Corp. v. Indep. Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752 (1984)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "United States v. AT&T Inc., No. 18-5214 (D.C. Cir. Oct. 18, 2018)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "United States v. U.S. Sugar Corp., No. 22-2806 (3d Cir. Nov. 1, 2022)", "lines": [ 37 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Commc\u2019ns, Inc., 555 U.S. 438 (2009)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "507 F. Supp. 412 (S.D.N.Y. 1980)", "lines": [ 40 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "quoting Copperweld Corp. v. Indep. Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752, 768-69 (1984))", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 5, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3, "wrongAuthority": 2 }, "decisions": 10, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 4, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-fubo-disney.careful.docx", "sha256": "352a05aedf4b52f70f5d134dbc81e9154d01539f5e6b9d1d6b92b036f3461272", "documentXmlSha256": "a8842c477477bc094f44fe2ce3cf576d43cd6fa893cd3578d8debc5db64ec3e2" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-fubo-disney", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-fubo-disney.first.docx", "lines": 47, "keyEntries": 43, "keyPieces": 43, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 37, "found": 35, "exact": 32, "defensible": 1, "passim": 2 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 3, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 2 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 } }, "total": { "key": 43, "found": 40, "exact": 34, "defensible": 1, "passim": 5 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 2, "garbledNames": 3, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 8, "weightedScore": 40, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 2, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 3, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 10, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 12, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 9, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "American Needle, Inc. v. NFL, 560 U.S. 183 (2010)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc., 659 F.2d 1063 (2d Cir. 1981)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Copperweld Corp. v. Independence Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752 (1984)", "line": "quoting Copperweld Corp. v. Indep. Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752, 768-69 (1984))", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "also on: Copperweld Corp. v. Indep. Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752 (1984)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "United States v. AT&T Inc., No. 18-5214 (D.C. Cir. Oct. 18, 2018)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "United States v. U.S. Sugar Corp., No. 22-2806 (3d Cir. Nov. 1, 2022)", "lines": [ 37 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Commc\u2019ns, Inc., 555 U.S. 438 (2009)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "507 F. Supp. 412 (S.D.N.Y. 1980)", "lines": [ 40 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "quoting Copperweld Corp. v. Indep. Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752, 768-69 (1984))", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 6, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3, "wrongAuthority": 2 }, "decisions": 11, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 4, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-fubo-disney.first.docx", "sha256": "015cf8b658f63bbff24134fc0af00c782f4b0bf2311d11134aa7595006bd74b7", "documentXmlSha256": "a8842c477477bc094f44fe2ce3cf576d43cd6fa893cd3578d8debc5db64ec3e2" }, "seconds": 6 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-fubo-disney.careful.docx", "lines": 47, "keyEntries": 43, "keyPieces": 43, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 37, "found": 35, "exact": 32, "defensible": 1, "passim": 2 }, "statutes": { "key": 4, "found": 3, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 2 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 0, "passim": 1 } }, "total": { "key": 43, "found": 40, "exact": 34, "defensible": 1, "passim": 5 }, "missing": 3, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 2, "garbledNames": 3, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 4, "errorsInFile": 8, "weightedScore": 40, "byType": { "missing": 3, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 2, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 3, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 1, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 15, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 10, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 12, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 3, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 9, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "American Needle, Inc. v. NFL, 560 U.S. 183 (2010)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "United States v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc., 659 F.2d 1063 (2d Cir. 1981)", "detail": "cases" }, { "type": "missing", "weight": 5, "key": "15 U.S.C. \u00a7 1", "detail": "statutes" }, { "type": "duplicate", "weight": 3, "key": "Copperweld Corp. v. Independence Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752 (1984)", "line": "quoting Copperweld Corp. v. Indep. Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752, 768-69 (1984))", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "also on: Copperweld Corp. v. Indep. Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752 (1984)" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "United States v. AT&T Inc., No. 18-5214 (D.C. Cir. Oct. 18, 2018)", "lines": [ 31 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "wrongAuthority", "weight": 5, "line": "United States v. U.S. Sugar Corp., No. 22-2806 (3d Cir. Nov. 1, 2022)", "lines": [ 37 ], "detail": "not in the brief" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Commc\u2019ns, Inc., 555 U.S. 438 (2009)", "lines": [ 6 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "507 F. Supp. 412 (S.D.N.Y. 1980)", "lines": [ 40 ], "detail": "starts with a digit (no case name)" }, { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "quoting Copperweld Corp. v. Indep. Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752, 768-69 (1984))", "lines": [ 41 ], "detail": "starts lowercase" } ], "asked": 6, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 4, "unsurfaced": 5, "unsurfacedByType": { "missing": 3, "wrongAuthority": 2 }, "decisions": 11, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 4, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 1, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 1, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 3, "suggestions": 1, "modelShown": 1, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 1, "suggestionClicks": 1 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-fubo-disney.careful.docx", "sha256": "c9f73df7ef5c0e2c52b2828c6f69aa335e37b52419eac5d2a1ad5acc69ac1d9e", "documentXmlSha256": "a8842c477477bc094f44fe2ce3cf576d43cd6fa893cd3578d8debc5db64ec3e2" }, "seconds": 9 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-fubo-disney", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [ { "kind": "model", "title": "Merger Guidelines \u00a7 3" } ] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-atr-fubo-disney", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-fubo-disney.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/media/1379316/dl?inline", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/appellate-briefs", "sourceSha256": "9bdf7234cb6ef03ebd6acf59a52a6764e25b4518cf10055004e3027d8cf9ecb1", "inputSha256": "d85dd4c80f57b19550bef317bb87618dde2f705bd85559e7d0f834f16494e22f", "keySha256": "575f6fc4b5818dc394a0d112420165c60c96f9f67ef451f5a561e35431d56424", "rawPrepKeySha256": "20813c73f366de333a17ac517bcc830d561275ab09d234f1f63f1396762bd23a", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit", "caseFamily": "CA2 24-2210: FuboTV v. Walt Disney", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "24-2210", "FuboTV" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:09:48.655573+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 44, "inputPages": 40, "keyEntries": 43, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "secondary" ], "keyNormalization": [], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 3, 6 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 3, "textSha256": "0f5082e6df40a5c310be52448342527bbc3e054dcbeaba998f42b62852079336", "start": "Case: 24-2210, 11/26/2024, DktEntry: 136.1, Page 3 of 44\n\n\n\n\n TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\nCases ", "end": "ack Meridian Health, Inc.,\n 30 F.4th 160 (3d Cir. 2022)...................................................................21\n\n\n\n\n ii" }, { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "5108935e6d595c853fdb3ae1e46fdb4f7f12daec3210525a505c98e6b31216cc", "start": "Case: 24-2210, 11/26/2024, DktEntry: 136.1, Page 4 of 44\n\n\n\n\nFTC v. Penn State Hershey Medical Center,\n 838 F.3d 327 (3d Cir. 2016) ................................................", "end": "Sons, Inc. v. JELD-WEN, Inc.,\n 988 F.3d 690 (4th Cir. 2021).................................................................24\n\n iii" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "833336aca09dd5a9f73829d3b53ee8ecac30779a9ba8604a21b0ca56bdc8c22b", "start": "Case: 24-2210, 11/26/2024, DktEntry: 136.1, Page 5 of 44\n\n\n\n\nTexaco Inc. v. Dagher,\n 547 U.S. 1 (2006) .............................................................................", "end": ". Waste Management, Inc.,\n 743 F.2d 976 (2d Cir. 1984) ..................................................................23\n\n\n\n\n iv" }, { "pdfPage": 6, "textSha256": "f31beede803549945c2a8c5414bfc74d12fde91528c20d760cc1ad62db5006a2", "start": "Case: 24-2210, 11/26/2024, DktEntry: 136.1, Page 6 of 44\n\n\n\n\nVerizon Communications Inc. v. Law Offices of Curtis V. Trinko, LLP,\n 540 U.S. 398 (2004)..............................", "end": "ties\n\nUnited States Department of Justice & Federal Trade Commission,\n Merger Guidelines (2023)\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026.\u2026\u2026...passim\n\n\n\n\n v" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "E OF COMPLIANCE........................................................37\nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE.................................................................38\n\n\n\n\n i", "followingRetainedPageStart": "Case: 24-2210, 11/26/2024, DktEntry: 136.1, Page 7 of 44\n\n\n\n\n INTEREST OF THE UNITED STATES\n\n The United States enforces the federal antitrust laws and has a\n\nstrong interest in their correct interpretation. The district court\n\npreliminarily enjoined the formation of Defendants\u2019 ", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } }, { "id": "fresh-atr-directv-nexstar", "task": { "id": "fresh-atr-directv-nexstar", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-directv-nexstar.pdf", "key": "counsel", "level": "federal-appellate", "jur": "US", "tags": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "secondary", "web-sources", "fresh-holdout", "text-pdf", "toa-only-removal" ], "why": "Primary-source brief newly collected for this release without model-output selection; available prior corpora/training provenance screened, with an interpretable printed counsel TOA and audited clean removal boundaries." }, "conditions": { "off": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-directv-nexstar.first.docx", "lines": 48, "keyEntries": 47, "keyPieces": 47, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 44, "found": 44, "exact": 42, "defensible": 1, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 47, "found": 47, "exact": 44, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 4, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Andreas, 39 F. Supp. 2d 1048 (N.D. Ill. 1998)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 1, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-directv-nexstar.first.docx", "sha256": "d939a14df4cc3e7bcc9c18b03a07b6a519f612ee5fb49bd4760d760534c07af7", "documentXmlSha256": "ff4fefb61fe42f08fe1cfc1b422f7695a62079ada99e290f9cf78414a6072f85" }, "seconds": 3 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/off/fresh-atr-directv-nexstar.careful.docx", "lines": 48, "keyEntries": 47, "keyPieces": 47, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 44, "found": 44, "exact": 42, "defensible": 1, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 47, "found": 47, "exact": 44, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 4, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Andreas, 39 F. Supp. 2d 1048 (N.D. Ill. 1998)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 1, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/off/fresh-atr-directv-nexstar.careful.docx", "sha256": "2eefd8ea78bd4ed2b266753b75568e1768351b28de954f6cdfe3148dd5f4756c", "documentXmlSha256": "ff4fefb61fe42f08fe1cfc1b422f7695a62079ada99e290f9cf78414a6072f85" }, "seconds": 3 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-directv-nexstar", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } }, "on": { "first": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-directv-nexstar.first.docx", "lines": 48, "keyEntries": 47, "keyPieces": 47, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 44, "found": 44, "exact": 42, "defensible": 1, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 47, "found": 47, "exact": 44, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 4, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Andreas, 39 F. Supp. 2d 1048 (N.D. Ill. 1998)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 1, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-directv-nexstar.first.docx", "sha256": "c6ac9bef2c49261d232e05903dc15e938238960d294519c9b9737f07baad39ce", "documentXmlSha256": "ff4fefb61fe42f08fe1cfc1b422f7695a62079ada99e290f9cf78414a6072f85" }, "seconds": 4 }, "careful": { "summary": { "result": "/tmp/briefauthority-release-20261007/fresh/on/fresh-atr-directv-nexstar.careful.docx", "lines": 48, "keyEntries": 47, "keyPieces": 47, "keyHeadings": 0, "keyFrontMatterOnly": 0, "unreadKeyEntries": 0, "byCategory": { "cases": { "key": 44, "found": 44, "exact": 42, "defensible": 1, "passim": 1 }, "statutes": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 0, "defensible": 1, "passim": 0 }, "other": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 }, "rules": { "key": 1, "found": 1, "exact": 1, "defensible": 0, "passim": 0 } }, "total": { "key": 47, "found": 47, "exact": 44, "defensible": 2, "passim": 1 }, "missing": 0, "wrongPages": 0, "invented": 0, "garbledNames": 1, "brokenLines": 0, "legitimateExtras": 1, "errorsInFile": 1, "weightedScore": 4, "byType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 1, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "weightedByType": { "missing": 0, "falseMerge": 0, "wrongAuthority": 0, "wrongPage": 0, "badLine": 4, "idPage": 0, "duplicate": 0, "nameOnly": 0, "cosmetic": 0 }, "corrections": 1, "keyKind": "counsel", "optionalMissing": 0 }, "errors": [ { "type": "badLine", "weight": 4, "line": "Andreas, 39 F. Supp. 2d 1048 (N.D. Ill. 1998)", "lines": [ 0 ], "detail": "one-word party before a comma" } ], "asked": 1, "safeFixes": 0, "surfaced": 1, "unsurfaced": 0, "unsurfacedByType": {}, "decisions": 1, "sources": { "yellow line, to fix (name missing / cut off / extra text / shared cite)": 1, "yellow line, worth reviewing (year / court and date / no page)": 0, "line left out automatically": 0, "suggestion: citation-like text not in the table": 0, "suggestion: Also cited? (citation model)": 0, "short citation with no full one": 0, "old-table entry missing (kept tables)": 0, "scanned-pages note": 0 }, "split": { "hunt": 0, "suggestions": 0, "modelShown": 0, "trueAccepts": 0, "falseDismisses": 0, "suggestionClicks": 0 }, "download": { "archiveMember": "fresh/on/fresh-atr-directv-nexstar.careful.docx", "sha256": "0fc79831415bb82bf6395b76d5ee0703017bbc80f7144badb4a8e66db2c3fe45", "documentXmlSha256": "ff4fefb61fe42f08fe1cfc1b422f7695a62079ada99e290f9cf78414a6072f85" }, "seconds": 6 }, "reviewPlan": { "id": "fresh-atr-directv-nexstar", "accept": [], "right": [], "wrong": [] } } }, "provenance": { "id": "fresh-atr-directv-nexstar", "source": "release-2026-10-07-fresh/fresh-atr-directv-nexstar.pdf", "sourceUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/media/1361556/dl?inline", "sourceIndexUrl": "https://www.justice.gov/atr/appellate-briefs", "sourceSha256": "60ab654ee206a1d3cbe69710c429854c80b39fefba3601f1466bc499d8eb5220", "inputSha256": "c9221d445c4230384ca52552e5fe993190f5a57f838957f9b3ec341029994fd5", "keySha256": "dac4ff9cbb6f2c27f2f8f0d4a1988306c284cdb6376a5ad247999663ea0f8e66", "rawPrepKeySha256": "569add0cbc892e99fba064422edd846f40cf8eb3c5262607164919e3b0f1b5cc", "court": "United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit", "caseFamily": "CA2 24-981: DirecTV v. Nexstar Media Group", "caseFamilyScreeningTokens": [ "24-981", "DirecTV", "Nexstar Media Group" ], "collectedAt": "2026-10-07T08:09:59.151104+00:00", "truth": "counsel-based; not lawyer-verified gold", "sourcePages": 32, "inputPages": 28, "keyEntries": 47, "categories": [ "cases", "statutes", "rules", "secondary", "web-sources" ], "keyNormalization": [], "keyLimits": [ "Counsel spelling, citation/year errors, duplicate identities and page-list accuracy are not independently lawyer-verified; only table interpretation and removal boundaries were inspected." ], "removalAudit": { "removedPdfPages": [ 3, 6 ], "method": "Inspected printed table rows, each removed page interior and both boundaries using source text before model evaluation; whole TOA-only pages. All retained page text compared exactly against prepared PDF.", "removedPages": [ { "pdfPage": 3, "textSha256": "972b930a9580d30d9c14baadf0fa0b1f52c6565af12cc53136e1e712cb41ba82", "start": "Case: 24-981, 07/24/2024, DktEntry: 54.1, Page 3 of 32\n\n\n\n\n TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\n ", "end": " Metro. Life Ins. Co.,\n 648 F.3d 98 (2d Cir. 2011). ..................................................................... 2\n\n\n ii" }, { "pdfPage": 4, "textSha256": "28fdfdd821dee1eded2e17dc7e9b5d8ffa8645259b654cc1e621669489277e22", "start": "Case: 24-981, 07/24/2024, DktEntry: 54.1, Page 4 of 32\n\n\n\n\nFreedom Holdings, Inc. v. Spitzer,\n 357 F.3d 205 (2d Cir. 2004) ........................................................", "end": "Associates v. Bloomberg, L.P., No. 20-cv-5428,\n 2022 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 172854 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 23, 2022) ................... 17\n\n iii" }, { "pdfPage": 5, "textSha256": "b118ad2e9d7950238ae93c8a34aba0f79be6d63e7b1e764b433e10cd6ba4b7e1", "start": "Case: 24-981, 07/24/2024, DktEntry: 54.1, Page 5 of 32\n\n\n\n\nNational Society of Professional Engineers v. United States,\n 435 U.S. 679 (1978) .......................................", "end": "ted States v. Koppers Co.,\n 652 F.2d 290 (2d Cir. 1981) .................................................................. 11\n\n iv" }, { "pdfPage": 6, "textSha256": "29bea56970ed11d07128f5165aa5010beea1dd1bfced6a5424a0c3fd664a0b47", "start": "Case: 24-981, 07/24/2024, DktEntry: 54.1, Page 6 of 32\n\n\n\n\nUnited States v. Socony-Vacuum Oil Co.,\n 310 U.S. 150 (1940) ............................................................", "end": "................... 4\n\nRules\n\nFederal Rule of Appellate Procedure 29(a). .............................................. 2\n\n\n\n\n v" } ], "precedingRetainedPageEnd": "..........................................................21\nCONCLUSION .........................................................................................23\n\n\n\n\n i", "followingRetainedPageStart": "Case: 24-981, 07/24/2024, DktEntry: 54.1, Page 7 of 32\n\n\n\n\n INTEREST OF THE UNITED STATES\n\n The United States enforces the federal antitrust laws, including\n\nSection 1 of the Sherman Act, and has a strong interest in their correct\n\napplication. The United States takes no position o", "substantivePagesRemoved": false } } } ] } } }